TARA Critical Thinking: Applying principles, set 1
Extracting the general rule an argument relies on, then finding the other case that the same rule decides. Test standard. 12 questions, 12 marks, about 22 minutes.
Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)
- Answer all twelve questions. No calculator.
- Assume the reasons given in each argument are true. Identify the general recommendation supporting its conclusion, then apply that recommendation to a different case.
- Each question has five options and exactly one correct answer. Each correct answer earns one mark; no marks are deducted for a wrong answer.
- 11 mark
A theatre needs to adapt a historic costume for a new performer. An internal alteration and a removable insert would fit equally well, cost the same and take the same time. The alteration would permanently remove some original fabric; the insert would leave it intact. The wardrobe manager therefore recommends the insert, since achieving the required fit gives no reason to accept an avoidable permanent loss.
Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case?
- 21 mark
A residents' association already pays a fixed annual fee for its hall. A member's private meeting adds a cleaning charge but does not alter that annual fee. The association should recover the cleaning charge from the member, but should not add a share of the annual fee. Its purpose here is solely to recover expenses caused by that meeting, not to raise general income.
Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case?
- 31 mark
Two machines need the workshop's only technician. Each repair takes an hour and restores the same amount of productive capacity. One machine can wait until tomorrow without further damage; delaying the other even an hour will permanently ruin it. The first fault was reported earlier, but the technician should nevertheless repair the second machine first: it cannot be recovered once the delay has destroyed it.
Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case?
- 41 mark
A makers' centre discovers a fault in one of its four workrooms. Locking that room completely removes the danger, and the other three rooms remain safe and useful. The manager should close only the faulty room rather than the entire centre. Since isolating the fault fully protects users, stopping the other activities would impose restrictions without adding protection.
Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case?
- 51 mark
A parcel service is considering a new sorting layout solely to reduce mistakes. Staff expect it to work, but it has not been tested. The service should first compare error rates under the old and new layouts using parcels representative of its normal work, with other conditions held alike. It should not adopt the layout throughout the service on favourable opinions alone: the trial must measure the intended improvement under ordinary conditions.
Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case?
- 61 mark
A recorder obtained permission to use a speaker's interview only in a room-based exhibition. The recorder now wants to put it on a publicly accessible website, which the original permission expressly excluded. The recorder should ask for fresh, explicit permission before doing so. The speaker has not objected to the website announcement, but the agreement covered visitors hearing the recording in the exhibition room.
Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case?
- 71 mark
Five groups have equally strong claims to the only available rehearsal session. The session cannot be divided, and no group has a relevant priority over another. The organiser should use a draw giving each group the same chance, rather than favour a group whose leader the organiser knows. Knowing that leader gives the organiser no reason to rate that group's claim more highly than the other four.
Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case?
- 81 mark
A footpath was closed solely because repair equipment blocked it. The equipment has now gone, the path is safe, and there is no other reason for closure. The council should reopen it rather than wait for its usual annual review. Waiting until the review would leave walkers barred from a path that the council already knows they can use safely.
Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case?
- 91 mark
A housing cooperative must decide whether to reimburse a repair bill. Its usual reviewer would personally receive the reimbursement if the claim succeeded. Although no one doubts her honesty, another suitably qualified reviewer with no stake in the result is available. The cooperative should use that reviewer. The usual reviewer's long record of trustworthy service does not change who would receive the money if this particular claim were approved.
Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case?
- 101 mark
A studio needs a cutter for three years. Both shortlisted cutters meet every requirement, last the whole period and have no resale value. Cutter P costs less to buy, but its required servicing makes its total three-year cost higher than Cutter Q's. All relevant costs are known. The studio should choose Q, since buying P would leave it spending more by the time it no longer needs the cutter.
Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case?
- 111 mark
A repair cooperative rewards teams according to how many jobs they close. Teams can raise that count by marking unfinished work as closed; doing so leaves the actual repairs unchanged. Its purpose is to reward completed, usable repairs. The cooperative should therefore base rewards on independently verified working repairs. An independent check would show whether each supposedly finished repair actually works, which the closed-job total does not establish.
Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case?
- 121 mark
A workshop sold annual passes with an explicit promise of free tool hire for the full twelve months. It now wants to charge for tool hire. Existing pass holders relied on the promised terms when paying, and there is no overriding obstacle to keeping them. The workshop should honour those terms until each current pass expires, while stating any new charges before selling future passes.
Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case?
