Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

UCAT Decision Making: Syllogisms, set 2

Five conclusions against a short set of premises, each to be marked Yes if it must follow and No if it does not, with the quantifiers read exactly as defined and no assumption added. Demanding. 8 questions, 16 marks, about 9 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Answer every question. Questions are standalone.
  • Multiple-statement questions are worth 2 marks; the real test gives 1 mark for a partly correct response. Other questions have exactly one correct answer.
  • A basic calculator is allowed in this subtest.
  1. 12 marks

    The following rules apply to exhibits at the Corrowdale Museum.

    Only exhibits that have been insured are displayed in the East Gallery.

    Every insured exhibit has been photographed for the catalogue.

    None of the exhibits on loan from private collectors has been photographed for the catalogue.

    Some ceramic exhibits are displayed in the East Gallery.

    Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.

    Answer Yes or No for each statement
    StatementYesNo
    1. No exhibit on loan from a private collector is displayed in the East Gallery.
    2. All exhibits that have been photographed for the catalogue are insured.
    3. At least one ceramic exhibit has been photographed for the catalogue.
    4. Every insured exhibit is displayed in the East Gallery.
    5. No ceramic exhibit is on loan from a private collector.
  2. 22 marks

    The following statements describe infusion pumps at Brennock General Hospital.

    No infusion pump leaves its ward unless it carries a green service tag.

    Every pump that carries a green service tag was checked by the electronics team this month.

    Not all of the pumps on Ward 7 were checked by the electronics team this month.

    Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.

    Answer Yes or No for each statement
    StatementYesNo
    1. At least one pump on Ward 7 does not carry a green service tag.
    2. Every pump that was checked by the electronics team this month carries a green service tag.
    3. At least one pump on Ward 7 does not leave the ward.
    4. Most of the pumps on Ward 7 were not checked by the electronics team this month.
    5. Any pump on Ward 7 that leaves the ward was checked by the electronics team this month.
  3. 32 marks

    The following statements describe the members of the Fenwick Cycling Club.

    Most members of the club ride road bikes.

    Most members of the club have entered the spring sportive.

    Some members who ride road bikes also own a mountain bike.

    No member who has entered the spring sportive is a club marshal.

    Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.

    Answer Yes or No for each statement
    StatementYesNo
    1. At least one member who rides a road bike has entered the spring sportive.
    2. At least one member who owns a mountain bike has entered the spring sportive.
    3. Most club marshals ride road bikes.
    4. At least one member who rides a road bike is not a club marshal.
    5. Fewer than half of the club's members are club marshals.
  4. 42 marks

    The words below are made up. Use only the information given.

    All brindels are quorps.

    No quorp is a vantic.

    Some vantics are telmers.

    Only telmers are hoxes.

    Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.

    Answer Yes or No for each statement
    StatementYesNo
    1. No brindel is a vantic.
    2. At least one telmer is not a quorp.
    3. No hox is a brindel.
    4. All telmers are hoxes.
    5. Some quorps are not brindels.
  5. 52 marks

    The following statements describe staff at the Larkspur Theatre Company.

    Every actor in the touring cast also understudies at least one role.

    None of the company's understudies is on a permanent contract.

    Only staff on permanent contracts are eligible for the company pension scheme.

    A few of the company's set builders are on permanent contracts.

    Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.

    Answer Yes or No for each statement
    StatementYesNo
    1. No member of the touring cast is eligible for the company pension scheme.
    2. Every member of staff on a permanent contract is eligible for the pension scheme.
    3. Most of the company's set builders are not on permanent contracts.
    4. Every set builder who is not on a permanent contract understudies a role.
    5. Any set builder who is eligible for the pension scheme is not an understudy.
  6. 62 marks

    The following statements describe the Arnfield Seed Bank.

    All seed samples stored in the deep vault are kept below -18 degrees Celsius.

    Some samples kept below -18 degrees Celsius are from wild relatives of crop plants.

    No sample from a wild relative of a crop plant is distributed to commercial growers.

    Most samples in the deep vault were collected before 2010.

    Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.

    Answer Yes or No for each statement
    StatementYesNo
    1. Some samples in the deep vault are from wild relatives of crop plants.
    2. At least one sample kept below -18 degrees Celsius is not distributed to commercial growers.
    3. Storing seeds below -18 degrees Celsius keeps them viable for longer.
    4. At least one sample collected before 2010 is kept below -18 degrees Celsius.
    5. No sample in the deep vault is distributed to commercial growers.
  7. 72 marks

    The minerals named below are fictional. Use only the information given.

