LNAT Section B: argument writing - Set 1
Our site-authored practice category for planning a position, developing reasons and answering an objection. This is not an official LNAT strand; one original unscored Section B set is available here, with site-authored guidance. Test standard. 3 essay choices; attempt one in 40 minutes. Unscored.
Download the essay choices (PDF) Download with site guidance (PDF)
- Choose one of the three essays. Attempt only one essay in 40 minutes, including choosing, planning, drafting and checking.
- This is original site-authored Section B practice. It is unscored: the essay does not contribute to the numerical LNAT score. It is supplied to universities in the actual test.
- Answer the question with a reasoned argument. Define terms where needed, develop your reasons and consider a serious objection. No specialist legal or subject knowledge is needed for these prompts; hypothetical examples may be used if clearly identified.
- Read the guidance after your timed attempt. The explanations, rubric bands and indicative content are site-authored guidance for self-review, not official LNAT or university assessment criteria. They carry no numerical marks and require no particular conclusion.
- 1Unscored choice
Should publicly funded museums be free to sell objects that they rarely display?
If chosen: 40 minutes.
- 2Unscored choice
Is it fair for an employer to give priority to applicants who already live near the workplace?
If chosen: 40 minutes.
- 3Unscored choice
Does making a promise give us a reason to act when breaking it would harm no one?
If chosen: 40 minutes.
Writing guidance
These unscored essay choices have no single correct answer. Rubrics and indicative content are site guidance for reviewing your writing.
Essay choice 1
Answer or working Marks Site-authored guidance: this question asks whether rare display is a sufficient basis for allowing a sale, not merely whether museums need money. Define the freedom you are considering: unrestricted choice, or permission subject to conditions. An object can have value through preservation, study or future display even if few visitors currently see it. Equally, retaining it has costs. You can reason about these possibilities without claiming facts about any real museum or its legal powers. A case for allowing sales could begin with public benefit. Suppose a museum holds several similar objects in storage while a damaged gallery remains closed. A sale might fund access to a wider collection. Explain why that use of resources could serve the public better than indefinite retention. Then test the example: a sale might raise little, the objects might have distinct research value, or the buyer might remove all public access. The example supports a conditional argument rather than proving every sale is worthwhile. A case for restricting sales could treat a museum as a custodian for future visitors, including people unable to express a preference now. Rare display need not mean low importance, and an irreversible sale can remove future opportunities. Answer the objection that this position protects stored objects at the expense of present access. Loans, shared storage or transfer to another public collection are possible alternatives, but their availability and costs must be argued rather than assumed. A defensible conclusion could permit sales after an independent assessment of public value and alternatives, or oppose sales while allowing transfers that preserve public access. An argument for wider discretion could instead explain why museum staff should be trusted to judge competing uses of funds. Whichever position you choose, identify who should decide, why rare display matters and which risk outweighs the other. These are possible approaches, not a model answer or a checklist of required views. Rubric: site guidance, not an official mark scheme or numerical score. Answers the question about freedom to sell and explains the relationship between public funding, custody and public benefit; distinguishes rare display from lack of value. Develops reasons with explicit links to the conclusion and uses examples to test claims; treats the strongest competing use of resources or preservation objection fairly. Explains why any proposed conditions would address the identified risks, or why conditions are unnecessary or inadequate; reaches a proportionate conclusion in clear, connected prose. Sustained argument - site guidance Offers a relevant position and some explanation, but leaves the meaning of freedom to sell or public value partly unclear. Considers a competing concern but does not fully weigh it against the main reason; a proposed safeguard or example is asserted rather than examined. Has an intelligible structure, though the conclusion is broader than the reasons establish or some paragraphs repeat the same point. Developing argument - site guidance Lists advantages or disadvantages without explaining why they justify a decision; assumes that objects in storage are worthless or that retention is always beneficial. Leaves a central objection unanswered, relies on unsupported factual claims, or drifts into describing museums without deciding the question. Limited argument - site guidance Indicative content (not exhaustive): Public funding may support a duty to widen present access, a duty to preserve future access, or both. Explain how to decide when these duties conflict. Distinguish sale to a private buyer from a transfer or loan to another public institution; each can change access and control differently. An object rarely displayed might still support study, complete a collection or become valuable for a future exhibition. These possibilities need weighing, not automatic priority. Consider whether sale proceeds should support collection care, public access or general expenses, and whether the purpose changes the justification. Consultation and independent review could reduce conflicts of interest, but cost time and may still misjudge future value. Test a safeguard against the problem it is meant to solve. A reasoned yes, no or conditional answer is possible. Review whether your conclusion follows from your own account of public benefit rather than from this list. Essay choice 2
Answer or working Marks Site-authored guidance: distinguish fairness from convenience and from legality. The question asks for a judgement about a hiring preference, not a report of employment law. Define priority: a tie-break between otherwise comparable applicants is different from excluding everyone outside a boundary. Consider whose claims matter, including applicants, the employer and people who depend on the service. Being nearby need not prove that someone is more suitable. A defence could connect proximity with a relevant need. In a hypothetical job involving urgent call-outs, a short journey might help provide a dependable service. Explain why that benefit could justify a preference and what evidence would make residence a useful indicator. Confront a counterexample: a person farther away may have reliable transport, while a neighbour may be unavailable. A direct requirement about response time might meet the need more fairly than a rule about current address. A challenge could focus on equal opportunity. Applicants may have little control over where they can afford to live, and a preference could repeatedly favour those who already have access to an area. Explain why this matters even if the employer applies the same rule to everyone. Then consider the strongest reply: an employer may reasonably value reliable attendance or the benefits of employing local residents. Address whether those aims justify this particular means, rather than assuming all interests of