Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

TARA Writing Task: Responding to a statement, set 1

The one essay form the task uses: explain a short statement, argue against it, and then say how far you agree and why. Test standard. 3 essay choices; attempt one in 40 minutes. Unscored. Maximum 750 words.

Download the essay choices (PDF) Download with site guidance (PDF)

  • Choose one of the three statements. Attempt only one essay in 40 minutes.
  • Write no more than 750 words. The 40 minutes includes planning and checking your response.
  • For your chosen statement, explain its meaning, give a reasoned argument against it and evaluate how far you agree.
  • This is original practice. The task is unscored; the planning guidance and qualitative rubrics are site guidance, not a university assessment scale.
  • You may use hypothetical examples. No specialist knowledge is required. A defensible conclusion may agree, disagree or qualify the statement.
  1. 1Unscored choice

    A rule is fair only if it allows no exceptions.

    Explain what the statement means. Give a reasoned argument against it. Discuss the extent to which you agree with it.

    If chosen: 40 minutes.

  2. 2Unscored choice

    Anyone making a decision on behalf of others should have to explain their reasons to those affected.

    Explain what the statement means. Give a reasoned argument against it. Discuss the extent to which you agree with it.

    If chosen: 40 minutes.

  3. 3Unscored choice

    An achievement deserves praise only for the effort it required.

    Explain what the statement means. Give a reasoned argument against it. Discuss the extent to which you agree with it.

    If chosen: 40 minutes.

Writing guidance

These unscored essay choices have no single correct answer. Rubrics and indicative content are site guidance for reviewing your writing.