    Most orlinite samples glow under ultraviolet light.

    No sample that glows under ultraviolet light contains iron.

    Every tavrite sample contains iron.

    Some orlinite samples are also classed as tavrite.

    Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.

    Answer Yes or No for each statement
    StatementYesNo
    1. Fewer than half of orlinite samples contain iron.
    2. No tavrite sample glows under ultraviolet light.
    3. Every sample that contains iron is tavrite.
    4. Most orlinite samples are not tavrite.
    5. Some samples that glow under ultraviolet light are tavrite.
  8. 82 marks

    The following statements describe defibrillators at Hollins Cross Hospital.

    A defibrillator is not signed off for use unless its battery has been tested in the past week.

    Every defibrillator on the surgical wards has been signed off for use.

    Most of the hospital's defibrillators are on the surgical wards.

    None of the defibrillators bought before 2015 has had its battery tested in the past week.

    Place 'Yes' if the conclusion does follow. Place 'No' if the conclusion does not follow.

    Answer Yes or No for each statement
    StatementYesNo
    1. No defibrillator on the surgical wards was bought before 2015.
    2. Most of the hospital's defibrillators have had their battery tested in the past week.
    3. Every defibrillator whose battery was tested in the past week has been signed off for use.
    4. Fewer than half of the hospital's defibrillators were bought before 2015.
    5. Every defibrillator that is not on a surgical ward was bought before 2015.

