Recognising Misleading Graphs (Higher) - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
46 original exam-style questions - 31 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Recognising Misleading Graphs (Higher) revision guideMore GCSE Statistics practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 1 of GCSE Statistics Higher Topic Workbook 3 and chapter 16 of GCSE Statistics Higher 10-Minute Tests 1.
2.8 Recognising Misleading Graphs (Higher)
(a) Work out how many times taller the Year 2 bar looks than the Year 1 bar.
(b) Work out the true ratio of Year 2 sales to Year 1 sales, to 2 decimal places.
(c) Explain why the graph is misleading.
(a) Work out the percentage increase between the two months shown, to 1 decimal place.
(b) State one way the choice of period makes the chart misleading.
(a) Work out how many times taller the Year 2 bar looks than the Year 1 bar.
(b) Work out the true ratio of Year 2 sales to Year 1 sales, to 2 decimal places.
(c) Explain why the graph is misleading.
| Class (minutes) | Frequency density |
|---|---|
| 10 < x ≤ 30 | 4 |
| 30 < x ≤ 40 | 4 |
| 40 < x ≤ 70 | 5 |
| 70 < x ≤ 75 | 1 |
| 75 < x ≤ 85 | 1 |
(a) Work out the frequency for each class.
(b) Work out the total frequency.
(a) Work out how many times taller the Year 2 bar looks than the Year 1 bar.
(b) Work out the true ratio of Year 2 sales to Year 1 sales, to 2 decimal places.
(c) Explain why the graph is misleading.
(a) By what factor is the area of the symbol multiplied?
(b) Explain why this is misleading.
| Class (minutes) | Frequency | Class width |
|---|---|---|
| 10 < x ≤ 30 | 40 | 20 |
| 30 < x ≤ 40 | 50 | 10 |
| 40 < x ≤ 45 | 5 | 5 |
| 45 < x ≤ 55 | 40 | 10 |
| 55 < x ≤ 85 | 60 | 30 |
(a) Work out the frequency density for each class.
(b) State the class that has the tallest bar.
(a) Work out how many times taller the Year 2 bar looks than the Year 1 bar.
(b) Work out the true ratio of Year 2 sales to Year 1 sales, to 2 decimal places.
(c) Explain why the graph is misleading.
| Class (kg) | Frequency |
|---|---|
| 10 < x ≤ 30 | 20 |
| 30 < x ≤ 50 | 80 |
| 50 < x ≤ 60 | 80 |
| 60 < x ≤ 100 | 80 |
| 100 < x ≤ 130 | 150 |
A histogram is drawn from this table. Use it to estimate the number of values greater than 115. Assume the values are spread evenly within each class.
(a) Work out the percentage increase between the two months shown, to 1 decimal place.
(b) State one way the choice of period makes the chart misleading.
| Class (kg) | Frequency density |
|---|---|
| 10 < x ≤ 20 | 2.5 |
| 20 < x ≤ 40 | 2 |
| 40 < x ≤ 80 | 6 |
| 80 < x ≤ 85 | 5 |
| 85 < x ≤ 95 | 2.5 |
(a) Work out the frequency for each class.
(b) Work out the total frequency.
| Class (pounds) | Frequency density |
|---|---|
| 0 < x ≤ 10 | 4 |
| 10 < x ≤ 30 | 2 |
| 30 < x ≤ 70 | 1 |
| 70 < x ≤ 100 | 2 |
| 100 < x ≤ 105 | 2 |
(a) Work out the frequency for each class.
(b) Work out the total frequency.
| Class (minutes) | Frequency density |
|---|---|
| 0 < x ≤ 20 | 3 |
| 20 < x ≤ 40 | 0.5 |
| 40 < x ≤ 70 | 2 |
| 70 < x ≤ 110 | 4 |
| 110 < x ≤ 115 | 4 |
(a) Work out the frequency for each class.
(b) Work out the total frequency.
| Class (pounds) | Frequency | Class width |
|---|---|---|
| 0 < x ≤ 40 | 80 | 40 |
| 40 < x ≤ 50 | 40 | 10 |
| 50 < x ≤ 60 | 5 | 10 |
| 60 < x ≤ 80 | 60 | 20 |
| 80 < x ≤ 100 | 30 | 20 |
(a) Work out the frequency density for each class.
(b) State the class that has the tallest bar.
(a) Work out the percentage increase between the two months shown, to 1 decimal place.
