Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

UCAT Situational Judgement: Rating appropriateness, set 1

Rating one action, from one named person's point of view, as very appropriate, appropriate but not ideal, inappropriate but not awful, or very inappropriate. Test standard. 15 questions, 15 marks, about 6 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Each scenario is followed by several questions. Answer from the point of view of the person named in the question.
  • Judge each response on its own: more than one response to a scenario can earn the same rating.
  • No medical knowledge is needed.
  1. 11 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Priya in this situation?

    Explain honestly that, as a student, she is not the right person to discuss his results, and that she will ask the nurse in charge to let the team know straight away that he is anxious to speak to them.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  2. 21 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Priya in this situation?

    Tell Mr Okafor what the report says, since he has a right to know about his own health.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  3. 31 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Priya in this situation?

    Tell Mr Okafor honestly that she is not able to discuss his results, and suggest that he asks one of the doctors himself when the team comes out of theatre.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  4. 41 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Priya in this situation?

    Tell Mr Okafor that the report has not come back yet, so that he does not worry before the consultant sees him.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  5. 51 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Priya in this situation?

    Change the subject to how his wound is healing, without responding to his question about the report.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  6. 61 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Tom in this situation?

    Suggest to Hannah that she tells Dr Mensah she needs to step away from clinic for the rest of the session, and offer to go with her to speak to him.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  7. 71 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Tom in this situation?

    Respect Hannah's wish and say nothing to Dr Mensah, but double-check everything Hannah hands him for the rest of the session.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  8. 81 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Tom in this situation?

    Post a message in the year group's chat saying that Hannah's relative is in hospital and she is struggling on clinic, so that classmates can support her.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  9. 91 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Tom in this situation?

    With Hannah's agreement, swap roles so that Tom handles every radiograph and record himself for the rest of the session, and go with her to tell Dr Mensah about the mix-up at the end of clinic.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  10. 101 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Tom in this situation?

    Tell Hannah that, because of the radiograph mix-up, Dr Mensah needs to know she is having a difficult day. Encourage her to tell him herself before the next patient, and say that if she would rather not, he will tell Dr Mensah himself.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  11. 111 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Kemi in this situation?

    Give the vaccine, following the instructions printed on the packet.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  12. 121 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Kemi in this situation?

    Take the history as planned and, when Dr Lewis joins them, explain to him that she has not been trained to give vaccines, so that he or someone who is trained can give it before Mrs Patel leaves.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  13. 131 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Kemi in this situation?

    Take the history, tell Mrs Patel that she will not be having her vaccine today, and mention to Dr Lewis only at the end of the day, after Mrs Patel has gone home, that she was not trained to give it.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  14. 141 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Kemi in this situation?

    Before seeing Mrs Patel, knock on Dr Lewis's door and briefly interrupt his consultation to tell him that she has not been trained to give vaccines.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  15. 151 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Kemi in this situation?

