Correlation and Causation (Higher) - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
42 original exam-style questions - 26 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Correlation and Causation (Higher) revision guideMore GCSE Statistics practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 3 of GCSE Statistics Higher Topic Workbook 6 and chapter 21 of GCSE Statistics Higher 10-Minute Tests 2.
4.3 Correlation and Causation (Higher)
(a) Work out Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n and Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n.
(b) Work out the gradient b = Sxy / Sxx of the regression line y = a + bx, to 3 significant figures.
(c) The mean of x is 7 and the mean of y is 35.71. Find a, then use the line to estimate y when x = 17. Give each answer to 3 significant figures, using unrounded values in your working.
(a) Work out Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n and Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n.
(b) Work out the gradient b = Sxy / Sxx of the regression line y = a + bx, to 3 significant figures.
(c) The mean of x is 8.71 and the mean of y is 54. Find a, then use the line to estimate y when x = 16. Give each answer to 3 significant figures, using unrounded values in your working.
(a) Describe the correlation. Use these descriptions: strong is |r| of 0.7 or more, moderate is from 0.4 up to 0.7, weak is below 0.4.
(b) A student says that a change in the number of ice creams sold causes a change in the number of sunburn cases. Comment on this claim.
(a) Work out Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n and Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n.
(b) Work out the gradient b = Sxy / Sxx of the regression line y = a + bx, to 3 significant figures.
(c) The mean of x is 7.8 and the mean of y is 54. Find a, then use the line to estimate y when x = 4. Give each answer to 3 significant figures, using unrounded values in your working.
| x | 4 | 6 | 8 | 10 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| y | 75 | 79 | 90 | 102 | 109 | 106 | 114 | 121 |
A line of best fit is drawn so that it passes through the points (6, 79) and (14, 114).
(a) Work out the gradient of the line.
(b) Find the equation of the line in the form y = mx + c.
(c) Use your equation to estimate y when x = 16.
(d) State whether your estimate in (c) is interpolation or extrapolation, and whether it is likely to be reliable.
(a) Work out Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n and Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n.
(b) Work out the gradient b = Sxy / Sxx of the regression line y = a + bx, to 3 significant figures.
(c) The mean of x is 6.33 and the mean of y is 31.5. Find a, then use the line to estimate y when x = 6. Give each answer to 3 significant figures, using unrounded values in your working.
| x | 2 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 11 | 20 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| y | 54 | 51 | 49 | 47 | 46 | 26 |
(a) Work out the mean of x and the mean of y, giving the coordinates of the mean point.
(b) Describe the type of correlation between x and y.
(a) Describe the correlation. Use these descriptions: strong is |r| of 0.7 or more, moderate is from 0.4 up to 0.7, weak is below 0.4.
(b) A student says that a change in the number of ice creams sold causes a change in the number of sunburn cases. Comment on this claim.
| x | 2 | 6 | 8 | 10 | 14 | 15 | 18 | 19 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| y | 98 | 89 | 79 | 74 | 69 | 64 | 54 | 52 |
A line of best fit is drawn so that it passes through the points (6, 89) and (18, 54).
(a) Work out the gradient of the line.
(b) Find the equation of the line in the form y = mx + c.
(a) Describe the correlation. Use these descriptions: strong is |r| of 0.7 or more, moderate is from 0.4 up to 0.7, weak is below 0.4.
(b) A student says that a change in the price of a house causes a change in the number of bedrooms. Comment on this claim.
(a) Work out Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n and Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n.
(b) Work out the gradient b = Sxy / Sxx of the regression line y = a + bx, to 3 significant figures.
(c) The mean of x is 5.71 and the mean of y is 42.29. Find a, then use the line to estimate y when x = 7. Give each answer to 3 significant figures, using unrounded values in your working.
(a) Work out Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n and Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n.
(b) Work out the gradient b = Sxy / Sxx of the regression line y = a + bx, to 3 significant figures.