(b) State one way the choice of period makes the chart misleading.
| Class (kg) | Frequency |
|---|---|
| 0 < x ≤ 40 | 240 |
| 40 < x ≤ 60 | 80 |
| 60 < x ≤ 65 | 10 |
| 65 < x ≤ 95 | 300 |
| 95 < x ≤ 105 | 30 |
A histogram is drawn from this table. Use it to estimate the number of values greater than 100. Assume the values are spread evenly within each class.
| Class (years) | Frequency |
|---|---|
| 10 < x ≤ 20 | 30 |
| 20 < x ≤ 50 | 240 |
| 50 < x ≤ 70 | 100 |
| 70 < x ≤ 110 | 200 |
| 110 < x ≤ 120 | 50 |
A histogram is drawn from this table. Use it to estimate the number of values greater than 60. Assume the values are spread evenly within each class.
(a) Work out how many times taller the Year 2 bar looks than the Year 1 bar.
(b) Work out the true ratio of Year 2 sales to Year 1 sales, to 2 decimal places.
(c) Explain why the graph is misleading.
| Class (minutes) | Frequency | Class width |
|---|---|---|
| 10 < x ≤ 30 | 20 | 20 |
| 30 < x ≤ 50 | 80 | 20 |
| 50 < x ≤ 80 | 30 | 30 |
| 80 < x ≤ 85 | 5 | 5 |
| 85 < x ≤ 125 | 40 | 40 |
(a) Work out the frequency density for each class.
(b) State the class that has the tallest bar.
| Class (minutes) | Frequency | Class width |
|---|---|---|
| 10 < x ≤ 30 | 20 | 20 |
| 30 < x ≤ 60 | 60 | 30 |
| 60 < x ≤ 70 | 30 | 10 |
| 70 < x ≤ 80 | 40 | 10 |
| 80 < x ≤ 120 | 120 | 40 |
(a) Work out the frequency density for each class.
(b) State the class that has the tallest bar.
(a) Work out the percentage increase between the two months shown, to 1 decimal place.
(b) State one way the choice of period makes the chart misleading.
| Class (pounds) | Frequency density |
|---|---|
| 0 < x ≤ 10 | 2 |
| 10 < x ≤ 15 | 6 |
| 15 < x ≤ 55 | 2 |
| 55 < x ≤ 75 | 2 |
| 75 < x ≤ 105 | 2 |
(a) Work out the frequency for each class.
(b) Work out the total frequency.
| Class (years) | Frequency | Class width |
|---|---|---|
| 0 < x ≤ 40 | 60 | 40 |
| 40 < x ≤ 70 | 60 | 30 |
| 70 < x ≤ 90 | 10 | 20 |
| 90 < x ≤ 100 | 10 | 10 |
| 100 < x ≤ 110 | 10 | 10 |
(a) Work out the frequency density for each class.
(b) State the class that has the tallest bar.
| Class (years) | Frequency density |
|---|---|
| 0 < x ≤ 20 | 5 |
| 20 < x ≤ 30 | 8 |
| 30 < x ≤ 50 | 5 |
| 50 < x ≤ 80 | 10 |
| 80 < x ≤ 85 | 5 |
(a) Work out the frequency for each class.
(b) Work out the total frequency.
| Class (kg) | Frequency | Class width |
|---|---|---|
| 10 < x ≤ 15 | 25 | 5 |
| 15 < x ≤ 25 | 30 | 10 |
| 25 < x ≤ 55 | 120 | 30 |
| 55 < x ≤ 65 | 20 | 10 |
| 65 < x ≤ 85 | 40 | 20 |
(a) Work out the frequency density for each class.
(b) State the class that has the tallest bar.
(a) Work out how many times taller the Year 2 bar looks than the Year 1 bar.
(b) Work out the true ratio of Year 2 sales to Year 1 sales, to 2 decimal places.
(c) Explain why the graph is misleading.
| Class (pounds) | Frequency | Class width |
|---|---|---|
| 0 < x ≤ 5 | 10 | 5 |
| 5 < x ≤ 15 | 30 | 10 |
| 15 < x ≤ 35 | 40 | 20 |
| 35 < x ≤ 45 | 20 | 10 |
| 45 < x ≤ 85 | 40 | 40 |
(a) Work out the frequency density for each class.
(b) State the class that has the tallest bar.
| Class (minutes) | Frequency density |
|---|---|
| 0 < x ≤ 30 | 3 |
| 30 < x ≤ 40 | 4 |
| 40 < x ≤ 60 | 5 |
| 60 < x ≤ 80 | 2.5 |
| 80 < x ≤ 85 | 2 |
(a) Work out the frequency for each class.
(b) Work out the total frequency.
(a) Work out the percentage increase between the two months shown, to 1 decimal place.
(b) State one way the choice of period makes the chart misleading.
| Class (minutes) | Frequency | Class width |
|---|---|---|
| 0 < x ≤ 20 | 100 | 20 |
| 20 < x ≤ 40 | 20 | 20 |
| 40 < x ≤ 80 | 160 | 40 |
| 80 < x ≤ 90 | 10 | 10 |
| 90 < x ≤ 120 | 30 | 30 |
(a) Work out the frequency density for each class.
