Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

UCAT Decision Making: Logical puzzles, set 1

Arranging people, places or times from a set of clues until one option is forced, and telling what must be true apart from what only might be. Test standard. 10 questions, 10 marks, about 11 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Answer every question. Questions are standalone.
  • Multiple-statement questions are worth 2 marks; the real test gives 1 mark for a partly correct response. Other questions have exactly one correct answer.
  • A basic calculator is allowed in this subtest.
  1. 11 mark

    Five healthcare assistants, Hana, Ivo, Jess, Kemal and Lior, sit in a row of five chairs for a training session. The chairs are numbered 1 to 5 from left to right.

    Hana sits in one of the two end chairs.

    Ivo sits immediately to the right of Jess.

    Lior does not sit in an end chair.

    Kemal does not sit next to Lior.

    Which of the following MUST be true?

    1. A Jess sits in chair 3.
    2. B Lior sits next to Hana.
    3. C Kemal sits in chair 5.
    4. D Ivo sits next to Kemal.
  2. 21 mark

    A dental practice has five hygienists: Pat, Quin, Rae, Sol and Tom. Each works exactly one late shift between Monday and Friday, and there is one hygienist on each day.

    Pat works on an earlier day than Rae.

    Quin does not work on Monday or Friday.

    Sol works on the day immediately after Quin.

    Tom works on Wednesday or Thursday.

    Which of the following COULD be true?

    1. A Rae works the day before Tom.
    2. B Pat works the Tuesday shift.
    3. C Quin works on Wednesday.
    4. D Sol works on Thursday.
  3. 31 mark

    Six runners, Ada, Ben, Cal, Dina, Eli and Fay, finish a charity 5 km race. There are no ties.

    Ben finished behind Ada but ahead of Cal.

    Dina finished immediately behind Eli.

    Fay did not finish in the top three.

    Cal finished ahead of Fay.

    Which of the following CANNOT be true?

    1. A Eli finished first.
    2. B Dina finished fourth.
    3. C Cal finished fifth.
    4. D Ben finished third.
  4. 41 mark

    Four nurses, Ola, Pia, Raj and Tess, each work on a different ward (Cardiology, Maternity, Renal or Stroke) and each qualified in a different year (2021, 2022, 2023 or 2024).

    The nurse on Renal qualified in 2022.

    Ola qualified before Pia, and Pia qualified before Raj.

    Tess works on Maternity.

    Ola does not work on Cardiology.

    The nurse on Stroke did not qualify in 2021.

    Which of the following MUST be true?

    1. A Pia works on the Stroke ward.
    2. B Tess qualified before Ola.
    3. C The Cardiology nurse qualified in 2024.
    4. D Raj qualified in 2023.
  5. 51 mark

    A shuttle bus runs from Kestle Station to Brayford Hospital. It leaves the station at 07:10, 07:35, 08:00 and 08:25.

    The journey normally takes 22 minutes. A shuttle that leaves between 07:30 and 08:10 (inclusive) takes 31 minutes instead, because of school traffic.

    From the hospital bus stop it is a 6-minute walk to the outpatient clinic.

    Nadia must be at the clinic by 08:30. What is the latest shuttle she can catch from Kestle Station?

    1. A 07:10
    2. B 07:35
    3. C 08:00
    4. D 08:25
  6. 61 mark

    A clinic building has five floors, numbered 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest). Each floor houses exactly one department: Outpatients, Pharmacy, Physiotherapy, Radiology or Records.

    Radiology is on a lower floor than Physiotherapy.

    Outpatients is on the floor directly above Pharmacy.

    Records is not on floor 1 or floor 5.

    Physiotherapy is not on floor 5.

    Which of the following CANNOT be true?

    1. A Records is on a higher floor than Pharmacy.
    2. B Records is directly above Radiology.
    3. C Physiotherapy is directly below Pharmacy.
    4. D Radiology is directly below Physiotherapy.
  7. 71 mark

    Six committee members, Uma, Vic, Wen, Xan, Yas and Zoe, sit around a circular table with six equally spaced chairs. Each person has exactly two neighbours, and 'directly opposite' means three chairs away.