(c) The mean of x is 10.33 and the mean of y is 55. Find a, then use the line to estimate y when x = 6. Give each answer to 3 significant figures, using unrounded values in your working.
| x | 2 | 7 | 10 | 11 | 13 | 16 | 17 | 19 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| y | 72 | 57 | 46 | 40 | 26 | 17 | 15 | 10 |
A line of best fit is drawn so that it passes through the points (7, 57) and (17, 15).
(a) Work out the gradient of the line.
(b) Find the equation of the line in the form y = mx + c.
(c) Use your equation to estimate y when x = 12.
(d) State whether your estimate in (c) is interpolation or extrapolation, and whether it is likely to be reliable.
(a) Work out Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n and Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n.
(b) Work out the gradient b = Sxy / Sxx of the regression line y = a + bx, to 3 significant figures.
(c) The mean of x is 9.17 and the mean of y is 52.5. Find a, then use the line to estimate y when x = 18. Give each answer to 3 significant figures, using unrounded values in your working.
(a) Describe the correlation. Use these descriptions: strong is |r| of 0.7 or more, moderate is from 0.4 up to 0.7, weak is below 0.4.
(b) A student says that a change in the number of fire engines at a fire causes a change in the damage caused. Comment on this claim.
(a) Work out Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n and Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n.
(b) Work out the gradient b = Sxy / Sxx of the regression line y = a + bx, to 3 significant figures.
(c) The mean of x is 8.17 and the mean of y is 43.83. Find a, then use the line to estimate y when x = 5. Give each answer to 3 significant figures, using unrounded values in your working.
| x | 1 | 3 | 4 | 7 | 8 | 10 | 19 | 20 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| y | 111 | 100 | 100 | 90 | 89 | 81 | 62 | 63 |
A line of best fit is drawn so that it passes through the points (3, 100) and (19, 62).
(a) Work out the gradient of the line.
(b) Find the equation of the line in the form y = mx + c.
| x | 5 | 10 | 13 | 16 | 17 | 20 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| y | 57 | 48 | 36 | 38 | 29 | 28 |
A line of best fit is drawn so that it passes through the points (10, 48) and (17, 29).
(a) Work out the gradient of the line.
(b) Find the equation of the line in the form y = mx + c.
(a) Describe the correlation. Use these descriptions: strong is |r| of 0.7 or more, moderate is from 0.4 up to 0.7, weak is below 0.4.
(b) A student says that a change in the number of hours of TV watched causes a change in a person's weight. Comment on this claim.
(a) Work out Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n and Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n.
(b) Work out the gradient b = Sxy / Sxx of the regression line y = a + bx, to 3 significant figures.
(c) The mean of x is 6.57 and the mean of y is 40.29. Find a, then use the line to estimate y when x = 10. Give each answer to 3 significant figures, using unrounded values in your working.
(a) Describe the correlation. Use these descriptions: strong is |r| of 0.7 or more, moderate is from 0.4 up to 0.7, weak is below 0.4.
(b) A student says that a change in a child's shoe size causes a change in the child's reading score. Comment on this claim.
(a) Work out Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n and Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n.
(b) Work out the gradient b = Sxy / Sxx of the regression line y = a + bx, to 3 significant figures.
(c) The mean of x is 7.17 and the mean of y is 30.83. Find a, then use the line to estimate y when x = 15. Give each answer to 3 significant figures, using unrounded values in your working.
| x | 2 | 3 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 14 | 20 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| y | 38 | 47 | 60 | 68 | 69 | 91 | 117 |
A line of best fit is drawn so that it passes through the points (3, 47) and (14, 91).
(a) Work out the gradient of the line.
(b) Find the equation of the line in the form y = mx + c.
(a) Work out Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n and Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n.
(b) Work out the gradient b = Sxy / Sxx of the regression line y = a + bx, to 3 significant figures.
(c) The mean of x is 8.6 and the mean of y is 40. Find a, then use the line to estimate y when x = 16. Give each answer to 3 significant figures, using unrounded values in your working.
(a) Describe the correlation. Use these descriptions: strong is |r| of 0.7 or more, moderate is from 0.4 up to 0.7, weak is below 0.4.
(b) A student says that a change in the number of fire engines at a fire causes a change in the damage caused. Comment on this claim.
| x | 1 | 6 | 7 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| y | 40 | 65 | 64 | 106 | 109 | 111 | 121 |
A line of best fit is drawn so that it passes through the points (6, 65) and (19, 111).
