Rational Decision Making and the Theory of Diminishing Marginal Utility - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
7 original exam-style questions - 3 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Rational Decision Making and the Theory of Diminishing Marginal Utility revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Economics practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 6 of A Level Economics Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 6 of A Level Economics 10-Minute Tests 1.
1.6 Rational Decision Making and the Theory of Diminishing Marginal Utility
Question 1
- states the equi-marginal condition: MUA / PA = MUB / PB for utility maximisation given a budgetM1
- applies the numbers: MUA / PA = 10/2 = 5; MUB / PB = 6/1 = 6M1
- concludes that MUB / PB > MUA / PA, so the consumer should buy more of B and less of A to increase total utility per pound spentA1
- explains final allocation condition: the consumer reallocates spending until MUA / PA rises or MUB / PB falls into equality, or until budget is exhaustedA1
- Answer: Since 10/2 = 5 and 6/1 = 6, B gives more utility per pound, so the consumer should buy more of B and less of A until MUA/PA = MUB/PB or budget exhausted.
Question 2
- strength 1: MU theory provides a clear, intuitive explanation of downward-sloping demand via diminishing MUB1
- develops strength 1: diminishing MU explains why willingness to pay falls for successive tickets, mapping to a demand curveA1
- strength 2: MU framework links price and quantity through a simple rule (buy while MU ≥ price), useful for pedagogic and analytical clarityB1
- develops strength 2: the MU ≥ price rule helps predict discrete purchase decisions and marginal analysis in many market situationsA1
- weakness 1: MU is ordinal and hypothetical, utils are unobservable and interpersonal comparisons are problematicB1
- develops weakness 1: this limits empirical testing and policy application because MU values cannot be measured directly across individualsA1
- weakness 2: the model assumes consistent, calculating consumers, ignoring contexts where habit, time pressure or heuristics drive behaviourB1
- Answer: Two strengths: clear explanation of downward-sloping demand via diminishing MU, and a simple purchase rule MU ≥ price. Two weaknesses: MU is unobservable and interpersonal comparisons are difficult, and the model assumes calculating rational consumers ignoring habits and heuristics.
Question 3
- Level 1 Basic statements about rational decision-making with limited or no application, weak structure, little or no use of diagram, and a simple unbalanced judgement1-4
- Level 2 Clear explanation of strengths and limitations of the rational model, some use of examples or a diagram, and a balanced discussion with a tentative conclusion5-8
- Level 3 Comprehensive analysis of the rational decision-making assumption, well-developed evaluation of limitations and their significance, effective use of diagrams and examples, and a clearly justified and supported judgement9-12
- Indicative content:
- Strengths: provides a coherent, parsimonious framework for predicting consumer responses to prices and incomes; yields testable comparative statics such as the MU >= price rule and equi-marginal principle; the law of diminishing MU explains downward-sloping individual demand and helps derive market demand when aggregated
- Use of diagrams: marginal utility schedules mapped to willingness-to-pay points that trace a downward-sloping individual demand curve; equi-marginal allocation between two goods shown by MU/P equalisation
- Limitations: utils are hypothetical and unobservable, interpersonal comparisons problematic; assumptions of complete information, transitive and stable preferences, and unbounded computation are unrealistic in many everyday choices
- Behavioural considerations: habits, heuristics, bounded rationality and time-inconsistent preferences can lead to systematic deviations from utility-maximising choices, though these are reserved for the behavioural pack, mention as boundary
- Magnitude and context: discuss when the rational model works well (high-stakes, infrequent decisions, markets with clear prices) and when it is weaker (habitual small purchases, complex multi-attribute goods), including policy implications
- Evaluation: weigh model simplicity and predictive power against realism; consider whether relaxing assumptions (e.g. satisficing, fuzzy preferences) preserves useful predictions; conclude with a supported view on the continued usefulness of the rational model for many economic analyses, while acknowledging important limits for some contexts
Question 4
- as more units of a good are consumed, the marginal utility of each additional unit eventually falls, holding other factors constantB1
- Answer: As more units are consumed, the marginal utility of each additional unit eventually decreases, ceteris paribus.
Question 5
- MU for 1st unit = 12 - 0 = 12 utilsM1
- MU for 2nd unit = 22 - 12 = 10 utilsM1
- MU for 3rd unit = 30 - 22 = 8 utilsM1
- MU for 4th unit = 36 - 30 = 6 utilsM1
- identifies point of diminishing marginal utility appears after the 1st unit, since MU falls from 12 to 10 on the second unit, so diminishing MU begins at the 2nd unit (or 'from the 2nd unit onward')B1
- Answer: MU column: 1st 12, 2nd 10, 3rd 8, 4th 6, 5th 4. Diminishing MU first appears at the 2nd unit (MU falls compared with previous unit).
Question 6
- MU for 1st unit = 8 - 0 = 8 utilsM1
- MU for 2nd unit = 15 - 8 = 7 utilsM1
- MU for 3rd unit = 21 - 15 = 6 utilsM1
- MU for 4th unit = 24 - 21 = 3 utilsM1
- MU for 5th unit = 24 - 24 = 0, so MU becomes zero at the 5th unit (identifies zero correctly)B1
- Answer: MU column: 1st 8, 2nd 7, 3rd 6, 4th 3, 5th 0. MU becomes zero at the 5th unit; it does not go negative in this table.
Question 7
- identifies that the price an individual is willing to pay for a unit is related to the marginal utility of that unit, since willing-to-pay equals the monetary equivalent of MUM1
- explains that as MU falls with successive units (diminishing MU), the maximum willingness to pay falls tooM1
- links this to a downward-sloping individual demand curve, with each point reflecting the price equal to MU for that unitA1
- mentions that at market price P the consumer buys units where MU ≥ P and stops when MU < P, showing quantity demanded depends on priceB1
- briefly notes the role of income/budget constraint: willingness to pay also constrained by the consumer's budget, so actual demand equals MU-price comparisons within budgetB1
- Answer: The individual is willing to pay up to the MU of each unit; diminishing MU means willingness to pay falls with each unit, producing a downward-sloping demand curve. Consumer buys units while MU ≥ market price, subject to budget constraints.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.