UCAT Situational Judgement: Most and least appropriate, set 1
Ranking three possible actions by choosing the single most appropriate and the single least appropriate, where both must be right to score. Test standard. 10 questions, 10 marks, about 5 minutes.
Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)
- Each question gives its own short scenario. Answer from the point of view of the person named in the question.
- Choose both the most appropriate and the least appropriate action. You score only if both are right.
- No medical knowledge is needed.
- 11 mark
Daniel is a third-year medical student on a surgical ward. An elderly patient, Mr Hughes, asks him for a glass of water. A sign above the bed says 'Nil by mouth', but Mr Hughes insists that the doctor told him this morning that he can drink again. The nurse looking after him is busy at a bed further down the bay. Daniel has no way of knowing from the bedside whether the instruction has changed.
Choose both the most appropriate and the least appropriate action for Daniel to take.
Choose the most appropriate and the least appropriate action. Both must be right for the mark.
- 21 mark
Sophie is a fourth-year dental student. After her patient has left the clinic, she realises that she recorded the wrong tooth in the notes for a filling that is planned for next week. The filling has not been done yet. Another student may be treating the patient at the next appointment. Sophie's clinical supervisor, Dr Adeyemi, is still in the clinic writing up her own notes.
Choose both the most appropriate and the least appropriate action for Sophie to take.
Choose the most appropriate and the least appropriate action. Both must be right for the mark.
- 31 mark
Ravi is a second-year medical student. In a crowded hospital lift he hears two classmates discussing a patient from their ward, using her full name and describing her diagnosis. Several visitors are in the lift and can clearly hear them. The classmates do not seem to realise how loudly they are speaking. The lift will reach their floor in under a minute.
Choose both the most appropriate and the least appropriate action for Ravi to take.
Choose the most appropriate and the least appropriate action. Both must be right for the mark.
- 41 mark
Hannah is a medical student on a placement at a GP surgery. A week after she sat in on his consultation, a patient of the practice, Mr Doyle, sends her a friend request on a social media site. He has added a message thanking her for being so kind and saying he would love to keep in touch. Hannah's placement at the surgery has four weeks left to run.
Choose both the most appropriate and the least appropriate action for Hannah to take.
Choose the most appropriate and the least appropriate action. Both must be right for the mark.
- 51 mark
Owen is a third-year medical student. For several weeks he has felt exhausted and low, and he is finding it hard to keep up with his placement. He has missed two teaching sessions this month without telling anyone why. His placement lead has emailed asking him to explain the absences. Owen is worried that admitting he is struggling will count against him.
Choose both the most appropriate and the least appropriate action for Owen to take.
Choose the most appropriate and the least appropriate action. Both must be right for the mark.
- 61 mark
Grace is a final-year medical student in an outpatient clinic. Her supervisor has asked her to take a history from Mr Novak, who speaks very little English, about a sensitive bowel symptom. His sixteen-year-old son has come with him and offers to interpret. The clinic can book a telephone interpreter, which usually takes about fifteen minutes to arrange. The clinic is running roughly on time.
Choose both the most appropriate and the least appropriate action for Grace to take.
Choose the most appropriate and the least appropriate action. Both must be right for the mark.
- 71 mark
Leo is a fourth-year medical student. While queuing in the hospital canteen at lunchtime, he notices a printed ward handover sheet lying on an empty table. It lists patients' names, ages and diagnoses, and the ward's name is printed at the top. The canteen is busy with staff and visitors. The ward is a few minutes' walk away, and Leo is due back on his own ward in four hours.
Choose both the most appropriate and the least appropriate action for Leo to take.
Choose the most appropriate and the least appropriate action. Both must be right for the mark.
- 81 mark
Maya is a third-year dental student carrying out a routine scale and polish under supervision. Halfway through, her patient, Ms Clarke, becomes visibly anxious, raises her hand and says she wants to stop. The treatment is not urgent and nothing will be harmed by pausing, although only a few minutes of work remain. Maya's supervisor is in the clinic, working with another student two chairs away.
Choose both the most appropriate and the least appropriate action for Maya to take.
Choose the most appropriate and the least appropriate action. Both must be right for the mark.
- 91 mark
Ben is a fifth-year medical student on a ward round. At one bedside, the consultant makes a joking remark about a patient's weight in front of her. The rest of the team laugh, and Ben notices that the patient looks embarrassed and upset. The consultant is senior to everyone present and moves straight on to the next bed. Ben has a supportive educational supervisor whom he meets every week.
Choose both the most appropriate and the least appropriate action for Ben to take.
Choose the most appropriate and the least appropriate action. Both must be right for the mark.