(b) State the class that has the tallest bar.
| Month | Jan | Feb | Mar | Apr | May |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Downloads (1000s) | 20 | 22 | 24 | 26 | 29 |
Graph R plots this data with the five months spaced equally along the horizontal axis. Graph S plots the same data and the same vertical axis, but the horizontal gap between April and May is drawn much narrower than the equal gaps used between the earlier months.
| Time (minutes) | 20-30 | 30-40 | 40-60 | 60-100 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Frequency | 12 | 18 | 20 | 10 |
A poster for the event plots these frequencies directly as bar heights on a chart, with time on the horizontal axis, so wider classes are also drawn as wider bars, without adjusting for the different class widths.
| Price (£1000s) | 100-150 | 150-200 | 200-300 | 300-500 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Frequency | 20 | 24 | 24 | 12 |
The website plots these frequencies directly as bar heights, with price on the horizontal axis, without adjusting for the different class widths.
Question 1
- (i) True caoB1
- (i) Answer: True
- (ii) False caoB1
- (ii) Answer: False
- (iii) False caoB1
- (iii) Answer: False
- (iv) True caoB1
- (iv) Answer: True
Question 2
- (80 - 40) / (72 - 40)M1
- 1.25 caoA1
- 1.11 caoB1
- the vertical axis does not start at zero, which exaggerates the differenceB1
- Answer: (a) 1.25; (b) 1.11; (c) axis does not start at zero, exaggerating the difference
Question 3
- Is frequency density (frequency divided by class width), rather than frequency, plotted on the vertical axis for classes of unequal width?B1
- Does the area of each bar (not just its height) correctly represent the frequency for that class?B1
- Does the vertical axis start at zero, with equally spaced numbers marked on it?B1
- Is the chart clearly labelled with a title, units and axis labels, so the class widths cannot be misread? (oe - accept any four valid checks, e.g. whether bars are drawn to a consistent scale, or whether the sample size/source is stated)B1
- Answer: e.g. (1) Is frequency density plotted, not frequency, for unequal-width classes? (2) Does bar area represent frequency? (3) Does the vertical axis start at 0 with equal intervals? (4) Is the chart fully labelled?
Question 4
- 10 / 367 x 100M1
- 2.7% caoA1
- only a short period is shown, which hides the overall fall (cherry-picking)B1
- Answer: (a) 2.7%; (b) short period hides the overall trend
Question 5
- (81 - 50) / (76 - 50)M1
- 1.19 caoA1
- 1.07 caoB1
- the vertical axis does not start at zero, which exaggerates the differenceB1
- Answer: (a) 1.19; (b) 1.07; (c) axis does not start at zero, exaggerating the difference
Question 6
- frequency = frequency density x class widthM1
- at least 3 frequencies correctA1
- all frequencies 80, 40, 150, 5, 10 caoA1
- total 285B1
- Answer: (a) 80, 40, 150, 5, 10; (b) 285
Question 7
- (57 - 40) / (53 - 40)M1
- 1.31 caoA1
- 1.08 caoB1
- the vertical axis does not start at zero, which exaggerates the differenceB1
- Answer: (a) 1.31; (b) 1.08; (c) axis does not start at zero, exaggerating the difference
Question 8
- 2 x 2M1
- 4 caoA1
- the area is 4 times larger, so the increase looks bigger than 2 timesB1
- Answer: (a) 4; (b) the area grows 4 times, exaggerating a 2 times increase
Question 9
- frequency divided by class widthM1
- at least 3 frequency densities correctA1
- all frequency densities correctA1
- 30 < x ≤ 40B1
- Answer: (a) 2, 5, 1, 4, 2; (b) 30 < x ≤ 40
Question 10
- (86 - 50) / (80 - 50)M1
- 1.20 caoA1
- 1.08 caoB1
- the vertical axis does not start at zero, which exaggerates the differenceB1
- Answer: (a) 1.20; (b) 1.08; (c) axis does not start at zero, exaggerating the difference
Question 11
- frequency density for the class 100 to 130 = 150/30M1
- finds the width above 115 within the final class: 130 - 115 = 15, oeM1
- multiplies this width by the frequency density: 15 x 5, or equivalently 150 x (130 - 115)/(130 - 100); no later classes need addingM1
- 75 caoA1
- Answer: 75
Question 12
- 38 / 105 x 100M1
- 36.2% caoA1
- only a short period is shown, which hides the overall fall (cherry-picking)B1
- Answer: (a) 36.2%; (b) short period hides the overall trend
Question 13
- frequency = frequency density x class widthM1
- at least 3 frequencies correctA1
- all frequencies 25, 40, 240, 25, 25 caoA1
- total 355B1
- Answer: (a) 25, 40, 240, 25, 25; (b) 355