  1. Essay choice 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    Plan around the force of "only if": the statement makes having no exceptions a necessary condition of fairness. It does not say that every inflexible rule is fair. Explain whether fairness means treating comparable cases alike, respecting relevant differences, or both. Keep a distinction between an exception with a public justification and a favour granted to a particular person.
    Develop the appeal of the statement before challenging it. If everyone knows that the same rule will apply, people can plan and can question a decision by referring to a common standard. In a hypothetical shared workshop, a rule against lending tools to committee members on preferential terms would protect equal access. Explain why discretion might threaten that protection; do not assume that every use of discretion does so.
    Build an argument against the necessary condition. Imagine a rule requiring every borrowed item to be returned in person on a fixed day. A borrower temporarily unable to leave home offers to have someone else return the item on time. If the purpose is to restore access for others, refusing this exception could impose an avoidable burden without advancing that purpose. Explain why this difference is relevant rather than simply asserting that flexibility is kinder.
    Test the objection with the strongest reply. The rule could instead permit anyone to nominate a substitute, so an apparent exception becomes part of a better general rule. Ask whether all relevant circumstances can be specified in advance. A justified exception may preserve the purpose of a rule, but an unexplained exception may leave similarly placed people without equal treatment. The objection supports controlled judgement more readily than unlimited discretion.
    Reach a conclusion by comparing the risks of rigidity and favouritism. One defensible judgement rejects the absolute statement while requiring reasons for exceptions that could also be offered to comparable cases. An alternative defensible conclusion accepts it within a stated understanding of a complete rule: every legitimate qualification belongs in the rule itself. Acknowledge that this interpretation must still address unforeseen circumstances rather than make unfairness disappear by definition.
    A workable essay could move from interpretation to a reason for consistency, then a developed counterexample, a reply and a final judgement. Select one or two examples and explain what they establish. The conclusion should say whether the original necessary condition survives, not merely recommend a mixture of strictness and flexibility. These are possible routes, not a required answer.
    Rubric: site guidance, not an official mark scheme or numerical score.
    Explains the necessary condition and distinguishes consistency from fairness. Develops an objection based on a relevant difference and tests it against the reply that a better rule can include qualifications. Reaches a supported judgement about exceptions, with clear organisation and precise examples; a different defensible conclusion is equally valid.Well-developed response
    Explains a plausible reading and offers reasons on both sides, but leaves the relevance of an example or the limits of discretion partly unexplained. Gives a conclusion whose connection to the argument needs further development.Developing response
    Mainly repeats the statement or substitutes the claim that all strict rules are fair. Lists benefits or exceptions without explaining a reasoned objection or evaluating agreement.Response needing further development
    Indicative content (not exhaustive):
    Equal treatment of comparable cases can be distinguished from identical treatment of every case.
    Predictability offers a reason to prefer clear rules, but does not establish that any particular rule is fair.
    A relevant difference may justify an exception if applying the rule would defeat its purpose or impose an unjustified burden.
    Compassion alone needs a link to fairness; a benefit for a friend is not justified merely by being described as an exception.
    Publishing qualifications or allowing review could constrain discretion, while adding complexity or delay.
    An essay may defend strict application in a defined context, provided it confronts the strongest case for an exception.
    Alternative defensible conclusions are welcome; examples and distinctions need not match this guidance.
  2. Essay choice 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    Identify the scope of the statement. Making a decision on behalf of others involves entrusted authority, not every private choice with an indirect effect. Explaining reasons means giving an intelligible account of why a choice was made; it need not mean obtaining unanimous approval or disclosing every piece of information. Decide whether "should have to" is a moral duty, a formal requirement, or both, and use that reading consistently.
    Develop a reason in favour. Suppose a group entrusts its organiser with allocating a shared room between activities. An explanation referring to the agreed purposes of the room gives those affected a way to challenge irrelevant preferences or a mistaken assumption. The justification is that entrusted power should be answerable to the people whose interests it serves. This remains a reason even if an explanation does not persuade everyone.
    Argue against the unrestricted requirement through a conflict of duties. Imagine an organiser changing a rota after privately learning that a volunteer cannot safely undertake a task. Revealing the full reason to everyone affected could betray confidential information. Giving an incomplete explanation might protect privacy but may not allow the others to assess the decision fully. Explain why protecting a confidence can justify limiting what the decision-maker owes directly to those affected.
    Consider a reply rather than treating confidentiality as decisive in every case. A general account of the relevant principle, or scrutiny by a trusted person who can see the confidential material, might preserve some accountability. Ask whether that meets the original requirement to explain reasons to those affected. A bare claim of confidentiality gives them little basis for challenge; equally, demanding details without limits could undermine the duty to the individual.
    Evaluate timing and burden as a further distinction if space permits. In a hypothetical urgent evacuation, the person directing a group may need to act before explaining. That challenges an immediate duty more strongly than a duty to account afterwards. A short explanation for a routine choice and a fuller explanation for a serious exclusion may meet the same principle without requiring identical procedures for every decision.
