Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

UCAT Decision Making: Recognising assumptions, set 1

Choosing the strongest of four Yes and No arguments on a practical question: the one that addresses the question directly and rests on stated fact rather than on an assumption or opinion. Test standard. 10 questions, 10 marks, about 10 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Answer every question. Questions are standalone.
  • Multiple-statement questions are worth 2 marks; the real test gives 1 mark for a partly correct response. Other questions have exactly one correct answer.
  • A basic calculator is allowed in this subtest.
  1. 11 mark

    Should Harrowfield Council replace the streetlights on its residential roads with LED lamps?

    Select the strongest argument from the statements below.

    1. A Yes, LED lamps are the modern choice, and before long every council in the country will be using nothing else.
    2. B Yes, the council's trial found LED lamps on the same roads used 60 per cent less electricity than the current ones.
    3. C No, residents may well find the new light too harsh and bright, and they will then complain to their councillors about it.
    4. D No, the council replaced all of its bus shelters only last year, and residents deserve a break from constant change.
  2. 21 mark

    Should the Northvale Trust start charging visitors to park at Kingsbridge Hospital, where parking is currently free?

    Select the strongest argument from the statements below.

    1. A No, hospital visitors are always far too stressed and worried to cope with the extra burden of paying for parking.
    2. B Yes, every other public building in the region charges for parking, so there is no reason for the hospital to be different.
    3. C Yes, charging would put people off driving to the hospital, and fewer car journeys are always better for the environment.
    4. D No, a Trust survey found 40 per cent of car-park users visit a patient daily, so long-stay families would pay most.
  3. 31 mark

    Should the village of Corram Bridge build a footbridge across the River Lenn at Mill Lane?

    Select the strongest argument from the statements below.

    1. A No, footbridges are always ugly concrete structures, and one at Mill Lane would spoil the view along the river.
    2. B Yes, the only crossing is a road bridge with no pavement, and four walkers have been injured on it in two years.
    3. C Yes, a new footbridge would attract many more tourists to the village and bring extra trade to its shops and pubs.
    4. D No, most people in the village drive everywhere, so hardly anyone would ever bother to walk across a new footbridge.
  4. 41 mark

    Should Westerby Library open on Sundays?

    Select the strongest argument from the statements below.

    1. A No, the library's Sunday trial last year averaged 11 visitors a session, compared with over 200 on a typical Saturday.
    2. B Yes, a public library should always be open whenever people have free time, and Sunday is when most people are free.
    3. C Yes, opening on Sundays would make the library more popular in Westerby than the leisure centre, which closes then.
    4. D No, the library staff would not want to give up their Sundays, and unhappy staff would soon start to leave.
  5. 51 mark

    Should the Dunmore Medical Practice let its patients book appointments online?

    Select the strongest argument from the statements below.

    1. A No, older patients cannot use computers, so an online system would leave them unable to get an appointment at all.
    2. B Yes, online booking is simply what patients want nowadays, and a practice that ignores this will look out of date.
    3. C Yes, the practice's phone line is engaged for 90 minutes each morning on average; online booking avoids that.
    4. D No, the practice's computer system failed for a day in 2019, which proves that computers cannot be relied on.
  6. 61 mark

    Should Fennick County Council ban cars from the centre of the market town of Oldgate on Saturdays?

    Select the strongest argument from the statements below.

    1. A No, a traders' survey found 70 per cent of Saturday customers come by car, and Oldgate has no park-and-ride.
    2. B Yes, research in big cities shows that places without cars are healthier, so a car-free Oldgate would be healthier too.
    3. C No, people have a basic right to drive wherever they like, and no council should ever be allowed to take that right away.
    4. D Yes, shoppers would enjoy a much calmer and more pleasant visit to the town if they did not have to dodge the traffic.
  7. 71 mark

    Should Marsden Sixth Form College require all students to wear a lanyard showing photo ID while on site?

