TARA Critical Thinking: Detecting reasoning errors, set 1
Saying why a conclusion does not follow from the reasons given, rather than why it happens to be false. Test standard. 12 questions, 12 marks, about 22 minutes.
Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)
- Answer all twelve questions. No calculator.
- Assume the stated reasons are true. Identify why the conclusion does not follow from those reasons. No specialist knowledge is required.
- Each question has five options and exactly one correct answer. Each correct answer earns one mark; no marks are deducted for a wrong answer.
- 11 mark
Whenever the warehouse alarm is being tested, a blue lamp beside the door flashes. The blue lamp is flashing now. The supervisor concludes that the alarm must be undergoing a test, so there is no need to find out why the lamp is flashing.
Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument?
- 21 mark
The local seed exchange guarantees a free packet of seeds to everyone who brings a labelled envelope. Tomas has brought no labelled envelope. The organiser therefore tells him that he cannot receive a free packet under any circumstances.
Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument?
- 31 mark
A shop moved its returns desk to the entrance at the start of April. In April it received fewer complaints than in March. The owner says that this proves the new position caused the fall in complaints, since the fall occurred after the move.
Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument?
- 41 mark
Each of six separate storage boxes can be carried safely by one person when it is full. The caretaker proposes fixing all six boxes together into a single unit, with all their contents still inside. Since every box is safe for one person to carry, the caretaker concludes that the full combined unit will also be safe for one person to carry.
Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument?
- 51 mark
The residents' committee has agreed that an empty room should be put to use rather than left permanently locked and useless. One member points out that turning it into a games room would put it to use. On that basis alone, she concludes that a games room is the only acceptable use and that the committee must choose it.
Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument?
- 61 mark
A craft group wants a light table so that its members can carry it between rooms. A catalogue describes a table as light because its surface is pale cream rather than dark brown. The group's buyer concludes that the catalogue has confirmed that this table will be easy to carry.
Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument?
- 71 mark
A club treasurer is asked why a new spending rule is fair. She replies: "It is fair because it treats members justly. We know it treats members justly because it is a fair rule." She concludes that these reasons establish the rule's fairness.
Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument?
- 81 mark
Two delivery teams recorded the proportion of their deliveries that arrived late. Team R's late-delivery rate was lower than Team S's. Their total numbers of deliveries have not been compared. The manager nevertheless concludes that Team R made fewer late deliveries than Team S.
Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument?
- 91 mark
A community group has spent money trying to restore an old clock. That money cannot be recovered whichever decision it makes now. It must decide whether to pay for another stage of work. The chair says: "We have already spent so much that we must pay for the next stage, regardless of what it costs or how likely it is to succeed."
Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument?
- 101 mark
A town choir has forty members. Some members can read music fluently, and some members can organise events confidently. The conductor concludes that at least one choir member can both read music fluently and organise events confidently, so one person can be chosen who has both skills.
Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument?
- 111 mark
At a club prize draw, each draw selects one of ten numbered tokens and then returns it to the bag. Every token has an equal chance on every draw, regardless of earlier results. Token 7 has not been selected on the last nine draws. A member concludes that token 7 now has a greater chance than any other token on the next draw because it is overdue.
Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument?
- 121 mark
At a model-making club, a volunteer proposes keeping the parts for each model in its own numbered tray. She argues that this would prevent parts for different models being mixed on the workbench. The manager rejects her conclusion solely because she often arrives late for meetings: "Someone who cannot organise her own arrival cannot have proposed an arrangement that would reduce the mixing of parts."
Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument?
Worked solutions
Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.
