UCAT Decision Making: Syllogisms, set 1
Five conclusions against a short set of premises, each to be marked Yes if it must follow and No if it does not, with the quantifiers read exactly as defined and no assumption added. Test standard. 8 questions, 16 marks, about 9 minutes.
Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)
- Answer every question. Questions are standalone.
- Multiple-statement questions are worth 2 marks; the real test gives 1 mark for a partly correct response. Other questions have exactly one correct answer.
- A basic calculator is allowed in this subtest.
- 12 marks
All the nurses at Fernhill Clinic have completed first-aid training.
Some of the staff at Fernhill Clinic who have completed first-aid training work night shifts.
No receptionist at Fernhill Clinic works night shifts.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. Some nurses at Fernhill Clinic work night shifts. 2. At least one member of staff at Fernhill Clinic who has completed first-aid training is not a receptionist. 3. Receptionists at Fernhill Clinic have not completed first-aid training. 4. Any member of staff at Fernhill Clinic who works night shifts is not a receptionist. 5. All staff at Fernhill Clinic who work night shifts have completed first-aid training. - 22 marks
Most members of the Larkhill Community Choir can read music.
Most members of the Larkhill Community Choir have sung with the choir for more than five years.
Every member of the choir who can read music attends the Tuesday rehearsal.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. At least one member of the choir who can read music has sung with the choir for more than five years. 2. Most members of the choir attend the Tuesday rehearsal. 3. Every member of the choir who attends the Tuesday rehearsal can read music. 4. Most members who have sung with the choir for more than five years can read music. 5. A member of the choir who does not attend the Tuesday rehearsal cannot read music. - 32 marks
Every plot on the Ashby Lane allotments grows potatoes.
Only plots that have a water butt grow tomatoes.
None of the plots on the north side of the Ashby Lane allotments has a water butt.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. No plot on the north side of the Ashby Lane allotments grows tomatoes. 2. Every plot that has a water butt grows tomatoes. 3. None of the plots on the north side of the Ashby Lane allotments grows potatoes. 4. Any plot on the Ashby Lane allotments that grows tomatoes also grows potatoes and has a water butt. 5. Plots on the Ashby Lane allotments that do not have a water butt grow only potatoes. - 42 marks
All the bus routes run by Corrbridge Transit stop at the hospital.
Some routes that stop at the hospital run after midnight.
Route 7 is run by Corrbridge Transit.
No route that runs after midnight uses a double-decker bus.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. Route 7 stops at the hospital. 2. Route 7 runs after midnight. 3. Some routes run by Corrbridge Transit run after midnight. 4. If Route 7 uses a double-decker bus, it does not run after midnight. 5. At least one route that stops at the hospital does not use a double-decker bus. - 52 marks
Every sample received by the Westmoor laboratory on Monday was a blood sample.
Few of the samples received by the Westmoor laboratory on Monday were labelled incorrectly.
Only incorrectly labelled samples are returned to the ward.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. Some of the samples received by the laboratory on Monday were urine samples. 2. Most samples received by the laboratory on Monday were labelled correctly. 3. Every incorrectly labelled sample received on Monday is returned to the ward. 4. Fewer than half of the samples received on Monday are returned to the ward. 5. A correctly labelled sample received on Monday is not returned to the ward. - 62 marks
All blims are trosks.
No trosk is a vell.
Some vells are quans.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. No blim is a vell. 2. At least one quan is not a trosk. 3. All trosks are blims. 4. Some quans are blims. 5. Every quan is a vell. - 72 marks
Most drels are pindles.
Every pindle is a sorf.
No sorf is a gast.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. Some drels are gasts. 2. Most drels are sorfs. 3. Most sorfs are drels. 4. No pindle is a gast. 5. At least one drel is not a gast. - 82 marks
All the physiotherapists at Brookside Health Centre also work at Kelda Hospital.
Only staff who work at Kelda Hospital may use the Kelda staff car park.
None of the physiotherapists at Brookside Health Centre works on Sundays.
Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.
Answer Yes or No for each statement Statement Yes No 1. Every member of staff at Kelda Hospital is a physiotherapist at Brookside Health Centre. 2. Every member of staff who may use the Kelda staff car park works at Kelda Hospital. 3. Physiotherapists at Brookside Health Centre may use the Kelda staff car park. 4. Anyone at Brookside Health Centre who works on Sundays is not one of its physiotherapists. 5. Nobody who works at Kelda Hospital works on Sundays.
Worked solutions
Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.