Question 14
- frequency = frequency density x class widthM1
- at least 3 frequencies correctA1
- all frequencies 40, 40, 40, 60, 10 caoA1
- total 190B1
- Answer: (a) 40, 40, 40, 60, 10; (b) 190
Question 15
- frequency = frequency density x class widthM1
- at least 3 frequencies correctA1
- all frequencies 60, 10, 60, 160, 20 caoA1
- total 310B1
- Answer: (a) 60, 10, 60, 160, 20; (b) 310
Question 16
- frequency divided by class widthM1
- at least 3 frequency densities correctA1
- all frequency densities correctA1
- 40 < x ≤ 50B1
- Answer: (a) 2, 4, 0.5, 3, 1.5; (b) 40 < x ≤ 50
Question 17
- 30 / 264 x 100M1
- 11.4% caoA1
- only a short period is shown, which hides the overall fall (cherry-picking)B1
- Answer: (a) 11.4%; (b) short period hides the overall trend
Question 18
- frequency density for the class 95 to 105 = 30/10M1
- finds the width above 100 within the final class: 105 - 100 = 5, oeM1
- multiplies this width by the frequency density: 5 x 3, or equivalently 30 x (105 - 100)/(105 - 95); no later classes need addingM1
- 15 caoA1
- Answer: 15
Question 19
- frequency density for the class 50 to 70 = 100/20M1
- 10 x 5 for the part of the class above 60M1
- adds the frequencies of all later classesM1
- 300 caoA1
- Answer: 300
Question 20
- (64 - 45) / (59 - 45)M1
- 1.36 caoA1
- 1.08 caoB1
- the vertical axis does not start at zero, which exaggerates the differenceB1
- Answer: (a) 1.36; (b) 1.08; (c) axis does not start at zero, exaggerating the difference
Question 21
- frequency divided by class widthM1
- at least 3 frequency densities correctA1
- all frequency densities correctA1
- 30 < x ≤ 50B1
- Answer: (a) 1, 4, 1, 1, 1; (b) 30 < x ≤ 50
Question 22
- frequency divided by class widthM1
- at least 3 frequency densities correctA1
- all frequency densities correctA1
- 70 < x ≤ 80B1
- Answer: (a) 1, 2, 3, 4, 3; (b) 70 < x ≤ 80
Question 23
- 16 / 302 x 100M1
- 5.3% caoA1
- only a short period is shown, which hides the overall fall (cherry-picking)B1
- Answer: (a) 5.3%; (b) short period hides the overall trend
Question 24
- frequency = frequency density x class widthM1
- at least 3 frequencies correctA1
- all frequencies 20, 30, 80, 40, 60 caoA1
- total 230B1
- Answer: (a) 20, 30, 80, 40, 60; (b) 230
Question 25
- frequency divided by class widthM1
- at least 3 frequency densities correctA1
- all frequency densities correctA1
- 40 < x ≤ 70B1
- Answer: (a) 1.5, 2, 0.5, 1, 1; (b) 40 < x ≤ 70
Question 26
- frequency = frequency density x class widthM1
- at least 3 frequencies correctA1
- all frequencies 100, 80, 100, 300, 25 caoA1
- total 605B1
- Answer: (a) 100, 80, 100, 300, 25; (b) 605
Question 27
- frequency divided by class widthM1
- at least 3 frequency densities correctA1
- all frequency densities correctA1
- 10 < x ≤ 15B1
- Answer: (a) 5, 3, 4, 2, 2; (b) 10 < x ≤ 15
Question 28
- (79 - 40) / (77 - 40)M1
- 1.05 caoA1
- 1.03 caoB1
- the vertical axis does not start at zero, which exaggerates the differenceB1
- Answer: (a) 1.05; (b) 1.03; (c) axis does not start at zero, exaggerating the difference
Question 29
- frequency divided by class widthM1
- at least 3 frequency densities correctA1
- all frequency densities correctA1
- 5 < x ≤ 15B1
- Answer: (a) 2, 3, 2, 2, 1; (b) 5 < x ≤ 15
Question 30
- frequency = frequency density x class widthM1
- at least 3 frequencies correctA1
- all frequencies 90, 40, 100, 50, 10 caoA1
- total 290B1
- Answer: (a) 90, 40, 100, 50, 10; (b) 290
Question 31
- 15 / 172 x 100M1
- 8.7% caoA1
- only a short period is shown, which hides the overall fall (cherry-picking)B1
- Answer: (a) 8.7%; (b) short period hides the overall trend
Question 32
- frequency divided by class widthM1
- at least 3 frequency densities correctA1
- all frequency densities correctA1
- 0 < x ≤ 20B1
- Answer: (a) 5, 1, 4, 1, 1; (b) 0 < x ≤ 20
Question 33
- (a) Oakdale = 64 and Ferrytown = 70, both caoB1
- (a) Answer: Oakdale = 64, Ferrytown = 70
- (b) identifies that the vertical axis starts at 60, not 0 (a truncated/non-zero axis)B1
- (b) explains this makes the real difference of 6 plants look much bigger than it really is, since the Ferrytown bar is drawn far taller even though it is only a small amount moreB1
- (b) Answer: The vertical axis starts at 60 instead of 0, so the small true difference of 6 plants (64 compared with 70) is stretched to fill most of the chart, making Ferrytown's sales look far higher than Oakdale's.