(a) Work out the gradient of the line.
(b) Find the equation of the line in the form y = mx + c.
r = Sxy / √Sxx * Syy
where Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n, Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n and Syy = (sum of y2) - (sum of y)2/n.
For a set of paired data, Sxy = 84, Sxx = 120 and Syy = 98.
Work out the value of r, giving your answer correct to 3 significant figures.
| Study | r |
|---|---|
| A | -0.92 |
| B | 0.15 |
| C | 0.68 |
| D | -0.40 |
| Pupil | Hours revising, x | Test score, y |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 48 |
| 2 | 4 | 62 |
| 3 | 5 | 52 |
| 4 | 7 | 74 |
| 5 | 9 | 80 |
You may use: Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n, Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n, Syy = (sum of y2) - (sum of y)2/n, and r = Sxy / √Sxx * Syy.
| Teenager | Hours of TV, x | Fitness score, y |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 5 | 44 |
| 2 | 8 | 40 |
| 3 | 10 | 30 |
| 4 | 14 | 32 |
| 5 | 18 | 24 |
| 6 | 21 | 16 |
You may use: Sxy = (sum of xy) - (sum of x)(sum of y)/n, Sxx = (sum of x2) - (sum of x)2/n, Syy = (sum of y2) - (sum of y)2/n, and r = Sxy / √Sxx * Syy.
Evaluate this claim.
Question 1
- (a) Negative caoB1
- (a) Answer: Negative correlation
- (b) identifies that as hours of sunshine increases, hot chocolate sales decrease, oeB1
- (b) correct context, e.g. sunnier afternoons are linked with fewer hot chocolates being soldB1
- (b) Answer: As the number of hours of sunshine increases, the number of hot chocolates sold tends to decrease.
- (c) a sensible practical use, e.g. to help decide how much hot chocolate stock to prepare based on the weather forecast, oeB1
- (c) Answer: It could help her decide how much hot chocolate to prepare based on the weather forecast (less on sunny days).
Question 2
- (i) False caoB1
- (i) Answer: False
- (ii) True caoB1
- (ii) Answer: True
- (iii) False caoB1
- (iii) Answer: False
- (iv) True caoB1
- (iv) Answer: True
Question 3
- (a) Positive caoB1
- (a) Answer: Positive correlation
- (b) Negative caoB1
- (b) Answer: Negative correlation
- (c) No correlation caoB1
- (c) Answer: No correlation
Question 4
- Sxy or Sxx formula usedM1
- Sxy = 268 and Sxx = 68A1
- b = 3.94A1
- a = mean of y minus b x mean of xM1
- a = 8.13A1
- 75.1 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 268, 68; (b) 3.94; (c) a = 8.13, y = 75.1
Question 5
- Sxy or Sxx formula usedM1
- Sxy = 378 and Sxx = 101.43A1
- b = 3.73A1
- a = mean of y minus b x mean of xM1
- a = 21.5A1
- 81.2 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 378, 101.43; (b) 3.73; (c) a = 21.5, y = 81.2
Question 6
- positiveB1
- strongB1
- correlation does not prove causationB1
- a third factor, such as hot weather, may affect bothB1
- Answer: (a) strong positive correlation; (b) correlation does not imply causation; a third factor such as hot weather may be the cause
Question 7
- Sxy or Sxx formula usedM1
- Sxy = 136 and Sxx = 54.8A1
- b = 2.48A1
- a = mean of y minus b x mean of xM1
- a = 34.6A1
- 44.6 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 136, 54.8; (b) 2.48; (c) a = 34.6, y = 44.6
Question 8
- change in y divided by change in xM1
- 4.375 caoA1
- substitutes a point to find cM1
- y = 4.375x + 52.75 caoA1
- substitutes x = 16M1
- 122.75 caoA1
- extrapolation and less reliable as outside the data rangeB1
- Answer: (a) 4.375; (b) y = 4.375x + 52.75; (c) 122.75; (d) extrapolation; less reliable because x = 16 is outside the observed range 4 to 15 and the linear pattern may not continue.