    Conclude on a defined version of the duty. One defensible position supports a presumption of accessible reasons, limited by justified privacy and urgency exceptions, with later scrutiny where possible. Another defends the statement by interpreting "explain" proportionately, while accepting that some information stays private. A stronger rejection could favour accountability through a chosen representative, but must address the loss to affected people who cannot question a decision themselves. Select a route and explain why its remaining costs are acceptable.
    Rubric: site guidance, not an official mark scheme or numerical score.
    Defines entrusted decision-making and the proposed duty to give reasons without equating explanation with consent. Develops an objection and assesses whether limited disclosure, later explanation or independent scrutiny answers it. Evaluates agreement with attention to the audience, timing or scope of reasons; a supported alternative conclusion is equally valid.Well-developed response
    Identifies accountability and an opposing consideration, but only partly explains how they conflict. Gives a judgement without fully testing whether an exception defeats or qualifies the original duty.Developing response
    Discusses leadership in general with little attention to explaining reasons to affected people. Asserts that explanations are always useful or always burdensome without a developed objection and evaluation.Response needing further development
    Indicative content (not exhaustive):
    Authority exercised for a group gives a distinct basis for accountability compared with a private decision.
    An explanation can expose an irrelevant consideration or mistaken assumption without guaranteeing a better outcome.
    People may be entitled to reasons even when they lack a right to reverse the decision.
    Confidentiality creates a possible limit on disclosure; it does not automatically justify silence about the governing principle.
    Urgency can distinguish explaining before action from accounting for it afterwards.
    Scrutiny by a representative may protect privacy, but differs from giving reasons directly to everyone affected.
    A defensible essay can support, qualify or reject the duty if it confronts both accountability and a substantive objection.
  3. Essay choice 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    Explain the restriction in "only for": effort is presented as the sole legitimate basis for praise of an achievement. This does not necessarily say that every strenuous attempt is an achievement or that all effort deserves praise. Distinguish praise for perseverance from admiration of skill, appreciation of a useful result and an award for meeting a standard. State how these ideas relate to your interpretation.
    Give the statement a serious defence. If two people reach the same goal from very different starting points, the person who had to overcome a greater difficulty may display more determination. A hypothetical beginner who practises patiently to perform a short piece could merit praise even beside an experienced performer whose result is more polished. Explain why attending to effort avoids treating an advantage someone did not choose as entirely their own credit.
    Construct an argument against making effort the exclusive basis. Suppose a person devises a simple, effective way to organise a shared cupboard, making the contents accessible to everyone who uses it. Even if the idea arrives quickly, its inventiveness and consideration for others could be worthy of praise. A cumbersome method requiring more work is not thereby more praiseworthy. Explain why this is a claim about a reason for praise, rather than merely a reason to prefer the useful outcome.
    Test both sides using the distinction between immediate and earlier effort. A skilled performance that now seems easy may depend on long preparation. That weakens a careless counterexample based only on apparent ease, but it does not show that all praise of skill is really praise of past work. Consider whether discovering a valuable solution with little preparation could still deserve recognition. Keep such cases hypothetical rather than making claims about how talent or motivation generally works.
    Evaluate the object and purpose of praise. Perseverance may be admirable when directed towards a worthwhile aim, yet effort put into a harmful project need not deserve approval. Equally, a fortunate result may be welcome without giving its recipient much personal credit. Weigh effort, judgement, intention and quality separately instead of assuming either that success proves merit or that effort proves merit.
    One defensible conclusion gives effort an important but non-exclusive role, so praise can recognise both overcoming difficulty and exercising good judgement. An alternative defends the statement by reserving moral praise for freely chosen exertion and treating approval of results or talent as a different kind of appreciation. That route needs to justify its narrower meaning of praise and consider credit for choosing a worthwhile aim. A conclusion rejecting effort as a relevant basis would need to answer the beginner example. Explain the chosen judgement rather than seeking a fixed balance between factors.
    Rubric: site guidance, not an official mark scheme or numerical score.
    Explains the exclusive basis for praise and distinguishes effort, achievement and other grounds for recognition. Develops an objection that survives consideration of hidden prior effort, and responds to the claim that effort reflects personal credit. Reaches a reasoned judgement about the grounds of praise using connected examples; a different defensible conclusion is equally valid.Well-developed response
    Offers a plausible interpretation and contrasting examples but leaves a link between effort, value and deserved praise unclear. States a view on agreement with limited engagement with a strong reply.Developing response
    Treats the statement as a claim that effort guarantees success, or discusses rewards without connecting them to praise. Relies on assertions about talent or effort without a reasoned argument against the statement and an evaluated conclusion.Response needing further development
    Indicative content (not exhaustive):
    The claim makes effort exclusive; showing that effort matters does not by itself establish the statement.
    Praise may concern perseverance, judgement, originality or benefit to others, and an essay should explain which of these grounds it accepts.
    Different starting points complicate comparisons of equal results without proving that quality is irrelevant.
    Apparent ease does not establish lack of past effort; a counterexample should address that reply.
    Hypothetical ingenuity with little exertion tests whether a worthwhile contribution can merit praise independently of effort.
    A harmful goal or a lucky outcome helps separate exertion, value and personal credit.
    Alternative defensible conclusions include a narrow defence of moral praise or a plural account of achievement, provided the definitions and reasons are explicit.

Keep going

More free TARA practice