- (c) suggests starting the vertical axis at 0 (instead of 60)B1
- (c) explains that on a 0 to 72 scale the two bars would then be almost the same height (64 out of 72, and 70 out of 72), giving a fair impression that matches the true difference of about 9%, instead of looking two and a half times as bigB1
- (c) Answer: Redraw the chart with the vertical axis starting at 0. On a 0 to 72 scale, Oakdale's bar would reach 64/72 of the height and Ferrytown's would reach 70/72, so the bars would look almost the same height, fairly reflecting the true 6-plant (about 9%) difference.
Question 34
- (a) (29-26)/26 x 100, oeM1
- (a) awrt 11.5%A1
- (a) Answer: 11.5%
- (b) identifies that squeezing the horizontal distance between April and May, while the vertical rise stays the same size, makes that part of the line much steeper on the page than the earlier, equally-spaced monthsB1
- (b) explains a reader could interpret this steep, near-vertical section as a sudden dramatic jump, when the true increase (about 11.5%) is only slightly bigger than the rate of increase in the earlier, fairly spaced months (rises of 2 thousand each month, about 8% to 10%)B1
- (b) Answer: Compressing the April-May gap keeps the same vertical rise but squeezes it into a much shorter horizontal distance, so the line becomes much steeper there than in the rest of the graph; a reader could easily read this as a sudden, dramatic surge, when the true increase of about 11.5% is only a little larger than the roughly steady rate of increase shown in the earlier months.
- (c) suggests spacing all five months equally along the horizontal axis (in proportion to the equal time gap between each pair of months)B1
- (c) explains that equal time gaps mean the slope drawn between each pair of points fairly reflects the true rate of change, so no part of the trend is exaggerated relative to anotherB1
- (c) Answer: Space Jan, Feb, Mar, Apr and May equally along the horizontal axis, since each represents the same one-month time gap; this way, the steepness of the line between any two months fairly reflects the true rate of change, and no single month-to-month rise is exaggerated compared with the others.
Question 35
- (a) 3.14 x 12, oeM1
- (a) 3.14 cm2 caoA1
- (a) Answer: 3.14 cm2
- (b) 3.14 x 32, oeM1
- (b) 28.26 cm2 caoA1
- (b) Answer: 28.26 cm2
- (c) correctly finds the area ratio 28.26 : 3.14 = 9 : 1, compared with the money ratio of 6000 : 2000 = 3 : 1B1
- (c) explains the Year 2 coin looks nine times as big as the Year 1 coin, even though only three times as much money was raised, exaggerating how much more successful Year 2 wasB1
- (c) Answer: The area ratio is 28.26 : 3.14 = 9 : 1, but the true amount-raised ratio is only 3 : 1; tripling the radius makes the picture look nine times bigger, so the poster exaggerates how much Year 2's fundraising improved on Year 1's.
- (d) valid method, e.g. keep every coin the same fixed size and draw three identical coins for Year 2 for every one coin used for Year 1, or scale the AREA of a single coin directly in proportion to the amount raised (so the area ratio is exactly 3 : 1) rather than scaling the radiusB1
- (d) explains why the suggested method is fairer, e.g. repeating identical, equally-sized coins means the number of coins (not their size) shows the multiple, so the visual impression matches the data exactlyB1
- (d) Answer: Keep the coin the same fixed size throughout, and show Year 2 with three identical coins for every one coin used for Year 1; since every coin is now the same size, the number of coins shown is directly proportional to the amount raised, giving a fair visual impression.