Question 9
- Sxy or Sxx formula usedM1
- Sxy = 299 and Sxx = 113.33A1
- b = 2.64A1
- a = mean of y minus b x mean of xM1
- a = 14.8A1
- 30.6 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 299, 113.33; (b) 2.64; (c) a = 14.8, y = 30.6
Question 10
- (a) sum of x divided by nM1
- (a) sum of y divided by nM1
- (a) (9.5, 45.5) caoA1
- (b) negative correlationB1
- Answer: (a) (9.5, 45.5); (b) negative correlation
Question 11
- negativeB1
- weakB1
- correlation does not prove causationB1
- a third factor, such as hot weather, may affect bothB1
- Answer: (a) weak negative correlation; (b) correlation does not imply causation; a third factor such as hot weather may be the cause
Question 12
- change in y divided by change in xM1
- gradient -2.9166666667 caoA1
- substitutes a point into y = mx + cM1
- y = -2.9166666667x + 106.5 caoA1
- Answer: (a) -2.9166666667; (b) y = -2.9166666667x + 106.5
Question 13
- positiveB1
- moderateB1
- correlation does not prove causationB1
- a third factor, such as the size of the house, may affect bothB1
- Answer: (a) moderate positive correlation; (b) correlation does not imply causation; a third factor such as the size of the house may be the cause
Question 14
- Sxy or Sxx formula usedM1
- Sxy = 420.57 and Sxx = 143.43A1
- b = 2.93A1
- a = mean of y minus b x mean of xM1
- a = 25.5A1
- 46.1 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 420.57, 143.43; (b) 2.93; (c) a = 25.5, y = 46.1
Question 15
- Sxy or Sxx formula usedM1
- Sxy = 406 and Sxx = 87.33A1
- b = 4.65A1
- a = mean of y minus b x mean of xM1
- a = 6.96A1
- 34.9 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 406, 87.33; (b) 4.65; (c) a = 6.96, y = 34.9
Question 16
- change in y divided by change in xM1
- -4.2 caoA1
- substitutes a point to find cM1
- y = -4.2x + 86.4 caoA1
- substitutes x = 12M1
- 36 caoA1
- interpolation and more reliable as within the data rangeB1
- Answer: (a) -4.2; (b) y = -4.2x + 86.4; (c) 36; (d) interpolation; likely to be reasonably reliable because x = 12 is within the observed range 2 to 19 and the data follows a clear linear pattern.
Question 17
- Sxy or Sxx formula usedM1
- Sxy = 345.5 and Sxx = 104.83A1
- b = 3.30A1
- a = mean of y minus b x mean of xM1
- a = 22.3A1
- 81.6 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 345.5, 104.83; (b) 3.30; (c) a = 22.3, y = 81.6
Question 18
- negativeB1
- moderateB1
- correlation does not prove causationB1
- a third factor, such as the size of the fire, may affect bothB1
- Answer: (a) moderate negative correlation; (b) correlation does not imply causation; a third factor such as the size of the fire may be the cause
Question 19
- Sxy or Sxx formula usedM1
- Sxy = 319.17 and Sxx = 102.83A1
- b = 3.10A1
- a = mean of y minus b x mean of xM1
- a = 18.5A1
- 34.0 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 319.17, 102.83; (b) 3.10; (c) a = 18.5, y = 34.0
Question 20
- (a) reads from the line of best fit at x = 18M1
- (a) awrt 34 (accept 32 to 36)A1
- (a) Answer: 34 (accept 32-36)
- (b) Interpolation caoB1
- (b) reliable/fairly reliable because x = 18 lies within the range of the recorded temperatures (14 to 26), oeB1
- (b) Answer: Interpolation; it should be fairly reliable because 18°C lies within the range of the temperatures recorded (14 to 26°C).
- (c) the data points do not all lie exactly on the line, so any single estimate may differ from the true value, oeB1
- (c) Answer: The actual data points do not lie exactly on the line of best fit, so the true value could be a little higher or lower.
