TARA Critical Thinking: Identifying the main conclusion, set 1
Picking out the one statement in a passage that the rest of the passage exists to support, and telling it apart from the reasons and from an intermediate conclusion. Test standard. 12 questions, 12 marks, about 22 minutes.
Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)
- Answer all twelve questions. No calculator.
- Assume the reasons given in each argument are true. Choose the option that best expresses its main conclusion.
- Each question has five options and exactly one correct answer. Each correct answer earns one mark; no marks are deducted for a wrong answer.
- 11 mark
The committee should keep the reading room open until eight on weekdays. Many residents finish work after the present closing time, so they cannot use it during the week. A trial of later opening brought in people who had never visited on Saturdays. It therefore reached residents whom the existing timetable did not serve. The extra staffing cost can be met from the committee's existing budget, without reducing any other service.
Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?
- 21 mark
At the repair workshop, volunteers often spend the first half-hour searching for tools. The tools are available, but they are returned to different cupboards each week. A labelled storage board would give every tool a fixed place, making searches much shorter. The workshop ought to install one. It would also let volunteers see what is missing before a session starts, rather than discovering the gap while someone is waiting for a repair.
Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?
- 31 mark
Last year the arts centre added more performances, and its total attendance rose. Its director calls this proof that the average performance attracted a larger audience. Yet the number of performances increased by a greater proportion than the total attendance. Average attendance per performance must therefore have fallen. The director's claim about larger audiences is mistaken. The rise in total attendance may still be welcome, but that is a different claim.
Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?
- 41 mark
A neighbourhood newsletter should publish corrections beside the original online articles. At present, it puts every correction on a separate page, although most readers arrive directly at an article through a shared link. Those readers can easily miss the correction and leave with the original false impression. Placing it beside the article would address that problem. Some editors favour a single corrections page because it is easy to maintain, but administrative convenience should not take priority over giving readers accurate information.
Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?
- 51 mark
The residents' association has praised the new online-only consultation because it received more responses than the previous paper survey. But responses came mainly from the same two streets, and several other streets had no respondents at all. The larger response count therefore does not establish that a wider range of residents was heard. The association should withdraw its claim that the consultation was more representative. This does not show that the old survey was representative either; it shows that the comparison offered is insufficient.
Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?
- 61 mark
The student exhibition catalogue describes a model bridge as a failed design because it collapsed during testing. That description confuses two different aims. The students were asked to discover which of two joints failed first, not to build a bridge that would remain intact indefinitely. The collapse exposed the weaker joint exactly as intended. The model therefore fulfilled the task it was built for. Its catalogue description ought to be changed, even though it would indeed be unsuitable as a bridge for people to cross.
Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?
- 71 mark
The orchestra should select next season's rehearsal venue by asking all its members, rather than only those attending this week. Several regular players are away for performances elsewhere. A vote this week would therefore leave out people who will use the venue throughout next season. Waiting for an online vote open to everyone would avoid that exclusion. The booking deadline is still a month away, so there is no need to decide before absent members can take part.
Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?
- 81 mark
A museum wants visitors to spend more time with each object. Its new labels contain twice as many words as the old ones, and visitors now spend longer reading them. The museum takes this as evidence that visitors are paying more attention to the objects themselves. However, observations show that visitors spend the extra time looking at the labels and no more time looking at the objects. Longer label-reading is therefore not evidence of closer attention to the objects. The museum should stop presenting its reading-time figures as proof that it has achieved its aim.
Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?
- 91 mark
Some people say that a school's fiction prize is unfair because the judges disagree about which story is best. But disagreement is compatible with careful judgement: two judges may agree about a story's strengths and reasonably give those strengths different weight. Their rankings can therefore differ without either judge ignoring the published criteria. Disagreement alone is not a good reason to abolish the prize. There might be other reasons to abolish it, but those would need their own evidence.
Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?
- 101 mark
An archive proposes allowing fragile letters to be read only as digital images. Images would prevent handling damage, so they would help preserve the originals. Yet researchers sometimes need to examine marks that the images do not capture, and supervised handling can keep damage within the archive's agreed limit. The archive should retain supervised access to the original letters. Digital images can still be the normal starting point for research; preserving access to originals does not require abandoning them.
Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?