Question 36
- (a) 60/200 x 100, oeM1
- (a) 30% caoA1
- (a) Answer: 30%
- (b) 45 + 35 + 25 + 15, oeM1
- (b) 120%, correctly identified as not equal to 100%A1
- (b) Answer: 120%
- (c) explains that because the percentages sum to 120% rather than 100%, every sector has effectively been labelled with too large a share of the whole, so the chart no longer fairly represents parts of a single complete set of 200 customersB1
- (c) explains that the added 3D tilt makes the sector drawn nearest the front of the chart look even bigger than its (already inflated) printed percentage, distorting the comparison between drinks still furtherB1
- (c) Answer: Because the printed percentages add up to 120% instead of 100%, every sector's labelled share is inflated beyond its true proportion of the 200 customers, so the parts no longer fairly represent the whole; on top of this, the 3D tilt makes whichever sector faces the viewer look even larger than its stated percentage, distorting the comparison between drinks further.
- (d) recalculate the sector angles/percentages directly from the true frequencies (80, 60, 40, 20 out of 200) so they sum to exactly 100% (360 degrees)B1
- (d) redraw the chart as a flat 2D pie chart instead of a 3D oneB1
- (d) Answer: (1) Recalculate each sector from the true frequencies out of 200, so the percentages sum to exactly 100%. (2) Redraw the pie chart as a flat 2D chart instead of a 3D one.
Question 37
- (a) 2 : 1 caoB1
- (a) Answer: 2 : 1
- (b) (2 x 2) : (1 x 1), oeM1
- (b) 4 : 1 caoA1
- (b) Answer: 4 : 1
- (c) identifies that a reader's eye naturally compares the overall size (area) of bars, not just their heightB1
- (c) explains the extra width makes the Pop bar look four times as big as the Jazz bar, when truly only twice as many albums were sold; every bar in a fair bar chart should be drawn the same width, with only the height varyingB1
- (c) Answer: A reader naturally judges bars by their overall size, not just their height, so making the Pop bar twice as wide as well as twice as tall makes it look four times as big as the Jazz bar, when really only twice as many albums were sold. In a fair bar chart every bar should be the same width, with only the height showing the value.
Question 38
- (a) 12/10 and 10/40, oeM1
- (a) 1.2 and 0.25 both shown correctlyA1
- (a) Answer: 1.2 and 0.25
- (b) identifies that because bar width also varies here, the area of each bar (not just its height) is what a reader visually judges as the amount of runners, and area = frequency x width once widths differ, not just frequencyB1
- (b) explains this makes the wide 60-100 class look like it takes up a similar visual area to the 40-60 class, even though it contains only half as many runners (10, compared with 20)B1
- (b) Answer: Because the class widths are unequal, plotting raw frequency as the bar height means the visual area of each bar is frequency multiplied by width, not frequency alone; this makes the wide 60-100 bar (10 runners, width 40) occupy a visual area similar to the 40-60 bar (20 runners, width 20), even though the 60-100 class actually has only half as many runners.
- (c) 20/20, oeM1
- (c) 1 (frequency density), correctly compared with the 60-100 class's 0.25 to show 40-60 is four times as densely packed with runners per minuteA1
- (c) Answer: The 40-60 class has frequency density 1, compared with 0.25 for the 60-100 class, so 40-60 has four times the concentration of runners per minute - confirming it is the more populous interval per minute, despite the misleading chart making the two classes look similarly sized.
- (d) frequency density (frequency divided by class width)B1
- (d) Answer: Frequency density (frequency divided by class width)
Question 39
- (a) valid decision suggested, e.g. which networks or sources to include, how many adverts to sample, or what counts as a 'bar chart' for this investigationB1
- (a) valid reason linked to getting a fair, representative sample or a workable, consistent definitionB1
- (a) Answer: e.g. Priya should decide in advance exactly how many adverts and from how many different networks she will look at, so that her sample is a consistent size and is not chosen to fit whatever result she expects to find.
- (b) 3/5 caoB1
- (b) Answer: 3/5
- (c) 9/15 x 100, oeM1
- (c) 60% caoA1
- (c) Answer: 60%
- (d) identifies a possible limitation of the sample, e.g. it may only cover a small number of networks, a short time period, or adverts from a single source, so it may not be representative of all data plan advertsB1
- (d) suggests a valid improvement, e.g. a bigger and more varied sample (more networks, more adverts, over a longer time period) would give more reliable evidenceB1
- (d) explains that 60% is a statistic about Priya's sample only, and does not automatically prove a fact about every phone data plan advert that existsB1
- (d) Answer: A sample of only 15 adverts, possibly from a small number of networks or a short time window, may not represent all phone data plan advertising; a bigger, more varied sample (more networks, more adverts, over a longer period) would give more reliable evidence. Even a correctly worked out 60% is a fact about Priya's own sample, not automatic proof about every advert that has ever been produced.