Question 21
- change in y divided by change in xM1
- gradient -2.375 caoA1
- substitutes a point into y = mx + cM1
- y = -2.375x + 107.125 caoA1
- Answer: (a) -2.375; (b) y = -2.375x + 107.125
Question 22
- change in y divided by change in xM1
- gradient -2.7142857143 caoA1
- substitutes a point into y = mx + cM1
- y = -2.7142857143x + 75.1428571429 caoA1
- Answer: (a) -2.7142857143; (b) y = -2.7142857143x + 75.1428571429
Question 23
- positiveB1
- weakB1
- correlation does not prove causationB1
- a third factor, such as overall lifestyle, may affect bothB1
- Answer: (a) weak positive correlation; (b) correlation does not imply causation; a third factor such as overall lifestyle may be the cause
Question 24
- Sxy or Sxx formula usedM1
- Sxy = 360.86 and Sxx = 117.71A1
- b = 3.07A1
- a = mean of y minus b x mean of xM1
- a = 20.1A1
- 50.8 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 360.86, 117.71; (b) 3.07; (c) a = 20.1, y = 50.8
Question 25
- negativeB1
- strongB1
- correlation does not prove causationB1
- a third factor, such as age, may affect bothB1
- Answer: (a) strong negative correlation; (b) correlation does not imply causation; a third factor such as age may be the cause
Question 26
- Sxy or Sxx formula usedM1
- Sxy = 353.17 and Sxx = 124.83A1
- b = 2.83A1
- a = mean of y minus b x mean of xM1
- a = 10.6A1
- 53.0 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 353.17, 124.83; (b) 2.83; (c) a = 10.6, y = 53.0
Question 27
- change in y divided by change in xM1
- gradient 4 caoA1
- substitutes a point into y = mx + cM1
- y = 4x + 35 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 4; (b) y = 4x + 35
Question 28
- (a) (23-7)/(10-2), oeM1
- (a) 2 caoA1
- (a) Answer: 2
- (b) substitutes gradient and one point to find c, e.g. 7 = 2(2) + cM1
- (b) y = 2x + 3 caoA1
- (b) Answer: y = 2x + 3
- (c) £15 cao, ft from (b)B1
- (c) Answer: £15
- (d) recognises that the original data range is not supplied, so unreliability or extrapolation cannot be established; accept a conditional explanation that the estimate could be unreliable if the linear fare pattern does not hold for long journeys, oeB1
- (d) Answer: The original data range is not given, so we cannot tell whether 50 miles is extrapolation or conclude that the estimate is unreliable. It could be unreliable if the fare follows a different rate for long journeys.
Question 29
- Sxy or Sxx formula usedM1
- Sxy = 513 and Sxx = 101.2A1
- b = 5.07A1
- a = mean of y minus b x mean of xM1
- a = -3.59A1
- 77.5 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 513, 101.2; (b) 5.07; (c) a = -3.59, y = 77.5
Question 30
- negativeB1
- weakB1
- correlation does not prove causationB1
- a third factor, such as the size of the fire, may affect bothB1
- Answer: (a) weak negative correlation; (b) correlation does not imply causation; a third factor such as the size of the fire may be the cause
Question 31
- change in y divided by change in xM1
- gradient 3.5384615385 caoA1
- substitutes a point into y = mx + cM1
- y = 3.5384615385x + 43.7692307692 caoA1
- Answer: (a) 3.5384615385; (b) y = 3.5384615385x + 43.7692307692
Question 32
- substitutes correctly into r = Sxy / √Sxx * SyyM1
- r = 0.774596... (or equivalent unrounded value)A1
- 0.775 (3 sf), ftA1
- Answer: 0.775
Question 33
- (a) a generally downward/falling pattern with a fair amount of scatter, oeB1
- (a) Answer: The points generally fall from left to right, but with a fair amount of scatter.
- (b) Yes caoB1
- (b) Answer: Yes, it is consistent.
- (c) the negative sign matches the falling pattern of the pointsB1
- (c) the size of r (moderate, not close to -1) matches the amount of scatter around the trend rather than a perfect straight lineB1
- (c) Answer: The negative sign matches the overall falling trend, and because -0.618 is only moderate in size (not close to -1), this matches the noticeable scatter around that trend rather than a perfect line.