    Vic sits directly opposite Uma.

    Wen sits next to Uma.

    Xan does not sit next to Vic.

    Which of the following COULD be true?

    1. A Zoe sits directly opposite Wen.
    2. B Wen sits next to Vic.
    3. C Xan sits next to Wen.
    4. D Yas sits directly opposite Uma.
  8. 81 mark

    Four netball teams, Ashby, Brent, Corby and Dunmore, each played every other team exactly once. A win earned 3 points, a draw earned 1 point for each team and a loss earned 0 points.

    The final points totals were: Ashby 7, Brent 4, Corby 4, Dunmore 1.

    Which of the following MUST be true?

    1. A Ashby beat Brent.
    2. B Corby beat Dunmore.
    3. C Exactly two of the six matches were drawn.
    4. D Brent and Corby drew their match with each other.
  9. 91 mark

    A laboratory analyser runs four tests, one at a time and with no gaps, starting at 09:00. Test P takes 40 minutes, Test Q 25 minutes, Test R 15 minutes and Test S 30 minutes.

    Test P cannot be run first.

    Test S must start the moment Test P finishes.

    Test R must be run at some point before Test Q.

    What is the earliest time at which Test S can finish?

    1. A 09:45
    2. B 10:10
    3. C 10:25
    4. D 10:50
  10. 101 mark

    Six gardeners, Greta, Hamid, Ines, Jun, Kofi and Lena, each rent one of six allotment plots in a straight row, numbered 1 to 6. Two plots are next to each other only if their numbers differ by 1.

    Hamid's plot is next to Ines's plot.

    Jun's plot number is lower than Kofi's.

    Ines's plot number is higher than Jun's.

    Lena has plot 1 or plot 6.

    Greta's plot is not next to Lena's.

    If Greta has plot 4, which of the following MUST be true?