- 111 mark
The council says that moving the public noticeboard into the leisure centre would make notices easier to see because more people enter the centre than pass the board's present site. But the centre is closed during the early morning and late evening, when many shift workers pass the current board. The higher visitor count does not establish that the new location would improve access for everyone who now uses it. The proposed move should be postponed until the council has assessed the effect on those users. This need not rule out moving the board later.
Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?
- 121 mark
A charity ranks its advice sessions by the number of people attending and plans to cancel the lowest-ranked session. However, that session serves a small group whose needs no other local service meets. Its modest attendance therefore need not indicate that it has little value. Since the charity exists to meet otherwise unmet needs, attendance alone should not determine which session it cancels. This leaves open the possibility that cancellation could be justified after costs and alternatives have also been considered.
Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument?
Worked solutions
Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.
Question 1
Answer or working Marks C 1 The passage asks the committee to retain later weekday opening. The access problem and the trial provide reasons for that recommendation. The claim that the trial reached previously unserved residents is an intermediate conclusion: the new Saturday non-visitors support it, and it in turn supports later opening. The budget point removes a practical obstacle to the same recommendation. Thus C states the main conclusion. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: Mistakes a reason about access for the recommendation that this reason supports. Why not B: Stops at the intermediate conclusion about the trial's reach, which supports retaining later opening. Why not D: Mistakes the affordability reason for the overall recommendation about opening hours. Why not E: Adds an unsupported replacement of Saturday opening; the argument recommends retaining later weekdays only. Question 2
Answer or working Marks A 1 The argument moves from wasted search time to a proposed remedy: installing a labelled storage board. Fixed places would reduce searching, while visible gaps would reveal missing tools sooner. Both benefits support installing the board. The final sentence supplies another reason; its position does not make it the main conclusion. A expresses the recommendation. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: Selects the problem motivating the recommendation rather than the recommendation itself. Why not C: Selects an intermediate consequence of fixed storage, which is a reason to install the board. Why not D: Introduces a recommendation to replace tools; the passage recommends a board, not a replacement policy. Why not E: Selects the final supporting benefit merely because it appears after the main conclusion. Question 3
Answer or working Marks E 1 The director's claim is about average audiences, whereas the initial evidence concerns total attendance. The faster proportional growth in performances means average attendance fell. That intermediate conclusion directly supports the judgement that the director's claim is mistaken. The closing concession does not reverse the criticism. E expresses the judgement the argument aims to establish. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit. Why not A: Treats the opening background as the main conclusion and strengthens an association into a causal claim. Why not B: Selects the numerical comparison used as a premise, rather than the judgement it supports. Why not C: Stops at the intermediate conclusion about falling averages, used to reject the director's claim. Why not D: Turns a qualified concession that the increase may be welcome into a recommendation. Question 4
Answer or working Marks C 1 The opening recommendation is supported by the way readers reach articles and the risk that a separate correction will go unseen. The closing priority about accuracy answers an objection to that recommendation. It does not replace the recommendation as the main conclusion. C states the change the author wants the newsletter to make. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: Selects an access-pattern premise that explains why the current correction system fails. Why not B: Selects the opposing consideration that the argument acknowledges and then outweighs. Why not D: Selects a consequence of the current arrangement, which supports changing that arrangement. Why not E: Selects a supporting priority used to answer the editors' objection rather than the specific main recommendation. Question 5
Answer or working Marks B 1 The geographical concentration of responses undermines the inference from more responses to greater representativeness. That intermediate conclusion supplies the reason for withdrawing the association's claim. The main conclusion is the proposed retraction, expressed in B. The final qualification limits the criticism: it does not establish that the paper survey was better or recommend restoring it. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit. Why not A: Selects the evidence cited by the association, which the author argues is insufficient. Why not C: Stops at the intermediate conclusion about what the response count cannot establish; this supports retracting the claim. Why not D: Infers a return to paper that the passage does not recommend and that its final qualification does not support. Why not E: Selects one supporting fact about the distribution of respondents rather than the requested retraction. Question 6
Answer or working Marks D 1 The assigned aim was to identify the weaker joint. The collapse achieved that aim, so the model fulfilled its task. The author uses that intermediate conclusion to recommend changing the catalogue's description. D states this final recommendation. The concession about a bridge for people does not challenge success in the different task the students were actually set. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit. Why not A: Selects a closing concession about a different purpose, rather than the recommendation concerning the catalogue. Why not B: Stops at the intermediate conclusion about fulfilling the task, which supports changing the description. Why not C: Selects the observation used to show that the model fulfilled its intended task. Why not E: Replaces the assigned experimental aim with an aim the passage explicitly distinguishes from it. Question 7