Question 1
Answer or working Marks 1 No, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 No 2 Sort the groups: nurses sit wholly inside 'first-aid trained'. Part of 'first-aid trained' (more than one person, but not everyone) overlaps 'night shifts'. 'Receptionists' and 'night shifts' do not overlap at all. Nothing ties nurses to the night-shift overlap, and nothing ties receptionists to the trained group either way, so statements 1 and 3 do not follow. Statement 5 reverses the direction of the 'some' premise, so it does not follow either. Statement 4 is the 'no' premise read from the other side. For statement 2, take any trained member of staff who works nights (the 'some' premise guarantees at least one); the third premise says that person cannot be a receptionist. Both follow. So the answers are No, Yes, No, Yes, No. Statement 1 (No): The night-shift workers are drawn from the first-aid trained staff, but the nurses are only part of that group. The trained staff who work nights could all be doctors or porters, so nothing places a nurse on nights. Statement 2 (Yes): Some trained staff work night shifts, so at least one trained person works nights. No receptionist works nights, so that person is not a receptionist. This holds whether 'some' is read strictly or loosely. Statement 3 (No): The premises say receptionists do not work nights; they say nothing about whether receptionists are trained. A trained receptionist who works days breaks no premise. Statement 4 (Yes): 'No receptionist works night shifts' means the two groups do not overlap at all, so read from the other side, no night-shift worker is a receptionist. Statement 5 (No): The premise says some trained staff work nights, not that only trained staff do. An untrained cleaner on nights is consistent with every premise, so this turns the premise round illegitimately. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 2
Answer or working Marks 1 Yes, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 No, 5 Yes 2 'Most' is defined by the consortium as a majority. Picture a choir of 10: readers are at least 6, long-serving members are at least 6, and all readers attend on Tuesday. Two groups of at least 6 out of 10 must share at least 2 members, so statement 1 follows; but the share can be as small as 2 out of 6, so statement 4 does not. Readers (at least 6) all attend, so attenders are a majority: statement 2 follows. Statement 3 reverses 'every reader attends', so it does not follow. Statement 5 is the same premise read backwards correctly (not attending rules out reading), so it follows. So the answers are Yes, Yes, No, No, Yes. Statement 1 (Yes): 'Most' means a majority. Two groups that are each more than half of the same choir cannot fit side by side without sharing at least one member, so the readers and the long-serving members overlap. Statement 2 (Yes): Every reader attends on Tuesday and the readers are already a majority, so the Tuesday attenders are at least that many: a majority too. Statement 3 (No): This is the converse of the third premise. Readers all attend, but non-readers may attend as well; nothing keeps them away. Statement 4 (No): Two majorities must overlap, but the overlap can be small. In a choir of 10 with readers numbered 1 to 6 and long-serving members 5 to 10, only 2 of the 6 long-serving members read music. Statement 5 (Yes): If such a member could read music, the third premise would put them at the Tuesday rehearsal. So anyone absent on Tuesday is not a reader. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 3
Answer or working Marks 1 Yes, 2 No, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 No 2 Rewrite 'only plots with a water butt grow tomatoes' as 'every tomato plot has a water butt'. That is the one direction the premise gives; its converse is not given. Chain it: north-side plots have no water butt, so they cannot be tomato plots (statement 1 follows). Tomato plots have a water butt and, like every plot there, grow potatoes (statement 4 follows). Statement 2 is the converse of the 'only' premise, statement 3 moves the north side's missing water butt onto potatoes, which the first premise contradicts, and statement 5 assumes potatoes and tomatoes are the only crops. None of them follows. So the answers are Yes, No, No, Yes, No. Statement 1 (Yes): A tomato plot must have a water butt, and no north-side plot has one, so no north-side plot can grow tomatoes. Statement 2 (No): 'Only plots with a water butt grow tomatoes' makes a water butt necessary for tomatoes, not sufficient. A plot with a water butt may still grow none. Statement 3 (No): North-side plots are Ashby Lane plots, and every Ashby Lane plot grows potatoes. The premises say north-side plots lack a water butt, which rules out tomatoes, not potatoes. Statement 4 (Yes): Every Ashby Lane plot grows potatoes (premise 1), and any tomato plot has a water butt (premise 2), so both parts hold. Statement 5 (No): The premises rule out tomatoes on those plots and confirm potatoes, but beans, onions or anything else are not mentioned and not excluded. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 4
Answer or working Marks 1 Yes, 2 No, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 Yes 2 Draw it as groups: Corrbridge routes sit wholly inside 'stops at the hospital'; part of 'stops at the hospital' overlaps 'after midnight'; 'after midnight' and 'double-decker' do not overlap. Route 7 is a single point inside Corrbridge. Route 7 is therefore inside 'stops at the hospital' (statement 1 follows), but it need not be in the after-midnight part, and neither need any Corrbridge route (statements 2 and 3 do not follow). A double-decker route lies outside 'after midnight', so statement 4 follows. The after-midnight hospital routes (at least one exists) also lie outside 'double-decker', so statement 5 follows. So the answers are Yes, No, No, Yes, Yes. Statement 1 (Yes): Route 7 is a Corrbridge Transit route, and every Corrbridge Transit route stops at the hospital. Statement 2 (No): Only some hospital routes run after midnight. Route 7 is a hospital route, but it may be one of those that stop before midnight. Statement 3 (No): The late-running hospital routes could all belong to other operators. Being inside the same 'hospital' group does not put the two subgroups in contact. Statement 4 (Yes): No after-midnight route uses a double-decker, so any route that does use one, Route 7 included, cannot be an after-midnight route. Statement 5 (Yes): Some hospital routes run after midnight, so at least one does, and no after-midnight route uses a double-decker. That route stops at the hospital and does not use a double-decker. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 5
