TARA Critical Thinking: Matching arguments, set 1
Recognising two arguments as having the same shape, when they are about entirely different things and the statements have been reordered to disguise it. Test standard. 12 questions, 12 marks, about 22 minutes.
Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)
- Answer all twelve questions. No calculator.
- Choose the argument with the same pattern of reasoning as the passage. Match the relationships between premises and conclusion, regardless of subject matter or statement order.
- Some passages contain invalid reasoning. Match their pattern even when the conclusion does not follow. Each question has exactly one correct answer and is worth one mark.
- 11 mark
Whenever the observatory opens its roof, its corridor lights dim. The observatory has opened its roof tonight. Therefore its corridor lights have dimmed.
Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage?
- 21 mark
If a community garden installs raised beds, its planting register is updated. The planting register has been updated. Therefore the garden has installed raised beds.
Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage?
- 31 mark
Any climbing session that uses the high wall requires a second supervisor. Today's session does not require a second supervisor. Therefore today's session does not use the high wall.
Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage?
- 41 mark
If a theatre books a touring orchestra, it hires extra music stands. The theatre has not booked a touring orchestra. Therefore it has not hired extra music stands.
Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage?
- 51 mark
Every wooden puppet in a collection has articulated joints. Some objects with articulated joints are painted red. Therefore some wooden puppets in the collection are painted red.
Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage?
- 61 mark
Every hand-bound notebook in a stationery shop has a cloth cover. Some gifts selected for a conference are hand-bound notebooks from that shop. Therefore some gifts selected for the conference have cloth covers.
Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage?
- 71 mark
The exhibition received funding from the town council or from a private trust, possibly both. It received no funding from the town council. Therefore it received funding from a private trust.
Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage?
- 81 mark
If the reading room extends its opening hours, the caretaker works an extra shift. If the caretaker works an extra shift, the payroll office receives a notice. Therefore, if the reading room extends its opening hours, the payroll office receives a notice.
Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage?
- 91 mark
All the charcoal drawings in this portfolio are monochrome works. Therefore all the monochrome works in this portfolio are charcoal drawings.
Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage?
- 101 mark
No overnight visitors at this campsite are holders of day-only passes. Some members of the walking club are overnight visitors at this campsite. Therefore some members of the walking club do not hold day-only passes.
Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage?
- 111 mark
If a research proposal receives a seed grant, it is assigned an adviser and given a project code. This proposal receives a seed grant. Therefore it is given a project code.
Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage?
- 121 mark
If the water supply is interrupted, the cafe closes early. If a fire drill is held, the cafe closes early. The cafe has closed early. Therefore either its water supply was interrupted or a fire drill was held, or both.
Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage?
Worked solutions
Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.
Question 1
Answer or working Marks D 1 The passage gives a rule connecting opening the roof to dimming the lights, states that the triggering event occurred, and concludes that the consequence occurred. D applies the same forward pattern: passing the inspection triggers a blue stamp, the bowl passed, so it receives the stamp. Stating the fact before the rule does not change the inference. A reverses the rule, B denies the triggering condition, C reasons from an absent consequence, and E denies the consequence despite the trigger. Only D preserves all three roles. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit. Why not A: Converse trap: the parcel argument works backwards from having a tracking code to express postage; the passage applies its rule forwards. Why not B: Inverse trap: the recipe argument denies the condition and then denies its consequence; the passage affirms the condition and its consequence. Why not C: The swimmer argument uses the contrapositive, moving from an absent consequence to an absent condition; the passage starts with the condition present. Why not E: The concert argument affirms the condition but concludes that its consequence is absent, reversing the polarity of the passage's conclusion. Question 2
Answer or working Marks A 1 The passage reasons backwards: installing raised beds would update the register, and the register was updated, so it claims raised beds were installed. A makes the same converse error. Recording would produce the red light, and the light is showing, so it claims recording is happening. The reordered premises leave the pattern intact. Both inferences are invalid because the stated rule allows other ways for the consequence to occur. B and D use different, valid patterns; C denies the condition and E negates the conclusion. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: The notebook argument applies a rule forwards from the condition to its consequence; the passage instead infers the condition from the consequence. Why not C: Inverse trap: the walker argument denies the condition and the consequence; the passage affirms the consequence and infers the condition. Why not D: The machine argument uses the contrapositive, denying the condition because the consequence is absent; the passage reasons from a present consequence. Why not E: The trolley argument concludes that the condition is absent, whereas the passage concludes that the condition is present after observing its consequence. Question 3
