Legal, Moral, Cultural and Ethical Issues - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
9 original exam-style questions - 7 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Legal, Moral, Cultural and Ethical Issues revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Computer Science practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 5 of A Level Computer Science Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 5 of A Level Computer Science 10-Minute Tests.
1.5 Legal, Moral, Cultural and Ethical Issues
Question 1
- (a) Data Protection Act 2018B1
- (a) UK GDPR / General Data Protection Regulation (oe)B1
- (a) Answer: Data Protection Act 2018, incorporating the UK GDPR.
- (b) Identifies the storage limitation principle (oe)B1
- (b) Explains that data must not be kept for longer than necessary for the purpose it was collectedB1
- (b) Applies this to the scenario: the athletes have left, so there is no ongoing purpose, so the records should be deleted or anonymisedB1
- (b) Answer: This breaches the storage limitation principle; data has no ongoing purpose once an athlete leaves and should not be retained indefinitely.
- (c) Identifies that health data is 'special category data' under the UK GDPR (oe)B1
- (c) Explains that special category data requires an extra lawful condition, normally explicit consent, before it can be processed/sharedB1
- (c) Explains a consequence/harm, e.g. potential discrimination against the athlete, loss of sponsorship, distress, breach of trustB1
- (c) Answer: Sharing special category data without explicit consent (or another Article 9 condition) is unlawful and can cause serious harm to the athlete.
Question 2
- (a) Open source: the source code is made available and users may view, modify and redistribute it (oe)B1
- (a) Proprietary: the source code is kept private/hidden and copying, modifying or redistributing it is restricted by the owner (oe)B1
- (a) Valid comparative point, e.g. open source can be cheaper/more customisable, proprietary can offer more guaranteed support/quality controlB1
- (a) Answer: Open source licences allow access to and reuse of source code; proprietary licences restrict access and reuse to protect the owner's rights.
- (b) Attribution: the user must credit Nadia as the original creator (oe)B1
- (b) NonCommercial: the user may only use the engine for non-commercial purposes, e.g. not sell a product built with it (oe)B1
- (b) Answer: Attribution = must credit the creator; NonCommercial = may not be used to make money.
- (c) Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988B1
- (c) Infringement of Nadia's copyright / right to reproduce and distribute her own work (oe)B1
- (c) Valid remedy, e.g. injunction to stop further sales, damages/compensation, account of profitsB1
- (c) Answer: Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988; infringement of copyright; remedy such as an injunction or damages.
Question 3
- (a) Freedom of Information Act 2000B1
- (a) Public authorities/public sector bodies, e.g. councils, government departments, state schools, NHS (oe, any one example accepted)B1
- (a) Answer: Freedom of Information Act 2000; applies to public authorities.
- (b) Valid exemption reason 1, e.g. information is commercially sensitive (ongoing supplier negotiations)B1
- (b) Valid exemption reason 2, e.g. information contains personal data of named staff, protected under data protection lawB1
- (b) Reference to the process, e.g. a public interest test must be applied to qualified exemptions, or the request must be answered within 20 working daysB1
- (b) Answer: Exemptions may apply for commercially sensitive information or personal data; qualified exemptions are subject to a public interest test.
- (c) Valid benefit, e.g. increases transparency and public accountability, builds trust in how public money is spentB1
- (c) Valid drawback, e.g. significant staff time/cost to process requests, risk of releasing information that harms commercial negotiationsB1
- (c) Balanced comparative or concluding comment linking benefit and drawbackB1
- (c) Answer: Benefit: greater transparency/accountability. Drawback: administrative cost and risk of commercially damaging disclosure. A balance must be struck using exemptions.
