TARA Critical Thinking: Assessing the impact of additional evidence, set 1
Judging what a new fact would do to an argument already on the page: strengthen it, weaken it, or leave it exactly where it was. Test standard. 12 questions, 12 marks, about 22 minutes.
Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)
- Answer all twelve questions. No calculator.
- Assume the reasons in each argument are true. For each option, consider what difference the additional evidence would make if it were true.
- Choose the single option that most strengthens or most weakens the argument, as requested. Each correct answer earns one mark; no marks are deducted for a wrong answer.
- 11 mark
A warehouse introduced a checklist at one packing bench. Over the next month, a smaller proportion of its parcels contained the wrong items than at the other benches. The supervisor concludes that using the checklist reduced packing errors.
Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
- 21 mark
A small theatre sold more seats for its Tuesday performances after introducing half-price Tuesday tickets. Its manager argues that the discount increased total ticket income across the whole week, because it brought more people to Tuesday performances.
Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?
- 31 mark
An employer asked staff to vote online on whether to retain a compulsory uniform. Four fifths of those voting supported retaining it. The personnel officer concludes that a majority of all staff support keeping the uniform.
Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
- 41 mark
A housing office introduced a new system for allocating repairs. The number of complaints recorded each month then fell. The director concludes that tenants are now more satisfied with the allocation of repairs, citing the fall in recorded complaints as the evidence.
Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?
- 51 mark
A communal garden began sending plot holders a weekly reminder to turn off taps. Water use fell in the following six weeks compared with the preceding six weeks. The committee concludes that the reminders caused the reduction.
Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?
- 61 mark
A document service plans to replace a leased scanner. The proposed scanner has a higher annual lease charge but a lower charge for each page scanned. Using last year's page total, the manager calculates that the page-charge saving would exceed the extra annual lease charge. The manager concludes that the replacement will reduce the service's combined lease and page charges next year.
Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
- 71 mark
A rehearsal centre often promises the same room to two groups at once because its two receptionists keep separate booking diaries. The centre proposes one shared calendar that both receptionists must use. Its manager argues that this will reduce these double bookings.
Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
- 81 mark
A training provider wants participants to become better at checking invoices for errors. After a workshop, participants rated their confidence in invoice checking more highly than before it. The provider concludes that the workshop improved their ability to detect invoice errors, relying on those confidence ratings.
Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?
- 91 mark
A storehouse tested a new trolley on its smooth indoor floor and found that moving a standard load took less time than with its present trolley. It now plans to use the new trolley for outdoor deliveries over cobbles. The supervisor concludes that it will also shorten the time taken to move standard loads on those deliveries.
Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
- 101 mark
A heritage centre needs at least twenty guides available every Saturday to run all its tours. Thirty people signed a form saying they would like to join its volunteer guide team. The organiser concludes that recruiting these people will provide enough guides for every Saturday, because thirty exceeds twenty.
Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?
- 111 mark
A firm finds that employees who attend its optional lunchtime mentoring sessions complete more assignments on time than employees who do not attend. The director concludes that attending mentoring improves employees' punctual completion of assignments.
Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?
- 121 mark
A collector argues that an unsigned wooden model was made by the workshop that occupied a particular building eighty years ago. The model was found in that building, and it has an unusual joint design seen on the workshop's signed models. However, other makers could have used the same design and objects may have been brought into the building later.
Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
Worked solutions
Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.