Answer or working Marks E 1 The passage says that using the high wall would require a second supervisor. The absence of that requirement rules out using the high wall. E has the same contrapositive pattern: mast climbing requires harnesses, but harnesses were not issued, so mast climbing is ruled out. Its negative fact appears before the rule. A instead denies the antecedent, B affirms the consequent, C applies the rule forwards and D gives the opposite conclusion. Only E matches the passage. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit. Why not A: Inverse trap: the folder argument starts by denying the condition, rather than denying the consequence as the passage does. Why not B: Converse trap: the gallery argument affirms the consequence and infers the condition; the passage denies both in the opposite direction. Why not C: The gate argument applies a rule to an affirmed condition. It does not eliminate a condition by observing that its required consequence is absent. Why not D: The bakery argument observes an absent consequence but affirms the condition; the passage concludes that the condition is absent. Question 4
Answer or working Marks B 1 The passage denies the rule's condition and therefore denies its consequence. This is the inverse error: other bookings might still require extra stands. B repeats that invalid pattern. Not using solvent varnish does not establish that the vents stayed shut, since another activity might require ventilation. The fact preceding the rule makes no structural difference. A rules out a condition from a missing consequence, C infers a condition from its consequence, D applies a rule forwards and E concludes a positive consequence. Only B matches. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit. Why not A: The parcel argument uses the contrapositive, starting from an absent consequence; the passage starts from an absent condition. Why not C: Converse trap: the restaurant argument affirms the consequence and infers the condition; the passage denies the condition and then the consequence. Why not D: The printer argument applies its rule forwards from an affirmed condition. The passage instead attempts to infer an absent consequence from an absent condition. Why not E: The school argument concludes that the consequence is present despite the absent condition; the passage concludes that the consequence is absent. Question 5
Answer or working Marks E 1 The passage joins two groups through articulated joints: all wooden puppets have them, and some jointed objects are red. Those red objects need not include any wooden puppets. E has the same invalid overlap pattern. All delegates have reserved seats, but the visitors with reserved seats might all be non-delegates. The existential premise is simply placed first. A identifies witnesses in the narrower class, B supplies a universal chain, C changes the conclusion's polarity and D changes its quantifier. Only E preserves the particular error. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit. Why not A: The Italian speakers are explicitly volunteers in A, so they inherit security passes. In the passage the red objects are not explicitly wooden puppets. Why not B: The van argument gives a universal second link and a universal conclusion. The passage instead uses an overlap somewhere within the middle class. Why not C: The bowl argument concludes that some bowls lack the property, blue. The passage concludes that some puppets possess the property, red. Why not D: Quantifier trap: the choir argument concludes that every choir member plays chess. The passage makes an existential conclusion about some puppets. Question 6
Answer or working Marks C 1 The passage places every member of one class inside a second class. Some conference gifts belong to the first class, so those same gifts belong to the second. C repeats this structure: some displayed objects are survey instruments, and every such instrument has an inventory number, so some displayed objects have an inventory number. Premise order does not matter. A uses only universal claims, B works backwards from a property, D overstates the number covered and E negates the inherited property. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: Quantifier trap: the ferry argument has an all premise and an all conclusion where the passage has some; it establishes a claim about the whole fleet. Why not B: Converse trap: the dish argument starts with items having the shared property, ovenproof, and infers membership of the narrower stoneware class. Why not D: Quantifier trap: the costume argument changes some qualifying costumes into a conclusion about all costumes; the passage retains some in its conclusion. Why not E: The apprentice argument denies the property in its conclusion, whereas the passage transfers the stated positive property to the identified members. Question 7
Answer or working Marks B 1 The passage states that at least one of two sources funded the exhibition. Excluding council funding leaves trust funding, even though both sources were initially allowed. B repeats this disjunctive elimination. The fault must be in at least one of cable and socket; once the cable is ruled out, the socket remains. The negative premise comes first. A incorrectly excludes an alternative after affirming the other, C asserts both alternatives, D denies the survivor and E supplies a conditional rather than alternatives. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit. Why not A: The walking argument treats an inclusive choice as exclusive, rejecting one possibility because the other occurs. The passage instead eliminates a possibility known to be absent. Why not C: The parcel argument starts with a conjunction, asserting both locations, rather than an inclusive disjunction. Its premises also contradict one another. Why not D: The booking argument denies the remaining alternative in its conclusion. The passage affirms the alternative left after one possibility is excluded. Why not E: The lamp argument uses a conditional, not a statement that at least one of two alternatives holds; denying its condition does not identify a remaining alternative. Question 8