Answer or working Marks 1 No, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 Yes 2 Translate the quantifiers first. 'Few' means less than 50%, so the mislabelled Monday samples are a minority. 'Only incorrectly labelled samples are returned' means every returned sample is mislabelled. Returned Monday samples are therefore inside the mislabelled minority, so fewer than half are returned (statement 4) and no correctly labelled sample is returned (statement 5). The correctly labelled samples are the majority, so statement 2 follows. Statement 3 is the converse of the 'only' premise, and statement 1 contradicts the first premise. Neither follows. So the answers are No, Yes, No, Yes, Yes. Statement 1 (No): Every Monday sample was a blood sample, so the premises leave no room for a urine sample among them. Statement 2 (Yes): The consortium defines 'few' as less than 50%. If fewer than half were labelled incorrectly, more than half were labelled correctly, and 'most' means a majority. Statement 3 (No): 'Only incorrectly labelled samples are returned' makes a labelling error necessary for return, not sufficient. Some mislabelled samples might be relabelled in the laboratory instead. Statement 4 (Yes): Any Monday sample that is returned must be incorrectly labelled, and fewer than half of Monday's samples were. The returned ones are part of that minority, so they are fewer than half. Statement 5 (Yes): Being returned requires an incorrect label, so a correctly labelled sample cannot be one of those returned. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 6
Answer or working Marks 1 Yes, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 No, 5 No 2 The words are made up, so work only from the structure: blims inside trosks; trosks and vells apart; vells and quans partly overlapping (at least two shared members). Blims are inside trosks, which are apart from vells, so blims and vells are apart (statement 1 follows). The shared vell-quans are outside the trosks, so at least one quan is not a trosk (statement 2 follows). Statement 3 reverses 'all blims are trosks', statement 4 links quans to blims with no premise to do it, and statement 5 reverses 'some vells are quans' into 'all quans are vells'. None follows. So the answers are Yes, Yes, No, No, No. Statement 1 (Yes): Every blim is a trosk and no trosk is a vell, so a blim that was a vell would be a trosk that was a vell, which the second premise forbids. Statement 2 (Yes): Some (more than one) vells are quans. Those quans are vells, and no vell is a trosk, so each of them is a quan that is not a trosk. Statement 3 (No): This is the converse of the first premise. Blims sit inside trosks; there may be trosks that are not blims. Statement 4 (No): The quans we know about are vells and so cannot be blims. Any other quans are not described at all, so nothing puts a quan among the blims. Statement 5 (No): The premise says some vells are quans, which tells us nothing about quans outside the vells. There may be many quans that are not vells. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 7
Answer or working Marks 1 No, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 Yes 2 Set the structure out: more than half of the drels lie inside pindles, pindles lie inside sorfs, and sorfs are entirely apart from gasts. Follow the chain forwards: the majority of drels that are pindles are sorfs (statement 2) and are not gasts (statement 5). Pindles inherit 'not a gast' from sorfs (statement 4). Statement 3 runs the chain backwards, and statement 1 makes a claim about the undescribed minority of drels. Neither follows. So the answers are No, Yes, No, Yes, Yes. Statement 1 (No): The drels that are pindles cannot be gasts, and the remaining minority of drels is not described at all. Nothing says any of them is a gast. Statement 2 (Yes): A majority of drels are pindles and every pindle is a sorf, so at least that majority of drels are sorfs. Statement 3 (No): This reverses the direction of the chain. Sorfs could vastly outnumber drels, so the drels may be only a small part of the sorfs. Statement 4 (Yes): Every pindle is a sorf and no sorf is a gast, so a pindle that was a gast would be a sorf that was a gast. Statement 5 (Yes): 'Most' means a majority, so at least one drel is a pindle. That drel is a sorf, and no sorf is a gast. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response. Question 8
Answer or working Marks 1 No, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 No 2 Set out the groups: Brookside physiotherapists sit wholly inside Kelda staff; car-park users sit wholly inside Kelda staff; Brookside physiotherapists and Sunday workers do not overlap. Statement 2 restates the 'only' premise and statement 4 restates the 'none' premise from the other side, so both follow. Statement 3 turns a necessary condition into a sufficient one, and statement 5 stretches a fact about a subgroup to the whole of Kelda's staff, so neither follows. Statement 1 is the converse of the first premise: physiotherapists are all Kelda staff, but that does not make all Kelda staff Brookside physiotherapists. It does not follow. So the answers are No, Yes, No, Yes, No. Statement 1 (No): This reverses the first premise. Brookside physiotherapists sit inside Kelda staff, but Kelda can employ nurses, porters and others who never work at Brookside. Statement 2 (Yes): This is the 'only' premise restated: if only Kelda staff may use the car park, everyone permitted to use it is Kelda staff. Statement 3 (No): Working at Kelda is necessary for using the car park, not sufficient. The car park might be limited further, for example to staff who hold a permit. Statement 4 (Yes): No Brookside physiotherapist works on Sundays, so a Sunday worker there cannot be one of them. Statement 5 (No): The Sunday premise covers only the Brookside physiotherapists, a subgroup of Kelda staff. Other Kelda staff may well work Sundays. 2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response.