Worked solutions
Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.
Question 1
Answer or working Marks C 1 The principle is to avoid permanent loss or alteration when an equally effective alternative, with no cost or effort disadvantage, preserves the original. The insert meets the fit requirement without sacrificing fabric. A: Substitutes replacement of an inadequate object for a choice between equally effective methods. Repair does not meet the school's needs, so the preservation condition is absent. B: Treats preservation as an overriding aim even when the required result is lost. The passage favours preservation only where the alternative fulfils the same purpose equally well. C: Both methods fulfil the labelling purpose on equal terms, but freestanding signs avoid permanent damage to the trees. The same conditional preference supports choosing them. D: Trades permanent change for a cost advantage. The record may benefit from protection, but the equal-cost condition supporting the theatre's recommendation does not hold. E: Chooses a permanent treatment for an appearance the removable alternative cannot supply. This lacks equal effectiveness and does not apply the stated preference for preservation. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: Substitutes replacement of an inadequate object for a choice between equally effective methods. Repair does not meet the school's needs, so the preservation condition is absent. Why not B: Treats preservation as an overriding aim even when the required result is lost. The passage favours preservation only where the alternative fulfils the same purpose equally well. Why not D: Trades permanent change for a cost advantage. The record may benefit from protection, but the equal-cost condition supporting the theatre's recommendation does not hold. Why not E: Chooses a permanent treatment for an appearance the removable alternative cannot supply. This lacks equal effectiveness and does not apply the stated preference for preservation. Question 2
Answer or working Marks A 1 The principle is to recover only the additional expenses attributable to an activity when cost recovery for that activity is the sole aim. Existing costs that remain unchanged are excluded. A: The paper expense is caused by the job, while the rent is unchanged. Recovering the former and excluding the latter applies precisely the same distinction. B: Confuses receiving a benefit with causing an expense. The unchanged security bill is an existing cost, like the annual hall fee, and falls outside this cost-recovery aim. C: Confuses unused capacity with absence of extra expense. The heating cost is caused by the booking and should be recovered under the passage's principle. D: Substitutes general fundraising for recovery of expenses caused by the visit. A contribution to future purchases is not an additional expense of admitting this visitor. E: Confuses ability to pay with responsibility for additional costs. Only the increase caused by the cooking, rather than the whole monthly bill, fits the principle. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: Confuses receiving a benefit with causing an expense. The unchanged security bill is an existing cost, like the annual hall fee, and falls outside this cost-recovery aim. Why not C: Confuses unused capacity with absence of extra expense. The heating cost is caused by the booking and should be recovered under the passage's principle. Why not D: Substitutes general fundraising for recovery of expenses caused by the visit. A contribution to future purchases is not an additional expense of admitting this visitor. Why not E: Confuses ability to pay with responsibility for additional costs. Only the increase caused by the cooking, rather than the whole monthly bill, fits the principle. Question 3
Answer or working Marks E 1 The principle is to prioritise prevention of an irreversible loss when competing tasks require equal time and deliver equal benefit, and the other task can safely wait. The second machine has that urgent vulnerability. A: Applies arrival order where neither request risks irreversible loss. This may settle a queue fairly, but it lacks the urgent vulnerability that overrides arrival order in the workshop. B: Prioritises convenience and time saved when neither task faces permanent loss. The workshop instead holds task time equal and gives priority to the machine that cannot safely wait. C: Treats a simpler schedule as a reason to permit preventable permanent loss. The urgent device must be dealt with before the delay destroys it. D: Prioritises shorter processing time when neither task faces lasting harm. The workshop's tasks take equal time, and the decisive difference is the consequence of delay. E: Equal value and treatment time reproduce the relevant comparison. The first drawing faces irreversible loss tonight, while the second can safely wait, so urgency determines priority. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit. Why not A: Applies arrival order where neither request risks irreversible loss. This may settle a queue fairly, but it lacks the urgent vulnerability that overrides arrival order in the workshop. Why not B: Prioritises convenience and time saved when neither task faces permanent loss. The workshop instead holds task time equal and gives priority to the machine that cannot safely wait. Why not C: Treats a simpler schedule as a reason to permit preventable permanent loss. The urgent device must be dealt with before the delay destroys it. Why not D: Prioritises shorter processing time when neither task faces lasting harm. The workshop's tasks take equal time, and the decisive difference is the consequence of delay. Question 4
