Decision Trees and Quantitative Decision-Making - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
14 original exam-style questions - 3 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Decision Trees and Quantitative Decision-Making revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Business practice
This topic is chapter 4 of A Level Business Topic Workbook 2 and chapter 13 of A Level Business 10-Minute Tests.
3.1 Decision Trees and Quantitative Decision-Making
- A) A table showing monthly cash flows
- B) A diagram showing decision and chance nodes with outcomes and probabilities
- C) A marketing plan that lists possible product names
- D) A staff rota showing shift patterns
Question 1
- B caoB1
- Answer: B
Question 2
- Decision node = 'Decision', Chance node = 'Chance' or 'Probability' (either phrasing)B1
- Answer: Decision node: Decision. Chance node: Chance.
Question 3
- states EV = 0 and net gain = 0B1
- Answer: Expected value = £0; Net gain = £0.
Question 4
- any valid non-numeric factor, e.g. effect on brand image, staff workload, customer convenience, regulatory issues, or long-term strategic fitB1
- Answer: For example, effect on brand image: a coffee van may improve local presence but could distract from the core cafe brand.
Question 5
- a clear statement that expected value is the probability weighted average of outcomesB1
- or equivalent, e.g. sum of each outcome multiplied by its probabilityB1
- Answer: Expected value is the sum of each possible outcome multiplied by its probability, the probability weighted average of outcomes.
Question 6
- 0.5 x 300 + 0.5 x 0 seenM1
- £150 caoA1
- Answer: £150.
Question 7
- 0.7 x 1,500 + 0.3 x 200 seenM1
- £1,110 caoA1
- Answer: £1,110.
Question 8
- identifies Option A and gives £2,600, or identifies Option C and gives £610, or Option B with 0, but correct highest is Option A 2,600B1
- Answer: Option A, net gain £2,600.
Question 9
- explains that if probabilities are wrong the expected values will be wrong, e.g. if the 0.6 success probability for the van is overestimated then the EV and net gain will be too high and option choice may be wrongB1
- Answer: If the 0.6 probability of van success is too high, the EV of £5,600 is overstated and the net gain £2,600 is misleading, so the recommended option could be wrong.
Question 10
- states that the net gain is positive, e.g. net gain of £2,600 so expected returns exceed the costB1
- Answer: The net gain is positive: expected net gain is £2,600, so the expected returns exceed the £3,000 cost.
Question 11
- 1,110 - 500 seen (ft from question 7)M1
- £610 caoA1
- Answer: £610.
Question 12
- states a practical limit, e.g. trees become complex with many branches and changing probabilities, making them hard to draw and unreliableB1
- Answer: Decision trees become complex and hard to manage for sequential or combined strategies, and probabilities for later stages may change, reducing reliability.
Question 13
- multiplies 0.6 by 8,000 or shows 0.6 x 8000M1
- £4,800 cao for 0.6 x 8,000A1
- multiplies 0.4 by 2,000 or shows 0.4 x 2000M1
- £800 cao for 0.4 x 2,000A1
- adds the two products, 4,800 + 800M1
- £5,600 cao for the expected value at the chance nodeA1
- subtracts the cost 3,000 from the expected value or shows 5,600 - 3,000M1
- £2,600 cao for the net gain of Option AA1
- Answer: Expected value = £5,600; Net gain = £2,600.
Question 14
- Level 1 Makes simple, undeveloped points about limitations of decision trees with little or no use of the case figures and no clear judgement.1-4
- Level 2 Develops several points about limitations, uses some case figures or examples, and offers a partial judgement but does not fully balance strengths and weaknesses.5-8
- Level 3 Provides a well developed evaluation of the limitations, applies case figures and examples (for example the 0.6 probability and the £3,000 cost for the van), analyses implications for Green Brew Ltd and reaches a balanced, justified conclusion.9-12
- Indicative content:
- Numeric limitations: decision trees depend on estimated probabilities and monetary outcomes; if the 0.6 success probability for the van is uncertain or biased, the EV of £5,600 and net gain of £2,600 are unreliable.
- Numeric limitations continued: decision trees usually ignore risk preferences and variance; two options with similar EVs may differ in risk, for example Option A has a wide outcome range 8,000 or 2,000, whereas Option C outcomes are smaller, so EV alone hides volatility.
- Practical limitations: complex or sequential decisions make trees large and impractical, and probabilities for later nodes may change after earlier decisions, reducing predictive value for strategies like 'test kiosk then buy van'.
- Qualitative factors: decision trees omit non-financial considerations such as brand impact, customer experience, staff capacity, or strategic fit, which might favour the van despite numbers or rule it out despite a positive net gain.
- Data availability and time: accurate probabilities and outcomes require good market research, which can be costly and time-consuming; small firms like Green Brew Ltd may lack reliable data, making estimates speculative.
- Behavioural limitations: managers may be overconfident about probabilities or influenced by bias, leading to inappropriate weighting of outcomes, so a numerically superior option in the tree might be rejected for intuitive reasons and vice versa.
- Counterbalance: decision trees are still useful as a structured, transparent way to compare options numerically; they force explicit assumptions and make it easier to test sensitivity by changing probabilities and figures.
- Conclusion guidance: a balanced conclusion might say decision trees are valuable as a decision aid but their output should not be followed blindly; for Green Brew Ltd the positive net gain for Option A is persuasive, but the firm should check the probability estimates, consider risk tolerance and qualitative factors before committing.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.