    Tell Mrs Patel that she does not need a flu vaccine this year, so that the problem does not arise.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (A very appropriate thing to do)1
    What the response does: Priya is honest about why she cannot answer, does not pretend the report is not there, and arranges for the people who can answer to hear about his worry while they are still in theatre.
    Against the principles: results such as a biopsy should be explained by a clinician who can interpret them, answer questions and plan next steps, so a student breaking that news would be working beyond her competence. Telling him honestly why she cannot help, and passing his concern on through the nurse in charge, respects both honesty and patient safety.
    Against the definitions: a response is 'a very appropriate thing to do' if it addresses at least one aspect of the situation. This one addresses his anxiety and his need for information, without creating any new problem.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "Appropriate, but not ideal" here would still score something, but "A very appropriate thing to do" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: a very appropriate thing to do.
    Why not B: Treats a prompt, honest response as merely acceptable. It does more than 'could be done': it is truthful, keeps Priya within her role and gets his worry to the team now rather than later.
    Why not C: Mistakes declining to share the result for being unhelpful to the patient. A student withholding a result she is not able to explain is correct, not something that 'should not really be done'.
    Why not D: Confuses not giving the result with deceiving him. Nothing in this response is untrue or makes the situation worse, so it cannot be very inappropriate.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (A very inappropriate thing to do)1
    What the response does: Priya gives a patient a biopsy result that has not been discussed with him by the clinical team, while that team is unavailable for an hour.
    Against the principles: a student must work within her competence. She cannot be sure she is interpreting the report correctly, cannot answer the questions it raises, and could leave him alone with frightening news. His right to the information is real, but it should be met by the consultant or a doctor on the team.
    Against the definitions: 'a very inappropriate thing to do' is something that should definitely not be done and would make the situation worse. Breaking significant news outside her role, with no support available, fits that exactly.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "Inappropriate, but not awful" here would still score something, but "A very inappropriate thing to do" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: a very inappropriate thing to do.
    Why not A: Takes 'he has a right to know' as decisive. He does have that right, but it is met by the right clinician explaining the result, not by a student reading it out.
    Why not B: Sees honesty and openness as making the action acceptable, overlooking that Priya would be acting well beyond her competence on a potentially serious result.
    Why not C: Underestimates the harm. Hearing a possibly serious result from a student with no one able to answer his questions or plan treatment would make the situation worse, not just be 'not ideal'.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Appropriate, but not ideal)1
    What the response does: Priya is honest that she cannot discuss the result and points Mr Okafor to the people who can, so she stays within her role.
    Its weakness is that she does nothing herself. The nurse in charge is on the ward and could get word to the team now, but Priya leaves it to an anxious patient to catch a doctor later, and nobody on the team learns that he is asking.
    Against the definitions: 'appropriate, but not ideal' covers something that could be done but is not necessarily a very good thing to do. An honest, safe reply that passes his concern on to no one fits that band; adding 'and I will let the team know now' would have made it very appropriate.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "A very appropriate thing to do" or "Inappropriate, but not awful" here would still score something, but "Appropriate, but not ideal" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is B: appropriate, but not ideal.
    Why not A: Credits the honesty and the respect for her role, but misses that nobody is told he is anxious: the burden of chasing the team is left on a worried patient when Priya could alert the nurse in charge now.
    Why not C: Treats leaving him to ask the doctors as something she should not really do. It is truthful, keeps her within her competence and points him to the right people, so it is acceptable.
    Why not D: Reads a limited reply as harmful. She says nothing untrue and discloses nothing, so the situation is not made worse.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (A very inappropriate thing to do)1
    What the response does: Priya tells the patient something she knows to be false about his own results.
    Against the principles: honesty with patients is fundamental. A student can decline to explain a result, but she must not deny that it exists. Once he finds out, his trust in Priya and in the team is damaged at the moment he most needs it.
    Against the definitions: this should definitely not be done and would make the situation worse, which is 'a very inappropriate thing to do'. A good motive does not change the rating.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "Inappropriate, but not awful" here would still score something, but "A very inappropriate thing to do" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: a very inappropriate thing to do.
    Why not A: Accepts the kind motive, sparing him worry, as justification. The motive does not make a false statement to a patient acceptable.
    Why not B: Treats the lie as a harmless delaying tactic. It deceives the patient about his own care, which is far worse than 'not ideal'.
    Why not C: Underrates dishonesty. When the consultant later discusses a report that was already back, Mr Okafor will learn he was lied to, which damages trust in Priya and the team.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Inappropriate, but not awful)1
    What the response does: Priya avoids disclosing the result, which is correct, but does it by ignoring his question and leaving his worry hanging.
    Against the principles: respect for patients means acknowledging their concerns and being open about what you can and cannot do. Brushing past his question is discourteous and gets no information to the team, but it involves no lie and no disclosure beyond her role.
    Against the definitions: 'inappropriate, but not awful' is something that should not really be done but would not be terrible. That fits an evasive, unhelpful reply that causes no real harm.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "Appropriate, but not ideal" or "A very inappropriate thing to do" here would still score something, but "Inappropriate, but not awful" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is C: inappropriate, but not awful.
    Why not A: Sees avoiding the result as the main goal and misses that ignoring a direct, anxious question is discourteous and leaves his concern unaddressed.
    Why not B: Treats sidestepping as a reasonable way to stay within her role. Staying within her role is right, but doing it by ignoring him, rather than explaining, is something she should not really do.
    Why not D: Overstates the harm. Priya says nothing untrue and discloses nothing; she is unhelpful rather than damaging, so this is not one that makes the situation clearly worse.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (A very appropriate thing to do)1
    What the response does: Tom addresses both the patient safety risk (a distracted clinician has already made one mix-up) and Hannah's wellbeing, while letting her decide how to tell the tutor and offering support.
    Against the principles: patients come first, and Dr Mensah needs to know a team member is not fit to continue the session. Encouraging Hannah to raise it herself is honest, kind and keeps her in control of her own information.
    Against the definitions: 'a very appropriate thing to do' addresses at least one aspect of the situation. This addresses two, safety and support, without creating a new problem.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "Appropriate, but not ideal" here would still score something, but "A very appropriate thing to do" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: a very appropriate thing to do.
    Why not B: Worries that the suggestion goes against Hannah's request. It respects her by letting her speak for herself while still making sure the tutor knows, so it is better than 'could be done'.
    Why not C: Treats encouraging her to involve the tutor as a betrayal. It is a supportive way to deal with a real risk to patients, which is the opposite of something that should not be done.
    Why not D: Misreads this as overriding her wishes. Tom tells no one himself; he encourages Hannah to act, which cannot make the situation worse.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Inappropriate, but not awful)1
    What the response does: Tom keeps Hannah's confidence and tries to manage the risk himself by checking her work.
    Against the principles: a near-miss with the wrong patient's radiograph is a patient safety concern, and the clinical tutor is the person who must know about it. Hiding it to protect a colleague puts loyalty above patients, although Tom's checking does reduce the immediate risk.
    Against the definitions: 'inappropriate, but not awful' is something that should not really be done but would not be terrible. Concealing the problem should not be done, but the checking stops it being terrible.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "Appropriate, but not ideal" or "A very inappropriate thing to do" here would still score something, but "Inappropriate, but not awful" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is C: inappropriate, but not awful.
    Why not A: Credits the double-checking as dealing with the risk. It reduces it, but leaves the person responsible for the clinic unaware of a known safety problem.
    Why not B: Treats loyalty to Hannah as a good enough reason. Keeping a safety concern from the supervising tutor is something Tom should not really do, not merely a less-than-ideal option.
    Why not D: Overstates the harm. Tom's extra checking does guard against a repeat of the mix-up, so the situation is not made clearly worse.
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (A very inappropriate thing to do)1
    What the response does: Tom shares a colleague's private family news, and the fact that she is struggling clinically, with the whole year group in writing, without her permission.
    Against the principles: respect for colleagues includes keeping what they confide in you private. A post in a group chat spreads it to dozens of people and cannot be withdrawn, and it does nothing about the real issue, because the tutor still does not know a team member is not coping.
    Against the definitions: it should definitely not be done and would make the situation worse for Hannah, so it is 'a very inappropriate thing to do'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "Inappropriate, but not awful" here would still score something, but "A very inappropriate thing to do" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: a very inappropriate thing to do.
    Why not A: Takes the caring motive at face value. Broadcasting Hannah's private news to the whole year breaks the confidence she placed in Tom and does nothing about the risk to patients.
    Why not B: Sees peer support as a reasonable aim. The aim is fine, but publishing her personal information to a group without her consent is not an acceptable way to reach it.
    Why not C: Underrates the breach. A written post to a whole year group cannot be taken back, exposes her family situation and her struggles on clinic, and leaves the tutor still unaware, so it actively makes things worse.
  9. Question 9

