UCAT Decision Making: Interpreting information, set 1
Reading a passage, table or chart and deciding, statement by statement, which conclusions the information supports and which it does not, however plausible they sound. Test standard. 8 questions, 16 marks, about 9 minutes.
Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)
- Answer every question. Questions are standalone.
- Multiple-statement questions are worth 2 marks; the real test gives 1 mark for a partly correct response. Other questions have exactly one correct answer.
- A basic calculator is allowed in this subtest.
- 12 marks
Using the information about Pinewell Pharmacy, decide whether each conclusion below follows.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion follows from the information. Place 'No' if it does not.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. The total number of vaccinations the pharmacy gave rose by 10 per cent from autumn 2024 to autumn 2025. 2. The extra Saturday opening hours caused the rise in vaccinations in autumn 2025. 3. In both seasons, more than half of the vaccinations the pharmacy gave were free of charge. 4. The 40 to 64 age group was the only age group in which the number of vaccinations fell. 5. A higher proportion of Harrowfield residents aged 80 and over was vaccinated against flu in autumn 2025 than in autumn 2024. - 22 marks
Using the information about Northvale Buses, decide whether each conclusion below follows.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion follows from the information. Place 'No' if it does not.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. Route 3 had the highest percentage of scheduled journeys that ran more than 5 minutes late. 2. Route 2 and Route 4 had the same percentage of scheduled journeys that ran more than 5 minutes late. 3. Across all four routes, fewer than 1 in 30 scheduled journeys were cancelled. 4. Route 4 was the most punctual route in March. 5. On average, passengers on Route 1 waited longer at their stops than passengers on Route 3. - 32 marks
Using the information about the Aldbury Surgery walking group, decide whether each conclusion below follows.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion follows from the information. Place 'No' if it does not.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. The average systolic blood pressure of the patients who joined fell by more than that of the patients who did not join. 2. Joining the walking group lowered the patients' blood pressure. 3. At the start, the average systolic blood pressures of the two groups were within 5 mmHg of each other. 4. Every patient who joined the walking group had a lower systolic blood pressure after 12 weeks than at the start. 5. Of all the patients in the table, 40 per cent joined the walking group. - 42 marks
Using the information about the Westbrook Library reading challenge, decide whether each conclusion below follows.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion follows from the information. Place 'No' if it does not.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. More than half of the children who registered completed the challenge. 2. The completion rate fell steadily as the age of the children increased. 3. Children aged 12 to 13 enjoy reading less than younger children do. 4. Children aged 8 to 9 made up more than a third of all the children who registered. 5. The 5 to 7 and 10 to 11 age bands had the same completion rate. - 52 marks
Using the information about patient falls at Ellerby General, decide whether each conclusion below follows.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion follows from the information. Place 'No' if it does not.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. The number of falls recorded on Ward A halved from the first half of the year to the second. 2. The bed-exit alarms caused the reduction in falls on Ward A. 3. Across the three wards together, the number of falls dropped by more than a quarter. 4. Ward C recorded more falls than Ward A from July to December. 5. If Ward B had been fitted with bed-exit alarms on 1 July, its falls would also have halved. - 62 marks
Using the information about Corran Bakery, decide whether each conclusion below follows.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion follows from the information. Place 'No' if it does not.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. The bakery took more money from selling loaves in April than in any of the other three months. 2. Each time the price rose from one month in the table to the next, the bakery sold fewer loaves than in the month before. 3. Raising the price of a loaf caused the bakery to sell fewer loaves. 4. The bakery took the same amount of money from selling loaves in June as in March. 5. The bakery made more profit from loaves in April than in any other month. - 72 marks
Using the information about the Brayford Hospital travel survey, decide whether each conclusion below follows.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion follows from the information. Place 'No' if it does not.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. More than half of the staff surveyed usually travel to work by car. 2. Of the four staff groups surveyed, doctors had the highest proportion who usually cycle or walk to work. 3. Of the four staff groups surveyed, nurses had the highest proportion who usually travel by bus. 4. Doctors cycle or walk to work more than other staff because they live closer to the hospital. 5. Fewer than one in five of the staff surveyed usually travel to work by bus. - 82 marks
Using the information about the district science test, decide whether each conclusion below follows.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion follows from the information. Place 'No' if it does not.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. Across the three schools, more than two thirds of the students entered passed the test. 2. Cole School had more students pass the test than either of the other two schools. 3. Brook School's revision clubs explain why it had the highest pass rate. 4. Ashby School and Brook School had the same number of students pass the test. 5. The pass rate for all the students entered, taken together, equals the average of the three schools' pass percentages.