Answer or working Marks B 1 The principle is to confine a protective restriction to the faulty part when isolating that part fully removes the danger and leaves the remainder safe and useful. The other workrooms add no reason for a wider closure. A: Bases a closure on efficient scheduling of cosmetic repairs, rather than on isolating a danger. No faulty part threatens users, so the passage's protective condition is absent. B: Isolating the faulty chute removes all the relevant danger, and the remaining chutes still serve their purpose safely. Disabling only that chute meets every condition. C: Expands the restriction beyond what protection requires. Isolating the damaged court is sufficient, so closing safe courts adds inconvenience without removing further danger. D: Confuses most equipment being safe with removal of the danger. Leaving the faulty freezer operating does not isolate its threatening cable and fails the protective condition. E: Selects a more convenient route between two safe alternatives. This can improve access, but it does not isolate a fault or limit a restriction needed to remove danger. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit. Why not A: Bases a closure on efficient scheduling of cosmetic repairs, rather than on isolating a danger. No faulty part threatens users, so the passage's protective condition is absent. Why not C: Expands the restriction beyond what protection requires. Isolating the damaged court is sufficient, so closing safe courts adds inconvenience without removing further danger. Why not D: Confuses most equipment being safe with removal of the danger. Leaving the faulty freezer operating does not isolate its threatening cable and fails the protective condition. Why not E: Selects a more convenient route between two safe alternatives. This can improve access, but it does not isolate a fault or limit a restriction needed to remove danger. Question 5
Answer or working Marks B 1 The principle is to test an unproven proposed improvement in a representative comparison that measures the intended outcome and holds other conditions alike before full adoption. The parcel service needs evidence about errors in normal work. A: Substitutes enthusiasm for outcome evidence. The demonstration supplies no comparison of double bookings, so it does not test the improvement the system is meant to achieve. B: Typical menus make the trial representative, comparable conditions isolate the routine, and waste measures the intended outcome. Waiting for that comparison applies the whole principle. C: Uses an unrepresentative sample. Results on unusually simple jobs do not test the checking method under the ordinary range of work it will face after adoption. D: Substitutes approval of an incidental feature for evidence of the target improvement. Liking colours does not establish shorter queues, the stated reason for the change. E: Confounds the proposed change with workload. Quiet and busy shifts differ in another relevant condition, so their results cannot isolate the effect of the picking routes. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit. Why not A: Substitutes enthusiasm for outcome evidence. The demonstration supplies no comparison of double bookings, so it does not test the improvement the system is meant to achieve. Why not C: Uses an unrepresentative sample. Results on unusually simple jobs do not test the checking method under the ordinary range of work it will face after adoption. Why not D: Substitutes approval of an incidental feature for evidence of the target improvement. Liking colours does not establish shorter queues, the stated reason for the change. Why not E: Confounds the proposed change with workload. Quiet and busy shifts differ in another relevant condition, so their results cannot isolate the effect of the picking routes. Question 6
Answer or working Marks D 1 The principle is to obtain fresh explicit agreement before extending a permitted activity into a use expressly outside the original permission. Silence does not supply that extension. Public online access falls outside the speaker's agreed use. A: Acts within an existing permission rather than seeking permission to extend it. The portrait display is already authorised, so the passage's trigger of an expressly excluded use is absent. B: Confuses agreement to private use with agreement to publicity and treats non-response as consent. The new use needs explicit agreement rather than an inference from silence. C: Demands renewed permission where no relevant extension occurs. Repeating a use already authorised on the same dates and terms lacks the passage's trigger of an excluded use. D: Advertising is expressly outside the internal-review permission. Obtaining express agreement before that extension meets the same condition as obtaining permission for online release. E: Substitutes a hoped-for benefit for agreement to the changed use. Greater readership does not extend a permission that explicitly excludes identification of the contributor. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit. Why not A: Acts within an existing permission rather than seeking permission to extend it. The portrait display is already authorised, so the passage's trigger of an expressly excluded use is absent. Why not B: Confuses agreement to private use with agreement to publicity and treats non-response as consent. The new use needs explicit agreement rather than an inference from silence. Why not C: Demands renewed permission where no relevant extension occurs. Repeating a use already authorised on the same dates and terms lacks the passage's trigger of an excluded use. Why not E: Substitutes a hoped-for benefit for agreement to the changed use. Greater readership does not extend a permission that explicitly excludes identification of the contributor. Question 7