    Select the strongest argument from the statements below.

    1. A No, lanyards make teenagers look like office workers, and sixth formers should be free to dress however they please.
    2. B Yes, hospitals make all their staff wear photo ID, and every school and college should copy hospital security rules.
    3. C No, students will simply forget their lanyards at home, so the rule will be ignored and enforcing it will waste time.
    4. D Yes, outsiders have entered unchallenged three times this year, and staff cannot recognise all 1,400 students.
  8. 81 mark

    Should Tarnby Leisure Centre extend the opening hours of its swimming pool later into the evening?

    Select the strongest argument from the statements below.

    1. A Yes, swimming is the best form of exercise for everyone, so the more hours the pool is open the better for the town.
    2. B No, the centre's staff are already very tired and overworked, and they would not cope with any more late shifts.
    3. C No, centre records show the evening sessions are under a fifth full, so later hours would see little use.
    4. D Yes, longer opening hours would give the town's teenagers something to do and keep them out of trouble at night.
  9. 91 mark

    Should the Ashgrove Dental Clinic send patients a text-message reminder the day before each appointment?

    Select the strongest argument from the statements below.

    1. A No, text messages feel cold and impersonal, and patients would much rather receive a proper letter through the post.
    2. B Yes, every business sends text reminders these days, so a dental clinic that does not will soon fall behind the rest.
    3. C No, some patients might not own a mobile phone, so a text reminder would not reach every single patient on the list.
    4. D Yes, in the clinic's trial, missed appointments fell from 12 to 5 per cent among patients sent a reminder.
  10. 101 mark

    Should Pellbury Council introduce a separate weekly collection of household food waste?

    Select the strongest argument from the statements below.

    1. A Yes, a bin audit found food is over a third of general waste by weight, and all general waste is landfilled.
    2. B No, residents simply will not bother to separate out their food waste, so the new bins would just stand empty.
    3. C Yes, a food-waste collection would make Pellbury the greenest town in the county and something to be very proud of.
    4. D No, food-waste bins attract rats wherever they are used, so they are a serious health hazard in every street.