Worked solutions
Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.
Question 1
Answer or working Marks 1 Yes, 2 No, 3 Yes, 4 Yes, 5 No 2 Read the passage first for the facts that change how the table is used: everyone vaccinated lives in Harrowfield, so free vaccination means exactly the people aged 65 and over, and the Saturday hours are only described as happening in 2025. Statements 1, 3 and 4 are arithmetic on the table. Totals are 1000 and 1100, so the rise is 10 per cent; the free groups give 620 of 1000 and 710 of 1100, both more than half; and 40 to 64 is the only row that goes down. Statement 2 claims a cause from two things that merely happened together, and statement 5 needs population figures that are not given, so neither follows. So the answers are Yes, No, Yes, Yes, No. Statement 1 (Yes): Add each column: 2024 is 120 + 260 + 410 + 210 = 1000 and 2025 is 150 + 240 + 470 + 240 = 1100. The rise is 100 on a base of 1000, which is exactly 10 per cent. Statement 2 (No): The passage only says the two things happened in the same season. Nothing rules out other reasons for the rise, so a cause cannot be concluded from the table; this is correlation read as cause. Statement 3 (Yes): The pharmacy vaccinates only Harrowfield residents, and for them free means aged 65 and over, so combine the bottom two rows: 410 + 210 = 620 of 1000 in 2024, and 470 + 240 = 710 of 1100 in 2025. Half of 1100 is 550, and 710 is more than that, so the claim holds in both seasons. Statement 4 (Yes): Compare each row: 18 to 39 rose (120 to 150), 40 to 64 fell (260 to 240), 65 to 79 rose (410 to 470) and 80 and over rose (210 to 240). Only one group fell. Statement 5 (No): The table counts vaccinations at one pharmacy. It gives neither the number of residents aged 80 and over nor vaccinations given anywhere else, so no proportion of residents can be worked out. Plausible, but not supported. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 2
Answer or working Marks 1 No, 2 Yes, 3 Yes, 4 No, 5 No 2 Turn every comparison into a rate: the routes run different numbers of journeys, so raw counts mislead. Late rates are 10, 20, 7 and 20 per cent for Routes 1 to 4, which settles statements 1 and 2. Cancellations total 28 of 1300, well under 1 in 30 (about 43). For punctuality use the passage's definition and remove both late and cancelled journeys: 88, 78, 90 and 80 per cent, so Route 3 is most punctual, not Route 4. Statement 5 needs passenger waiting data that the information does not contain. So the answers are No, Yes, Yes, No, No. Statement 1 (No): Route 3 had 35 late of 500, which is 7 per cent. Route 1 had 40 of 400 (10 per cent) and Routes 2 and 4 had 20 per cent each. Route 3's figure is the lowest, not the highest; the error is reading the smallest absolute count as a rate without dividing. Statement 2 (Yes): Route 2: 50 / 250 = 1/5 = 20 per cent. Route 4: 30 / 150 = 1/5 = 20 per cent. They are equal. Statement 3 (Yes): Total cancelled is 8 + 5 + 15 + 0 = 28. Total scheduled is 400 + 250 + 500 + 150 = 1300. One in 30 of 1300 is about 43, and 28 is fewer than that (28 x 30 = 840, which is less than 1300). Statement 4 (No): Punctual means ran and not late, so subtract both columns. Route 1: 400 - 40 - 8 = 352 of 400, 88 per cent. Route 2: 195 of 250, 78 per cent. Route 3: 450 of 500, 90 per cent. Route 4: 120 of 150, 80 per cent. Route 3 was the most punctual; Route 4 only looks best if you notice its zero cancellations and forget its lateness. Statement 5 (No): The table records journeys, not passengers or waiting times. How long passengers waited depends on things not given, such as how often buses run and how late the late ones were, so this does not follow. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 3