    1. A Hamid has plot 2.
    2. B Jun has plot 3.
    3. C Lena has plot 6.
    4. D Kofi's plot is next to Greta's.

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    Lior is not at an end, so Lior is in chair 2, 3 or 4. Test each, remembering that Jess and Ivo need two neighbouring chairs with Jess on the left.
    Lior in chair 3: Kemal cannot use chair 2 or 4, so Kemal and Hana take the two ends. That leaves chairs 2 and 4 for Jess and Ivo, which are not next to each other. Impossible.
    Lior in chair 2: Kemal cannot use chair 1 or 3, so Kemal is in chair 4 or 5. If Hana took chair 5, Kemal would be in 4 and Jess and Ivo would be left with 1 and 3, which fails. So Hana is in chair 1. Kemal in 4 would leave 3 and 5 (fails), so Kemal is in 5, Jess in 3 and Ivo in 4: Hana, Lior, Jess, Ivo, Kemal.
    Lior in chair 4: by the mirror-image argument Hana is in chair 5, Kemal in 1, Jess in 2 and Ivo in 3: Kemal, Jess, Ivo, Lior, Hana.
    In both arrangements Lior is beside Hana (chairs 2 and 1, or 4 and 5). Every other option holds in only one arrangement. The answer is B.
    Why not A: Stops after finding the first arrangement (Hana, Lior, Jess, Ivo, Kemal). In the mirror arrangement Kemal, Jess, Ivo, Lior, Hana, Jess is in chair 2, so chair 3 is possible but not forced.
    Why not C: Comes from the same single arrangement. Kemal is in chair 5 only when Hana takes chair 1; when Hana takes chair 5, Kemal is in chair 1.
    Why not D: True in Hana, Lior, Jess, Ivo, Kemal (Ivo 4, Kemal 5) but false in Kemal, Jess, Ivo, Lior, Hana (Kemal 1, Ivo 3). It could be true, but the question asks what MUST be true.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    Quin works Tuesday, Wednesday or Thursday, and Sol works the next day. Test the three cases against Tom, who needs Wednesday or Thursday.
    Quin on Wednesday puts Sol on Thursday, so Tom has no allowed day. This case is impossible.
    Quin on Tuesday puts Sol on Wednesday, so Tom works Thursday. Monday and Friday are left for Pat and Rae, and Pat is earlier: Pat Monday, Quin Tuesday, Sol Wednesday, Tom Thursday, Rae Friday.
    Quin on Thursday puts Sol on Friday, so Tom works Wednesday. Monday and Tuesday are left: Pat Monday, Rae Tuesday, Tom Wednesday, Quin Thursday, Sol Friday.
    In the second rota Rae (Tuesday) works the day before Tom (Wednesday), so option A could be true. Pat is on Monday in both rotas, and options C and D both need the impossible Wednesday-Thursday case. The answer is A.
    Why not B: Treats 'Pat before Rae' as leaving Pat free, without placing the others first. In both possible rotas the only days left for Pat and Rae include Monday, and Pat must take the earlier one, so Pat always works Monday.
    Why not C: Places Quin on Wednesday and Sol on Thursday without checking Tom's clue: Tom then has neither Wednesday nor Thursday available, so this rota breaks a rule.
    Why not D: The same missed check from Sol's side: Sol on Thursday forces Quin onto Wednesday, which again leaves Tom with no permitted day.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    The order runs Ada, then Ben, then Cal, then Fay (not necessarily next to each other), with Eli and Dina as an unbroken pair somewhere. Fay is fourth or lower.
    Suppose Ben is third. Ada is first or second, and Cal and Fay are both behind Ben, so the other top-two place must go to Eli or Dina. That runner needs their partner in the very next or very previous place.
    If Ada is first, place 2 must be Eli or Dina: Eli second needs Dina third (Ben's place), and Dina second needs Eli first (Ada's place). If Ada is second, place 1 must be Eli (Dina cannot be first), and then Dina needs second (Ada's place). Every case fails, so Ben cannot be third.
    The other options each have a valid order: Eli, Dina, Ada, Ben, Cal, Fay (Eli first) and Ada, Ben, Eli, Dina, Cal, Fay (Dina fourth and Cal fifth).
    The only statement that cannot be true is that Ben finished third. The answer is D.
    Why not A: Assumes Ada must win because she is ahead of Ben and Cal, forgetting that Eli and Dina are not ranked against Ada at all. Eli, Dina, Ada, Ben, Cal, Fay satisfies every clue.
    Why not B: Assumes Ben and Cal must finish in consecutive places, so the Eli-Dina pair cannot sit between them. Ada, Ben, Eli, Dina, Cal, Fay puts Dina fourth and breaks no clue.
    Why not C: Assumes Fay must be placed fourth or fifth, which squeezes Cal into the top four. Fay can be sixth, as in Ada, Ben, Eli, Dina, Cal, Fay, where Cal is fifth.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    Tess is on Maternity, so she is not the Renal nurse and did not qualify in 2022. Ola, Pia and Raj take the other three years in that order, so the only question is whether Tess has 2021, 2023 or 2024.
    If Tess qualified in 2023 or 2024, then Ola qualified in 2021 and Pia in 2022 (Pia is on Renal). Ola must then be on Cardiology or Stroke; Cardiology is ruled out, and the Stroke nurse did not qualify in 2021. So these cases are impossible.
    Therefore Tess qualified in 2021, and Ola 2022, Pia 2023, Raj 2024. Ola is the 2022 nurse, so Ola works on Renal.
    Pia and Raj take Cardiology and Stroke in either order; both allocations obey every clue. So options A and C hold in only one allocation, and option D is false in both.
    In every allocation Tess (2021) qualified before Ola (2022). The answer is B.
