Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

TARA Critical Thinking: Identifying an assumption, set 1

Finding the unstated step an argument needs in order to get from its reasons to its conclusion. Test standard. 12 questions, 12 marks, about 22 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Answer all twelve questions. No calculator.
  • Assume the reasons given in each argument are true. Identify an unstated assumption required by the reasoning, rather than a statement that would merely strengthen it.
  • Each question has five options and exactly one correct answer. Each correct answer earns one mark; no marks are deducted for a wrong answer.
  1. 11 mark

    A design studio offers a travel grant only to applicants who have completed its introductory course and live outside the city. Every applicant who meets both conditions receives the grant. Leena completed the course last month. Leena will therefore receive a travel grant when she applies.

    Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    1. A Everyone who completes the course applies for a travel grant.
    2. B Leena found the introductory course useful for her design work.
    3. C The grant will cover the full cost of Leena's journey.
    4. D Leena lives outside the city.
    5. E Leena completed the course faster than most other applicants.
  2. 21 mark

    A bakery currently puts a fresh paper label on every reusable delivery box for each trip. It plans to engrave a permanent address code on each box instead. The bakery argues that this change will reduce the total amount of paper it uses for identifying those boxes, because it will no longer need the paper labels.

    Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    1. A Every delivery box returns to the bakery on the day it is sent.
    2. B Any supporting records needed for the codes use less paper than the labels they replace.
    3. C Engraving a box costs less than printing a single paper label.
    4. D Customers prefer engraved codes to the bakery's present labels.
    5. E No other bakery uses paper labels on reusable delivery boxes.
  3. 31 mark

    The organisers of a weekend course asked participants who stayed for the optional final discussion whether the course should be repeated. Almost all of those asked said yes. On this basis, the organisers conclude that most people who attended the course want it to be repeated.

    Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    1. A Every participant who stayed for the discussion attended every course session.
    2. B The discussion covered exactly the same material as the earlier sessions.
    3. C The organisers can afford to run the course again next year.
    4. D Participants who want a repeat also want the course to be longer.
    5. E Early leavers' views do not overturn the apparent majority.
  4. 41 mark

    A parcel depot finds that every parcel sent to the wrong loading bay last week had an unreadable destination tag. It will replace its tag printer with one that produces tags that remain readable throughout sorting. The manager concludes that this will eliminate parcels being sent to the wrong loading bay.

    Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    1. A No other cause will produce wrong-bay errors after the change.
    2. B The new printer will produce tags faster than the current printer does.
    3. C All parcels with unreadable tags were sent to the wrong bay last week.
    4. D The depot will handle the same number of parcels each week.
    5. E The new tags will use the same colour of ink as the old tags.
  5. 51 mark

    A campsite has a fixed number of pitches, and every pitch was occupied each night last summer. It charges a fee per pitch per night. Its owner plans to increase that fee this summer while keeping the number of pitches and the length of the season unchanged. The owner concludes that the campsite's total pitch-fee income will increase.

    Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    1. A All last summer's guests will return to the campsite this summer.
    2. B Any occupancy fall will not cancel out the higher fee.
    3. C The campsite's running costs will remain unchanged this summer.
    4. D The campsite charges less per night than every campsite nearby.
    5. E The owner will spend the additional income on improving the campsite.
  6. 61 mark

    A music school currently holds auditions behind a screen so that selectors cannot see candidates. It proposes replacing live auditions with named audio files. The director says this will preserve the present protection against selectors favouring candidates whose families they know, because the selectors will still be unable to see the candidates perform.

    Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    1. A Every selector can identify every instrument from an audio recording.
    2. B Recorded auditions are cheaper to organise than live auditions.
    3. C The file names will not identify candidates from known families.
    4. D Every candidate will record exactly the same piece of music.
    5. E Candidates prefer recording at home to performing at the school.
  7. 71 mark

    A pottery cooperative must choose either Kiln P or Kiln Q. Both meet all its firing requirements and cost the same to buy and maintain. P uses less electricity for each identical load. The cooperative's agreed rule is to choose whichever acceptable kiln will have the lower total cost over five years. Its treasurer therefore recommends P.

    Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    1. A Other costs will not outweigh P's electricity saving.
    2. B P can fire more pots in a single load than Q can.
    3. C The cooperative will fire exactly one load on every working day.
    4. D The cooperative could buy both kilns without borrowing money.
    5. E Every cooperative member prefers P's appearance to Q's appearance.
  8. 81 mark

    A wildlife group compares two annual counts of nesting platforms along a canal. Its volunteers recorded more occupied platforms this year than last year. The group therefore concludes that more pairs of birds nested on the canal this year. It bases this conclusion entirely on the platform counts.

    Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    1. A The same volunteers counted the platforms in both years.
    2. B Every nesting pair successfully raised young in both years.
    3. C The total number of platforms remained unchanged between the counts.
    4. D Every bird species on the canal nests on a platform.
    5. E The extra platform nests are not all relocations from uncounted sites.
  9. 91 mark

    A college has promised to give every student access to the specialist software required for their course. It proposes fulfilling this promise solely by allowing students to install the software free on their own computers. The software cannot run on phones or tablets. The principal concludes that making the installation free will fulfil the college's promise.

    Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    1. A The software is also useful for activities outside the students' courses.
    2. B Students already know how to use every feature of the software.
    3. C Every student needing the software has a suitable computer available.
    4. D The software supplier charges other colleges for each installation.
    5. E Most students would prefer to use the software on a phone.
  10. 101 mark

    A film society has a rule: it will replace its projector if and only if the current projector cannot be repaired before the next screening. The technician reports that the current projector needs a replacement part. The chair concludes that the society must replace the projector to comply with its rule.

    Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    1. A The current projector has needed a repair at least once before.
    2. B A new projector would give a sharper picture than the current one.
    3. C The replacement part costs more than the society paid for the projector.
    4. D The repair cannot be completed before the next screening.
    5. E The next screening will attract more people than the previous one.
  11. 111 mark

    A walking club wants to shorten the time its members spend travelling from the station to the start of its walks. A proposed meeting point is closer to the station in a straight line than the present meeting point. The organiser concludes that moving there will shorten that journey for members who walk from the station, relying only on the difference in straight-line distance.

    Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    1. A Obstacles on the walking route do not cancel the time advantage.
    2. B All club members arrive at the station on the same train.
    3. C The proposed point is closer to every member's home as well.
    4. D The club will choose shorter walks after moving the meeting point.
    5. E The organiser has personally walked to both meeting points before.
  12. 121 mark

    An amateur league wants every team to have equal opportunity to appeal a disputed result. The league secretary argues that charging the same appeal fee to each team achieves this aim. The secretary's sole reason is that the fee would be identical for all teams, regardless of their size or budget.

    Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?

    1. A Every team will lodge the same number of appeals during the season.
    2. B The league will uphold every appeal that a team submits.
    3. C The common fee will not exclude some teams through inability to pay.
    4. D The cost of administering an appeal is identical in every case.
    5. E The appeal fee will supply most of the league's annual income.

