Conflicts and Trade-Offs Between Macroeconomic Objectives - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
9 original exam-style questions - 3 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Conflicts and Trade-Offs Between Macroeconomic Objectives revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Economics practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 14 of A Level Economics Topic Workbook 3 and chapter 13 of A Level Economics 10-Minute Tests 2.
2.12 Conflicts and Trade-Offs Between Macroeconomic Objectives
Question 1
- identifies that SRAS becomes steeper as output approaches potential, so supply is less responsiveM1
- explains that increased AD in this region mainly raises prices rather than output, so unemployment falls little while inflation risesA1
- Answer: Near potential output SRAS is steep, so demand stimulus mostly increases the price level with little extra output; unemployment therefore falls only a little while inflation rises.
Question 2
- identifies that growth above potential uses spare capacity and increases demand relative to supplyM1
- explains mechanism: as output approaches capacity firms face rising costs and bid up prices, causing demand-pull inflationA1
- links to conflict: policy aimed at higher growth therefore risks higher inflation when near full capacityA1
- Answer: When growth pushes output above potential, spare capacity is used up, production costs rise and firms raise prices, so policies that raise short-run growth can generate demand-pull inflation.
Question 3
- identifies that stronger growth raises domestic income and spending, including on importsM1
- explains mechanism: higher imports reduce net exports, worsening the current account while growth increases GDPA1
- links to conflict: a policy boosting growth can therefore worsen the trade balance via import leakageA1
- Answer: Higher domestic growth increases incomes and spending on imported goods, reducing net exports and potentially deteriorating the current account, so growth can conflict with external balance.
Question 4
- valid policy option one named, e.g. carbon pricing or an emissions taxB1
- brief explanation of how it helps, e.g. raises cost of polluting activities so firms and consumers switch to cleaner production/consumption, reducing emissions while allowing growth in low-carbon sectorsB1
- Answer: Example: implement carbon pricing (emissions tax) which makes polluting activity more expensive and encourages cleaner production; subsidise green investment which shifts growth toward low-carbon industries and reduces environmental damage.
Question 5
- states a conflict, e.g. export-led growth can lead to overreliance on external demand and vulnerability to foreign shocksM1
- explains consequence: a boom in exports may improve the trade balance but can cause exchange rate appreciation, making other tradable sectors less competitive, or create terms of trade volatilityA1
- links to balanced current account: rapid export growth can mask deficits in other components (income account, services) or produce cyclical swings that make a balance harder to sustainA1
- Answer: Export-led growth can cause exchange rate appreciation and dependence on external demand, which may create volatility and undermine a stable, balanced current account.
Question 6
- states that in the long run inflation expectations adjust so there is no trade-off between inflation and unemploymentM1
- explains that workers and firms incorporate expected inflation into wage and price setting, returning unemployment to the natural rateA1
- concludes that the long-run Phillips curve is vertical, so attempts to keep unemployment below NAIRU cause accelerating inflationA1
- Answer: As inflation expectations adapt, wages and prices adjust so unemployment returns to the natural rate; therefore the long-run Phillips curve is vertical and there is no permanent inflation-unemployment trade-off.
Question 7
- identifies that expansionary policy raises AD, temporarily reducing unemployment below the natural rateM1
- explains that over time workers and firms expect higher inflation and negotiate higher wages/prices, eroding the real wage effect that reduced unemploymentA1
- concludes that unemployment returns to the natural rate while inflation continues to rise, producing accelerating inflation if policy persistsA1
- Answer: Expansionary policy raises AD and temporarily cuts unemployment, but as inflation expectations adjust wages and prices rise, removing the temporary employment gain; unemployment returns to the natural rate while inflation accelerates if policy continues.
Question 8
- identifies that higher domestic income increases demand for imports or that imports have a positive income elasticityM1
- explains mechanism using MPm or income elasticity: a higher marginal propensity to import means each extra pound of domestic income produces a relatively large increase in import spendingA1
- relates to net exports: rising imports reduce (X-M), so net exports fall as domestic demand recoversM1
- links to current account: the trade balance and current account can deteriorate even while GDP rises because import leakage offsets some of the rise in outputA1
- Answer: If imports are income elastic or the marginal propensity to import is high, a recovery raises import spending strongly as incomes grow; this raises M and reduces (X-M), so the current account can worsen even as GDP rises.
Question 9
- Level 1 Basic statements about possible conflicts or complements between macro objectives are offered with limited development. Answers may show little use of theory, no diagrams, and conclusions are undeveloped or missing.1-5
- Level 2 Clear explanation of at least two trade-offs or interactions, for example between growth and inflation, growth and the current account, or growth and the environment. May include reference to the short-run Phillips curve, expectations and the difference between short-run and long-run policy effects. Some evaluation is present and partial judgement offered.6-10
- Level 3 Comprehensive analysis of multiple trade-offs, including the monetarist critique of a permanent inflation-unemployment trade-off, role of expectations, and how supply-side policies can shift possibilities. Draws on diagrams where appropriate, considers time horizons and distributional issues, weights arguments, and reaches a well-supported and balanced judgement on whether all objectives can be achieved together.11-15
- Indicative content:
- Recognise the existence of genuine trade-offs: e.g. short-run Phillips curve trade-off between inflation and unemployment; demand-led growth can worsen the current account via import leakage; growth can increase pollution unless green measures accompany it.
- Monetarist critique: in the long run the Phillips curve is vertical, so attempting to keep unemployment permanently below NAIRU leads to accelerating inflation; expectations matter for the persistence of trade-offs.
- Time horizons: some objectives may be jointly achievable in the short run if spare capacity exists, but conflicts re-emerge as the economy approaches potential; supply-side policies can change the trade-off by shifting LRAS and the LRPC.
- Role of supply-side policies: investment in infrastructure, education and technology can expand productive capacity, reduce structural unemployment and allow higher growth without inflation, though with long implementation lags and potential financing costs.
- Policy mix and sequencing: monetary and fiscal policy can stabilise demand in the short run while supply-side reforms aim to improve long-run outcomes; active macroprudential or industrial policies can mitigate exchange rate or current account effects.
- Constraints and practical limits: political economy, financing requirements, international shocks, and distributional consequences can prevent simultaneous attainment; environmental objectives may require growth to be restructured rather than maximised.
- Evaluation: consider magnitude and speed of policies, trade-off intensity, whether a government accepts some relaxation of one objective to meet others, and conclude with a balanced judgement on feasibility, likely partial attainment, or need for prioritisation.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.