Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

UCAT Situational Judgement: Rating appropriateness, set 2

Rating one action, from one named person's point of view, as very appropriate, appropriate but not ideal, inappropriate but not awful, or very inappropriate. Demanding. 15 questions, 15 marks, about 6 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Each scenario is followed by several questions. Answer from the point of view of the person named in the question.
  • Judge each response on its own: more than one response to a scenario can earn the same rating.
  • No medical knowledge is needed.
  1. 11 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Megan in this situation?

    Send Josh a private message straight away, asking him to delete the post because the patient's name can be read on the screen.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  2. 21 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Megan in this situation?

    Message Josh saying the post is stupid and that he has embarrassed the whole year, then tell him to delete it.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  3. 31 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Megan in this situation?

    Take a screenshot of the post and share it in the year group chat to ask whether others think it is acceptable.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  4. 41 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Megan in this situation?

    Message Josh asking him to delete the post because it might get him into trouble, without mentioning the patient.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  5. 51 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Megan in this situation?

    Alongside asking Josh to delete the post, tell the clinical tutor what has happened when the afternoon clinic finishes, so the clinic can decide whether the patient should be informed.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  6. 61 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Daniel in this situation?

    Tell Chloe that writing Dr Okafor's signature is dishonest, and urge her to cross out the entry and speak to Dr Okafor today.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  7. 71 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Daniel in this situation?

    Agree with Chloe that it is a harmless shortcut and say nothing more about it.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  8. 81 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Daniel in this situation?

    Offer to sign the entry himself as a witness, so that it carries a genuine signature.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  9. 91 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Daniel in this situation?

    If Chloe will not correct the entry, tell the placement lead what he saw.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  10. 101 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Daniel in this situation?

    If Chloe will not correct the entry, tell Dr Okafor what he saw, rather than the placement lead, and leave it with him.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  11. 111 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Ellie in this situation?

    Tell the daughter what the report shows, since she is Mr Hughes's next of kin.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  12. 121 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Ellie in this situation?

    Explain that she cannot share his results without his agreement, and offer to ask Mr Hughes, when he is awake, whether he wants his daughter involved.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  13. 131 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Ellie in this situation?

    Tell the daughter she cannot share her father's results without his agreement, and leave it there.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  14. 141 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Ellie in this situation?

    Tell the daughter she is too busy to talk and walk on without answering.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do
  15. 151 mark

    How appropriate are each of the following responses by Ellie in this situation?

    Tell the daughter the scan was normal, so that she does not worry before her father has been told.

    1. A A very appropriate thing to do
    2. B Appropriate, but not ideal
    3. C Inappropriate, but not awful
    4. D A very inappropriate thing to do