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Appropriate, but not ideal)1
    What the response does: Tom removes the immediate risk by taking over the tasks where the mix-up happened, keeps Hannah on side, and makes sure Dr Mensah hears about the near-miss the same morning.
    Its weakness is timing. Hannah is still shaken, Dr Mensah is easy to reach between patients, and as the tutor responsible for the session he should decide, before more patients are seen, whether she should carry on at all. Leaving that until the end of clinic means three patients are treated without the person in charge knowing.
    Against the definitions: 'appropriate, but not ideal' is something that could be done but is not necessarily a very good thing to do. A safe, honest plan that tells the right person too late fits that band; telling Dr Mensah before the next patient would have made it very appropriate.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "A very appropriate thing to do" or "Inappropriate, but not awful" here would still score something, but "Appropriate, but not ideal" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is B: appropriate, but not ideal.
    Why not A: Credits the swap and the eventual report, but misses that Hannah is still shaken and that Dr Mensah, who is easy to reach, does not learn of a safety concern, or get to decide whether she should carry on, until three more patients have been seen.
    Why not C: Treats the delay as making this something he should not do. The immediate risk is actively removed by the swap and the concern does reach the tutor the same morning, so it is acceptable.
    Why not D: Reads the response as a cover-up. Tom reduces the risk at once and makes sure the tutor is told, so the situation is improved, not worsened.
  10. Question 10