Answer or working Marks A 1 The opening sentence recommends involving every member in the venue choice. The absence of regular users explains why consulting only this week's attendees would be inadequate. The online vote is a means of including those members, and the deadline shows there is time to do so. The argument supports consultation of all members, expressed by A; neither a single supporting fact nor the procedure's benefit captures that main point. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: Selects the factual explanation for the absences, which motivates wider consultation. Why not C: Selects an intermediate conclusion about the defect in this week's vote rather than the main recommendation. Why not D: Selects a reason why waiting is feasible, rather than the proposal this reason supports. Why not E: Selects a benefit of the suggested procedure rather than the overall recommendation about who should be consulted. Question 8
Answer or working Marks D 1 The museum's aim concerns attention to objects, while its figures measure reading labels. The observations separate these activities. The resulting intermediate conclusion is that longer reading is not evidence of closer attention to objects. That supports the recommendation to stop presenting the figures as proof of success. D gives that recommendation. The argument does not ask the museum to remove or shorten its labels. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit. Why not A: Selects the observation the museum relies on rather than the author's conclusion about using it. Why not B: Stops at the intermediate conclusion about the evidence, which supports the recommendation about reporting success. Why not C: Adds a recommendation to shorten labels; the author criticises a claim about success, not the labels' length itself. Why not E: Selects a background change that helps explain the reading times rather than the author's main point. Question 9
Answer or working Marks E 1 The passage explains how careful judges can assign different weights to the same strengths. Thus different rankings do not by themselves establish disregard of the criteria. That intermediate conclusion supports a limited main conclusion: disagreement alone is not a good reason to abolish the prize. E preserves that limitation. The final sentence leaves open abolition on other grounds, so an unconditional defence of the prize goes too far. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit. Why not A: Turns a permitted difference in judgement into a requirement for agreement that the argument does not propose. Why not B: Selects a supporting explanation of how reasonable disagreement can arise. Why not C: Overstates the conclusion by removing the explicit allowance that other reasons might justify abolition. Why not D: Stops at the intermediate conclusion that different rankings can respect the criteria; this supports rejecting disagreement alone as grounds for abolition. Question 10
Answer or working Marks B 1 The preservation benefit supports using images, but the missing marks provide a reason to retain some access to originals. Supervision makes that access compatible with the archive's damage limit. These reasons support retaining supervised access, expressed in B. The final sentence clarifies that the recommendation supplements digital access rather than ending it. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit. Why not A: Selects a conceded advantage of the proposal rather than the recommendation reached after weighing its limitation. Why not C: Selects the research need that supports retaining access rather than the recommendation itself. Why not D: Reverses the closing qualification, which explicitly permits images to remain the normal starting point. Why not E: Selects a feasibility premise explaining how access can be retained responsibly rather than the main recommendation. Question 11
Answer or working Marks C 1 The centre's opening hours raise a concern about existing users that the larger total visitor count does not settle. That limitation of the evidence supports postponing the move until its effect on those users is assessed. C states this recommendation. The last sentence limits the recommendation to a delay; it does not argue that the board must stay permanently. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: Selects the council's initial justification, which the author argues leaves a relevant group unexamined. Why not B: Stops at the intermediate conclusion about the limits of the visitor count rather than the action it supports. Why not D: Turns a temporary postponement into permanent rejection despite the explicit final qualification. Why not E: Selects the factual reason for concern about access rather than the recommendation to investigate it. Question 12
Answer or working Marks A 1 The otherwise unmet need provides evidence of value despite modest attendance. The intermediate conclusion is that low attendance need not mean little value. The charity's purpose makes that value relevant to cancellation, so attendance alone should not determine the choice. A states the main conclusion. The final qualification allows cancellation for a fuller set of reasons. It does not undermine the criticism of using attendance alone. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: Selects the premise about the session's distinctive contribution rather than the conclusion about the decision rule. Why not C: Overstates a criticism of attendance as the sole criterion into an unconditional requirement to retain the session. Why not D: Stops at the intermediate conclusion about attendance and value, which supports rejecting attendance as the sole criterion. Why not E: Selects the charity's stated purpose, which connects the unmet need to the recommendation about cancellations.