Question 34
- (a) A caoB1
- (a) Answer: A
- (b) B caoB1
- (b) Answer: B
- (c) A and D caoB1
- (c) Answer: A and D
- (d) positive, moderate to fairly strong, oeB1
- (d) Answer: A moderate to fairly strong positive association.
Question 35
- (a) Sxy = 1842 - (27)(316)/5 = 135.6B1
- (a) Sxx = 175 - 272/5 = 29.2B1
- (a) Syy = 20728 - 3162/5 = 756.8B1
- (a) Answer: Sxy = 135.6, Sxx = 29.2, Syy = 756.8
- (b) r = 135.6 / √29.2 * 756.8, oeM1
- (b) 0.912 (3 sf), ft from (a)A1
- (b) Answer: 0.912
- (c) identifies a strong positive correlation/associationB1
- (c) correct context, e.g. pupils who revised for longer tended to get higher test scores, oeB1
- (c) Answer: There is a strong positive correlation - pupils who spent longer revising tended to achieve higher test scores.
Question 36
- (a) Positive (strong) caoB1
- (a) Answer: Strong positive correlation
- (b) confounding variable / third variable, oeB1
- (b) Answer: A confounding (or third) variable
- (c) identifies that a third factor (warm/sunny weather) could increase both sunglasses sales and pool visits independentlyB1
- (c) correct conclusion, e.g. the correlation could be explained by weather rather than one variable causing the otherB1
- (c) Answer: Warm, sunny weather could independently increase both sunglasses sales and pool visits, so the correlation may simply reflect the weather rather than one thing causing the other.
- (d) e.g. also record temperature/hours of sunshine each week and compare weeks with similar weather to see whether the link remains, oeB1
- (d) Answer: Record the weather (e.g. temperature) each week too, and compare weeks with similar weather to see if the link between sunglasses sales and pool visits weakens.
Question 37
- (a) Positive caoB1
- (a) Answer: Positive correlation
- (b) national wealth/GDP per person, oeB1
- (b) a second distinct sensible factor, e.g. access to good healthcare, clean water and sanitation, or education levels, oeB1
- (b) Answer: For example: national wealth (GDP per person), and access to good healthcare.
- (c) identifies that wealth (or another confounding factor) could cause both higher phone ownership and higher life expectancyB1
- (c) correct conclusion, e.g. the correlation may be entirely explained by wealth/healthcare rather than phones themselves having any effect on lifespanB1
- (c) Answer: Wealth (or healthcare access) could independently cause both higher mobile phone ownership and higher life expectancy, so the correlation may have nothing to do with phones themselves affecting lifespan.
- (d) e.g. compare only countries with similar GDP/wealth and see whether the correlation between phone ownership and life expectancy still holds among just those countries, oeB1
- (d) Answer: Compare only countries with similar levels of wealth, and see whether mobile phone ownership still correlates with life expectancy within that group.
Question 38
- (a) Strong positive caoB1
- (a) Answer: Strong positive
- (b) there is no sensible/plausible mechanism linking the two business types directly, oeB1
- (b) Answer: There is no realistic way that opening a coffee shop would directly cause someone to open a yoga studio, or vice versa.
- (c) suggests a plausible shared influence, e.g. population growth or rising incomes, as a possibility; also accept recognising that the correlation alone does not establish an upward trend over time, oeB1
- (c) Answer: If both counts increased over time, a growing population or rising incomes could have encouraged both types of business to open. The stated correlation does not establish that either count increased over the 10 years.
- (d) explains that a shared factor or coincidence could produce the association without one business type causing the other, oeB1
- (d) states that correlation alone cannot establish causation or justify classifying this particular relationship as spurious, oeB1
- (d) Answer: The correlation alone does not show that opening one type of business causes the other to open. A shared factor, such as the town's population, or coincidence could explain the association, but the information given does not establish that it is spurious or rule out a causal link.