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (A very appropriate thing to do)1
    The most urgent aspect is patient safety in the wider sense: a patient's full name and radiograph are on a public site with a mocking caption, and every minute it stays up more people can see it.
    Josh reads his messages between lectures, so a private message is the fastest route to getting the post removed, and it is discreet and respectful to Josh.
    It does not deal with every aspect (the clinic may still need to know about the breach), but 'A very appropriate thing to do' means the response addresses at least one aspect of the situation, not necessarily all of them.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so B would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is A: A very appropriate thing to do.
    Why not B: Treats a prompt private request as merely acceptable, when it is the quickest way to end a live breach of patient confidentiality and is exactly what a colleague should do first.
    Why not C: Confuses contacting Josh privately with confronting him; a private message is discreet, respectful and gets the patient's name off a public site fastest.
    Why not D: Mistakes acting on a colleague's post for disloyalty; nothing here makes the situation worse, and it reduces the harm to the patient.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Inappropriate, but not awful)1
    The one thing that matters most here is getting the patient's name off a public site, and this message does ask Josh to delete the post.
    But the way it is done is unprofessional: calling a colleague's post stupid and telling him he has embarrassed the whole year is belittling, will make Josh defensive, gives him no reason that concerns the patient, and fails the respect owed to a fellow team member. That takes it below 'appropriate, but not ideal'.
    It is still private and still asks for the post to come down, so it does not spread the breach or make anything worse: 'Inappropriate, but not awful' means the response should not really be done but would not be terrible.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so B or D would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is C: Inappropriate, but not awful.
    Why not A: Credits the request to delete the post but ignores the put-downs; belittling a colleague is not a very appropriate way to deal with a concern.
    Why not B: Treats the put-downs as a forgivable side issue; belittling a colleague is something that should not really be done, not merely a less good option.
    Why not D: Overstates the harm; the message is private, nothing about the patient is spread further, and the post is likely to come down, so the situation is not made worse.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (A very inappropriate thing to do)1
    The core problem is that identifiable patient information is being shared without consent.
    A screenshot in a group chat repeats that breach to a new audience and cannot be withdrawn, and it also exposes Josh to gossip rather than giving him a chance to put it right.
    The response actively worsens both the confidentiality breach and the team relationship: 'A very inappropriate thing to do' means the response should definitely not be done and would make the situation worse.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so C would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is D: A very inappropriate thing to do.
    Why not A: Mistakes seeking peer opinion for good practice; the screenshot copies the patient's name to dozens more people.
    Why not B: Treats canvassing views as a harmless extra step, missing that the screenshot spreads the breach and survives even if Josh deletes the post.
    Why not C: Underrates the harm; this is not just unhelpful, it creates a second, permanent copy of identifiable patient information.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Appropriate, but not ideal)1
    Asking Josh privately and promptly to delete the post is the right action, and it will end the public breach.
    The reason given is the weakness. It frames the problem as a risk to Josh rather than as a breach of the patient's confidentiality and dignity, so Josh is less likely to understand why it was wrong and more likely to repeat it. Compare the response that names the patient's identifiable details as the reason.
    So it could be done and achieves the main aim, but it is not ideal: 'Appropriate, but not ideal' means the response could be done but is not necessarily a very good thing to do.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so A or C would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is B: Appropriate, but not ideal.
    Why not A: Rates it alongside a message that explains the real problem; this one gets the post down but gives Josh the wrong reason, so it is not the best version of the response.
    Why not C: Mistakes an incomplete explanation for wrongdoing; nothing in the message should not be done, and it ends the breach quickly.
    Why not D: Confuses a weak reason with harm; the post comes down, so the situation is improved, not worsened.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (A very appropriate thing to do)1
    The tutor is told the same day, at the first point she is free, while the request to Josh deals with the public exposure in the meantime.
    A breach of patient confidentiality is something the clinic needs to know about, for example to decide whether the patient should be told and whether Josh needs support or guidance. Megan is raising a concern through the appropriate person, not punishing Josh.
    It addresses an important aspect of the situation: 'A very appropriate thing to do' means the response addresses at least one aspect of the situation, not necessarily all of them.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so B would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is A: A very appropriate thing to do.
    Why not B: Treats informing the tutor as optional extra; a confidentiality breach is something the clinic needs to know about so it can act for the patient.
    Why not C: Mistakes reporting for disloyalty; Josh is still asked to remove the post himself, and raising concerns through the right person is expected.
    Why not D: Confuses honesty with making things worse; telling the person responsible for the clinic harms no one.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (A very appropriate thing to do)1
    The aspects are Chloe's dishonesty, the false record and the deadline tomorrow.
    Talking to Chloe directly names the problem, gives her the chance to correct it herself, and points to an honest route while Dr Okafor is still available on the ward.
    It addresses the central aspect of the situation: 'A very appropriate thing to do' means the response addresses at least one aspect of the situation, not necessarily all of them.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so B would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is A: A very appropriate thing to do.
    Why not B: Underrates a direct, honest conversation that gives Chloe the chance to correct the record herself while Dr Okafor is still on the ward.
    Why not C: Mistakes challenging a peer for disloyalty or interference; raising a concern directly with the person involved is the expected first step.
    Why not D: Confuses honesty with hostility; the response makes nothing worse and corrects a false record.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (A very inappropriate thing to do)1
    Even if Chloe did insert the cannula, writing Dr Okafor's signature is dishonest: the logbook claims a doctor confirmed the procedure, and none did.
    Agreeing that it is harmless goes further than staying silent. It reassures Chloe that forging a signature is acceptable, makes it more likely she submits the entry and does it again, and draws Daniel into the dishonesty.
    The response makes the situation worse: 'A very inappropriate thing to do' means the response should definitely not be done and would make the situation worse.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so C would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is D: A very inappropriate thing to do.
    Why not A: Accepts Chloe's account of the cannula as settling things; the problem is that she wrote another person's signature.
    Why not B: Treats agreeing as keeping the peace, missing that it endorses dishonesty and encourages her to do it again.
    Why not C: Underrates the effect; this is not mere silence, it actively tells Chloe that forging a signature is acceptable.
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (A very inappropriate thing to do)1
    Daniel did not observe the cannula, and he is a student, not a supervising doctor, so his signature could not validly confirm it.
    Signing would add a second false statement to the record and involve Daniel in the dishonesty, which is a probity matter for both students.
    The response makes the situation worse: 'A very inappropriate thing to do' means the response should definitely not be done and would make the situation worse.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so C would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is D: A very inappropriate thing to do.
    Why not A: Reads the offer as supportive teamwork; Daniel did not see the procedure, so his signature would be a second false statement.
    Why not B: Treats this as a workable fix, missing that it adds Daniel's own dishonesty to Chloe's.
    Why not C: Underrates the harm; this does not just fail to help, it extends the falsification to a second student.
  9. Question 9