Question 1
Answer or working Marks C 1 The conclusion attributes the lower error proportion to the checklist, rather than to differences between benches. C makes systematic differences in packer skill and order difficulty less plausible explanations: random allocation gives the checklist and comparison benches a fairer mix. This strengthens the causal link, although it does not prove it. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: Confuses a smaller workload with evidence for the checklist. Reduced pressure could itself explain fewer errors, so this introduces an alternative cause rather than strengthening the inference. Why not B: Confuses a shared visual feature with evidence of effectiveness. Matching handbook colours supplies no link between using the checklist and packing the correct items. Why not D: Ignores the starting position. A pre-existing advantage could explain the lower error proportion without any effect from the checklist, so this weakens the causal inference. Why not E: Substitutes a preference about presentation for an outcome. Wanting a screen does not show that the checklist reduced wrong-item parcels. Question 2
Answer or working Marks A 1 The conclusion concerns income for the whole week, whereas the reason concerns attendance on one evening. A shows displacement: most discount sales replace sales that would have earned more that week. More Tuesday customers can therefore coexist with lower weekly income, undermining the move from attendance to revenue. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: Focuses on new visitors while ignoring weekly income. These visitors may add sales, which would support the manager rather than show that the discount reduced total receipts. Why not C: Confuses a common booking condition with a change in ticket income. An identical fee does not show whether extra sales offset the lower ticket prices. Why not D: Adds background about the cast. Keeping the cast the same gives no reason to infer that the discount failed to increase weekly ticket income. Why not E: Overstates the need for universal uptake. The discount could increase total income even if some customers still prefer full-price performances. Question 3
Answer or working Marks E 1 The conclusion extends the result from people who chose to vote to the entire workforce. E supplies independent evidence about the missing group. Similar support among randomly sampled non-voters makes it less likely that voluntary voting produced an unrepresentative result, strengthening the majority claim. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit. Why not A: Confuses feasibility with staff opinion. Continued supply makes retention possible but does not show that a majority of workers want it. Why not B: Ignores selection bias. Supporters circulating the link especially often could make supporters overrepresented among voters, which weakens rather than strengthens the generalisation. Why not C: Substitutes length of service for an expressed view. Long-serving non-voters could support or oppose the uniform; their tenure does not bridge the sampling gap. Why not D: Substitutes a financial reason for an opinion count. A cheaper policy need not be the one supported by a majority of all staff. Question 4
Answer or working Marks B 1 The conclusion treats recorded complaints as a comparable measure of satisfaction before and after the change. B changes that measure. Excluding telephone complaints can reduce the recorded total even if the true level of dissatisfaction is unchanged, so the fall no longer provides the claimed support. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit. Why not A: Reverses the requested direction. Independent reports of greater satisfaction support the conclusion rather than weaken it. Why not C: Adds staffing information without an outcome link. An unchanged number of contractors does not tell us whether tenants are more satisfied or complaints are measured consistently. Why not D: Confuses unchanged terminology with a test of satisfaction. Keeping category names supplies no reason to doubt the interpretation of the complaint figures. Why not E: Mistakes support from a subgroup for a challenge. Some former complainants reporting improvement is consistent with greater satisfaction and does not undermine it. Question 5
Answer or working Marks B 1 The conclusion singles out the reminders as the cause of lower metered water use. B supplies a competing cause at exactly the relevant time: repairing a leak could reduce metered water loss without any change in tap-turning habits. The before-and-after figures cannot separate the two changes. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit. Why not A: Confuses delivery with causal impact. Reaching everyone makes an effect possible but gives no rival explanation for the water saving, so it does not weaken the argument. Why not C: Substitutes approval for evidence of causation. Requests to continue the messages do not show that something other than the reminders reduced water use. Why not D: Supplies measurement continuity rather than a challenge. Using the same meter avoids one possible comparability concern and does not explain the reduction away. Why not E: Removes an alternative explanation rather than supplying one. Stable plot occupancy makes a fall caused merely by fewer active plots less likely. Question 6
Answer or working Marks D 1 The conclusion projects a saving calculated at last year's volume into next year. Because the page-charge difference favours the replacement, higher volume increases its saving relative to the fixed extra lease charge. D establishes both a minimum volume sufficient for the calculated saving and stable prices. It therefore supports the link from the calculation to next year's combined charges. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit. Why not A: Confuses appearance with the specified costs. Casing colours have no stated effect on either the annual lease charge or the per-page saving. Why not B: Substitutes speed for the charges being compared. Faster scanning may have other benefits but does not establish next year's volume or the two quoted charges. Why not C: Uses popularity as a substitute for the relevant calculation. Rivals choosing the supplier does not establish this service's future page volume or rates. Why not E: Ignores dependence on volume. Losing the largest scanning client could reduce the page-charge saving below the extra lease charge, weakening the projected saving. Question 7