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    The conclusion is that Leena will receive the grant. Completing the course meets one eligibility condition, but the rule also requires residence outside the city.
    Negate D: Leena does not live outside the city. She then fails a required condition for receiving the grant, so completing the course no longer supports the conclusion.
    Therefore D supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Confuses a general application habit with individual eligibility. Other course participants need not apply for Leena to qualify.
    Why not B: Confuses personal benefit with eligibility. The grant rule does not require the course to have been useful.
    Why not C: Adds a claim about the size of the benefit. Receiving a grant does not require it to meet every travel expense.
    Why not E: Adds an irrelevant comparison. Completion speed is not one of the stated eligibility conditions.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    The conclusion concerns total identification paper, not just the disappearance of labels. The argument needs the new codes not to create an equal or larger paper requirement elsewhere in the identification process.
    Negate B: using the codes requires at least as much identification paper as the labels did. Removing the labels then produces no reduction in the total claimed.
    Therefore B supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Adds an unnecessary return deadline. Slower returns do not by themselves remove the paper saving.
    Why not C: Substitutes financial cost for paper use. The change could use less paper even if engraving costs more.
    Why not D: Confuses customer approval with material use. The paper saving can occur without a preference for codes.
    Why not E: Adds an irrelevant comparison with competitors. Their labelling practices do not determine this bakery's paper use.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    E1
    The evidence describes a self-selected subgroup, but the conclusion describes a majority of all participants. It needs support to extend far enough beyond any selection effect to form that majority.
    Negate E: the views of the early leavers overturn the apparent majority among those who stayed. The favourable responses can still be exactly as reported, but most participants overall do not want a repeat.
    Therefore E supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Confuses complete attendance with representativeness. A supporter could have missed a session and still belong to an overall majority.
    Why not B: Adds an unnecessary content restriction. The discussion can introduce new material without preventing an overall majority from wanting a repeat.
    Why not C: Confuses demand with feasibility. Participants can want a repeat even if the organisers cannot afford one.
    Why not D: Conflates repeating the course with extending it. A majority could support a repeat of precisely the same length.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    The evidence links last week's errors with unreadable tags. The conclusion promises no errors after the change, which requires readable tags to rule out wrong-bay errors in that future operation.
    Negate A: at least one parcel with a readable tag will go to the wrong bay after the change. All the historical evidence can remain true, yet the promise to eliminate these errors fails.
    Therefore A supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
    Why not B: Adds an unrelated performance improvement. Printing speed need not rise for wrong-bay errors to disappear.
    Why not C: Reverses the stated implication. Some unreadable tags could have reached the correct bay without affecting the argument about preventing errors.
    Why not D: Adds an unnecessary fixed workload. The conclusion could hold with different parcel numbers.
    Why not E: Confuses a printing detail with the missing causal guarantee. Nothing in the reasoning requires the ink colour to stay the same.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    Income depends on both the fee and the number of occupied pitch-nights. Full occupancy last summer does not establish what occupancy will be at the higher price.
    Negate B: occupied pitch-nights fall enough to cancel out the higher fee. Total fee income then stays the same or falls, despite the price rise, so the conclusion fails.
    Therefore B supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Demands far more than necessary. New guests could replace old ones, and even a small occupancy fall could leave income higher.
    Why not C: Confuses income with profit. Costs can change without determining the total pitch fees received.
    Why not D: Introduces an unnecessary price comparison. Income could rise even if the campsite were already the most expensive nearby.
    Why not E: Confuses the use of income with its receipt. The conclusion does not depend on what the owner buys.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    The conclusion concerns protection against favouring known families. Hiding a face supports that conclusion only if the proposed names do not supply the identity information the screen currently withholds.
    Negate C: the names enable selectors to recognise candidates whose families they know. The absence of a visible performance then does not preserve the claimed protection against that favouritism.
    Therefore C supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Adds an irrelevant expertise requirement. Identifying instruments does not close the gap about identifying families.
    Why not B: Substitutes an administrative advantage for the claimed protection. Lower costs are not required for that protection.
    Why not D: Confuses musical comparability with anonymity. Different pieces need not reveal which family a candidate belongs to.
    Why not E: Confuses candidate preference with selectors' access to identities. The protection could be preserved even if candidates disliked recording.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    The rule concerns total five-year cost, while the comparison covers purchase, maintenance and electricity. The recommendation needs any other cost differences not to outweigh P's electricity advantage.
    Negate A: other cost differences outweigh the electricity saving. Q then has the lower total cost, despite the stated comparisons, so the agreed rule no longer supports choosing P.
    Therefore A supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
    Why not B: Adds a capacity advantage that is not required. Both already meet the cooperative's requirements, and equal load capacity is compatible with P being cheaper.
    Why not C: Adds an exact schedule without justification. Many firing schedules could leave P with the lower total cost.
    Why not D: Confuses affordability of two purchases with the comparison between the two options. The rule calls for choosing one.
    Why not E: Substitutes aesthetic unanimity for the stated cost rule. Members' tastes need not agree for P to be the cheaper choice.
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    E1
    The conclusion is about all nesting pairs on the canal, but the evidence counts only occupied platforms. More platform occupants need not mean more pairs overall if existing pairs changed where they nested.
    Negate E: the entire increase reflects existing pairs moving from uncounted sites. More occupied platforms can then coexist with no increase in nesting pairs, removing the stated basis for the conclusion.
    Therefore E supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Confuses continuity of personnel with the coverage gap. Different volunteers could count reliably without affecting the inference.
    Why not B: Confuses nesting with breeding success. The conclusion concerns pairs that nested, whether or not they raised young.
    Why not C: Adds an unnecessary restriction on available platforms. Extra platforms could accommodate genuinely additional nesting pairs.
    Why not D: Demands complete platform use by every species. Some off-platform nests are compatible with a real overall increase; the issue is whether relocation alone explains the count.
  9. Question 9