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (A very appropriate thing to do)1
    The timing is what makes this response strong: Daniel raises it only after Chloe has been given the chance to correct the entry herself.
    If she refuses, the falsified record will be submitted tomorrow, and the placement lead is the appropriate person to deal with it. Raising concerns about probity is part of a doctor's duty, and it applies to students too.
    It addresses the integrity aspect directly: 'A very appropriate thing to do' means the response addresses at least one aspect of the situation, not necessarily all of them.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so B would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is A: A very appropriate thing to do.
    Why not B: Treats escalation as a last-resort compromise; once Chloe refuses, escalating is the right step, and it comes after she has had the chance to put it right.
    Why not C: Mistakes escalation for disloyalty; leaving a known falsified record in place would be the poorer choice.
    Why not D: Confuses raising a concern with making things worse; escalation through the placement lead is the proper channel.
  10. Question 10

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Appropriate, but not ideal)1
    Escalating once Chloe refuses to correct the entry is right: a forged signature is a probity concern that should not be left in place.
    Dr Okafor is a reasonable person to tell, because it is his signature, he is on the ward today and he can refuse to stand behind the entry. The shortfall is the channel: the placement handbook says concerns about a student's professionalism go to the placement lead, who is on site, so leaving it only with Dr Okafor relies on him to pass it on.
    So the response could be done and does address the concern, but it is not the best route: 'Appropriate, but not ideal' means the response could be done but is not necessarily a very good thing to do.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so A or C would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is B: Appropriate, but not ideal.
    Why not A: Treats any senior as the right channel; Dr Okafor can act on his own signature, but the handbook names the placement lead, who is on site, as the person for concerns about a student's professionalism, so this is not the ideal person.
    Why not C: Mistakes telling the wrong-but-reasonable senior for something that should not be done; Dr Okafor is directly involved, is on the ward today and can stop the false entry being relied on.
    Why not D: Confuses raising a concern with making things worse; telling the doctor whose signature was used harms no one.
  11. Question 11

