Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

TARA Critical Thinking: Drawing a conclusion, set 1

Deciding which of five statements the passage gives good reason to accept, when no conclusion is stated in the passage at all. Test standard. 12 questions, 12 marks, about 22 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Answer all questions. No calculator.
  • Assume the information in each passage is true. Use only that information.
  • Choose the one conclusion supported by each passage. Each question has exactly one correct answer.
  1. 11 mark

    Eighteen residents each returned one ballot about a proposed courtyard. Eleven ballots supported adding benches, and ten supported adding planters. Each ballot could support either proposal, both proposals or neither. These figures include every returned ballot.

    Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage?

    1. A Most residents who returned ballots supported both benches and planters.
    2. B Everyone supporting benches also supported adding planters to the courtyard.
    3. C At least three returned ballots supported both benches and planters.
    4. D Exactly three returned ballots supported both benches and planters.
    5. E Adding benches would make most courtyard residents use the space more often.
  2. 21 mark

    A language centre issues a conversation badge only to learners who have attended a practice session and passed an oral check. Both conditions are required, but meeting them does not guarantee a badge because places are limited. None of the learners in the Thursday class has attended a practice session. Several have passed the oral check.

    Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage?

    1. A No learner in the Thursday class has received a conversation badge.
    2. B Every learner who passes the oral check will receive a conversation badge.
    3. C No learner in any class has received a conversation badge this term.
    4. D Practice sessions cause learners to perform better in the oral check.
    5. E All Thursday learners will receive badges after attending one practice session.
  3. 31 mark

    A cafe began using a shorter menu at the start of June. On the same day it added a second cook to every lunchtime shift. Its average recorded waiting time was lower in June than in May. No separate trial of either change was made, and the records give no information about how busy the cafe was in either month.

    Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage?

    1. A The shorter menu was responsible for the whole fall in average waiting time.
    2. B The additional cook had no effect on the average waiting time in June.
    3. C Every customer in June waited less time than every customer in May.
    4. D Returning to the longer menu would certainly restore the May waiting time.
    5. E The records do not establish how much of the fall was due to the shorter menu.
  4. 41 mark

    Three proposals, Alder, Birch and Cedar, are the only proposals being considered for a play area. The committee permits a proposal to proceed only if it stays within the budget and provides step-free entry. Alder exceeds the budget. Birch has no step-free entry. No budget or access assessment has yet been made for Cedar. Passing both assessments would still leave a proposal subject to a separate vote.

    Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage?

    1. A At most one of the three proposals can proceed under the committee's rule.
    2. B Cedar will certainly proceed once the separate committee vote takes place.
    3. C None of the three proposals can possibly satisfy both assessment requirements.
    4. D Meeting the budget requirement is sufficient for any proposal to proceed.
    5. E The lack of step-free entry caused Birch to exceed the available budget.
  5. 51 mark

    A seed club sends the same number of packets each spring. This year it paid more for postage than last year, but its spending on envelopes fell by a larger amount than its postage spending rose. These are its only two dispatch costs. The club has not recorded whether the new envelopes protect packets better or worse.

    Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage?

    1. A The club paid less postage per packet this year than it did last year.
    2. B The new envelopes caused the increase in the club's postage spending.
    3. C The club's dispatch costs will fall again when it sends packets next spring.
    4. D The club's total dispatch cost per packet was lower this year than last year.
    5. E Every packet arrived in better condition this year because of the new envelopes.
  6. 61 mark

    A building inspector keeps a register solely of faults she personally sees. Entries are made only after she sees the fault, and every fault she sees is entered. Any vibration above the building's agreed limit counts as a fault. On Monday an instrument recorded vibration above the building's agreed limit in a locked plant room. The inspector did not personally see this vibration.

    Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage?

    1. A The inspector's Monday register contains every fault that occurred in the building.
    2. B The vibration must have begun after the inspector finished work on Monday.
    3. C A fault can occur without appearing in the inspector's register for that day.
    4. D The lack of a register entry proves that the instrument recorded vibration incorrectly.
    5. E Every fault omitted from the register occurs in a room that has been locked.
  7. 71 mark

    At a training centre, last year 50 people applied for a place and 40 met the entry requirements. This year 100 people applied and 60 met the same requirements. These figures count distinct applicants once in each year. Meeting the requirements does not guarantee a place. The centre has given no information about who attended its optional preparation sessions.

    Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage?

    1. A The preparation sessions caused more applicants to meet the requirements this year.
    2. B More applicants met the requirements this year, although a smaller proportion did so.
    3. C The centre offered places to fewer applicants this year than it did last year.
    4. D The proportion meeting the requirements will continue to fall in future years.
    5. E Most of this year's applicants who met the requirements also applied last year.
  8. 81 mark

    A rehearsal hall used its old heating timer throughout October. On 5 November it recorded the first of several days with lower fuel use than on any day in October. Staff installed a new timer on 12 November, and the old timer remained in use until that installation. The hall also recorded low fuel use on several days after 12 November. No other information about heating conditions is available.

    Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage?

    1. A The new timer caused every day of low fuel use recorded during November.
    2. B Fuel use would certainly have stayed high throughout November without the new timer.
    3. C Installing the new timer had no effect on fuel use on any day after 12 November.
    4. D Colder weather must have been responsible for the lower fuel use on 5 November.
    5. E At least one recorded low-use day cannot be attributed to operation of the new timer.
  9. 91 mark

    Every hanging sculpture in a gallery has a numbered safety cable. Some objects in the east room have no numbered safety cable. Objects may be displayed in the east room whether or not they are sculptures, and the passage gives no other rules about which objects need cables.

    Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage?

    1. A Every object with a numbered safety cable is a hanging sculpture.
    2. B Some objects in the east room are not hanging sculptures.
    3. C No object in the east room is a hanging sculpture.
    4. D Fitting a numbered cable would make any east-room object safe to hang.
    5. E Most objects without numbered cables are displayed in the east room.
  10. 101 mark

    A service desk closes a repair report either when the repair is completed or when the report duplicates an earlier report about the same fault. A duplicate report is closed immediately on receipt, even if the earlier report remains open. Yesterday report R was received about exactly the same fault as an earlier report P. At the end of yesterday work on that fault had not yet begun. The daily summary lists only the number of closed reports, without separating the two reasons for closure.

    Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage?

    1. A Every report closed yesterday concerned a fault that remained unrepaired.
    2. B No report closed yesterday can have been closed after a completed repair.
    3. C Closing duplicate reports causes the underlying repairs to take longer.
    4. D Some reports closed yesterday did not correspond to completed repairs.
    5. E The number of closed reports equals the number of completed repairs yesterday.
  11. 111 mark

    The store log concerns a single numbered seal, which can be attached to only one cabinet at a time. Nia's entry says that at exactly noon yesterday it was attached to Cabinet K. Owen's entry says that at exactly noon yesterday it was attached to Cabinet L, a different cabinet. Both entries refer to the same seal and the same instant. Nothing is recorded about how either person obtained the information.

    Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage?

    1. A At least one of the two entries is inaccurate about the seal's location.
    2. B Nia deliberately wrote a false entry about the seal's location at noon.
    3. C Owen's entry accurately identifies the cabinet holding the seal at noon.
    4. D Both entries must be inaccurate about where the seal was at noon.
    5. E Moving the seal between cabinets caused the disagreement between the entries.
  12. 121 mark

    A print dealer tests a scanner using two sheets: one genuine print and one reproduction. Their status has been established independently of the scanner. The scanner gives the sheets identical readings. Its classification system uses only those readings and always gives the same classification to identical readings. For each sheet it must choose exactly one of two classifications, genuine or reproduction.

    Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage?

    1. A The system must classify both tested sheets as genuine prints.
    2. B Every reproduction tested by the system will receive a genuine classification.
    3. C The system cannot classify both of these tested sheets correctly.
    4. D The identical readings show that the two sheets were produced in the same way.
    5. E Adding a further source of information would certainly make all classifications correct.