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    A strong argument must address the question directly (should these streetlights be replaced?) and rest on something stated as fact rather than on a guess or an opinion.
    Option B cites a specific result from the council's own trial on the same roads: a 60 per cent cut in electricity use. That is a measured fact about the exact change being proposed, and it bears directly on whether to make it.
    Option A rests on an unsupported prediction about other councils, option C on speculation about how residents might react, and option D on an unrelated earlier project plus an opinion.
    Only B combines direct relevance with a stated fact, so the strongest argument is B.
    Why not A: Overgeneralisation and assumption: 'every council in the country' is a prediction with no evidence behind it, and what other councils do says nothing about whether the change suits Harrowfield.
    Why not C: Assumption: 'may well find' is speculation about residents' reactions, not a stated fact; no survey or trial result is given to show the light is too harsh.
    Why not D: Irrelevance and opinion: the bus shelters have nothing to do with streetlights, and 'residents deserve a break' is the speaker's view, not a fact about the lamps.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    Look for the argument that speaks directly to charging Kingsbridge's visitors and is grounded in a stated fact.
    Option D reports the Trust's own survey finding that 40 per cent of car-park users visit a patient every day. A daily charge would therefore be paid repeatedly by the families of long-stay patients, which is a direct, evidence-based consequence of the proposal.
    Option A depends on the word 'always', option B on the assumption that other buildings set the right standard, and option C on two assumptions (that a charge changes how people travel, and that this is always better).
    Only D rests on a stated fact about this hospital's visitors, so the strongest argument is D.
    Why not A: Overgeneralisation: 'always' turns a feeling some visitors have into a claim about every visitor, and no evidence is given for it.
    Why not B: Assumption and irrelevance: it assumes that what other buildings do is right for a hospital, and gives no fact about Kingsbridge's own visitors or needs.
    Why not C: Overgeneralisation and assumption: it assumes a charge would reduce car journeys rather than just cost visitors more, and 'always better' is a sweeping claim that ignores visitors who have no other way to reach the hospital.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    B1
    The question is whether a footbridge should be built at Mill Lane, so the strongest argument must bear on the need for, or harm of, that crossing and rest on a stated fact.
    Option B states two facts: the existing crossing is a road bridge with no pavement, and four pedestrians have been injured on it in two years. Together they show a real safety need that a footbridge would directly address.
    Options A and D rest on sweeping claims ('always ugly', 'most people drive') given without evidence, and option C assumes a tourism benefit that nothing supports.
    Only B is both directly relevant and factual, so the strongest argument is B.
    Why not A: Overgeneralisation and opinion: not all footbridges are concrete or ugly, and whether one spoils a view is a matter of taste, not fact.
    Why not C: Assumption: nothing is given to show that a footbridge would draw tourists, let alone extra trade; it is a hoped-for outcome stated as if certain.
    Why not D: Assumption: 'most people drive' is not supported, and even if it were true it would not show that the people who do walk would not use the bridge.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    The strongest argument must address whether Sunday opening is worthwhile for this library and must rest on stated fact, whichever side it takes.
    Option A gives the measured outcome of a Sunday trial at the library itself: an average of 11 visitors a session against over 200 on a typical Saturday. That is direct evidence that there is very little demand for Sunday opening.
    Option B is an opinion with an unsupported claim about when people are free, option C aims at an irrelevant comparison with the leisure centre, and option D guesses what staff want.
    Only A rests on a fact directly about the proposal, so the strongest argument is A.
    Why not B: Opinion and overgeneralisation: 'should always be open' is a view, not a fact, and 'most people are free on Sunday' is asserted without evidence.
    Why not C: Irrelevance and assumption: being more popular than the leisure centre is not the aim of a library, and nothing shows Sunday opening would achieve it.
    Why not D: Assumption: the staff's wishes are guessed rather than reported, and the claim that they would leave is a further guess built on the first.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    Ask which argument deals directly with whether online booking would help or harm this practice's patients, using a stated fact.
    Option C states a measured problem at Dunmore itself: the phone line is engaged for 90 minutes each morning on average. Online booking gives patients a route that does not depend on that phone line, so the fact bears directly on the proposal.
    Option A generalises about all older patients and wrongly assumes phone booking would end, option B is an unsupported opinion about what patients want, and option D draws a sweeping conclusion from one incident.
    Only C is both relevant and grounded in fact, so the strongest argument is C.
    Why not A: Overgeneralisation: many older patients do use computers, and adding online booking need not remove phone booking, so 'unable to get an appointment at all' does not follow.
    Why not B: Opinion and assumption: 'what patients want nowadays' is asserted with no survey or figure behind it, and looking out of date is not a reason grounded in the practice's situation.
    Why not D: Overgeneralisation: a single one-day failure years ago does not prove that computers in general, or an online booking system, cannot be relied on.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    The strongest argument must bear directly on a Saturday car ban in Oldgate and rest on a stated fact.
    Option A gives two facts: 70 per cent of traders' Saturday customers arrive by car, and there is no park-and-ride service to replace that access. Together they show that a ban would cut off most of the town's Saturday customers, a direct consequence of the proposal.
    Option B transfers city research to a small town without justification, option C is an opinion presented as a principle, and option D predicts shoppers' feelings without evidence.
    Only A is grounded in fact about Oldgate itself, so the strongest argument is A.
    Why not B: Overgeneralisation: it assumes findings from big cities carry over to a small market town closed to cars for one day a week, with no evidence that they do.
    Why not C: Opinion: an unlimited 'right to drive wherever they like' is the speaker's belief, not a fact, and it does not engage with Oldgate's circumstances at all.
    Why not D: Assumption: shoppers' enjoyment is predicted rather than shown, and it ignores whether those shoppers could still reach the town without a car.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    The question is about photo ID at this college, so the strongest argument should identify a real problem or cost at Marsden and rest on a stated fact.
    Option D gives two facts: unauthorised people have entered unchallenged three times this year, and staff cannot recognise all 1,400 students by sight. Visible photo ID addresses exactly that gap, so the argument is direct and factual.
    Option A is opinion about appearance and freedom, option B generalises from hospitals to all schools, and option C guesses at student behaviour.
    Only D rests on stated facts that bear directly on the proposal, so the strongest argument is D.
    Why not A: Opinion: how lanyards look and how sixth formers ought to dress are matters of taste and belief, not facts about the college's security.
    Why not B: Overgeneralisation and irrelevance: it assumes rules that suit a hospital suit every school and college, without showing that the risks are the same.
    Why not C: Assumption: it predicts that students will forget and that the rule will be ignored, with no evidence from the college or elsewhere.
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    C1
    A strong argument here must speak to whether later opening would be worthwhile at Tarnby and be based on a stated fact.
    Option C cites the centre's own records: existing evening sessions are less than a fifth full. If current evening capacity is mostly unused, extra later hours are unlikely to be needed, which bears directly on the decision.
    Option A rests on a sweeping claim about exercise, option B on unsupported claims about staff, and option D on two chained assumptions about teenagers.
    Only C is grounded in a fact about this pool, so the strongest argument is C.
    Why not A: Overgeneralisation: 'the best form of exercise for everyone' is a sweeping claim, and it does not show that more hours would actually be used.
    Why not B: Assumption and opinion: the staff's tiredness is asserted without any record or figure, and later hours could be covered by new shifts rather than longer ones.
    Why not D: Assumption: it assumes teenagers would choose to swim late and that this would reduce trouble, with nothing given to support either step.
  9. Question 9

