UCAT Verbal Reasoning: Comprehension and inference, set 2
The four-option question types: finishing an incomplete statement, choosing what the passage best supports, finding the one option the passage does not give as a reason, and judging what is most likely when the passage stops short of saying. Demanding. 12 questions, 12 marks, about 6 minutes.
Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)
- Read each passage and answer the four questions that follow it.
- Answer from the passage alone, not from what you know.
- Each question has exactly one correct answer. No calculator.
- 11 mark
The opponents' main objection to the release is that...
- 21 mark
According to the passage, which of the following is true of the partnership's five-year survey?
- 31 mark
The passage presents each of the following as part of the case for using bison rather than machines to clear the scrub EXCEPT:
- 41 mark
Which of the following is most likely to be true, based on the passage?
- 51 mark
The critics' first objection is that the pilot's results...
- 61 mark
Each of the following is given in the passage as part of the college's case for the change, or its response to critics, EXCEPT:
- 71 mark
Based on the passage, which of the following is most likely?
- 81 mark
According to the passage, which of the following is true of the planned change?
- 91 mark
The defenders of the night ferry argue that Strait Lines' account of the service's losses is incomplete because it...
- 101 mark
Each of the following is stated or implied in the passage EXCEPT:
- 111 mark
According to the passage, why do hauliers use the night ferry?
- 121 mark
Which of the following is most likely, based on the passage?
Worked solutions
Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.
Question 1
Answer or working Marks B 1 This is an incomplete-statement question, so find the paragraph that states the opponents' position and finish the sentence from it. Paragraph 3 says their objection is 'to risk and to precedent'. Risk: a fence is only as good as its maintenance and funding is secured for only six years, so the fence may not be kept up (the safeguard may lapse). Precedent: they suspect the herd will be enlarged or the fence extended without a fresh consultation (the safeguard may be sidestepped). Option B combines exactly these two worries. A is ruled out because they 'do not dispute the survey'; C and D introduce arguments the opponents never make. The answer is B. Why not A: Contradicted by the passage: paragraph 3 says the opponents 'do not dispute the survey'. Picking this assumes that anyone opposing a scheme must be attacking its evidence. Why not C: Plausible from general knowledge of large animals, but the passage never raises public safety; guided walks appear only as a hoped-for source of income. This is the 'true in the world, not in the passage' trap. Why not D: Cost of machine clearance is mentioned only by the supporters, who say it has to be paid for every year. Nothing attributes a cost argument to the opponents, so this borrows a point from the wrong side of the debate. Question 2
Answer or working Marks C 1 An 'according to the passage' question needs an option the text directly supports, so check each against what the passage says about the survey. The survey appears twice: in paragraph 2 (a fall of roughly a third in flowering plant species in the most heavily scrubbed plots) and in paragraph 3, where the opponents 'do not dispute the survey'. Option C restates the second of these. A widens 'most heavily scrubbed plots' to the whole site, B credits the survey with the supporters' insect argument, and D has no support at all. The answer is C. Why not A: Overstates the scope of the finding. The fall of roughly a third was in 'the most heavily scrubbed plots', not across the whole holding. Why not B: Attributes the supporters' argument to the survey. The survey counted flowering plant species; the claim about insects is part of what supporters 'argue' about grazing, not a survey result. Why not D: Invents a sequence of events. The passage gives no reason for the survey, and the farmers' objections are described as a response to the proposal, not as its cause. Question 3
Answer or working Marks C 1 In an 'except' question, three options are supported by the passage and the answer is the one that is not. Work through paragraph 2, which sets out the case for bison. Paragraph 2 says machine clearance has to be paid for every year (A) and leaves uniform ground (D), while grazing creates a patchwork of short turf, bare earth and thicket (B). All three are part of the case. Option C overstates a hedged claim. The passage says the partnership 'expects, though it does not promise' that the herd will meet 'some of its own costs'. 'Will cover its running costs' turns an expectation into a promise and 'some' into all. The answer is C. Why not A: Stated: supporters argue machine clearance 'has to be paid for every year'. Choosing it means the candidate did not check paragraph 2 line by line. Why not B: Stated almost word for word: grazing animals 'create a patchwork of short turf, bare earth and thicket'. A candidate picking this has probably been put off by the paraphrase 'mix'. Why not D: Stated: machine clearance 'leaves uniform ground'. This is in the same sentence as A, so missing it suggests the sentence was read only halfway. Question 4