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    1 Yes, 2 No, 3 Yes, 4 No, 5 No2
    Turn the 'only' rule round the right way first: 'Only insured exhibits are displayed in the East Gallery' means every East Gallery exhibit is insured. It does not mean every insured exhibit is there.
    Now chain: East Gallery -> insured -> photographed. The contrapositive of the whole chain is: not photographed -> not insured -> not in the East Gallery. Private loans are never photographed, so they sit at the start of that contrapositive chain.
    The ceramics premise only tells you about the ceramics that are in the East Gallery. Anything said about ceramics outside it is an assumption.
    Statements 1 and 3 follow from the chain; statements 2 and 4 reverse a premise; statement 5 extends a fact about some ceramics to all of them.
    So the verdicts are Yes, No, Yes, No, No.
    Statement 1 (Yes): Chain the first three premises: East Gallery -> insured -> photographed. A private loan is never photographed, so it cannot be insured, so it cannot be in the East Gallery.
    Statement 2 (No): This reverses premise 2. Every insured exhibit is photographed, but nothing says every photographed exhibit is insured; an uninsured exhibit could still have been photographed.
    Statement 3 (Yes): Some (more than one) ceramics are in the East Gallery, so they are insured (premise 1) and therefore photographed (premise 2).
    Statement 4 (No): 'Only insured exhibits are in the East Gallery' means East Gallery -> insured, not insured -> East Gallery. Insured exhibits can be elsewhere in the museum.
    Statement 5 (No): Only the ceramics in the East Gallery are ruled out as private loans. Ceramics outside the East Gallery are not covered by any premise, so some of them could be private loans.
    2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    1 Yes, 2 No, 3 Yes, 4 No, 5 Yes2
    Rewrite 'unless' as a condition: 'No pump leaves its ward unless it carries a green tag' means leaves ward -> green tag. It does not say every tagged pump leaves.
    Chain the first two premises: leaves ward -> green tag -> checked this month. Its contrapositive is: not checked -> no green tag -> does not leave the ward.
    'Not all' is defined by the consortium as 1-99%. So at least one Ward 7 pump was not checked, but you cannot say how many; 'most' is not justified.
    Feed the unchecked Ward 7 pump through the contrapositive chain to settle statements 1 and 3, and use the forward chain for statement 5. Statement 2 is the converse of premise 2.
    So the verdicts are Yes, No, Yes, No, Yes.
    Statement 1 (Yes): 'Not all' (1-99%) means at least one Ward 7 pump was not checked this month. By the contrapositive of premise 2, an unchecked pump has no green tag.
    Statement 2 (No): This is the converse of premise 2. Green tag -> checked does not give checked -> green tag; a pump could be checked and still not tagged.
    Statement 3 (Yes): The unchecked Ward 7 pump has no green tag (statement 1), and premise 1 says no pump leaves its ward without a green tag.
    Statement 4 (No): 'Not all' covers anything from 1% to 99%. It could be that only one Ward 7 pump missed its check, so 'most were not checked' does not follow.
    Statement 5 (Yes): Leaving the ward requires a green tag (premise 1), and a green tag means the pump was checked this month (premise 2). This applies to every pump, including those on Ward 7.
    2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    1 Yes, 2 No, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 Yes2
    Use the consortium meaning of 'most': a majority, more than half. Two majorities of the same group always overlap, because together they add up to more than the whole.
    A 'some' group carries no such guarantee. 'Some road riders own a mountain bike' and 'most members entered the sportive' can be arranged so the two never meet; a counter-example is enough to say No.
    The 'no' premise puts every marshal in the minority who did not enter the sportive, which caps the number of marshals at under half and makes every sportive entrant a non-marshal.
    Test each conclusion against an arrangement of 10 members: road riders 1-6, sportive entrants 3-8, mountain-bike owners 1 and 2, marshals 9 and 10. All four premises hold, statements 2 and 3 are false in it, and statements 1, 4 and 5 hold in every arrangement.
    So the verdicts are Yes, No, No, Yes, Yes.
    Statement 1 (Yes): Two groups that are each more than half of the same club must share at least one member. Most = a majority, so road riders and sportive entrants overlap.
    Statement 2 (No): A 'some' group and a 'most' group need not overlap. The mountain-bike owners could all be among the minority who did not enter the sportive.
    Statement 3 (No): Marshals come only from members who did not enter the sportive, and nothing links that group to road bikes. Every marshal could ride something else, and there may be no marshals at all.
    Statement 4 (Yes): From statement 1, some road rider entered the sportive, and no sportive entrant is a marshal, so that road rider is not a marshal.
    Statement 5 (Yes): Every marshal is outside the sportive group. The sportive group is a majority, so the members outside it are fewer than half, and the marshals are at most that many.
    2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    1 Yes, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 No, 5 No2
    Write each premise as an arrow: brindel -> quorp; quorp -> not vantic (equivalently vantic -> not quorp); some vantics are telmers; hox -> telmer.
    Chain the first two: brindel -> quorp -> not vantic. The vantic telmers are therefore neither quorps nor brindels, but that tells you nothing about the telmers that are not vantics.
    Watch the two converse traps: 'only telmers are hoxes' points from hox to telmer, and 'all brindels are quorps' points from brindel to quorp. Neither can be read backwards, and neither tells you the bigger group has members outside the smaller one.
    Statements 1 and 2 follow from the chain; 3 assumes something about non-vantic telmers; 4 and 5 each read a premise backwards.
    So the verdicts are Yes, Yes, No, No, No.
    Statement 1 (Yes): Every brindel is a quorp, and no quorp is a vantic, so no brindel can be a vantic.
    Statement 2 (Yes): Some (more than one) vantics are telmers. Those telmers are vantics, and no vantic is a quorp, so they are telmers that are not quorps.
    Statement 3 (No): Hoxes are all telmers, but only the vantic telmers are ruled out of being quorps or brindels. A non-vantic telmer could be a brindel and a hox at once.
    Statement 4 (No): 'Only telmers are hoxes' means every hox is a telmer. Reading it as every telmer is a hox reverses the 'only' rule.