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    The two support totals add to 21, but there are only 18 ballots. With no overlap, 21 separate ballots would be needed.
    At least 21 - 18 = 3 ballots must have been counted in both totals. C states this lower bound without treating it as an exact count.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Overstates the minimum overlap as a majority: three shared supporters suffice for these totals, whereas a majority of eighteen requires ten.
    Why not B: Assumes complete containment of the bench supporters in the planter supporters. Eleven bench supporters cannot all fit within ten planter supporters.
    Why not D: Treats a lower bound as an exact count. More than three could support both if some residents supported neither proposal.
    Why not E: Infers an effect on use from preferences about proposals, and extends the scope beyond the residents returning ballots. No usage evidence is supplied.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    Receiving a badge requires attendance at a practice session. Every Thursday learner lacks this necessary condition.
    None can have received a badge under the rule, so A follows. Passing the oral check alone does not remove the attendance requirement.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
    Why not B: Treats one necessary condition as sufficient and drops both the attendance requirement and the explicit limit on places.
    Why not C: Extends a fact about Thursday learners to every class. The attendance and badge status of other classes are not given.
    Why not D: Adds a causal relationship between attendance and performance. An eligibility rule supplies no evidence about learning effects.
    Why not E: Turns future attendance into a guarantee, despite unknown oral-check results for some learners and the stated limit on places.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    E1
    Menu length and staffing changed together. There is no comparison in which one changed while the other was held fixed, and demand is unrecorded.
    The lower average is compatible with several different contributions from these factors. E states the resulting limit on attribution without asserting that the menu had no effect.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Assigns the entire change to the menu without separating it from staffing or possible differences in demand between the months.
    Why not B: Rules out a staffing effect even though the cook was added alongside the menu change. The records do not isolate either effect.
    Why not C: Converts a comparison of averages into a claim about every individual. The distributions of waiting times could overlap.
    Why not D: Predicts a certain reversal while staffing would still differ and demand is unknown. The earlier average is not a guaranteed outcome.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    Alder fails one required condition and Birch fails the other, so neither can proceed under the rule.
    Only Cedar remains possible. It may also fail an assessment or the vote, so the warranted conclusion is at most one, as in A, rather than exactly one.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
    Why not B: Treats the only proposal not already ruled out as certain to proceed. Cedar's assessments are unknown and a vote is still required.
    Why not C: Turns missing information about Cedar into proof of failure. Cedar could meet both conditions, even though this has not been established.
    Why not D: Drops the access condition and the separate vote, converting one necessary condition into a sufficient condition.
    Why not E: Invents a budget failure for Birch and a causal link to its access. Only Alder is said to exceed the budget.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    Subtracting a larger envelope saving than the postage increase makes the combined dispatch cost fall. There are no other dispatch costs to offset that fall.
    The number of packets is unchanged, so dividing the lower total by the same packet count gives a lower cost per packet. D follows for this year only.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Reverses the per-packet postage comparison. More postage spending spread over the same number of packets means a higher postage cost per packet.
    Why not B: Assigns causation to the envelopes without evidence about why postage spending rose. The two spending changes alone do not show this link.
    Why not C: Projects one observed saving into a certain future trend. No next-year prices, materials or spending figures are provided.
    Why not E: Invents a universal improvement in condition and attributes it to the envelopes despite the explicit absence of comparative protection records.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    The recorded vibration exceeds the agreed limit and therefore counts as a fault. The inspector did not see it, and entries are made only for faults she sees.
    The register must omit this Monday fault. C follows from combining the fault definition with the observation rule; it does not establish the frequency or location of other omissions.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Equates a complete record of personally observed faults with a complete record of all faults. The instrument recorded an unentered fault.
    Why not B: Invents a time sequence. The inspector did not see the vibration, but the timing of the vibration relative to her working hours is not given.
    Why not D: Treats absence from an observation-limited register as proof against independent evidence. The registration rule explains why a real fault can be absent.
    Why not E: Generalises from this locked-room instance to every omission. Unseen faults could occur elsewhere; no restriction to locked rooms is stated.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    The eligible count rose from 40 to 60. The eligible fraction changed from 40/50 = 4/5 to 60/100 = 3/5.
    Thus the absolute count increased while the proportion fell. B combines these two comparisons; neither offers nor effects of preparation are determined.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Attributes the change to sessions without any attendance data or comparison isolating their effect. Changed applicant numbers alone do not establish causation.
    Why not C: Confuses meeting requirements with being offered a place. Neither year's offer total is given, and eligibility is explicitly not a guarantee.
    Why not D: Turns a two-year comparison into a certain future trend without evidence about future applicants or entry outcomes.
    Why not E: Invents overlap between this year's eligible applicants and last year's applicants. Distinct counting within each year gives no information about repeat applicants.
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    E1
    The hall recorded low use on 5 November, seven days before the new timer was installed. The old timer was still in use then.
    Operation of the later timer cannot explain that earlier observation. E has the warranted scope of at least one day and leaves later effects unresolved.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Attributes even the 5 November observation to a timer not installed until 12 November. Later operation cannot account for that earlier use.
    Why not B: Makes a counterfactual guarantee contradicted by low use while the old timer was still operating on 5 November.
    Why not C: Extends exclusion of a cause for an earlier day to every later day. The timer may have affected use after installation; these records do not isolate that effect.
    Why not D: Invents both weather conditions and their causal effect. No weather information is supplied, so this alternative explanation is not established.
  9. Question 9