Answer or working Marks A 1 A 'most likely' question asks which option the passage makes most probable, even if it is not stated outright. Start from what the opponents care about. Their stated worry is risk tied to funding: the money is secured for six years only, and a fence is only as good as its maintenance. Paragraph 4 then points out the one gap the partnership has not filled: what happens to the animals if funding lapses. A group whose objection centres on what happens when funding ends would very probably want that question answered, so A is strongly suggested. B reads more into the bond than is written, C is contradicted by 'longer than any written record', and D has no support. The answer is A. Why not B: The bond is described as covering 'removing the fence', and the very next sentence says the partnership has not said what would happen to the animals. Extending the bond to the animals reads in a provision the passage pointedly leaves out. Why not C: Contradicted: bison 'have been absent from the uplands for longer than any written record', which rules out living memory. Choosing this ignores a time clue in the first paragraph. Why not D: The council has said only that it will not decide before reading every response. Nothing indicates which way it leans, so this treats a promise about process as a hint about the outcome. Question 5
Answer or working Marks D 1 This is an incomplete statement: find the critics' first point and complete the sentence with it. Paragraph 3 begins 'First, the volunteers chose to take part and may have been more motivated than their peers'. The consequence they draw is that 'the pilot cannot show what small groups would do for a whole year group'. In other words, the results might be explained by the kind of student who volunteered rather than by small-group teaching itself. Option D says exactly this. A, B and C each describe a criticism that could be made of a pilot, but none is the one the passage gives. The answer is D. Why not A: The near-identical scores are reported in paragraph 2, but it is the college, not the critics, that draws on them. The critics never argue that close scores prove nothing. Why not B: The pilot did last one year, but no critic objects to its length. This invents a methodological complaint that sounds reasonable in general but is not in the passage. Why not C: Nothing is said about the design of the examination. This is a plausible real-world worry about assessment, not one the passage raises. Question 6
Answer or working Marks B 1 In an 'except' question, three options appear in the passage and one does not. Check each against paragraphs 2 and 4, where the college's case and responses are given. A is in paragraph 2 (more hours in independent study). C and D are both in paragraph 4 (comparing the next three cohorts with the last three taught by lecture; a two-day training course and a written guide to each case). B is not supported: the passage says the two groups 'scored almost identically'. The college's argument is explicitly 'equal results with greater engagement', so a higher score is the opposite of what it claims. The answer is B. Why not A: Stated in paragraph 2 as part of the pilot's findings and used by the college as evidence of 'greater engagement'. Why not C: Stated in paragraph 4 as the college's response to the first criticism. A candidate choosing it may have missed the final paragraph. Why not D: Stated in paragraph 4 as the college's response on tutors. It is the answer to the second criticism, so it does count as a response to critics. Question 7
Answer or working Marks A 1 For 'most likely', look for the option the passage makes probable even though it does not state it. The critics' first point is that the pilot's volunteers were self-selected, so it cannot show the effect on a whole year group. The college 'accepts the first point' and plans to compare the next three whole cohorts with the last three taught by lecture. Whole cohorts are not volunteers, so this comparison removes the self-selection the critics complained of. It is therefore likely that the critics would regard the comparison as addressing their first point. B overstates 'many', C misreads the dean's remark, and D has no basis in the passage. The answer is A. Why not B: Overstates a hedged claim: the passage says 'many' of the tutors will be junior doctors. 'Many' of thirty could be well under half, so 'most' does not follow. Why not C: The dean says only that supporting quieter students is 'a question we take seriously', which concedes there is an issue. Reading it as a belief that they learn equally well turns acknowledgement into reassurance. Why not D: No fallback is mentioned anywhere. The college's stated plan for tutors is training, not reversal, so this speculates beyond the passage. Question 8