Question 39
- (a) Positive caoB1
- (a) Answer: Positive correlation
- (b) identifies that it may be the level of patient risk/need that determines nurse numbers, not the other way roundB1
- (b) correct explanation, e.g. wards with higher-risk or more frail patients are given more nurses, and these same patients are more likely to fall regardless of staffingB1
- (b) Answer: It is more likely that wards with higher-risk, more frail patients are given more nurses in the first place, and these same patients are more likely to fall anyway - so patient risk may be causing both higher nurse numbers and more falls, not nurse numbers causing falls.
- (c) identifies patient frailty/risk level (or similar) as a factor affecting both nurse numbers and fall riskB1
- (c) expresses this as a case of reverse causation (fall risk influences staffing, rather than staffing influencing fall risk), oeB1
- (c) Answer: Wards are likely staffed with more nurses because their patients are already more frail or at higher risk of falling - so the higher risk of falling is causing the higher nurse numbers (reverse causation), rather than nurse numbers causing the falls.
Question 40
- (a) Sxy = -300B1
- (a) Sxx = 187.3 (awrt), or 562/3B1
- (a) Syy = 526B1
- (a) Answer: Sxy = -300, Sxx = 187.3 (4 sf), Syy = 526
- (b) r = -300 / √187.33... * 526, oe, ft from (a)M1
- (b) -0.956 (3 sf)A1
- (b) Answer: -0.956
- (c) identifies a strong negative correlation/associationB1
- (c) correct context, e.g. teenagers who watched more TV tended to get lower fitness scores, oeB1
- (c) Answer: There is a strong negative correlation - teenagers who watched more hours of TV per week tended to get lower fitness test scores.
Question 41
- (a) paired data from the same individuals is needed to see whether screen time and sleep duration are linked for each person, so a correlation can be calculated, oeB1
- (a) Answer: Correlation can only be measured between two variables recorded for the same individuals, so both measurements must come from the same teenagers.
- (b) one school is not representative of all teenagers (e.g. differences in area/school rules), and volunteers may not be typical, oeB1
- (b) Answer: Teenagers at one school (and volunteers in particular) may not be representative of teenagers generally, e.g. because of differences in school rules or the type of pupils who volunteer.
- (c) r (the product moment correlation coefficient) caoB1
- (c) gives a reason, e.g. r gives an exact numerical value that can be compared precisely, whereas a visual description is subjective, oeB1
- (c) Answer: r (the product moment correlation coefficient); it gives a precise numerical value, whereas describing a graph by eye is more subjective.
- (d) correctly interprets r = -0.7 as a fairly strong negative correlation, e.g. teenagers with more screen time tend to sleep lessB1
- (d) identifies that this does not prove causation, e.g. a confounding variable such as a late bedtime routine or high stress/workload could affect both screen time and sleep durationB1
- (d) Answer: r = -0.7 shows a fairly strong negative correlation - more screen time is linked with less sleep - but this does not prove screens cause poor sleep, since a confounding factor (e.g. a generally late bedtime routine, or high stress/workload) could independently affect both.
Question 42
- correctly reads r = 0.97 as a very strong positive correlation between the two variablesB1
- states that even a very strong correlation does not by itself establish causationB1
- identifies a plausible confounding variable, e.g. national wealth/investment in research, which could independently raise both chocolate consumption and university research fundingB1
- notes that the data is collected at the level of whole countries, so it says nothing about whether an individual person eating more chocolate improves their own brainpowerB1
- suggests what further evidence or research design would be needed to test a causal claim properly, e.g. controlling for national wealth, or a controlled experiment on individualsB1
- reaches a balanced overall conclusion that the newspaper's causal claim is not supported by the correlation aloneB1
- Answer: r = 0.97 shows a very strong positive correlation between the two country-level variables, but even a very strong correlation does not establish causation. National wealth is a plausible confounding variable: wealthier countries may be able to afford both more chocolate and better-funded universities. Country-level data does not show whether an individual eating more chocolate improves their brainpower. Further research could control for national wealth, and a controlled experiment on individuals would be needed to test the claim about eating chocolate and brainpower. The newspaper's causal claim is not supported by this correlation alone.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.