Answer or working Marks 1 Yes, 2 No, 3 Yes, 4 No, 5 Yes 2 Note the design before the numbers: patients chose for themselves whether to join, and the table gives averages only. Statements 1, 3 and 5 are checks on the table: falls of 11 and 3 mmHg, starting averages 2 mmHg apart, and 60 of 150 patients, which is 40 per cent. Statement 2 reads a causal effect into a self-selected comparison, and statement 4 turns an average into a claim about every individual; neither follows. So the answers are Yes, No, Yes, No, Yes. Statement 1 (Yes): Joined: 152 - 141 = 11 mmHg fall. Did not join: 150 - 147 = 3 mmHg fall. 11 is more than 3. Statement 2 (No): Patients chose whether to join, so the two groups may differ in other ways, such as motivation, diet or medication. A bigger fall in one group shows an association, not that walking caused it. Statement 3 (Yes): The starting averages are 152 and 150, a difference of 2 mmHg, which is within 5. Statement 4 (No): Only group averages are given. An average fall of 11 mmHg is consistent with some individuals rising, so 'every patient' cannot be concluded. Statement 5 (Yes): Combine the rows: 60 + 90 = 150 patients in total, and 60 / 150 = 2/5 = 40 per cent. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 4
Answer or working Marks 1 Yes, 2 No, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 Yes 2 Work out each band's completion rate once and reuse it: 50, 62.5, 50 and 25 per cent. Those rates settle statements 2 and 5: the pattern rises before it falls, and the 5 to 7 and 10 to 11 bands are both 50 per cent. Totals of 700 registered and 360 completed settle statements 1 and 4 (360 is over 350, and 240 is over 233). Statement 3 swaps a measured thing (completion) for an unmeasured one (enjoyment), so it does not follow. So the answers are Yes, No, No, Yes, Yes. Statement 1 (Yes): Registered total: 180 + 240 + 200 + 80 = 700. Completed total: 90 + 150 + 100 + 20 = 360. Half of 700 is 350, and 360 is more than 350. Statement 2 (No): Completion rates are 90/180 = 50 per cent, 150/240 = 62.5 per cent, 100/200 = 50 per cent and 20/80 = 25 per cent. The rate rose from the youngest band to the next, so it did not fall steadily. Statement 3 (No): The table measures completion of one library challenge, not enjoyment of reading. Older children may read other books, or be busier in August; the conclusion is plausible but goes beyond the information. Statement 4 (Yes): A third of 700 is about 233 (700 / 3 = 233.3), and 240 registered in that band, so it is more than a third. Statement 5 (Yes): 90 of 180 and 100 of 200 are both exactly a half, so both rates are 50 per cent. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 5
Answer or working Marks 1 Yes, 2 No, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 No 2 Use the passage for the setting: the wards are equal in size and full, so raw counts are comparable, and only Ward A changed its equipment. Statements 1 and 4 are direct reads. For statement 3, total the columns (62 and 48): a drop of 14 is less than a quarter of 62, which is 15.5. Statements 2 and 5 both assume the alarms caused Ward A's fall; the data show only that the two happened together, and Ward B improved without alarms. So the answers are Yes, No, No, Yes, No. Statement 1 (Yes): Ward A recorded 24 falls from January to June and 12 from July to December, and 12 is half of 24. Statement 2 (No): The fall in numbers coincides with the alarms, but Ward B also had fewer falls without any alarms, and nothing else about the wards is reported. Timing alone does not establish cause. Statement 3 (No): Combine the rows: 24 + 18 + 20 = 62 in the first half and 12 + 15 + 21 = 48 in the second. The drop is 14, and a quarter of 62 is 15.5, so the drop is less than a quarter (about 23 per cent). Ward A's halving does not carry the total with it. Statement 4 (Yes): From July to December Ward C recorded 21 falls and Ward A recorded 12. Statement 5 (No): This predicts what would have happened under conditions that did not occur. The information does not show that the alarms caused Ward A's change, let alone that the same size of change would happen on another ward. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 6