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (A very appropriate thing to do)1
    What the response does: Tom is honest with Hannah about why the tutor must know, gives her the chance to tell Dr Mensah herself, and makes sure the tutor knows before any more patients are treated, whichever of them says it.
    Against the principles: patient safety comes before a colleague's wish to keep a problem quiet. Raising it promptly, with the right person, while being open with Hannah, respecting her wish to speak for herself where possible and sharing only what is needed, is how concerns should be raised.
    Against the definitions: it addresses the main aspect of the situation, the risk to the three remaining patients, and supports Hannah as well, so it is 'a very appropriate thing to do'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "Appropriate, but not ideal" here would still score something, but "A very appropriate thing to do" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: a very appropriate thing to do.
    Why not B: Gives too much weight to Hannah's request for silence. Tom gives her the chance to raise it herself first, and makes sure the tutor knows before any more patients are seen, so this is more than merely acceptable.
    Why not C: Treats going against a colleague's wishes as wrong in itself. Raising a safety concern openly, after giving her the chance to raise it herself, is exactly what a student should do.
    Why not D: Sees this as betraying Hannah. Tom is open with her, lets her speak for herself if she wants to, and involves only the tutor, which makes the situation better.
  11. Question 11

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (A very inappropriate thing to do)1
    What the response does: Kemi carries out an injection she has never been trained to give, with no one supervising her.
    Against the principles: students must work within their competence and ask for help when asked to go beyond it. Following a packet insert does not equip her to give an injection safely or to respond if something goes wrong.
    Against the definitions: it should definitely not be done and could make the situation worse for the patient, so it is 'a very inappropriate thing to do'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "Inappropriate, but not awful" here would still score something, but "A very inappropriate thing to do" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: a very inappropriate thing to do.
    Why not A: Treats doing what the supervisor asked as automatically right. A request from a senior does not make it safe to perform a procedure she has never been trained in.
    Why not B: Sees the printed instructions as enough to make it acceptable. Instructions on a packet do not replace training in technique, consent and managing a reaction.
    Why not C: Underestimates the risk. An untrained, unsupervised injection could harm Mrs Patel, so this would make the situation worse, not just be something she should not really do.
  12. Question 12

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (A very appropriate thing to do)1
    What the response does: Kemi does the task she is competent to do, and tells her supervisor about the task she is not, at a point when it can still be sorted out for the patient.
    Against the principles: working within competence and being honest with a supervisor about the limits of your training protects the patient. Raising it when Dr Lewis joins them avoids interrupting another consultation and still gets Mrs Patel vaccinated today.
    Against the definitions: it addresses the key aspect of the situation safely and honestly, so it is 'a very appropriate thing to do'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "Appropriate, but not ideal" here would still score something, but "A very appropriate thing to do" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: a very appropriate thing to do.
    Why not B: Worries that she should have raised it sooner. Dr Lewis is with another patient and will be joining Kemi and Mrs Patel in about fifteen minutes anyway, so raising it then loses nothing.
    Why not C: Treats not doing what she was asked as a failing. Declining a task beyond her competence, and saying so to her supervisor, is what she should do.
    Why not D: Misreads this as refusing to help. Mrs Patel still gets her history taken and her vaccine, from someone trained to give it.
  13. Question 13