    Answer or workingMarks
    D1
    Find the argument that tells us directly whether text reminders would help this clinic, and that rests on a stated fact.
    Option D reports the clinic's own trial: among patients sent a reminder, missed appointments fell from 12 per cent to 5 per cent. That is measured evidence that the proposal achieves its purpose.
    Option A is an opinion about texts, option B generalises about all businesses, and option C speculates about a minority of patients without showing that this outweighs the benefit to the rest.
    Only D is a stated fact that addresses the question directly, so the strongest argument is D.
    Why not A: Opinion and assumption: 'cold and impersonal' is a judgement, and patients' preference for letters is assumed rather than shown.
    Why not B: Overgeneralisation and irrelevance: 'every business' is unsupported, and keeping up with other businesses is not a reason tied to the clinic's patients.
    Why not C: Assumption, and it misses the point: 'might not own' is speculation, and a reminder that fails to reach a few patients is no argument against helping the many it does reach.
  10. Question 10

    Answer or workingMarks
    A1
    The strongest argument must address whether a separate food-waste collection is worth having in Pellbury and rest on a stated fact.
    Option A reports a bin audit of Pellbury's waste: food makes up over a third of the weight of general waste, and all of that waste currently goes to landfill. A separate collection would target a large, measured share of what is being landfilled, so the argument is direct and factual.
    Option B predicts residents' behaviour without evidence, option C rests on an unsupported claim and civic pride, and option D generalises a possible risk to every street.
    Only A rests on a stated fact about Pellbury's own waste, so the strongest argument is A.
    Why not B: Assumption: residents' behaviour is predicted with no evidence, such as a trial or survey, to show they would not use the bins.
    Why not C: Assumption and opinion: nothing shows the scheme would make Pellbury 'the greenest town', and civic pride is not a reason grounded in fact.
    Why not D: Overgeneralisation: 'wherever they are used' and 'in every street' turn a possible risk into a universal one, with no evidence given.

Keep going

More free UCAT practice