the employer are irrelevant. A qualified judgement might allow a residence preference only where proximity is essential and a less restrictive test cannot achieve the same aim. Alternatively, a writer could defend a transparent local tie-break because a business has obligations to its surrounding community, or reject address preferences because relevant abilities can be assessed directly. Explain why your chosen criterion is fair and how it treats an applicant willing to relocate. These routes are illustrative; an argued conclusion on any side can be convincing. Rubric: site guidance, not an official mark scheme or numerical score. Offers an explicit account of fairness and applies it to a defined form of priority; distinguishes current residence from the ability to meet a job requirement. Develops the case for a relevant employer or community interest and the objection about unequal opportunity without treating either as decisive by assertion. Uses a hypothetical example or counterexample to examine the proposed rule, weighs alternatives and reaches a clear conclusion whose scope matches the reasons. Sustained argument - site guidance Takes a relevant position, but shifts between exclusion and tie-breaking or leaves the standard of fairness partly implicit. Explains at least one reason and recognises a competing interest, but does not fully examine whether residence is a suitable measure or whether an alternative would work. Organises the discussion intelligibly, with a conclusion that may leave an important exception unexplained. Developing argument - site guidance Equates a short journey with reliability, or labels the rule unfair, without explaining the connection to the decision. Describes hiring practices or asserts legal rules in place of reasoning about fairness; overlooks affected applicants or the legitimate needs of the job. Limited argument - site guidance Indicative content (not exhaustive): Equal application of a rule does not by itself establish equal opportunity. Explain whether and why unequal effects matter in this case. Compare a blanket boundary, a tie-break and a requirement to arrive within a specified time. A reason supporting one need not support all three. Proximity could matter for some urgent duties while being less relevant to work with predictable hours or remote tasks. Use clearly hypothetical examples. An applicant may be willing to relocate. Consider whether current residence tells the employer what it actually needs to know. Local employment could benefit a community, but it could also exclude capable outsiders. Explain whether an employer has a special obligation to local residents and how far it extends. Consider transparency, consistency and a way to demonstrate reliable attendance as possible improvements. Explain whether these remove the underlying fairness objection or only make the process clearer. No knowledge of employment law or preferred political position is required. The conclusion should follow from the fairness principle and trade-offs you have defended. Essay choice 3
Answer or working Marks Site-authored guidance: separate having a reason from having an overriding duty. A promise might count in favour of acting without settling what one must do overall. Also distinguish a genuine voluntary promise from a casual prediction, a promise obtained by coercion or an undertaking whose recipient has released the speaker. Define harm carefully, but engage with the possibility stated in the question rather than answering only that every broken promise secretly causes harm. A case for saying yes could begin with the control a promise gives its recipient. If someone freely undertakes to do something, the other person may gain a claim to its performance even when they suffer no loss from non-performance. For example, imagine an agreed minor task whose omission would disappoint or disadvantage nobody. Explain why the undertaking itself might still matter: it lets people decide what commitments they can make to each other. Then answer the objection that insisting on a pointless act values a form of words above anyone's welfare. A case for saying no could argue that reasons must ultimately connect with people's interests. If no person loses anything, is deceived or has their plans frustrated, the promise may provide no remaining reason to perform. Explain why that account is persuasive rather than treating the absence of harm as self-evidently decisive. Confront the objection that it allows the person who promised to decide unilaterally that another person's claim no longer matters. Asking for release might respect the recipient, although the question remains whether performance has value before release is given. A conclusion might recognise a modest reason to keep a promise that can be outweighed, defend a duty grounded in voluntary commitment, or deny any promise-based reason once all harm is excluded. If you discuss wider damage to trust, distinguish uncertain real situations from the stipulated harmless case. Showing that promises usually prevent harm does not alone establish why this harmless promise matters. These possible conclusions are site-authored suggestions, not required moral beliefs. Rubric: site guidance, not an official mark scheme or numerical score. Answers whether the promise itself supplies a reason in the harmless case; distinguishes a reason from an absolute duty and uses a consistent meaning of harm. Explains a principled case about voluntary commitment or the interests served by promises, and tests it against a serious objection from the other perspective. Uses an example without quietly adding harm back into the premise; acknowledges the limits of the argument and reaches a clear, supported judgement in connected prose. Sustained argument - site guidance Gives a relevant position with some supporting explanation, but sometimes treats having a reason as identical to having an overriding duty. Recognises an objection yet leaves the basis of the promise or the definition of harm unclear; an example only partly tests the stated harmless case. Has a recognisable progression, though the conclusion does not fully resolve the tension raised by the objection. Developing argument - site guidance Repeats that promises should be kept or that harmless acts do not matter without explaining why; substitutes a moral slogan for an argument. Discusses only harmful breaches, assumes an opposing position must be dishonest, or gives a conclusion unrelated to the question's distinction. Limited argument - site guidance Indicative content (not exhaustive): A promise can be understood as a voluntary commitment to another person. Consider whether creating that relationship provides a reason independent of consequences. Permission to withdraw differs from deciding for oneself that withdrawal is harmless. Explain whether the recipient has authority to release the speaker and why that matters. An account based on welfare can explain many useful promises. Test whether it leaves anything to explain when every harmful effect is excluded. Loss of trust, disappointment and inconvenience may be harms in ordinary cases. They cannot simply be smuggled into an example stipulated to harm no one. Consider whether a reason can remain even when another reason defeats it, such as avoiding a waste of time. The question need not be read as demanding unconditional obedience. A writer may challenge whether complete harmlessness can be known in practice, but should also address what follows if it is granted for the argument. No philosophical names, theories or quotations are needed. A reasoned yes, no or qualified answer can succeed; evaluate the reasoning rather than agreement with these suggestions.