    Statement 5 (No): 'All brindels are quorps' does not say there are quorps outside the brindels. Every quorp could be a brindel, so this does not follow.
    2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    1 Yes, 2 No, 3 Yes, 4 No, 5 Yes2
    Write the chain: touring cast -> understudy -> not permanent -> not eligible. The last step is the contrapositive of 'only permanent staff are eligible', which means eligible -> permanent.
    Use the consortium meaning of 'few': a small number, less than 50%. Its complement is therefore more than 50%, which is the meaning of 'most'.
    Check every conclusion that runs an arrow backwards. Statement 2 reverses 'only'; statement 4 reverses 'none of the understudies is permanent'. Both are converse traps.
    Statement 5 runs the chain from the other end: eligible -> permanent -> not an understudy, which is valid.
    So the verdicts are Yes, No, Yes, No, Yes.
    Statement 1 (Yes): Touring cast -> understudy -> not permanent. Pension eligibility needs a permanent contract, so no touring actor is eligible.
    Statement 2 (No): 'Only permanent staff are eligible' means eligible -> permanent. It does not say every permanent member of staff is eligible.
    Statement 3 (Yes): 'A few' is defined as a small number, less than 50%. If fewer than half of the set builders are permanent, more than half are not, which is 'most'.
    Statement 4 (No): This reverses premise 2. Understudies are never permanent, but a non-permanent member of staff need not be an understudy.
    Statement 5 (Yes): Eligible -> permanent (premise 3), and no understudy is permanent (premise 2), so an eligible set builder cannot be an understudy.
    2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    1 No, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 No2
    Draw the groups: the deep vault sits entirely inside 'kept below -18 degrees Celsius'. The wild-relative samples overlap 'kept below -18 degrees Celsius' too, but nothing says where they overlap.
    Statements 1 and 5 both assume the wild-relative samples are in the deep vault. That is the classic undistributed middle: two groups inside a third need not meet.
    Statement 3 sounds sensible but rests on knowledge outside the premises, so it cannot be a valid conclusion here.
    Statements 2 and 4 each link two premises through a shared group that the premises do connect: the wild-relative samples below -18 degrees, and the pre-2010 samples in the deep vault.
    So the verdicts are No, Yes, No, Yes, No.
    Statement 1 (No): The wild-relative samples are among the samples kept below -18 degrees Celsius, but the deep vault is only one place such samples are kept. They could all be stored elsewhere.
    Statement 2 (Yes): Some samples kept below -18 degrees Celsius are wild relatives (premise 2), and no wild-relative sample is distributed to commercial growers (premise 3).
    Statement 3 (No): This may be true of seeds in general, but no premise says anything about why the samples are cold or what cold does. A conclusion must come from the premises, not from outside knowledge.
    Statement 4 (Yes): Most deep-vault samples were collected before 2010, so there is at least one, and every deep-vault sample is kept below -18 degrees Celsius.
    Statement 5 (No): Only wild-relative samples are barred from distribution, and nothing places any wild-relative sample in the deep vault. Other deep-vault samples could be distributed.
    2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    1 Yes, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 No2
    Write the arrows: glows -> no iron (so iron -> does not glow); tavrite -> iron. Chained: tavrite -> iron -> does not glow.
    Use the meaning of 'most': more than half of orlinite glows, so the orlinite that does not glow is fewer than half.
    Anything that must be non-glowing (iron-bearing orlinite, tavrite orlinite) is squeezed into that minority, so each is fewer than half of orlinite.
    Statement 3 reads premise 3 backwards, and statement 5 contradicts the chain.
    So the verdicts are Yes, Yes, No, Yes, No.
    Statement 1 (Yes): More than half of orlinite samples glow, and no glowing sample contains iron. So iron can only be in the non-glowing orlinite samples, which are fewer than half.
    Statement 2 (Yes): Tavrite -> contains iron (premise 3), and the contrapositive of premise 2 is contains iron -> does not glow.
    Statement 3 (No): This is the converse of premise 3. All tavrite contains iron, but other minerals, including some orlinite, could contain iron without being tavrite.
    Statement 4 (Yes): The orlinite samples that are tavrite contain iron and so do not glow. Non-glowing orlinite is fewer than half, so tavrite orlinite is fewer than half and most orlinite is not tavrite.
    Statement 5 (No): Statement 2 shows that no tavrite sample glows, so this conclusion contradicts what the premises establish.
    2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response.
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    1 Yes, 2 Yes, 3 No, 4 Yes, 5 No2
    Turn 'not signed off unless tested' into an arrow: signed off -> battery tested. Then chain: surgical ward -> signed off -> tested -> not bought before 2015.
    The contrapositive runs the other way: bought before 2015 -> not tested -> not signed off -> not on a surgical ward.
    'Most' means more than half are on the surgical wards, so everything forced off the surgical wards (the pre-2015 machines) is fewer than half, and everything that follows from being on them (tested, signed off) covers more than half.
    Statements 3 and 5 each reverse an arrow, which the premises never allow.
    So the verdicts are Yes, Yes, No, Yes, No.
    Statement 1 (Yes): Surgical ward -> signed off -> battery tested in the past week. A defibrillator bought before 2015 has not been tested, so it cannot be on a surgical ward.
    Statement 2 (Yes): Most defibrillators are on the surgical wards, and every one of those has been signed off and so tested. The tested group therefore contains a majority.
    Statement 3 (No): Premise 1 says signed off -> tested. Reading it as tested -> signed off is the converse; a tested defibrillator might still be awaiting sign-off.
    Statement 4 (Yes): A pre-2015 defibrillator is untested, so not signed off, so not on a surgical ward. Defibrillators off the surgical wards are fewer than half, so pre-2015 ones are fewer than half.
    Statement 5 (No): The premises say pre-2015 -> not on a surgical ward, not the reverse. A newer defibrillator could be on another ward.
    2 marks if all five statements are placed correctly; the real test gives 1 mark for a partially correct response.

Keep going

More free UCAT practice