Question 4
- (a) Converts 300 W to 0.3 kW and multiplies by 24 hours (oe method)M1
- (a) 7.2 kWh, caoA1
- (a) Answer: 7.2 kWh
- (b) Multiplies answer to (a) by 2000 (ft from a)M1
- (b) 14400 kWh (ft from a), caoA1
- (b) Answer: 14 400 kWh (14.4 MWh)
- (c) L1 Basic, undeveloped identification of one or two impacts (e.g. energy use, e-waste) with little or no discussion of reduction methods.1-2
- (c) L2 Clear explanation of two or more impacts (e.g. energy use/carbon emissions, cooling water use, e-waste from hardware replacement) with at least one reasonably developed method of reduction.3-4
- (c) L3 Sustained, well-developed discussion covering multiple impacts and a clearly evaluated method of reduction, reaching a reasoned judgement about its effectiveness or limitations.5
- (c) Indicative content:
- High continuous electricity demand contributes to carbon emissions, especially where power is not from renewable sources.
- Cooling systems for servers use large amounts of energy and, in some designs, large amounts of water.
- Frequent hardware replacement/upgrade cycles generate electronic waste (e-waste), some of which contains hazardous materials and is difficult to recycle safely.
- Reduction methods: server virtualisation to reduce the number of physical servers needed; sourcing renewable electricity; locating data centres in cooler climates to reduce cooling energy; reusing waste heat to warm nearby buildings.
- Evaluation: reduction methods often involve upfront cost or practical limitations (e.g. renewable supply is not always available, virtualisation still requires hardware refresh), so impact reduction is a trade-off rather than a complete solution.
- (c) Answer: N/A - levels-marked extended response.
Question 5
- (a) Valid factor 1, e.g. reading direction/layout (right-to-left text for Arabic)B1
- (a) Valid factor 2, e.g. colours, symbols or imagery that have different cultural or religious meanings in different countriesB1
- (a) Valid factor 3, e.g. date/number/currency formats, local data protection laws that may differ from UK GDPR, or local content/censorship rulesB1
- (a) Answer: Any three of: reading direction/layout; culturally sensitive colours/symbols/imagery; date, number or currency formats; local data protection or censorship laws.
- (b) L1 Identifies a benefit or challenge of a global platform with limited explanation or evaluation.1-2
- (b) L2 Clear discussion of both benefits (e.g. shared access to quality resources, cost-effectiveness) and challenges (e.g. cultural imperialism, censorship conflicts, cost/time of localisation), with a reasoned evaluative judgement about achievability or desirability.3-4
- (b) Indicative content:
- Benefit: a shared global platform can be cheaper to build and maintain, and can widen access to good-quality educational resources, potentially reducing the digital divide.
- Challenge: exporting content designed around one culture's norms and values risks 'cultural imperialism', imposing assumptions that do not fit other cultures.
- Challenge: content acceptable in the UK (e.g. discussion of certain scientific, religious or social topics) may conflict with local censorship rules or cultural sensitivities elsewhere.
- Challenge: full localisation is costly and time-consuming for a small company, so genuine adaptation for every market may not be commercially achievable.
- Evaluation: a balance is often struck through partial localisation (adapting the most sensitive elements) rather than either a single global version or full bespoke versions for every market.
- (b) Answer: N/A - levels-marked extended response.
Question 6
- (a) Benefit: consistent, fast detection across a whole cohort supports fairness and deters deliberate academic dishonestyB1
- (a) Drawback: false positives are possible, e.g. common technical phrases, properly cited quotations, or writing conventions from a student's first language/culture may be flagged unfairlyB1
- (a) Developed point linking to Sophie's case, e.g. a similarity score alone does not distinguish plagiarism from legitimate quotation/paraphrase, so context and human review are needed before judging herB1
- (a) Answer: Benefit: consistent, scalable, fair detection across all students. Drawback: risk of false positives, especially for legitimately cited or common technical language, which can unfairly disadvantage individual students such as Sophie.
- (b) Point that a raw score lacks context/nuance, e.g. it cannot reliably distinguish properly referenced quotation from genuine plagiarismB1
- (b) Point about due process/fairness, e.g. a student should have the right to explain flagged sections before a judgement is madeB1
- (b) Point recognising the institution's argument, e.g. efficiency/consistency at scale across thousands of submissionsB1
- (b) Evaluative concluding statement, e.g. the score should trigger further human review, not act as an automatic verdict, to be considered ethicalB1
- (b) Answer: It is not fully ethical to rely on the score alone; it should be used as a trigger for human review rather than a final verdict, balancing efficiency with fairness and due process.