Answer or working Marks A 1 The principle is to allocate an indivisible scarce opportunity by an equal-chance draw where claims are equal and no relevant priority distinguishes them. The session cannot serve everyone, and personal familiarity is not a priority. A: The single slot is indivisible, claims are equal, and no priority applies. An equal-chance draw therefore transfers the same recommendation to the field station. B: Replaces equal chances with personal favouritism. Familiarity supplies no relevant difference between the equally qualified applicants, just as knowing a group leader supplies none. C: Applies equality of chances despite a relevant difference in claims. The agreed priority removes the equal-claim condition on which the passage's recommendation depends. D: Confuses equal distribution of fragments with equal chances of a useful opportunity. The session is indivisible for its purpose, so unusable pieces do not meet the requirement. E: Removes the scarcity that triggers selection. Giving everyone a place may be appropriate, but it does not apply a rule for choosing one winner of an indivisible opportunity. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: Replaces equal chances with personal favouritism. Familiarity supplies no relevant difference between the equally qualified applicants, just as knowing a group leader supplies none. Why not C: Applies equality of chances despite a relevant difference in claims. The agreed priority removes the equal-claim condition on which the passage's recommendation depends. Why not D: Confuses equal distribution of fragments with equal chances of a useful opportunity. The session is indivisible for its purpose, so unusable pieces do not meet the requirement. Why not E: Removes the scarcity that triggers selection. Giving everyone a place may be appropriate, but it does not apply a rule for choosing one winner of an indivisible opportunity. Question 8
Answer or working Marks C 1 The principle is to remove a restriction once its sole temporary justification has ceased and no other justification exists, without waiting for a routine review. The safe, unobstructed footpath meets both conditions. A: Introduces a continuing independent justification. The unsafe ceiling means that removing the leak does not leave the room without a reason for closure. B: Ends a restriction while its justification remains. Customer preference does not establish that the crowding problem, the reason for the limit, has disappeared. C: The spill was the sole reason for locking the room and has been cleared. Restoring access immediately rather than waiting for review follows the same recommendation. D: Treats a review date as a substantive reason to restrict access. The only defect is gone and no other danger remains, exactly the conditions supporting reopening. E: Treats familiarity as a reason to preserve a restriction after its sole justification ends. Habit does not supply a new need for keeping the aisle closed. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: Introduces a continuing independent justification. The unsafe ceiling means that removing the leak does not leave the room without a reason for closure. Why not B: Ends a restriction while its justification remains. Customer preference does not establish that the crowding problem, the reason for the limit, has disappeared. Why not D: Treats a review date as a substantive reason to restrict access. The only defect is gone and no other danger remains, exactly the conditions supporting reopening. Why not E: Treats familiarity as a reason to preserve a restriction after its sole justification ends. Habit does not supply a new need for keeping the aisle closed. Question 9
Answer or working Marks E 1 The principle is to use a qualified decision-maker without a personal stake instead of a qualified decision-maker who would personally benefit from the outcome, even if the latter is trusted. The repair reviewer stands to receive the payment herself. A: Bases replacement on demonstrated poor judging, not a personal interest in the result. This may justify replacement independently, but it does not apply the cooperative's independence test. B: Treats confidence in character as a substitute for independence. Deciding her own bonus creates a personal stake that the available independent decision-maker would avoid. C: Treats relevant experience as a disqualifying interest and sacrifices qualification. Neither prior experience nor a lack of personal benefit creates the conflict described in the passage. D: Selects among independent reviewers by expertise. The recommendation may be appropriate, but no reviewer has the personal stake that triggers replacement in the cooperative's case. E: The usual judge has a direct personal interest in one outcome, while the substitute is equally qualified and has none. Replacement applies the independence requirement precisely. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit. Why not A: Bases replacement on demonstrated poor judging, not a personal interest in the result. This may justify replacement independently, but it does not apply the cooperative's independence test. Why not B: Treats confidence in character as a substitute for independence. Deciding her own bonus creates a personal stake that the available independent decision-maker would avoid. Why not C: Treats relevant experience as a disqualifying interest and sacrifices qualification. Neither prior experience nor a lack of personal benefit creates the conflict described in the passage. Why not D: Selects among independent reviewers by expertise. The recommendation may be appropriate, but no reviewer has the personal stake that triggers replacement in the cooperative's case. Question 10