Answer or working Marks 1 Yes, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 No 2 Work out takings for each month as price times loaves sold: 240,000p, 242,000p, 220,000p and 240,000p. Those figures settle statements 1 and 4. For statement 2, find each step in the table where the price rose (March to April and May to June) and check sales fell at each, which they did. Statement 3 claims a cause even though sales also fell in May with no price change, and statement 5 needs cost data that is not given, so neither follows. So the answers are Yes, Yes, No, Yes, No. Statement 1 (Yes): Takings are price x loaves. March: 200 x 1200 = 240,000p. April: 220 x 1100 = 242,000p. May: 220 x 1000 = 220,000p. June: 250 x 960 = 240,000p. April is the highest. Statement 2 (Yes): Between months in the table the price rose twice: March to April (200p to 220p) and May to June (220p to 250p). Sales fell in April (1200 to 1100) and in June (1000 to 960), so the claim holds for both rises. Statement 3 (No): Sales also fell in May, when the price did not change, so something other than price was reducing sales. The data show the two moving together, not that price caused the fall. Statement 4 (Yes): June: 250 x 960 = 240,000p. March: 200 x 1200 = 240,000p. Both are 2400 pounds. Statement 5 (No): Profit is takings minus costs, and no costs are given. April had the highest takings, but takings are not profit. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 7
Answer or working Marks 1 Yes, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 No, 5 No 2 The groups are different sizes (160, 80, 100 and 60), so any comparison between groups must use proportions, while whole-survey claims use the column totals out of 400. Column totals: car 220 (55 per cent) and bus 110 (27.5 per cent), which settle statements 1 and 5. Within-group shares: cycle or walk is highest for doctors (37.5 per cent); bus is highest for 'other' (about 33 per cent), not nurses (31.25 per cent). Statement 4 adds a reason the survey never asked about, so it does not follow. So the answers are Yes, Yes, No, No, No. Statement 1 (Yes): Car total: 90 + 40 + 60 + 30 = 220 of 400, which is 55 per cent, more than half. Statement 2 (Yes): Cycle or walk as a share of each group: nurses 20/160 = 12.5 per cent, doctors 30/80 = 37.5 per cent, administrative 10/100 = 10 per cent, other 10/60 = about 17 per cent. Doctors are highest. Statement 3 (No): Nurses had the most bus users (50), but as a proportion: nurses 50/160 = 31.25 per cent, doctors 10/80 = 12.5 per cent, administrative 30/100 = 30 per cent, other 20/60 = about 33 per cent. The 'other' group is highest; the error is comparing counts across groups of different sizes. Statement 4 (No): The survey records how people travel, not where they live or why they choose a mode. The reason given is an assumption, not something in the information. Statement 5 (No): Bus total: 50 + 10 + 30 + 20 = 110 of 400, which is 27.5 per cent. One in five would be 80, and 110 is more than that. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 8
Answer or working Marks 1 No, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 No 2 Percentages of different-sized groups must be converted to counts before they are compared or combined: 120, 120 and 130 passes from 200, 150 and 250 entries. Counts settle statements 2 and 4. Totals of 370 passes from 600 entries give about 61.7 per cent overall, below two thirds (400 of 600) and not equal to the unweighted average of 64 per cent, so statements 1 and 5 do not follow. Statement 3 reads a cause into the fact that the school with clubs had the highest rate, which the information cannot support. So the answers are No, Yes, No, Yes, No. Statement 1 (No): Passes total 120 + 120 + 130 = 370 out of 200 + 150 + 250 = 600 entered. Two thirds of 600 is 400, and 370 is fewer, so the overall rate is about 62 per cent. Statement 2 (Yes): Convert percentages to numbers: Ashby 60 per cent of 200 = 120, Brook 80 per cent of 150 = 120, Cole 52 per cent of 250 = 130. Cole's 130 is the most, despite having the lowest pass rate. Statement 3 (No): Brook does have the highest rate and does run clubs, but nothing in the information links the two. The schools may differ in many other ways, so the clubs cannot be concluded to be the cause. Statement 4 (Yes): Ashby: 0.6 x 200 = 120. Brook: 0.8 x 150 = 120. The numbers are equal. Statement 5 (No): The simple average of 60, 80 and 52 is 192 / 3 = 64 per cent, but the overall rate is 370 / 600, about 61.7 per cent. They differ because the schools entered different numbers of students, so the percentages need weighting. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response.