Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

UCAT Verbal Reasoning: True, False or Can't tell, set 2

Deciding whether the passage shows a statement to be true, shows it to be false, or leaves it open, and keeping the line between 'false' and 'not stated' exactly where the passage puts it. Demanding. 12 questions, 12 marks, about 6 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Read each passage and answer the four questions that follow it.
  • Answer from the passage alone, not from what you know.
  • Each question has exactly one correct answer. No calculator.
  1. 11 mark

    Provided the steelworks keeps supplying heat, the Ostrey plant would draw less electricity from the grid for each thousand litres it produced than the Calder plant would.

    1. A True
    2. B False
    3. C Can't tell
  2. 21 mark

    Neither of the proposed plants would supply more than half of Port Kellan's average daily demand.

    1. A True
    2. B False
    3. C Can't tell
  3. 31 mark

    According to the marine adviser, the Ostrey plan as it currently stands would harm the bay's seagrass.

    1. A True
    2. B False
    3. C Can't tell
  4. 41 mark

    The Ostrey Consortium maintains that its plant would cost less to run than Calder's whatever happens to the steelworks.

    1. A True
    2. B False
    3. C Can't tell
  5. 51 mark

    In 1841 Velmark's postal service handled more than twice as many letters as it had handled in 1840.

    1. A True
    2. B False
    3. C Can't tell
  6. 61 mark

    Postal revenue was lower in 1841 than in any later year before 1853.

    1. A True
    2. B False
    3. C Can't tell
  7. 71 mark

    Parliament enacted Holm's scheme exactly as his pamphlet had set it out.

    1. A True
    2. B False
    3. C Can't tell
  8. 81 mark

    Between the arrival of letter boxes and 1860, a letter posted without a stamp would not reach the person it was addressed to.

    1. A True
    2. B False
    3. C Can't tell
  9. 91 mark

    In the spring, Brookfield pupils slept on average more than three-quarters of an hour longer each school night than Linwood pupils did.

    1. A True
    2. B False
    3. C Can't tell
  10. 101 mark

    For each minute its start time moved later, Carrow pupils gained more sleep than Brookfield pupils did.

    1. A True
    2. B False
    3. C Can't tell
  11. 111 mark

    Brookfield pupils did not gain their extra sleep by falling asleep earlier.

    1. A True
    2. B False
    3. C Can't tell
  12. 121 mark

    If the bus company agrees to a later timetable, the trust will move Linwood's start time.

    1. A True
    2. B False
    3. C Can't tell

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (True)1
    The statement only asks about the case where the steelworks keeps supplying heat, so the uncertainty over renewal and the gas fallback are outside it.
    For that case the passage gives Ostrey's grid demand as 1.5 kilowatt-hours for every thousand litres, because most of its heat is waste heat from the steelworks.
    Calder's grid demand is 3.5 kilowatt-hours for every thousand litres. Since 1.5 is less than 3.5, the Ostrey plant would draw less grid electricity per thousand litres.
    The passage directly supports the statement, so the answer is A, True.
    Why not B: Mixes up grid electricity with running costs: the passage says Ostrey's running costs would exceed Calder's only if the steelworks closed, which the statement's condition rules out, and costs are not the same thing as grid electricity anyway.
    Why not C: Lets the uncertainty over renewing the heat agreement decide the answer, missing that the statement is itself conditional on the steelworks continuing to supply heat, the case the passage gives a figure for.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (False)1
    Half of the city's average daily demand of 110 million litres is 55 million litres.
    The Calder plant would produce 60 million litres a day, which is more than 55 million. The Ostrey plant would produce 45 million, which is less.
    So one of the plants, Calder, would supply more than half of the demand, and the claim that neither would is contradicted by the passage's figures.
    The answer is B, False.
    Why not A: Checks only the Ostrey figure (45 million litres, which is below half of demand), or compares both outputs with the whole 110 million litres instead of with half of it, and so concludes that neither plant passes the halfway mark.
    Why not C: Treats the demand figure as missing, overlooking that the last sentence of the passage gives average daily demand as 110 million litres, so the half can be worked out.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Can't tell)1
    The adviser's view is conditional: neither outfall would harm the seagrass provided the brine is spread through diffusers.
    The passage adds that only the Calder plan includes diffusers at present, so the condition the adviser gave is not met by the Ostrey plan as it stands.
    A condition for 'no harm' that is not met does not turn into a prediction of harm. The adviser has said nothing about what would happen without diffusers, so the passage neither supports nor contradicts the statement.
    The answer is C, Can't tell.
    Why not A: Reverses the adviser's condition: 'no harm provided diffusers are used' does not mean 'harm if they are not', so the missing diffusers in the Ostrey plan do not show that the adviser predicted harm (denying the antecedent).
    Why not B: Reads 'neither outfall would harm the seagrass' as an unconditional verdict and drops the proviso about diffusers, then concludes the adviser cleared the Ostrey plan as well.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (False)1
    The statement attributes to the consortium a claim that Ostrey would be cheaper to run in every circumstance, including a closure of the steelworks.
    The passage says that if the steelworks closed, the plant would have to burn gas, and that 'the consortium accepts that its running costs would then be higher than Calder's'.
    A consortium that accepts its costs would be higher in one case cannot be maintaining that they would be lower whatever happens, so the passage contradicts the statement.
    The answer is B, False.
    Why not A: Assumes that the much lower grid demand of the Ostrey plant means it is cheaper to run in every case, ignoring the passage's statement about what happens if the steelworks closes.
    Why not C: Thinks the passage never compares the two plants' running costs, missing the final sentence of the third paragraph, which reports the consortium's own admission.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (True)1
    The passage gives the number of letters handled as 7 million in 1840 and 16 million in 1841.
    Twice the 1840 figure is 2 x 7 million = 14 million.
    16 million is more than 14 million, so the 1841 volume was more than double the 1840 volume.
    The answer is A, True.
    Why not B: Confuses letter volume with revenue: revenue fell by more than a third in 1841, and carrying that fall over to the number of letters gives the wrong idea that the service handled fewer letters, not more than twice as many.
    Why not C: Thinks the statement needs an exact multiple that the passage does not give, when the two figures it does give (7 million and 16 million) are enough to settle 'more than twice'.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Can't tell)1
    The passage gives two facts about revenue: it fell by more than a third in 1841, and it did not get back to its 1840 level until 1853.
    Neither fact compares 1841 with the years 1842 to 1852. Revenue could have recovered gradually from 1841, or fallen further before recovering; both fit the passage.
    Because the passage leaves open whether 1841 was the lowest year, it can neither confirm nor deny the statement.
    The answer is C, Can't tell.
    Why not A: Assumes revenue climbed steadily back after the first year, so that 1841 must have been the lowest point; the passage gives no figures for 1842 to 1852.
    Why not B: Takes the long wait until 1853 as evidence that revenue kept falling after 1841, when 'did not regain its 1840 level until 1853' says nothing about whether later years were above or below 1841.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (False)1
    Holm's pamphlet proposed a single charge of 1 skilling for any letter up to 15 grams, whatever the distance.
    Parliament adopted the scheme but raised the weight limit to 20 grams and kept a higher charge of 3 skillings for letters sent abroad.
    Both changes mean the law differed from the pamphlet, so it was not enacted exactly as set out.
    The answer is B, False.
    Why not A: Notices that Parliament 'adopted the scheme' in 1841 and stops there, missing the 'but' clause that lists two changes made to it.
    Why not C: Thinks the passage does not give enough detail of the pamphlet to compare it with the law, although it states the pamphlet's weight limit (15 grams) and the different limit Parliament set (20 grams).
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (False)1
    The last paragraph covers letters dropped in a box without a stamp, the situation the statement describes.
    It says such a letter 'was still delivered, but its receiver was charged double the normal rate', and that this rule lasted until it was abolished in 1860.
    So in the period the statement names, an unstamped letter did reach its addressee, which contradicts the statement.
    The answer is B, False.
    Why not A: Assumes that because prepayment became the rule, an unpaid letter must have been stopped, missing the passage's statement that an unstamped letter 'was still delivered'.
    Why not C: Confuses the old practice of carrying refused letters back to the sender, which the passage describes for the years before 1841, with the treatment of unstamped letters after the reform, and so thinks delivery is uncertain.
  9. Question 9