- 101 mark
Ella is a fourth-year medical student on an orthopaedic ward. Mrs Ibrahim, who has been offered a knee operation by her consultant, tells Ella she is thinking of refusing it because she is frightened of the anaesthetic. She asks Ella what she would do in her place. The consultant is not on the ward today, but the junior doctor on the team is nearby.
Choose both the most appropriate and the least appropriate action for Ella to take.
Choose the most appropriate and the least appropriate action. Both must be right for the mark.
Worked solutions
Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.
Question 1
Answer or working Marks Most appropriate B, least appropriate C 1 Patient safety comes first: Daniel must not act on an instruction he cannot confirm, and he must not ignore a patient's reasonable request either. Option B does both: nothing is given until the nurse confirms the current plan, and Mr Hughes gets an answer. Option A is safe but leaves the question unresolved. Option C acts on an unverified claim against a written instruction and could cause real harm. So B is most appropriate, A sits in the middle and C is least appropriate. Remember that the real test only credits this item if both choices are right. Answer: most appropriate B, least appropriate C. A: Middle. Refusing keeps Mr Hughes safe while the sign is up, but Daniel walks away without checking, so a patient who may now be allowed to drink is left thirsty and his question is never answered. B: Most appropriate. It puts safety first by not giving anything until the instruction is confirmed, and it resolves the patient's question by asking the nurse responsible for his care, who can check the plan. C: Least appropriate. The written instruction says nil by mouth and Daniel cannot verify the patient's account. Giving water on an unconfirmed report could harm a patient awaiting surgery or with a swallowing problem, which is a direct risk to safety. Question 2
Answer or working Marks Most appropriate A, least appropriate B 1 Two principles decide this: patient safety, because a wrong tooth in the notes could lead to the wrong tooth being treated, and honesty about mistakes. Option A deals with both at once, openly and with the supervisor's help. Option C protects only against Sophie's own error and leaves a wrong record for others. Option B hides the mistake, which is dishonest and is a serious breach of record keeping. So A is most appropriate, C is in the middle and B is least appropriate. Answer: most appropriate A, least appropriate B. A: Most appropriate. It is honest, it brings in the supervisor who is available now, and it corrects the record openly so that whoever treats the patient next works from accurate notes. B: Least appropriate. Clinical records must never be altered to hide an error. Concealing it is dishonest, breaks the rules on record keeping and removes the trail that shows what happened. C: Middle. It might stop Sophie herself drilling the wrong tooth, but the incorrect record stays in place and another clinician reading it next week could act on it. It is well meant but does not fix the real risk. Question 3
Answer or working Marks Most appropriate C, least appropriate A 1 The patient's confidentiality is being breached in front of members of the public, and it is happening now, so the best response stops it promptly. Option C does that discreetly. Option B is passive: it causes no new harm but lets the breach continue. Option A makes the breach larger, so it is clearly the worst. So C is most appropriate, B is in the middle and A is least appropriate. Answer: most appropriate C, least appropriate A. A: Least appropriate. Joining in adds to the breach of confidentiality in front of the public instead of stopping it, so it actively makes the situation worse. B: Middle. Ravi does not add to the breach, but he lets it carry on when a quiet word would stop it. Confidentiality is every student's responsibility, not only that of the patient's own team. C: Most appropriate. A quiet, polite word stops the disclosure straight away without embarrassing his classmates in public, and it protects the patient's confidentiality. Question 4
Answer or working Marks Most appropriate A, least appropriate C 1 Students, like doctors, should keep professional boundaries with patients, and should seek advice from their supervisor when a boundary issue arises. Option A keeps the boundary and involves the supervisor. Option B keeps the boundary only by default and leaves things unresolved. Option C crosses the boundary. So A is most appropriate, B is in the middle and C is least appropriate. Answer: most appropriate A, least appropriate C. A: Most appropriate. Declining keeps a clear professional boundary, and telling her supervisor means the practice knows and can advise her if Mr Doyle raises it again. B: Middle. Not accepting avoids crossing the boundary, but leaving it pending is unresolved and the supervisor, who could support her, is not told. C: Least appropriate. Becoming social media friends with a patient blurs the professional relationship and could expose personal information on both sides; wanting to seem friendly does not justify it. Question 5
Answer or working Marks Most appropriate C, least appropriate B 1 Two things are at stake: honesty with the medical school, and Owen's own wellbeing, which affects how safely he can work. Option C is honest and seeks help. Option A avoids a lie but leaves him unsupported and the request unanswered. Option B is a deliberate falsehood, which is the most serious problem here. So C is most appropriate, A is in the middle and B is least appropriate. Answer: most appropriate C, least appropriate B. A: Middle. Keeping quiet is not dishonest, but working late every night while already exhausted is likely to make things worse, and Owen still has not answered the email or sought help. B: Least appropriate. Giving a false reason for the absences is dishonest to the medical school, which is a probity issue, and it also means he gets no support for the real problem. C: Most appropriate. It answers the placement lead honestly and gets Owen the support he needs, which looks after his own health and his ability to learn safely. Question 6