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (A very inappropriate thing to do)1
    Mr Hughes has capacity, so decisions about who hears his results are his. Being next of kin does not give his daughter a right to them without his consent.
    He has not even been told the result himself. Disclosing it to his daughter breaches confidentiality and risks him hearing about a possible tumour from her, without the consultant's planned discussion.
    The response makes the situation worse: 'A very inappropriate thing to do' means the response should definitely not be done and would make the situation worse.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so C would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is D: A very inappropriate thing to do.
    Why not A: Assumes next of kin is entitled to results; it gives no legal right to an adult patient's information when he has capacity and has not consented.
    Why not B: Treats disclosure as a kindness, missing that it breaches confidentiality and means Mr Hughes learns about a possible tumour second-hand.
    Why not C: Underrates the harm; this is a breach of confidentiality that also takes the news away from the patient himself.
  12. Question 12

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (A very appropriate thing to do)1
    The aspects are Mr Hughes's confidentiality, his right to hear the result first, and the daughter's understandable worry.
    This response protects confidentiality, explains the reason honestly and gives the daughter a real route to involvement that respects Mr Hughes's choice.
    It addresses more than one aspect of the situation: 'A very appropriate thing to do' means the response addresses at least one aspect of the situation, not necessarily all of them.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so B would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is A: A very appropriate thing to do.
    Why not B: Underrates a response that keeps confidentiality, explains why and offers the daughter a proper route to being involved.
    Why not C: Mistakes declining to share results for unhelpfulness; it is a respectful and correct answer to the daughter.
    Why not D: Confuses refusing disclosure with making things worse; nothing here harms the patient or the relationship.
  13. Question 13

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Appropriate, but not ideal)1
    Refusing to share the result without Mr Hughes's agreement is correct: he has capacity and has not yet been told himself.
    But stopping there leaves a worried relative with nothing: no explanation of how she could be involved, and no offer to ask her father. A better response would add that offer, as the one that suggests asking Mr Hughes when he wakes does.
    So the response is correct and could be done, but it is not ideal: 'Appropriate, but not ideal' means the response could be done but is not necessarily a very good thing to do.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so A or C would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is B: Appropriate, but not ideal.
    Why not A: Rates a bare refusal alongside one that also offers the daughter a route to being involved; this keeps confidentiality but does nothing for her worry.
    Why not C: Mistakes a correct refusal for something that should not be done; protecting the patient's confidentiality is exactly right.
    Why not D: Confuses declining to disclose with making things worse; the patient's confidentiality is kept.
  14. Question 14

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Inappropriate, but not awful)1
    Walking on means no results are disclosed, so Mr Hughes's confidentiality is not breached.
    But it is dismissive of a worried relative, gives no explanation of why she cannot be told, and may leave the daughter asking other staff until someone says something they should not.
    It is a poor response that should not really be chosen, yet it does not actively harm the patient: 'Inappropriate, but not awful' means the response should not really be done but would not be terrible.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so B or D would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is C: Inappropriate, but not awful.
    Why not A: Credits the response with protecting confidentiality, but it does so by brushing the daughter off rather than by explaining.
    Why not B: Treats a curt refusal as acceptable, missing the lack of respect and explanation to a worried relative.
    Why not D: Overstates the harm; no information is disclosed, so the patient's confidentiality is kept, even though the manner is poor.
  15. Question 15

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (A very inappropriate thing to do)1
    Avoiding worry is a kind intention, but the statement is false: the report suggests a possible tumour.
    Lying about a result breaches honesty, which is a core professional duty. It will be found out once the consultant speaks to Mr Hughes, and it will damage the family's trust in the team.
    The response makes the situation worse: 'A very inappropriate thing to do' means the response should definitely not be done and would make the situation worse.
    The real test gives partial credit for a rating one step away from the key, so C would score some marks; the other ratings score nothing.
    So the rating is D: A very inappropriate thing to do.
    Why not A: Sees protecting the daughter from worry as a good aim; the means is a lie about a patient's result.
    Why not B: Treats a reassuring white lie as harmless, missing that it is dishonest and will be exposed tomorrow.
    Why not C: Underrates the harm; dishonesty about a result damages trust in the whole team and misleads the family about a serious finding.

Keep going

More free UCAT practice