Question 7
- (a) BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT (oe)B1
- (a) Valid principle, e.g. members must have due regard for the public health, privacy, security and wellbeing of othersB1
- (a) Answer: BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT; its code of conduct requires members to prioritise public safety and wellbeing.
- (b) Explains the potential harm to public safety, given this is a life-critical/safety-critical systemB1
- (b) Explains that a professional's ethical duty of care can override a manager's commercial instruction when public safety is at riskB1
- (b) Explains a consequence of not acting, e.g. legal/professional liability, loss of public trust, risk of prosecution if harm occursB1
- (b) Answer: Because the system is safety-critical, Leah's professional duty of care to protect the public overrides commercial pressure to meet the deadline; failing to act could cause real harm and expose her and the company to liability.
- (c) L1 States one or two options with little explanation or evaluation.1-2
- (c) L2 Explains a range of options with some evaluation of which is most appropriate, but the argument may be one-sided or not fully developed.3-4
- (c) L3 Sustained discussion of multiple options with a clear, reasoned evaluation leading to a justified recommendation.5
- (c) Indicative content:
- Options: report the bug formally to senior management/quality assurance in writing; refuse to sign off the release; escalate to a safety regulator such as the Office of Rail and Road; delay release until the fix is made; as a last resort, disclose externally/whistleblow.
- The Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998 offers UK employees legal protection against dismissal for whistleblowing on genuine safety concerns, but this is typically considered a last resort after internal routes are exhausted.
- Documenting concerns in writing protects Leah professionally and creates a record that due diligence was carried out.
- Evaluation: escalating internally first (formally, in writing, to a level above the immediate manager) is usually the most proportionate first step, reserving external whistleblowing for cases where internal escalation fails and the risk to the public is imminent.
- (c) Answer: N/A - levels-marked extended response.
Question 8
- (a) Identifies at least two possible responsible parties, e.g. the manufacturer, the software developers, the vehicle owner/supervising 'driver', the insurerB1
- (a) Explains the difficulty: the decision was made by a pre-programmed algorithm rather than a real-time human judgement, so it is unclear whose 'choice' actually caused the outcomeB1
- (a) Valid reference to relevant framework, e.g. the Automated and Electric Vehicles Act 2018 makes insurers primarily liable for incidents while a vehicle is driving itselfB1
- (a) Answer: Responsibility could fall on the manufacturer, developers, owner or insurer; assigning it is harder because the decision was embedded in code in advance rather than made by a human in the moment, though UK law (the Automated and Electric Vehicles Act 2018) assigns initial liability to the insurer.
- (b) L1 Basic identification of the dilemma (e.g. 'the car has to choose who to hurt') with little explanation.1-2
- (b) L2 Clear explanation of the ethical challenge using relevant ideas (e.g. utilitarian vs rule-based approaches, differing priorities between individuals/cultures) with some attempt at evaluation.3-5
- (b) L3 Sustained, well-reasoned evaluation that considers multiple ethical perspectives and cultural variation, and reaches a justified conclusion about whether universally acceptable rules are achievable.6-7
- (b) Indicative content:
- This is a variant of the 'trolley problem': there is no action-free option, so the software must be pre-programmed with a rule for an unavoidable harm scenario.
- A utilitarian approach (minimise total harm/number of injuries) may conflict with a rule-based approach (e.g. never deliberately steer towards a person) or with protecting the paying customer (the passenger) above all else.
- Research such as the MIT 'Moral Machine' study has shown that people in different countries and cultures prioritise these dilemmas differently (e.g. some cultures prioritise the young over the old, or pedestrians over passengers, more strongly than others), suggesting a single universally 'moral' rule may not exist.
- Manufacturers face a commercial tension: customers may be less willing to buy a car programmed to sacrifice its own passenger in some scenarios.