Answer or working Marks Most appropriate B, least appropriate A 1 Accurate communication and the patient's privacy matter most, especially for a sensitive symptom. A professional interpreter is available at the cost of a short delay. Option B secures both and keeps the supervisor informed. Option C is workable but risks inaccuracy and embarrassment. Option A records guesses as if they were the patient's answers, a misleading history that could harm him. So B is most appropriate, C is in the middle and A is least appropriate. Answer: most appropriate B, least appropriate A. A: Least appropriate. Recording guesses as if they were Mr Novak's answers puts a history in his notes that nobody can tell is unreliable, which could lead to wrong decisions about his care, and he may not understand what is happening. B: Most appropriate. A professional interpreter gives an accurate history and protects Mr Novak's privacy on a sensitive subject, and the delay is short and explained to the supervisor. C: Middle. Checking that Mr Novak is comfortable helps, but a teenage relative may not translate medical terms accurately and Mr Novak may hold back on a sensitive symptom in front of his son. Whatever is lost, though, nothing false is passed off as his own answer. Question 7
Answer or working Marks Most appropriate A, least appropriate B 1 Patient confidentiality is at risk in a public place, and anyone who finds such information should secure it and pass it to the responsible team promptly. Option A does this immediately. Option C secures it but delays returning and reporting it, and keeps it on his person meanwhile. Option B leaves the breach running, which makes the situation worse. So A is most appropriate, C is in the middle and B is least appropriate. Answer: most appropriate A, least appropriate B. A: Most appropriate. It removes confidential information from public view at once, returns it to the team responsible, and lets them dispose of it securely and report the lapse. B: Least appropriate. Leaving it exposes patients' confidential details to everyone passing through a busy canteen, when Leo could easily stop that. C: Middle. Pocketing the sheet does stop the public seeing it, but carrying patient details around for four hours is a risk in itself, and the ward does not learn about the lapse until much later. Question 8
Answer or working Marks Most appropriate C, least appropriate A 1 A patient can withdraw consent at any point, and the student must respect it. The treatment is not urgent, so there is no safety reason to continue. Option C respects her wish and handles it well. Option B respects it but abruptly, without support. Option A overrides her refusal, which is a serious failure of respect and consent. So C is most appropriate, B is in the middle and A is least appropriate. Answer: most appropriate C, least appropriate A. A: Least appropriate. Ms Clarke has withdrawn her consent, and continuing regardless ignores her clearly stated wish. Reassurance does not make it acceptable. B: Middle. Stopping respects her wish, but sending her away without exploring her worry or involving the supervisor misses the chance to help her and may leave her unwilling to return. C: Most appropriate. It respects her right to stop, explores what is wrong, and brings in the supervisor so that a sensible plan is agreed with her. Question 9
Answer or working Marks Most appropriate B, least appropriate C 1 Patients should be treated with dignity and respect, and students are expected to raise concerns about unprofessional behaviour through an appropriate route, even when a senior is involved. Option B looks after the patient and raises the concern sensibly. Option A causes no new harm but lets it pass. Option C adds to the harm. So B is most appropriate, A is in the middle and C is least appropriate. Answer: most appropriate B, least appropriate C. A: Middle. Staying silent on the ward round is understandable for a student, but saying nothing at all lets disrespectful behaviour pass and does nothing for the upset patient. B: Most appropriate. It attends to the patient's distress, and raising the concern privately with a trusted senior is a proportionate way for a student to act on unprofessional behaviour. C: Least appropriate. Joining in endorses a remark that hurt the patient, adding to her distress and undermining her dignity. Question 10
Answer or working Marks Most appropriate C, least appropriate B 1 Mrs Ibrahim has the right to decide about her treatment, and she needs accurate information from the team to do so. A student should not advise on the decision but can listen and pass concerns on. Option C does exactly that. Option A stays within Ella's role but does nothing for the patient. Option B pressures the patient and oversteps Ella's competence. So C is most appropriate, A is in the middle and B is least appropriate. Answer: most appropriate C, least appropriate B. A: Middle. It is right that Ella should not advise on the decision, but stopping there leaves a frightened patient's concerns unheard and the team unaware of them. B: Least appropriate. Pressuring Mrs Ibrahim disrespects her right to decide about her own treatment, goes beyond Ella's competence as a student, and may make her feel unable to voice her fears. C: Most appropriate. It shows empathy, stays within Ella's role, and makes sure the team can discuss the decision and the anaesthetic properly with Mrs Ibrahim.