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Inappropriate, but not awful)1
    What the response does: Kemi rightly avoids a procedure she is not trained for and is eventually honest with Dr Lewis, but she withholds the information until it is too late to act on it, so Mrs Patel misses a vaccine that someone else could have given that day.
    Against the principles: working within competence means passing a task you cannot do to someone who can, in time for the patient to benefit. Taking the decision alone and reporting it afterwards puts the patient's care second to avoiding an awkward conversation.
    Against the definitions: 'inappropriate, but not awful' is something that should not really be done but would not be terrible. Sending the patient home unvaccinated should not be done, but nothing unsafe or dishonest happens and the vaccine can be rebooked, so it is not terrible.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "Appropriate, but not ideal" or "A very inappropriate thing to do" here would still score something, but "Inappropriate, but not awful" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is C: inappropriate, but not awful.
    Why not A: Credits Kemi for not giving an injection she is untrained for. Avoiding the unsafe action is right, but she sends the patient away unvaccinated without giving anyone the chance to give it today.
    Why not B: Treats the eventual honesty with Dr Lewis as enough. Deciding on her own to send the patient home without a due vaccine, and telling her supervisor only once nothing can be done, is something she should not really do.
    Why not D: Overstates the harm. Kemi does nothing unsafe, says nothing untrue and does tell her supervisor, and Mrs Patel is due a vaccine this season rather than on this exact day, so it can be given at a later visit. This is not terrible.
  14. Question 14

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Appropriate, but not ideal)1
    What the response does: Kemi is honest with her supervisor straight away about a task beyond her training, so the vaccine will be given by someone competent.
    Its weakness is the interruption. Dr Lewis is with another patient, and there is no urgency, because he will be joining Kemi and Mrs Patel in about fifteen minutes and she can raise it then, before Mrs Patel leaves. Breaking into another consultation was unnecessary.
    Against the definitions: 'appropriate, but not ideal' is something that could be done but is not necessarily a very good thing to do. It solves the problem safely and honestly, but in a less considerate way than waiting a few minutes.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "A very appropriate thing to do" or "Inappropriate, but not awful" here would still score something, but "Appropriate, but not ideal" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is B: appropriate, but not ideal.
    Why not A: Credits the prompt honesty, but misses that she disturbs another patient's consultation over something that could wait: Dr Lewis will be joining her and Mrs Patel in about fifteen minutes anyway.
    Why not C: Treats the interruption as something she should not do. A brief knock to flag a safety limit is discourteous at worst; it is honest, keeps her within her competence and gets the vaccine given by someone trained.
    Why not D: Reads the interruption as harmful. A short knock on a colleague's door does not make the situation worse, and it resolves the problem of the vaccine.
  15. Question 15

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (A very inappropriate thing to do)1
    What the response does: Kemi gives the patient advice she knows to be untrue, to get herself out of an awkward task.
    Against the principles: honesty with patients is fundamental, and a student must never give clinical advice she knows is wrong. Mrs Patel could miss a vaccine she needs because of it.
    Against the definitions: it should definitely not be done and makes the situation worse, so it is 'a very inappropriate thing to do'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing "Inappropriate, but not awful" here would still score something, but "A very inappropriate thing to do" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: a very inappropriate thing to do.
    Why not A: Sees avoiding an untrained injection as the main aim. That aim is right, but it is achieved by giving the patient false medical information.
    Why not B: Treats this as a convenient way to stay within her competence. Misleading a patient about her own care is far worse than 'not ideal'.
    Why not C: Underrates the harm. Mrs Patel may now decline a vaccine she was due, on the strength of advice Kemi knows to be false, which makes the situation worse.

Keep going

More free UCAT practice