- Possible mitigations: transparency about how decisions are made, independent regulation/certification of decision rules, and legal frameworks assigning liability rather than expecting a perfect moral answer.
- A well-reasoned conclusion should recognise that full universal agreement is unlikely given cultural variation, so transparency, regulation and legal accountability may matter more than finding one 'correct' ethical rule.
- (b) Answer: N/A - levels-marked extended response.
Question 9
- (a) (i) Section 1: unauthorised access to computer material appliesB1
- (a) (i) Valid justification, e.g. he accessed the system without the hospital's consent, regardless of his benign intent, which is sufficient for the Section 1 offenceB1
- (a) (ii) Recognises that publishing the exploit code is not itself an act of unauthorised access, so it does not directly commit the Section 1 or Section 3 offenceB1
- (a) (ii) Valid nuance, e.g. this could potentially fall under Section 3A (making, supplying or obtaining articles for use in a computer misuse offence) if the code is judged likely to be used for such offences, though this is a more complex legal question than (i)B1
- (a) Answer: (i) Section 1 offence applies to the unauthorised access. (ii) Publishing alone is not a direct access/modification offence, but could potentially engage Section 3A depending on intent and likely use.
- (b) Data Protection Act 2018 / UK GDPRB1
- (b) Explains the requirement to report the breach to the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) without undue delay, and where feasible within 72 hoursB1
- (b) Explains the requirement to notify the affected patients directly if the breach is likely to result in a high risk to their rights and freedomsB1
- (b) Explains a possible consequence for the trust, e.g. an ICO fine, reputational damage, a requirement to improve security measuresB1
- (b) Answer: Data Protection Act 2018/UK GDPR requires the trust to report the breach to the ICO within 72 hours where feasible, notify affected patients if the risk is high, and it may face a fine or enforcement action.
- (c) L1 Basic explanation of responsible disclosure or of a legal issue, with limited reference to the scenario and little evaluation.1-3
- (c) L2 Clear explanation of responsible disclosure principles and of the limitations of current legislation, with reference to the scenario, and some evaluation, though it may be one-sided.4-6
- (c) L3 Sustained, well-structured evaluation that draws directly on the scenario to weigh the interests of researchers, organisations and the public, considers the adequacy of current law, and reaches a well-justified overall conclusion.7-9
- (c) Indicative content:
- Responsible disclosure norms: report privately first, allow a reasonable fixed period (commonly around 90 days in industry practice) for the organisation to patch the flaw, only publish full technical details afterwards, and ideally withhold or delay publication of working exploit code even then.
- In this scenario, Ryan followed part of the process (private report first) but the hospital trust failed to respond, and Ryan then published full working exploit code rather than a limited disclosure or an extended private escalation, which arguably went beyond responsible practice and directly enabled the criminal attack.
- The Computer Misuse Act 1990 does not provide an explicit statutory defence or 'safe harbour' for good-faith security research; the Section 1 offence can technically apply even where access was for a benign purpose, unlike some other jurisdictions that provide specific protections for authorised or good-faith testing.
- This creates a chilling effect: legitimate researchers may be deterred from testing real systems for fear of prosecution, meaning vulnerabilities may go undiscovered or unreported, reducing overall public benefit.
- Counter-argument: without some deterrent, any unauthorised access could be excused as 'research', which would undermine legitimate prosecution of malicious actors, so the law cannot simply exempt all such access.
- Possible reforms discussed by security professionals include an explicit public interest defence for authorised/ethical security research, wider adoption of formal bug bounty and vulnerability disclosure programmes by organisations, and clearer statutory response-time obligations on organisations receiving vulnerability reports.
- A well-reasoned conclusion should recognise that the harm in this case arose from failures on both sides (the hospital's lack of response and the researcher's decision to publish working exploit code), and that legal reform alongside better organisational processes, rather than either the criminal law or individual ethics alone, is likely needed to properly balance these interests.
- (c) Answer: N/A - levels-marked extended response.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.