Question 1
Answer or working Marks D 1 The reason says that a test guarantees flashing. The conclusion reverses that direction: flashing is taken to guarantee a test. The lamp could also flash for another reason without violating the stated rule. D identifies this unsupported reversal, often called affirming the consequent. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit. Why not A: The passage places the flashing during a test, not after one. The supervisor makes no claim about a test having finished. Why not B: The supervisor applies the general rule to the present flashing; the argument does not limit the rule to a previous test. Why not C: The rule about flashing during tests is given as a premise. The supervisor concludes that a test is occurring, not that tests cause the flashing. Why not E: The conditional rule is stated without a past-only restriction. The error remains even if that rule still holds now, because other events could produce flashing. Question 2
Answer or working Marks A 1 Bringing a labelled envelope is enough to guarantee a free packet. Nothing says that it is the only route to a free packet. Tomas could receive one through another arrangement while the guarantee remains true. A identifies the mistaken treatment of a sufficient condition as necessary. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: The guarantee and the conclusion both concern individual recipients, including Tomas. No move from individuals to groups occurs. Why not C: The organiser concludes that Tomas cannot receive a packet, not that he does or does not want one. Eligibility and motivation are not confused here. Why not D: The organiser makes a claim about what Tomas can receive under the scheme, not about whether Tomas would accept a packet if offered one. Why not E: The guarantee is a stated premise. The organiser does not argue that universal application makes that guarantee fair or justified. Question 3
Answer or working Marks C 1 The evidence establishes the order of the move and the fall in complaints. It does not isolate the move as the cause. Another change could account for the fall while both stated facts remain true. C identifies the unsupported move from sequence to causation. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: The owner draws a causal conclusion about complaints, without making any claim about how many goods were returned. Why not B: The evidence and conclusion concern a fall in complaints, not a change in their seriousness. That distinction does not diagnose the causal leap. Why not D: The March complaint count is part of the stated comparison. It is not calculated from where the desk stood in April. Why not E: No conclusion about benefits to all customers is drawn. The owner claims a particular cause of the lower complaint count. Question 4
Answer or working Marks C 1 The premise concerns carrying one full box at a time. The conclusion concerns carrying all six together as one unit. The safety of each separate load does not establish the safety of the combined load. C identifies this transfer from parts to whole. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: The caretaker need not assume identical contents: the premise already grants that each full box is individually safe to carry. Why not B: This describes the opposite direction of inference. The argument starts with the separate boxes and concludes something about their combination. Why not D: The conclusion is about whether carrying the unit would be safe, not whether anyone is obliged to carry it. Why not E: The caretaker concludes that one person can safely carry the combined unit. There is no claim that help from additional people is forbidden. Question 5
Answer or working Marks E 1 The reasons establish that the room should be used and that a games room would fulfil that aim. The member then treats games room and permanent closure as the only choices. Other uses could also fulfil the agreed aim. Showing that one use is acceptable does not establish that it is the only acceptable use. E identifies the unsupported exclusion of alternatives. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit. Why not A: No cost comparison is offered or required by the stated either-or reasoning. The defect concerns the range of choices presented. Why not B: The member recommends a games room; she does not infer that one would be unpopular from the rejection of leaving the room locked. Why not C: Only leaving the room locked is rejected. The member does not reject the games room before declaring it the only acceptable use. Why not D: Neither the agreed aim nor the conclusion makes a claim about affordability. The member excludes other uses rather than inferring that conversion costs can be met. Question 6
Answer or working Marks B 1 The group uses light to mean low in weight. The catalogue uses light to describe the colour of the surface. The catalogue description can be true without establishing anything about weight. B identifies the change of meaning that breaks the inference. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit. Why not A: The buyer makes a claim about carrying the table, not about its suitability for every use. The evidence changes the meaning of light rather than extending suitability to all purposes. Why not C: No individual member's experience is used as evidence about all members. The evidence is a description of the table's colour. Why not D: The buyer accepts the catalogue description but offers no argument that liking the table establishes the catalogue's reliability. Why not E: The buyer concludes that the table is easy to carry, not that the catalogue recommends buying it. The relevant problem is which property the description establishes. Question 7