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (True)1
    The spring averages are 7 hours 45 minutes at Brookfield and 6 hours 55 minutes at Linwood.
    The difference is 7 hours 45 minutes - 6 hours 55 minutes = 50 minutes.
    Three-quarters of an hour is 45 minutes, and 50 minutes is more than 45 minutes.
    The answer is A, True.
    Why not B: Uses Brookfield's own gain over the year (7 hours 45 minutes minus 7 hours 5 minutes = 40 minutes) instead of the gap between the two schools in the spring, and 40 minutes is less than three-quarters of an hour.
    Why not C: Lets the report's caution about comparing the schools decide the answer, when the statement only asks about the spring averages, which the passage states.
  10. Question 10

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (False)1
    Carrow moved its start by 30 minutes (8.30 to 9.00) and its average sleep rose from 7 hours 10 minutes to 7 hours 25 minutes, a gain of 15 minutes: 15 / 30 = 0.5 minutes of sleep per minute of delay.
    Brookfield moved its start by 45 minutes (8.30 to 9.15) and its average sleep rose from 7 hours 5 minutes to 7 hours 45 minutes, a gain of 40 minutes: 40 / 45, which is about 0.89 minutes per minute of delay.
    Brookfield gained more sleep for each minute of delay, not Carrow, so the statement is contradicted by the passage's figures.
    The answer is B, False.
    Why not A: Divides the wrong way round: minutes of start delay per minute of sleep gained is 30 / 15 = 2 at Carrow and 45 / 40 = 1.125 at Brookfield, and reading the bigger number as the bigger gain makes Carrow look better.
    Why not C: Believes the passage gives too little data to compare the schools minute for minute, when it gives both the start-time shifts and the before and after sleep averages needed.
  11. Question 11

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (True)1
    The second paragraph says that at all three schools pupils fell asleep at about the same time as before.
    It adds that the extra sleep came from waking later.
    Brookfield is one of the three schools, so its pupils' extra sleep came from waking later, not from falling asleep earlier. The double negative in the statement matches that.
    The answer is A, True.
    Why not B: Assumes that pupils who sleep longer must have gone to sleep earlier, against the passage's statement that the extra sleep came from waking later.
    Why not C: Thinks the sentence about the timing of sleep applies only to some schools, missing that it opens 'At all three schools', which includes Brookfield.
  12. Question 12

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Can't tell)1
    The trust has said it will not move Linwood's start unless the bus company agrees to a later timetable. That makes the bus company's agreement necessary for a change.
    A necessary condition is not a sufficient one: the bus company could agree and the trust could still decide in July to keep 8.30, for example because of the parents' concerns reported for Carrow.
    The passage gives no promise that the change will follow the bus company's agreement, and no statement that it will not, so it neither confirms nor contradicts the statement.
    The answer is C, Can't tell.
    Why not A: Reads 'will not do so unless the bus company agrees' as 'will do so if the bus company agrees', turning a condition the trust needs into one that guarantees the change.
    Why not B: Takes the trust's caution and its July deadline as a decision not to move the start, although the passage says only that the decision is still to be made.

Keep going

More free UCAT practice