The Balance of Payments: Causes and Correction of Disequilibrium - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
8 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
The Balance of Payments: Causes and Correction of Disequilibrium revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Economics practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 8 of A Level Economics Topic Workbook 3 and chapter 7 of A Level Economics 10-Minute Tests 2.
2.6 The Balance of Payments: Causes and Correction of Disequilibrium
Question 1
- any one valid way, e.g. higher relative wage or production costs raise UK export prices and reduce export volumesB1
- a second, different valid way (e.g. an appreciation of the pound, higher relative inflation), or: slower productivity growth increases unit costs for UK firms, encouraging imports and reducing net exportsB1
- Answer: Higher relative wages or costs that make UK goods more expensive overseas; slower productivity growth raising unit costs and encouraging imports.
Question 2
- in a boom domestic incomes and spending rise, boosting imports more than exports and worsening the current accountM1
- in a recession domestic demand and imports fall, which can temporarily improve the current accountA1
- Answer: During booms higher incomes raise import demand and can worsen the current account; during recessions lower demand reduces imports and can improve the current account temporarily.
Question 3
- protectionist measures are policies such as tariffs, quotas or import restrictions designed to reduce import volumes and protect domestic industriesB1
- negative side effect: they raise prices for UK consumers, reducing consumer welfare and potentially causing retaliation from trading partnersB1
- Answer: Protectionism uses tariffs or quotas to cut imports; a likely negative effect is higher prices for consumers and lower consumer choice.
Question 4
- investment in vocational training or education, which raises labour productivity and lowers unit labour costs, making UK firms more price competitive abroadB1
- subsidies or tax relief for R and D and capital investment, which improve technology and product quality, increasing non-price competitiveness and export demandB1
- each linked to how that policy helps net exports: higher productivity lowers costs and prices; better technology raises quality and demand overseasB1
- Answer: Examples: better vocational training raises productivity reducing unit costs; R and D tax relief improves technology and quality, boosting export demand.
Question 5
- Level 1 Basic statements about current account deficits, limited analysis. May identify one or two causes or costs with little development. Judgement, if present, is unsupported or implied.1-5
- Level 2 Clear explanation of causes and some costs of a persistent deficit, and some analysis of policy options. Some evaluation, but argument may be unbalanced or lacking depth. Diagrams mentioned or partially explained.6-10
- Level 3 Detailed analysis of the causes and consequences of a persistent deficit, with balanced evaluation of different scenarios. Considers policy effectiveness, time lags, distributional effects and financing issues. Clear judgement supported by evidence or reasoned argument. Diagrams are correctly described and used to support points.11-15
- Level 4 Comprehensive analysis and evaluation, including consideration of macroeconomic context, role of capital flows, credibility, and structural factors. Contrasting positions explored and limitations of models assessed. Diagrams are integrated and used effectively. A nuanced, well-supported conclusion is given.16-20
- Level 5 Excellent, sustained evaluation showing mastery of the topic. Arguments are balanced, explore alternative interpretations and policy trade offs, and integrate short-run and long-run perspectives. Diagrams and empirical reasoning are used to support a sophisticated, well-justified judgement.21-25
- Indicative content:
- Causes: persistent relative inflation and weak productivity growth reducing competitiveness; exchange rate overvaluation; structural issues in tradable sectors; high domestic demand and import dependence; cyclical factors made persistent by policy or structural change.
- Costs: ongoing net outflows requiring financing, rising foreign liabilities and income payments abroad, vulnerability to sudden stops in capital inflows, possible depreciation pressures, loss of tradable sector jobs, crowding out of domestic tradables.
- Circumstances where a deficit may not be problematic: if it finances productive investment that raises future growth and returns (eg financing R and D, infrastructure), if capital inflows are stable and finance productive assets, or if deficit simply reflects a high level of imports of capital goods that will raise future export capacity.
- Financing and sustainability: distinction between temporary deficits and structural deficits; role of capital and financial account inflows and their volatility; rollover risk and interest cost dynamics.
- Policy options and trade offs: expenditure-switching (depreciation, tariffs) can restore competitiveness quickly but risk inflation, retaliation, and higher import input costs; expenditure-reducing (fiscal/monetary tightening) lowers import demand but causes recession and unemployment; supply-side reforms improve competitiveness long term but have long lags and political costs.
- Distributional and macro effects: who gains and who loses, effects on inflation, wages, unemployment, real incomes and growth; impacts on investment and confidence.
- Diagrams to draw: real exchange rate diagram showing depreciation effect on net exports; a goods market AD/AS or Import demand curve showing the effect of expenditure-reducing policy; a loanable funds or capital flow schematic to show financing of the deficit.
- Evaluation points: magnitude and persistence matter; composition of the deficit (goods versus services, capital imports versus consumption imports) matters; the openness of capital markets and credibility of financing sources; empirical UK context: strong services exports may mitigate goods deficit; policy mix often required.
- Supported judgement: weigh short-term stabilisation needs against long-run structural reform, conclude under what conditions a persistent deficit is a serious problem for the UK and when it may be manageable or even beneficial.
Question 6
- faster domestic inflation raises UK prices relative to foreign prices, reducing price competitivenessM1
- this tends to reduce export volumes as foreign buyers switch to cheaper alternatives and increase import demand as foreign goods become relatively cheaperA1
- the combined effect is a deterioration in net exports, which can widen the current account deficitA1
- Answer: Higher UK inflation makes domestic goods relatively more expensive, reducing exports and increasing imports, thereby worsening the current account balance.
Question 7
- expenditure-switching policies are measures that aim to change the pattern of domestic spending away from imports toward domestically produced goods and servicesB1
- example: a deliberate depreciation of the pound sterling to make UK exports cheaper and imports more expensive, or targeted temporary tariffs on certain importsB1
- Answer: Expenditure-switching policies change spending towards domestic goods, for example a depreciation of the pound to boost exports and discourage imports.
Question 8
- depreciation makes UK exports cheaper in foreign currency terms and imports more expensive in domestic currency terms, tending to increase export volumes and reduce import volumesM1
- this improves net exports (X - M) and shifts aggregate demand toward domestic production, reducing the current account deficitA1
- condition: the Marshall-Lerner condition must hold over time, i.e. the sum of price elasticities of demand for exports and imports must exceed 1, so volume responses offset price effectsA1
- Answer: Depreciation makes exports cheaper and imports costlier, raising export volumes and lowering import volumes to improve net exports, provided the Marshall-Lerner condition holds so volumes respond sufficiently.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.