    Why not A: Pia and Raj end up sharing Cardiology and Stroke with nothing to decide between them. Pia on Stroke is one of two valid allocations, so it could be true but is not forced.
    Why not C: True only in the allocation where Raj (2024) is on Cardiology. When Pia takes Cardiology, the Cardiology nurse qualified in 2023.
    Why not D: Comes from putting Tess last (2024) and filling Ola 2021, Pia 2022, Raj 2023 without checking Ola's ward. Ola qualified in 2021 could then only work on Stroke, which the last clue forbids.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    Work out when each shuttle gets Nadia to the clinic: departure, plus journey time, plus the 6-minute walk.
    07:10 is outside the slow window: 07:10 + 22 = 07:32, then 07:38 at the clinic. 07:35 is inside it: 07:35 + 31 = 08:06, then 08:12 at the clinic.
    08:00 is also inside the slow window: 08:00 + 31 = 08:31, then 08:37 at the clinic, which is too late. 08:25 is outside it: 08:25 + 22 = 08:47, then 08:53, also too late.
    The shuttles that get her there by 08:30 leave at 07:10 and 07:35, and the later of these is 07:35. The answer is B.
    Why not A: Reads the slow journey as 31 minutes on top of the normal 22: 07:35 + 22 + 31 + 6 = 08:34, which looks too late, so the earlier 07:10 is chosen. The text says 31 minutes instead of 22.
    Why not C: Forgets the school-traffic rule and uses 22 minutes for every shuttle: 08:00 + 22 + 6 = 08:28 looks in time, but 08:00 is inside the slow window, so the real arrival is 08:37.
    Why not D: Treats 08:30 as the time to board rather than the time to be at the clinic, and picks the last departure before it. 08:25 + 22 + 6 = 08:53.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    Start with floor 5. Records and Physiotherapy are banned from it, Radiology must be below Physiotherapy, and Pharmacy needs Outpatients above it. So floor 5 is Outpatients, and Pharmacy is on floor 4.
    Floors 1 to 3 hold Radiology, Physiotherapy and Records. Records is not on floor 1, and Physiotherapy cannot be on floor 1 because Radiology must be below it. So Radiology is on floor 1.
    Physiotherapy and Records share floors 2 and 3 in either order, giving two valid buildings: Radiology, Physiotherapy, Records, Pharmacy, Outpatients, or Radiology, Records, Physiotherapy, Pharmacy, Outpatients (floors 1 to 5).
    Options B, C and D each hold in one of these buildings. Records is on floor 2 or 3 and Pharmacy is always on floor 4, so Records can never be higher than Pharmacy. The answer is A.
    Why not B: Fixes Physiotherapy on floor 2 and treats that as the only arrangement. With Records on floor 2 and Physiotherapy on floor 3, Records sits directly above Radiology on floor 1.
    Why not C: Again settles on one arrangement too early. When Physiotherapy is on floor 3 it is directly below Pharmacy on floor 4.
    Why not D: Rejects this by keeping Records on floor 2. When Physiotherapy takes floor 2 and Records floor 3, Radiology on floor 1 is directly below it.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    Number the chairs 1 to 6 round the table and put Uma in chair 1, so Vic is in chair 4. Uma's neighbours are chairs 2 and 6; Vic's neighbours are chairs 3 and 5.
    Xan is not beside Vic, so Xan is in chair 2 or 6. Wen is beside Uma, so Wen is also in chair 2 or 6. Wen and Xan therefore fill chairs 2 and 6, and Yas and Zoe fill chairs 3 and 5.
    The chair opposite 2 is 5, and the chair opposite 6 is 3. Whichever of chairs 2 and 6 Wen has, the chair opposite is one that Yas or Zoe sits in, so Zoe can be directly opposite Wen.
    Wen (chair 2 or 6) is never beside Vic (neighbours 3 and 5), chairs 2 and 6 are not neighbours, and the chair opposite Uma is Vic's. The answer is A.
    Why not B: Misses that both chairs beside Uma are two chairs away from Vic. Wen must be beside Uma, so Wen can never be beside Vic.
    Why not C: Assumes the two chairs either side of Uma touch each other. In a six-chair circle they are separated by Uma, so Wen and Xan, who fill those two chairs, are never neighbours.
    Why not D: Forgets that only one chair is directly opposite Uma, and the first clue gives that chair to Vic.
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    Four teams playing each other once means 6 matches. A decided match hands out 3 points in total and a drawn match hands out 2 (1 each).
    If all 6 matches had a winner, the totals would add up to 6 x 3 = 18. The actual total is 7 + 4 + 4 + 1 = 16, and each draw lowers the total by 1, so there were exactly 18 - 16 = 2 draws.
    Check that the other options are not forced with one valid table: Ashby drew with Brent and beat Corby and Dunmore (7); Brent beat Dunmore and lost to Corby (1 + 3 + 0 = 4); Corby beat Brent and drew with Dunmore (0 + 3 + 1 = 4); Dunmore has 1. Here Ashby did not beat Brent, Corby did not beat Dunmore, and Brent and Corby did not draw.
    So options A, B and D can all be false, while exactly two draws follows from the points total alone. The answer is C.
    Why not A: Assumes the top team must have beaten the runner-up. Ashby can earn its 7 points by drawing with Brent and beating Corby and Dunmore.
    Why not B: Assumes the bottom team lost every match it did not draw against the top team. Dunmore's one draw can be against Corby instead.
    Why not D: Assumes two teams level on points must have drawn with each other. Brent and Corby can each get 4 points from one win, one draw and one loss with a result between them.
  9. Question 9

