Stakeholders and their conflicting interests - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
14 original exam-style questions - 5 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Stakeholders and their conflicting interests revision guideMore GCSE Business practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 4 of GCSE Business Topic Workbook 1.
1.4 Stakeholders and their conflicting interests
- A) A regular customer buying groceries every week
- B) An employee working on the tills
- C) A shareholder attending the annual general meeting
- D) A local environmental campaign group calling on Marrow Lane Grocers to reduce plastic packaging
Calculate the corporation tax Marrow Lane Grocers must pay. Show your working.
Recommend whether Marrow Lane Grocers' board should approve the shareholders' request. Justify your answer using the figures and points made earlier in this pack.
Question 1
- fair or competitive prices (oe)B1
- good quality products, reliable stock availability, or good customer service (oe)B1
- Answer: Any two, e.g. fair or competitive prices; good quality products and reliable stock availability.
Question 2
- one acceptable external stakeholder, e.g. suppliersB1
- a second acceptable external stakeholder, e.g. the local community, the government, or a bank/lenderB1
- Answer: Any two, e.g. suppliers; the local community.
Question 3
- 3,240 / 12 seen (ft from question 9b)M1
- £270 caoA1
- Answer: £270.
Question 4
- D caoB1
- Answer: D
Question 5
- 80,000 x 0.19 seenM1
- £15,200 caoA1
- Answer: £15,200.
Question 6
- 80,000 - 15,200 seen (ft from question 5)M1
- £64,800 caoA1
- Answer: £64,800.
Question 7
- identifies the conflict, e.g. shareholders want costs kept low to maximise profit and dividendsB1
- develops the point, e.g. this could mean the community donation fund (question 10a) or measures to reduce noise/traffic near the store are kept to a minimumB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. local residents may then feel the business is not giving enough back, which could damage its reputation and local supportB1
- Answer: Shareholders wanting costs kept low to maximise dividends could mean the community donation fund or measures to reduce local traffic/noise are kept to a minimum, which could damage the business's reputation and local support.
Question 8
- identifies the conflict, e.g. customers want low prices, while shareholders want higher profit and a larger dividend pool (question 9a)B1
- develops the point, e.g. keeping prices low to keep customers happy reduces the profit available to pay out as dividendsB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. Marrow Lane Grocers must balance competitive pricing against shareholder pressure for a larger dividend (question 12), which is difficult to satisfy fully for both groupsB1
- Answer: Customers want low prices, while shareholders want higher profit and a larger dividend pool (question 9a); keeping prices low to keep customers happy reduces the profit available to pay out as dividends, so Marrow Lane Grocers must balance competitive pricing against shareholder pressure for a larger dividend (question 12), which is difficult to satisfy fully for both groups.
Question 9
- (a) 64,800 x 0.40 seen (ft from question 6)M1
- (a) £25,920 caoA1
- (a) Answer: £25,920.
- (b) 64,800 x 0.05 seen (ft from question 6)M1
- (b) £3,240 caoA1
- (b) Answer: £3,240.
Question 10
- (a) 64,800 x 0.02 seen (ft from question 6)M1
- (a) £1,296 caoA1
- (a) Answer: £1,296.
- (b) 64,800 - 25,920 - 3,240 - 1,296 seen (ft from question 6, 9a, 9b, 10a)M1
- (b) £34,344 caoA1
- (b) Answer: £34,344.
Question 11
- identifies a method, e.g. consulting stakeholder groups before making a major decision, or setting a fixed percentage split of profit (as in questions 9 and 10) between groupsB1
- develops the point, e.g. this ensures no single stakeholder group's interests are ignored, and each group receives an agreed, predictable shareB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. this can reduce conflict and build trust between the business and its stakeholders over timeB1
- Answer: A business could set a fixed percentage split of after-tax profit between stakeholder groups (as Marrow Lane Grocers does in questions 9 and 10), ensuring each group gets a predictable share, which reduces conflict and builds trust over time.
Question 12
- identifies a reason, e.g. shareholders took the financial risk of investing in Marrow Lane Grocers and expect a return in exchangeB1
- develops the point, e.g. they may compare their return with what they could earn investing the same money elsewhereB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. if the dividend feels too low compared with the risk taken, shareholders may sell their shares or refuse to invest further, weakening the business's access to financeB1
- Answer: Shareholders took the risk of investing and expect a competitive return; if the dividend is too low compared with the risk taken or with other investments available, they may sell their shares or refuse further investment, weakening the business's access to finance.
Question 13
- Level 1 Makes simple, undeveloped comments about the dividend request, with little or no use of the pack's figures and no clear recommendation.1-3
- Level 2 Gives a developed argument for or against approving the request, using some of the pack's figures, but does not fully weigh both sides or reach a clearly justified recommendation.4-6
- Level 3 Weighs the evidence for and against approving the request, using the dividend, retained-profit and stakeholder figures from this pack, and reaches a justified recommendation supported by that analysis.7-9
- Indicative content:
- For approving: shareholders took the financial risk of investing in Marrow Lane Grocers (question 12) and a higher, more competitive dividend could help retain their support and make it easier to raise further finance from them in future.
- For approving: the employee bonus pool and community donation fund are protected/unchanged, so this specific conflict does not directly worsen relations with those two stakeholder groups.
- Against approving: retained profit would fall from £34,344 (question 10b) by the full amount of the dividend increase, leaving less money for reinvestment in the store, which could limit future growth or maintenance.
- Against approving: reduced reinvestment could eventually affect employees and customers indirectly (e.g. an ageing store, fewer opportunities for pay rises funded by growth), even though the bonus pool itself is untouched this year.
- Judgement: a reasonable recommendation is that the board should only approve part of the increase, or delay it, since retained profit funds the business's own future (and indirectly all other stakeholders' long-term interests), so protecting a reasonable level of reinvestment alongside a modest, not maximal, dividend rise is likely to balance shareholder and business interests better than the full request.
Question 14
- Level 1 Makes simple, undeveloped points about the packaging change, with limited application to Marrow Lane Grocers and little or no reference to the pack's stakeholder groups or figures.1-3
- Level 2 Provides a developed and applied analysis of the benefits and drawbacks of the packaging change for both shareholders and customers, referring to Marrow Lane Grocers' figures or stakeholder interests.4-6
- Indicative content:
- Biodegradable packaging costs more than plastic packaging, which would reduce Marrow Lane Grocers' profit and therefore the after-tax profit available for the dividend pool (question 9a), directly affecting shareholders' interests.
- Shareholders may accept a smaller short-term dividend if the change protects the business's reputation and long-term sales, since ignoring pressure group campaigns can risk a damaging boycott or negative publicity.
- Customers concerned about the environment are likely to welcome the change, which could attract new environmentally conscious customers or increase loyalty among existing ones (question 1).
- Other customers focused mainly on price (question 1) may be less positive if higher packaging costs are eventually passed on through higher prices, which would work against their main interest.
- A balanced conclusion might note that the change is likely to satisfy the pressure group and environmentally conscious customers while creating a short-term cost pressure on shareholders' dividends, so Marrow Lane Grocers needs to judge whether the reputational benefit outweighs the reduced profit, similar to the dividend-versus-reinvestment trade-off already considered in question 13.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.