Answer or working Marks D 1 The principle is to choose the lowest total cost over the planned period of use among alternatives that all meet the requirements. Initial price or one running-cost component is insufficient. Q has the lower relevant total despite its higher purchase price. A: Substitutes purchase price for total cost over the planned use. The printer's consumables and servicing overturn the initial saving, just as P's servicing does. B: Drops the requirement that the chosen alternative meet the stated needs. A low total cost does not qualify a pump that cannot supply the required amount of water. C: Uses the wrong time horizon. A ten-year running-cost advantage does not determine the total cost of the single year for which the theatre actually needs the system. D: Both mixers satisfy the requirements throughout the actual four-year period. Comparing their totals over that period, rather than initial prices, selects the one the principle recommends. E: Substitutes a running-cost component for the whole-period total. A lower annual fuel bill cannot justify the heater when its purchase cost makes the relevant total higher. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit. Why not A: Substitutes purchase price for total cost over the planned use. The printer's consumables and servicing overturn the initial saving, just as P's servicing does. Why not B: Drops the requirement that the chosen alternative meet the stated needs. A low total cost does not qualify a pump that cannot supply the required amount of water. Why not C: Uses the wrong time horizon. A ten-year running-cost advantage does not determine the total cost of the single year for which the theatre actually needs the system. Why not E: Substitutes a running-cost component for the whole-period total. A lower annual fuel bill cannot justify the heater when its purchase cost makes the relevant total higher. Question 11
Answer or working Marks B 1 The principle is to replace a reward measure that can improve without achievement of the stated aim with a measure that verifies that achievement. A closed-job count can be manipulated, whereas checking working repairs addresses the cooperative's actual purpose. A: Applies equal rewards to equivalent achievements on different shifts. Verification is already in place, and no defective score is being replaced, so the passage's reason for changing the measure is absent. B: The seed log can improve without producing plants, whereas verified healthy deliveries check the actual result. Replacing the former measure with the latter applies the principle. C: Changes the attractiveness of the reward while retaining the same verified measure. The passage changes what is measured because its old score can rise without achieving its aim. D: Substitutes continuity of scores for verification of results. Unchecked delivery labels can rise without parcels arriving, so preserving comparability leaves the defective incentive intact. E: Replaces an outcome measure with an unrelated feature that can improve independently. Attractive notebooks do not verify completed courses and therefore move away from the principle. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit. Why not A: Applies equal rewards to equivalent achievements on different shifts. Verification is already in place, and no defective score is being replaced, so the passage's reason for changing the measure is absent. Why not C: Changes the attractiveness of the reward while retaining the same verified measure. The passage changes what is measured because its old score can rise without achieving its aim. Why not D: Substitutes continuity of scores for verification of results. Unchecked delivery labels can rise without parcels arriving, so preserving comparability leaves the defective incentive intact. Why not E: Replaces an outcome measure with an unrelated feature that can improve independently. Attractive notebooks do not verify completed courses and therefore move away from the principle. Question 12
Answer or working Marks A 1 The principle is to honour explicit terms relied on in a purchase for the full paid period, absent an overriding obstacle, while allowing clearly disclosed changes for future purchases. The workshop may change future passes but must fulfil its existing twelve-month promise. A: The existing memberships carry a paid-period promise, which remains honoured. New charges are disclosed before future purchases, so both parts of the recommendation transfer correctly. B: Treats notice of new terms as cancelling an existing paid-period promise. Displaying a notice does not fulfil the benefit already sold to current members. C: Extends a time-limited obligation to all future customers indefinitely. The passage protects existing paid periods while expressly permitting disclosed changes to future terms. D: Treats a new future tariff as authority to alter completed purchases. The prepaid stays already include showers, and no obstacle prevents honouring that promise. E: Applies a purchase-based obligation where there was neither a promised paid benefit nor reliance in buying. The indefinite continuation is also broader than the promised-period protection. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: Treats notice of new terms as cancelling an existing paid-period promise. Displaying a notice does not fulfil the benefit already sold to current members. Why not C: Extends a time-limited obligation to all future customers indefinitely. The passage protects existing paid periods while expressly permitting disclosed changes to future terms. Why not D: Treats a new future tariff as authority to alter completed purchases. The prepaid stays already include showers, and no obstacle prevents honouring that promise. Why not E: Applies a purchase-based obligation where there was neither a promised paid benefit nor reliance in buying. The indefinite continuation is also broader than the promised-period protection.