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    The promise concerns access for every student who needs the software. Free installation removes a charge, but access through this sole proposed route also requires a suitable computer.
    Negate C: at least one student who needs the software has no access to a computer on which it runs. Free installation then leaves that student without access, so the promise is not fulfilled.
    Therefore C supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Adds a benefit beyond the promise. Access to required course software does not depend on its usefulness elsewhere.
    Why not B: Confuses access with expertise. A student can have access before learning how to use every feature.
    Why not D: Adds an irrelevant comparison with other buyers. The promise can be fulfilled regardless of what other colleges pay.
    Why not E: Confuses preference with availability. Students can have computer access even while preferring a phone.
  10. Question 10

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    The rule requires replacement exactly when timely repair is impossible. Needing a replacement part does not by itself establish that repair is impossible before the screening.
    Negate D: the repair can be completed before the screening. The replacement condition is then not met, and the rule rules out replacement. The chair must assume D to move from the need for a part to mandatory replacement.
    Therefore D supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Confuses repair history with the current deadline. Even a first fault could be impossible to fix in time.
    Why not B: Substitutes picture quality for the stated replacement condition. Better performance does not establish inability to repair in time.
    Why not C: Substitutes cost for timing. An expensive part might arrive immediately, while a cheap part might arrive too late.
    Why not E: Adds an irrelevant audience comparison. The rule turns on repair timing, not audience size.
  11. Question 11

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    The conclusion concerns walking time, but the reason concerns straight-line distance. Barriers or indirect paths could make the nearer point no quicker to reach on foot.
    Negate A: the necessary walking route takes at least as long as the present journey. The straight-line advantage then fails to deliver the shorter journey claimed.
    Therefore A supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
    Why not B: Adds an unnecessary coordination condition. Members on different trains can all benefit from a shorter onward walk.
    Why not C: Changes the starting point. The conclusion concerns journeys from the station, not from members' homes.
    Why not D: Confuses the access journey with the club walk itself. Walk length need not change for the station journey to shorten.
    Why not E: Confuses the organiser's experience with the relevant route property. The journey could be quicker even if the organiser has not tested it personally.
  12. Question 12

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    The conclusion concerns equal opportunity, while the reason establishes only an equal charge. The missing bridge is that the charge does not selectively prevent access because some teams cannot pay it.
    Negate C: the common fee is an access barrier for some teams because of their ability to pay, but not for others. Equal charges then fail to establish the equal opportunity claimed.
    Therefore C supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference.
    Mark | Award condition
    B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
    Why not A: Confuses opportunity with use. Teams can have equal access while choosing to appeal different numbers of results.
    Why not B: Confuses access to a process with success in it. Equal opportunity to appeal does not require every appeal to succeed.
    Why not D: Substitutes administrative cost for teams' access. Different processing costs do not necessarily create unequal opportunity to appeal.
    Why not E: Confuses revenue with fairness of access. The proportion of income supplied by fees does not establish whether teams can afford to appeal.

Keep going

More free TARA practice