Answer or working Marks B 1 An 'according to the passage' question needs an option directly supported by the text, so compare each with paragraph 1, which describes the change. Paragraph 1 says each small group will be 'led by a tutor whose job is to guide discussion of a clinical case rather than to deliver content'. Option B restates this. A turns 'about two thirds' into 'entirely', C invents a qualification requirement, and D claims evidence of better doctors when the pilot showed only equal scores with greater engagement. The answer is B. Why not A: Overstates the scale: the college will replace 'about two thirds' of the lectures, so about a third remain. Why not C: The passage mentions a two-day training course, not a qualification, and says many tutors will have little teaching experience. This imports a requirement the passage does not contain. Why not D: A widely held view about active learning, perhaps, but not in the passage. The pilot produced near-identical examination scores, and nothing is said about the quality of doctors produced. Question 9
Answer or working Marks A 1 This incomplete statement asks for the defenders' reason, which is in paragraph 3: the operator 'is counting the wrong things'. The final sentence of paragraph 3 explains what is missing: a count of the night ferry's losses 'ignores the revenue that night freight brings to the daytime ships through return bookings'. Option A states this. B and C concern costs that paragraph 2 says are not in dispute, and D objects to a time period no one in the passage questions. The answer is A. Why not B: Paragraph 2 says the figures 'are not in dispute', and the defenders do not challenge the crew cost. This mistakes an undisputed cost for a contested one. Why not C: Lower fuel cost is part of the undisputed figures in paragraph 2, not a point the defenders raise. It is drawn from the wrong paragraph and the wrong speaker. Why not D: The four years are simply the period Strait Lines reports on. No one in the passage objects to the length of the record. Question 10
Answer or working Marks D 1 In an 'except' question, three options are in the passage and one is not. Here the test is simply whether the passage states or implies each option. A and B are both in paragraph 2's account of the costs, and C appears in paragraph 3's description of the daytime sailings. D reverses the passage. Paragraph 2 says 'Fuel is the one cost that is lower, because the ship sails at reduced speed'. A candidate relying on a vague sense that a long night voyage must use more fuel would fall for it. The answer is D. Why not A: Stated in paragraph 2: cabins 'take up space that would otherwise hold seats'. Why not B: Stated in paragraph 2: the ship 'needs a full crew through the night'. Why not C: Stated in paragraph 3, inside the defenders' argument: the daytime sailings 'are already close to full in summer'. A candidate who rejects it because it comes from one side has confused 'stated in the passage' with 'agreed by everyone'. Question 11
Answer or working Marks C 1 An 'according to the passage' question asks for the reason the passage gives. Paragraph 3 explains the hauliers' use of the service. It says hauliers use the night ferry 'so that drivers can take their legally required rest while the lorry is moving'. Option C paraphrases this. A is unsupported, while B and D are contradicted by the defenders' own prediction that freight would move to the daytime sailings or to the road. The answer is C. Why not A: A natural guess about why a business would choose one service over another, but the passage says nothing about freight rates. Why not B: Contradicted: the defenders say some freight would 'move to the daytime sailings' if the night ferry ended, which only makes sense if daytime ferries carry lorries. Why not D: The passage says some freight would 'take the longer road around the strait', so the road is an available alternative; nothing suggests it closes at night. Question 12
Answer or working Marks D 1 For 'most likely', find the option that the passage's facts make probable. Paragraph 3 says that if the service ends, some freight will move to the daytime sailings, 'which are already close to full in summer'. Ships that are already close to full have little spare space, so adding freight from the night ferry would very probably strain them in summer. Option D follows from this. A assumes facts about the route's daytime finances that the passage does not give, B misidentifies the hauliers' objection, and C contradicts 'Neither side has published the share'. The answer is D. Why not A: The passage says only that the night service loses money; it gives no figures for the daytime ships, and the defenders argue that withdrawal could cost daytime revenue. 'End the losses on the route' goes well beyond anything stated. Why not B: The hauliers' objection to a seasonal service is about schedules planned for the whole year, not price. A fare cut does nothing to answer it. Why not C: The passage says 'Neither side has published the share'. Strait Lines claims return bookings would survive, which is a claim about hauliers' behaviour, not knowledge of the share.