Question 40
- (a) 20/10, oeM1
- (a) 2 (times) caoA1
- (a) Answer: 2 times
- (b) identifies that the two vertical axes use very different scales and units (temperature in °C, drinks sold as a count), chosen deliberately so the lines coincideB1
- (b) explains a reader could wrongly think the two quantities are directly linked, matched, or of similar size, without noticing the mismatched scales - drinks sold are actually always twice the temperature value, not literally equal to itB1
- (b) Answer: The left axis (0 to 50) and right axis (0 to 100) use completely different scales and units, chosen so the two lines exactly coincide; a reader glancing at the graph could think temperature and drinks sold are closely matched or directly linked in size, without noticing that drinks sold are actually always double the temperature reading in this data set.
- (c) valid method, e.g. plot the paired values as a scatter graph of temperature against drinks sold, or clearly label both axes with their true scales so a reader can see they are differentB1
- (c) explains this fairer method lets the reader judge the true relationship from the paired values, rather than being misled by a coincidental visual match caused by the choice of axesB1
- (c) Answer: Plot the data as a scatter graph of temperature against drinks sold (one point per hour), rather than as two separate lines on mismatched axes; this way a reader can judge the true relationship directly from the paired values, instead of being misled by a visual overlap that was only created by choosing two very different axis scales.
Question 41
- (a) (45-20)/20 x 100, oeM1
- (a) 125% caoA1
- (a) Answer: 125%
- (b) the vertical axis starts at 12, not 0 (a truncated axis)B1
- (b) the Q4 bar is drawn wider than the other three bars (inconsistent bar width), adding extra visual area beyond the true height differenceB1
- (b) Answer: (1) The vertical axis starts at 12, not 0. (2) The Q4 bar is drawn twice as wide as the Q1, Q2 and Q3 bars, giving it extra visual area on top of its already-taller height.
- (c) start the vertical axis at 0B1
- (c) make every bar (including Q4) the same widthB1
- (c) explains that equal bar widths and a zero baseline make bar heights proportional to the actual values: Q4 is 3 times Q1 and 2.25 times Q3 (a 125% increase from Q3), without extra visual exaggerationB1
- (c) Answer: Redraw the chart with the vertical axis starting at 0, and make the Q4 bar the same width as Q1, Q2 and Q3. Q4's height would then be proportional to its value: 45/15 = 3 times Q1 and 45/20 = 2.25 times Q3, showing the true 125% increase from Q3 without extra visual exaggeration.
Question 42
- (a) (25-13)/13 x 100, oeM1
- (a) awrt 92.3%A1
- (a) Answer: 92.3%
- (b) explains that a taller, more stretched vertical scale makes the same rise cover a bigger visual angle, so the line looks steeperB1
- (b) explains that none of the numbers or data have changed at all; only the proportions of the drawn axes have changed, so the 'steepness' a reader sees is a drawing choice, not a fact about the dataB1
- (b) Answer: Stretching the vertical axis spreads the same numerical rise over a much bigger vertical distance on the page, so the line covers a steeper angle for the same true change; but the actual profit figures have not changed at all, so how steep the trend looks depends on the axes chosen, not on the underlying data.
- (c) valid method, e.g. calculate the actual percentage or numerical change between points directly from the data, rather than judging steepness by eyeB1
- (c) correct supporting reason, e.g. a calculated percentage change does not depend on how the axes are drawn, so it gives a fair comparison whatever aspect ratio the graph usesB1
- (c) Answer: Calculate the actual percentage change between the points directly from the figures, rather than judging the trend by how steep the line looks; a calculated percentage does not depend on how tall, narrow, short or wide the axes are drawn, so it gives a fair, consistent comparison.
Question 43
- (a) 8 cm3 caoB1
- (a) Answer: 8 cm3
- (b) 64 cm3 caoB1
- (b) Answer: 64 cm3
- (c) correctly finds the volume ratio 64 : 8 = 8 : 1, compared with the true profit ratio of 16000 : 8000 = 2 : 1B1
- (c) explains that scaling all three dimensions of the cube by the same factor cubes the visual effect, so Branch B's cube looks eight times as big by volume even though it made only twice the profit - a bigger distortion than scaling a flat shape's areaB1
- (c) Answer: The volume ratio is 64 : 8 = 8 : 1, but the true profit ratio is only 2 : 1; doubling every side of the cube makes its volume eight times as big (since 23 = 8), so Branch B's cube looks eight times bigger even though it made only twice as much profit - a far bigger distortion than resizing a flat 2D shape would give.