Answer or working Marks D 1 The passage links two conditional rules through a shared middle step. It concludes that the first condition is sufficient for the last consequence, without claiming either actually happens. D supplies the same chain in reverse premise order: an overrun moves the rehearsal, and moving the rehearsal sends a message, so an overrun leads to a message. A reverses the derived rule, B has a shared result rather than a chain, C takes the inverse and E adds a factual trigger. Only D matches the two-rule conditional conclusion. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit. Why not A: Converse trap: the tin argument reverses the complete chain, inferring its initial condition from its final consequence. Why not B: The reservoir argument has two rules leading into the same consequence, a warning. It has no chain leading from the reservoir to river pollution. Why not C: Inverse trap: the parcel argument denies the first condition to deny the final consequence. The passage retains a positive conditional linking the chain's ends. Why not E: The badge argument adds a fact that triggers the chain and concludes a fact. The passage has only two rules and concludes another conditional rule. Question 9
Answer or working Marks A 1 The passage takes an inclusion of the charcoal class within the monochrome class and reverses it. Other materials could also produce monochrome works. A repeats this invalid universal conversion: all brass fittings are reusable does not imply that every reusable component is brass. The single premise and universal converse conclusion both match. B uses negation to form the contrapositive; C weakens the conclusion to some; D converts an exclusion; E converts an existential overlap. These are different patterns. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit. Why not B: The tutor argument uses a contrapositive, excluding tutor status from those without passes. The passage reverses a positive inclusion without negating either class. Why not C: Quantifier trap: the train argument concludes that some members belong to the reversed class. The passage concludes that all members do. Why not D: The rug argument reverses a no-members overlap statement, which is symmetric. The passage reverses a positive all-members inclusion, which need not be symmetric. Why not E: Quantifier trap: the village argument converts a some statement into another some statement. The passage has universal claims in both premise and conclusion. Question 10
Answer or working Marks C 1 The passage excludes every overnight visitor from the day-pass class. Some club members are overnight visitors, so those members are outside the day-pass class. C has the same exclusion pattern: some listed works are detective novels, none of those novels are reference manuals, so some listed works are not reference manuals. Its existential premise appears first. A changes some to all, B starts with people outside the excluded class, D affirms the excluded property and E replaces exclusion with positive inclusion. Only C matches. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit. Why not A: Quantifier trap: the tile argument extends an exclusion concerning some sample pieces to all sample pieces. The passage concludes only about some club members. Why not B: The festival argument treats not belonging to the orchestra as sufficient for being a beginner. The passage instead starts with membership of the class covered by its exclusion. Why not D: The battery argument concludes membership of the excluded class. The passage concludes non-membership of the class ruled out by its first premise. Why not E: The rose argument uses positive inclusion and inherits a positive property. The passage uses a no-members exclusion and concludes a negative property. Question 11
Answer or working Marks D 1 The passage states that a condition guarantees two consequences together. It affirms the condition and then selects one of those consequences. D matches: selection guarantees both subtitles and a catalogue entry; the film is selected; the conclusion selects its catalogue entry. The triggering fact is placed before the rule. A replaces and with or, B reverses the inference, C denies the triggering condition and E concludes both consequences. Only D preserves the selection of one guaranteed consequence. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit. Why not A: The ticket argument guarantees at least one benefit through or, rather than both benefits through and. It cannot select the programme as a guaranteed consequence. Why not B: Converse trap: the sculpture argument observes one consequence and infers the triggering condition. The passage starts with the condition and obtains one consequence. Why not C: Inverse trap: the delivery argument denies the triggering condition to deny one consequence. The passage affirms the condition and obtains one consequence. Why not E: The subscription argument concludes the whole pair of consequences. The passage selects just one member of its guaranteed pair as its conclusion. Question 12
Answer or working Marks B 1 The passage offers two sufficient reasons for early closure, observes early closure, and treats those reasons as if they exhausted every possible reason. An unmentioned reason could explain the closure. B repeats that invalid pattern. Two events would each notify the team; the team was notified; it infers that at least one of those events happened. Another notification source is not excluded by either rule. A applies the rules forwards, C uses their contrapositives, D concludes both conditions and E denies the result from absent conditions. Only B preserves the observed-result to either-condition inference. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit. Why not A: The bridge argument starts with at least one sufficient condition and derives their shared consequence. The passage starts with that consequence and infers that a condition occurred. Why not C: The coach argument denies the shared consequence and rules out both sufficient conditions by contraposition. The passage observes the consequence and affirms at least one condition. Why not D: The camera argument concludes that both conditions occurred, using and. The passage concludes only that at least one of its two conditions occurred, allowing either or both. Why not E: Inverse trap: the order argument denies both sufficient conditions to deny the result. The passage observes the result and claims at least one sufficient condition must have occurred.