Answer or working Marks A 1 Treating members justly restates the fairness claim in this context. Its offered support is then the original assertion that the rule is fair. Neither statement has independent support: each depends on accepting the other. A identifies the circular reasoning. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: No earlier period is mentioned. The reasoning does not compare the rule's past fairness with its future fairness. Why not C: The treasurer does not attack or dismiss a critic. The problem is the content of the offered reasons, not the identity of a speaker. Why not D: The conclusion concerns this spending rule alone. There is no generalisation from one rule to every rule in the club. Why not E: No vote or majority is mentioned. The claim of fairness is supported only by restating it in terms of just treatment. Question 8
Answer or working Marks E 1 A lower late-delivery rate means fewer late deliveries per delivery made. It does not by itself mean a lower total count of late deliveries. Team R could have made enough more deliveries overall to have more late ones despite its lower rate. E identifies the missing comparison of totals. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit. Why not A: No cause of the teams' different rates is proposed. The manager moves from a rate comparison to a comparison of counts. Why not B: The manager makes a numerical comparison, not a causal claim that one team produced the other's delays. Why not C: The smaller proportion is the premise and the smaller count is the conclusion. This option describes the inference in reverse. Why not D: The comparison remains between teams. The manager does not distribute either team's rate to each of its individual members. Question 9
Answer or working Marks D 1 The money already spent is lost under either available decision. It cannot by itself make additional work worth its further cost. The next decision needs reasons concerning the future costs and benefits, which the chair expressly sets aside. D identifies reliance on sunk costs. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit. Why not A: The chair recommends continuing regardless of the likelihood of success. The argument does not infer guaranteed success from the earlier spending. Why not B: The chair does not use the age of the clock as evidence of success; indeed the recommendation explicitly disregards the likelihood of success. Why not C: No comparison with another project or its benefits is made. The chair relies on money already spent on this clock. Why not E: The chair accepts that the earlier spending cannot be recovered either way. The flaw persists without any belief in a refund. Question 10
Answer or working Marks B 1 The reasons establish that both skill groups are non-empty. They do not establish any overlap between them. For example, the fluent readers could all be different people from the confident organisers. B identifies the unsupported inference that someone belongs to both groups. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit. Why not A: The conductor claims that at least one member has both skills, not that every member does. This option overstates the conclusion. Why not C: No causal relationship between the skills is asserted. The issue is whether the two skill groups overlap at all. Why not D: The conductor concludes that someone has both skills. The failure to name members is not offered as evidence that the overlap is empty. Why not E: The passage grants that some members have each skill and concludes that the groups overlap. It does not infer universal lack of a skill. Question 11
Answer or working Marks C 1 The stated procedure makes each token equally likely on the next draw independently of earlier results. Nine non-selections do not change that. The member treats a run of past results as something the next draw must compensate for. C identifies this error without disputing any premise about the draw. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: The member compares tokens on the next draw, not the probabilities of complete sequences. The flaw is that past absence is treated as changing the next chance. Why not B: The member predicts a higher chance for token 7 but never says that other tokens cannot recur. Replacement is part of the stated procedure. Why not D: The conclusion claims a greater chance for token 7, not certainty that it will be drawn. Even that weaker probability comparison fails given independence. Why not E: The nine non-selections are accepted as having happened. The member does not deny a past sequence, but wrongly adjusts a future probability to compensate for it. Question 12
Answer or working Marks A 1 The manager concludes that the numbered trays would not reduce mixing, relying solely on the volunteer's lateness to reject her claim. Even accepting that she often arrives late, that does not establish a defect in the tray arrangement. A identifies the substitution of a personal criticism for an assessment of her reasoning. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: The manager does not claim that numbered trays would affect arrival times. Lateness is used to dismiss the proposer's arrangement, not presented as a problem the trays solve. Why not C: The manager denies the specific benefit concerning mixed parts. Neither speaker infers that the entire club would be better run from that benefit. Why not D: The volunteer's lateness is given as a reason for rejecting her proposal. The proposal is not presented as the cause of her lateness. Why not E: No other club or trial is mentioned. The dispute concerns this arrangement and a criticism of the person proposing it, not transfer between settings.