- (d) attempts the cube root of 2 (the side-length scale factor that would double the volume), oe, or an alternative method (e.g. repeating equally-sized cubes in a ratio of 2 : 1 for Branch B against Branch A)M1
- (d) cube root of 2 awrt 1.26; or calculates 16000/8000 = 2 (profit ratio B : A = 2 : 1) to justify using two identical cubes for B for every one for AA1
- (d) correctly applies this to state the fairer side length, awrt 2.52 cm (= 2 x 1.26), or gives a fully justified equal-icon alternative (e.g. keep the cube a fixed size and draw two identical cubes for Branch B for every one used for Branch A, so the icon count is exactly proportional to profit)B1
- (d) Answer: To make the volume exactly double (matching the true 2 : 1 profit ratio), the side length should scale by the cube root of 2, awrt 1.26, giving a fairer side length of about 2.52 cm (2 x 1.26) rather than 4 cm. Alternatively, keep every cube a fixed size and draw two identical cubes for Branch B for every one cube for Branch A, so the number of icons is exactly proportional to the profit.
Question 44
- (a) 24/100 and 12/200, oeM1
- (a) 0.24 and 0.06, both caoA1
- (a) Answer: 0.24 and 0.06
- (b) 24 x 100 and 12 x 200, oeM1
- (b) both equal 2400, correctly concluding the visual areas are equal despite frequencies of 24 and 12 (i.e. the 300-500 class represents exactly half as many houses)A1
- (b) Answer: 24 x 100 = 2400 and 12 x 200 = 2400 - the two bars have the same visual area even though the 300-500 class contains only half as many houses (12, compared with 24) as the 200-300 class.
- (c) identifies the 200-300 class has frequency density 0.24, compared with 0.06 for the 300-500 classB1
- (c) 0.24 / 0.06 = 4, so the 200-300 class is four times as densely packed with houses per £1000 as the 300-500 class, even though the misleading chart makes them look similarly commonB1
- (c) Answer: The 200-300 class has frequency density 0.24, four times the 300-500 class's 0.06 (0.24/0.06 = 4), so house prices are four times as concentrated per £1000 in the 200-300 range, despite the chart making the two classes look like they cover a similar area.
- (d) bar heights should be the frequency densities (0.24 and 0.06), so the 300-500 bar would be drawn much shorter than the 200-300 bar, and the area of each bar (not raw frequency) would then correctly represent the class's frequencyB1
- (d) Answer: The bar heights should be 0.24 and 0.06 (the frequency densities), making the 300-500 bar much shorter than the 200-300 bar; the area of each bar would then correctly represent its true frequency.
Question 45
- (a) (25-21)/21 x 100, oeM1
- (a) awrt 19.0%A1
- (a) Answer: 19.0%
- (b) (25-20)/20 x 100, oeM1
- (b) 25% caoA1
- (b) Answer: 25%
- (c) axis truncation: the vertical axis starts at 20, not 0, stretching the modest gap between 21 and 25 to fill most of the height of the chartB1
- (c) unequal bar width: the Week 6 bar is drawn one and a half times as wide as the Week 5 bar, adding extra visual area beyond the true height differenceB1
- (c) cherry-picked window: showing only Weeks 5 and 6 hides that sign-ups were fairly flat over the first four weeks (20, 21, 19, 22), presenting the final small uptick in isolation as if it were the whole storyB1
- (c) overall conclusion that combining all three features turns a genuinely modest increase of about one-fifth to one-quarter into something that looks like a dramatic surgeB1
- (c) Answer: (1) The vertical axis starts at 20, not 0, stretching the true gap between 21 and 25 to fill most of the chart. (2) The Week 6 bar is drawn 1.5 times as wide as the Week 5 bar, adding extra visual area on top of the height difference. (3) Showing only Weeks 5 and 6 hides that sign-ups were roughly flat for the first four weeks (20, 21, 19, 22), so the small final rise is shown in isolation as if it were a sudden breakthrough. Together, these three choices turn a genuinely modest 19-25% increase into what looks like a dramatic surge in growth.
Question 46
- (a) (6-3)/6 x 100, oeM1
- (a) 50% caoA1
- (a) Answer: 50%
- (b) comments on the presentation: the axis starting at 2 stretches the true (correct) 50% difference further than necessary, and with no source or sample size given, a reader cannot judge how many households, or which households, this data came fromB1
- (b) comments on proof: even a perfectly fair chart of a small or unspecified sample cannot 'prove' cause and effect for an entire campaign, since other explanations (e.g. fewer people buying bottled drinks generally, seasonal changes, or an unrepresentative sample) could also explain the fallB1
- (b) gives a balanced overall conclusion: the 50% figure may well be accurate, but both the chart's presentation and the word 'proves' overstate what a single, unsourced bar chart can honestly establishB1
- (b) Answer: The true decrease is a genuine 50%, but the chart's truncated axis (starting at 2) exaggerates this beyond what is needed, and without a stated source or sample size a reader cannot judge how reliable or representative the data is. Even if the chart were drawn perfectly fairly, a single before-and-after bar chart cannot 'prove' that the campaign caused the fall, since other factors could also explain it. The 50% figure may well be true, but the claim of 'proof' overstates what this chart can honestly demonstrate.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.