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    P and S always run together as a block, P then S, lasting 40 + 30 = 70 minutes. Find which test can go first.
    P cannot be first, S cannot be first because it follows P, and Q cannot be first because R must come before it. So R runs first, from 09:00 to 09:15.
    After R there are two possible orders: the P-S block then Q, or Q then the P-S block. In the first, S finishes 15 + 70 = 85 minutes after 09:00, at 10:25. In the second, S finishes 15 + 25 + 70 = 110 minutes after 09:00, at 10:50.
    The earlier of these is 10:25. The answer is C.
    Why not A: Runs R then S (15 + 30 = 45 minutes, so 09:45), ignoring that S can only start straight after P has finished.
    Why not B: Runs P and then S first (40 + 30 = 70 minutes, so 10:10), ignoring the rule that P cannot be first.
    Why not D: Puts Q straight after R before running P and S (15 + 25 + 40 + 30 = 110 minutes, so 10:50). That order is allowed, but it is the later of the two, not the earliest.
  10. Question 10

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    With Greta on plot 4, Lena (plot 1 or 6) is never next to her, so both of Lena's plots are still open. Hamid and Ines need two neighbouring free plots.
    Lena on plot 6 leaves plots 1, 2, 3 and 5. Hamid and Ines take 1-2 or 2-3. If they take 1-2, Jun and Kofi take 3 and 5, so Jun is on 3, higher than Ines: not allowed. So Hamid and Ines take 2 and 3, Jun takes 1 and Kofi takes 5.
    Lena on plot 1 leaves plots 2, 3, 5 and 6. If Hamid and Ines took 2-3, Jun would be on 5 or 6, above Ines: not allowed. So Hamid and Ines take 5 and 6, and Jun and Kofi take 2 and 3 with Jun lower: Jun 2, Kofi 3.
    That gives four arrangements (Hamid and Ines can swap in each case). Kofi is on plot 5 in the first two and plot 3 in the last two, so Kofi is always next to Greta on plot 4. The answer is D.
    Why not A: True in only one arrangement (Jun 1, Hamid 2, Ines 3, Greta 4, Kofi 5, Lena 6). Hamid and Ines can swap plots 2 and 3, and when Lena has plot 1 Hamid is on plot 5 or 6.
    Why not B: Comes from putting Hamid and Ines on plots 1 and 2 when Lena has plot 6, which leaves Jun 3 and Kofi 5. That breaks the clue that Ines's number is higher than Jun's, so Jun is never on plot 3.
    Why not C: Lena on plot 6 is one of two possibilities. Lena 1, Jun 2, Kofi 3, Greta 4, with Hamid and Ines on 5 and 6, also satisfies every clue.

Keep going

More free UCAT practice