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    An object without a numbered cable cannot be a hanging sculpture under the gallery rule.
    There are such objects in the east room. Those objects supply the instances required by B, without ruling out hanging sculptures elsewhere in that room.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Reverses the cable requirement. Hanging sculptures need cables, but other objects could also have numbered cables.
    Why not C: Expands some cable-free objects into an exclusion of every object. Other east-room objects may have cables and be hanging sculptures.
    Why not D: Treats a necessary safety requirement as sufficient for safe hanging and invents a causal guarantee about any object.
    Why not E: Changes an existence claim about one room into a majority claim about all cable-free objects. No totals outside the room are supplied.
  10. Question 10

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    R duplicates the earlier report P, so the immediate-closure rule requires R to have been closed yesterday.
    Work on the fault had not even begun by the end of yesterday. R is therefore a closed report without a completed repair, establishing D without determining the status of other closures.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Extends the unrepaired status of the fault in report R to every closed report. Other reports may have been closed after completed repairs.
    Why not B: Excludes repair-based closures without evidence. The case of R establishes a duplicate closure, not the absence of the other type.
    Why not C: Infers a delay caused by administrative closure. The passage describes recording rules and unrepaired faults but gives no evidence of effects on repair time.
    Why not E: Equates two counts despite closures of unrepaired duplicates. No one-to-one correspondence between closed reports and completed repairs is given.
  11. Question 11

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    The same seal cannot occupy two different cabinets at the same instant. The entries cannot both accurately describe its location.
    At least one must therefore be inaccurate, as A states. This reasoning establishes neither which entry is inaccurate nor how the error arose.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
    Why not B: Selects Nia as the mistaken writer and attributes deliberate deception. Neither which entry is wrong nor either person's intent is established.
    Why not C: Resolves the conflict in Owen's favour without evidence. Nia could be right, Owen could be right, or both entries could be wrong.
    Why not D: Overstates incompatibility as joint falsity. One entry could accurately name the cabinet while the other does not.
    Why not E: Invents a causal history involving movement. The entries conflict about the same instant, and the passage gives no observation of any movement.
  12. Question 12

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    Identical readings force the same classification for the two tested sheets. Their independently established true classifications are different.
    If both are labelled genuine, the reproduction is misclassified; if both are labelled reproduction, the genuine print is misclassified. C follows in either case without predicting which output occurs.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Chooses one of two possible shared outputs without evidence. The system might instead label both sheets as reproductions.
    Why not B: Generalises from one reproduction to every reproduction and assumes the shared output is genuine. Neither claim is specified.
    Why not D: Infers a common production process from identical scanner readings. Different sheets can share these readings, and no production rule is supplied.
    Why not E: Guarantees a universal solution from unspecified extra information. Its relevance, reliability and use by the system have not been described.

Keep going

More free TARA practice