Answer or working Marks A 1 The conclusion predicts fewer double bookings by replacing separate records with a shared one. A supplies a direct mechanism: once a room is booked, the required calendar blocks an overlapping booking. This specifically addresses the error the proposal is intended to reduce. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: Confuses staff preference with a preventive mechanism. Liking the colours does not show that the calendar will detect or stop conflicting room bookings. Why not C: Selects a useful but unrelated feature. Storing repair contacts does not prevent two groups from being assigned the same room at the same time. Why not D: Adds continuity in the service offered. Keeping session lengths does not show whether the shared calendar prevents booking conflicts. Why not E: Reverses the requested effect. Allowing clashes without warning exposes a way for double bookings to persist and therefore weakens the manager's case. Question 8
Answer or working Marks C 1 The conclusion is about skill, but the only stated evidence measures confidence. Confidence and accuracy need not improve together. C directly measures the target skill on comparable tasks and finds worse performance. That evidence undermines the inference that higher self-ratings demonstrate improved error detection. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: Substitutes presentation quality for detection ability. Readable examples do not establish whether participants can find more invoice errors afterwards. Why not B: Confuses satisfaction with performance. A recommendation may reflect enjoyment or confidence and does not provide evidence against improved error detection. Why not D: Addresses comparability of confidence ratings, not their link to ability. Using the same scale does not show that higher confidence represents worse performance. Why not E: Adds a control on the questionnaire process. Equal response time does not challenge the claimed improvement in invoice-checking ability. Question 9
Answer or working Marks E 1 The conclusion generalises from a smooth indoor surface to a different delivery surface. The original trial does not establish performance on cobbles. E tests the relevant surface with the relevant loads and reproduces the saving. It supplies direct support for the proposed generalisation rather than another attractive feature of the trolley. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit. Why not A: Substitutes storage convenience for delivery speed. A smaller storage requirement does not support transferring the indoor timing result to cobbles. Why not B: Adds a difference between trial and use without a stated effect. Time of day alone supplies no evidence that the indoor saving carries over outdoors. Why not C: Confuses appearance with performance. Handle colour has no stated connection with the time taken to move loads over cobbles. Why not D: Reverses the requested direction. A steering problem on the actual surface gives a reason to doubt that the indoor speed advantage will transfer. Question 10
Answer or working Marks D 1 The conclusion treats the total number of interested recruits as the number available on Saturdays. D distinguishes willingness to join from availability at the required time. Only twelve can work Saturdays, which is fewer than twenty, so these recruits cannot by themselves supply the claimed coverage. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit. Why not A: Supports qualification rather than undermining coverage. Having completed the required training removes one obstacle to using the recruits as guides. Why not B: Confuses resources with attendance. Enough badges and books make staffing possible but do not show that the volunteers cannot cover Saturdays. Why not C: Repeats the evidence of willingness. Continued interest does not reveal a shortfall in Saturday availability, so it does not weaken the staffing inference. Why not E: Substitutes demand for the stated staffing requirement. Interest in tours does not change the given twenty-guide threshold or show that the recruits fail to meet it. Question 11
Answer or working Marks A 1 The conclusion moves from an association between attendance and performance to the claim that attendance causes better performance. A reverses the proposed causal direction: already finishing on time enables attendance. Selection into mentoring could therefore explain the difference without mentoring producing any improvement. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: Reverses the direction requested. Discussing planning supplies a possible mechanism for mentoring to improve punctual completion, so it can support the director. Why not C: Treats favourable reports as a challenge. Reports of improved scheduling are consistent with mentoring helping completion and do not undermine that causal explanation. Why not D: Confuses accurate attendance records with evidence of cause. Reliable group membership does not show whether mentoring or prior performance explains the difference. Why not E: Supplies comparability rather than a rival cause. A shared recording system reduces a measurement concern and does not explain away the performance difference. Question 12
Answer or working Marks C 1 The conclusion attributes manufacture to one workshop. Location and a shared joint design are suggestive but allow later arrival and another maker. C independently connects this particular model to production in the workshop: the unique carved pattern identifies the object and the dated record identifies where it was made. This addresses both stated alternative explanations. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: Ignores an alternative route to the find location. A later mixed collection makes it easier for another maker's model to have reached the building, so this weakens attribution. Why not B: Uses a common feature as though it identified a maker. Similar size across many makers does not distinguish this workshop from the alternatives. Why not D: Reverses the requested effect. Another workshop using the same joint makes that design less useful for identifying the maker and weakens the inference. Why not E: Substitutes a desired display arrangement for provenance. The collector's preference provides no evidence about who made the model or when it arrived.