Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

UCAT Situational Judgement: Rating importance, set 1

Rating how much one consideration should weigh with a named person deciding what to do: very important, important, of minor importance, or not important at all. Test standard. 15 questions, 15 marks, about 6 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Each scenario is followed by several questions. Answer from the point of view of the person named in the question.
  • Judge each response on its own: more than one response to a scenario can earn the same rating.
  • No medical knowledge is needed.
  1. 11 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Ben when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That Mrs Lindqvist feels light-headed and unsteady and could fall if she is left to walk on her own.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  2. 21 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Ben when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That Dr Ashworth has been known to make sarcastic remarks to students who arrive late.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  3. 31 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Ben when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That other students have described Mrs Lindqvist as difficult and demanding.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  4. 41 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Ben when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That he may miss the first few minutes of the teaching session.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  5. 51 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Ben when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That Dr Ashworth may hold up the start of her session waiting for him unless he lets her know that he has been delayed.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  6. 61 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Chloe when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    Whether she understands the audit's methods well enough to answer questions on them after the talk.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  7. 71 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Chloe when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That presenting the audit as her own would mislead the audience about who did the work.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  8. 81 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Chloe when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    Whether going along with Dr Grant's suggestion would make him more likely to give her a favourable end-of-placement report.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  9. 91 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Chloe when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That Chloe has never given a talk at a regional meeting before, so she would need extra time to prepare.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  10. 101 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Chloe when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    Whether Sam's contribution to the audit would be properly acknowledged.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  11. 111 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Raj when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That covering part of Ellie's section might cost Raj one afternoon of the weekend he had planned to spend visiting his family.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  12. 121 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Raj when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    Ellie's wellbeing and whether she has support while her father is ill.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  13. 131 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Raj when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That Ellie did not help Raj when he fell behind on a different assignment last year.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  14. 141 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Raj when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That the poster is due for assessment in a week.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  15. 151 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Raj when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    Ellie's request that he does not tell the rest of the group about her father.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (Very important)1
    Read the consideration from Ben's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Very important' means something vital to take into account.
    What the situation turns on: an elderly patient who feels light-headed and is walking with a frame is at real risk of falling, and no one else is there to help. Patient safety comes before everything else in clinical practice, and a fall could cause a serious injury.
    So this is the central consideration. Whatever Ben decides about his teaching, he must first make sure she is safe, for example by staying with her and getting her back to the ward and to a nurse.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing B here would still score something, but "Very important" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: very important.
    Why not B: Treats the risk of a fall as relevant but not vital. A patient's immediate physical safety is the one thing Ben cannot leave out of his decision, so it is more than 'important but not vital'.
    Why not C: Treats her safety as optional, something that does not matter whether Ben considers it or not. That reverses the priority: a possible fall is the main reason he has to act at all.
    Why not D: Treats her safety as something to ignore, as if getting to teaching on time came first. Ignoring a patient at risk of falling would make the situation worse, which is the opposite of the right rating.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (Not important at all)1
    Read the consideration from Ben's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Not important at all' means something that should definitely not be taken into account.
    What the situation turns on: this consideration is about Ben avoiding embarrassment, not about the patient or his duties. A chance of a sharp comment from a consultant has nothing to do with whether a patient at risk of falling needs help.
    If Ben let it weigh on his decision, it could push him towards leaving an unsteady patient alone to save face. Self-interest of this kind should definitely not shape a decision about patient safety.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing C here would still score something, but "Not important at all" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: not important at all.
    Why not A: Treats Ben's fear of a remark as vital, which would let personal embarrassment decide whether he helps a patient at risk of falling.
    Why not B: Treats his wish to avoid criticism as important. It is not a proper reason for anything Ben might do here, so giving it weight at all is a mistake.
    Why not C: Treats the remark as harmless to consider. The definition of 'Of minor importance' is something it does not matter whether he weighs; this should definitely not be weighed, because it could only push him towards the wrong choice.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (Not important at all)1
    Read the consideration from Ben's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Not important at all' means something that should definitely not be taken into account.
    What the situation turns on: second-hand gossip about a patient's personality has nothing to do with whether she is at risk of falling now. Every patient is owed the same care and respect whatever others think of her.
    If Ben let her reputation weigh, it could push him towards brushing off a genuine request from an unsteady elderly patient. Prejudging a patient on hearsay should definitely not be taken into account.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing C here would still score something, but "Not important at all" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: not important at all.
    Why not A: Treats gossip about her personality as vital, as if whether a patient is liked could decide whether she gets help when she might fall.
    Why not B: Treats her reputation as important. It tells Ben nothing about her current risk, and letting it shape his response would be unfair to her.
    Why not C: Treats her reputation as harmless to consider. It is not merely optional: weighing it could only bias Ben against helping a patient at risk, so it should definitely not be taken into account.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Of minor importance)1
    Read the consideration from Ben's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Of minor importance' means something that could be taken into account, but it does not matter whether it is considered or not.
    What the situation turns on: Ben's learning matters, and arriving on time is part of being professional, so the teaching session is a fair thing for him to have in mind. But missing a few minutes of one session costs him very little and can be made up.
    Set against a patient who might fall, it should not change what he does. It could be taken into account, but his decision is the same whether he considers it or not, which is exactly the definition of minor importance.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing B or D here would still score something, but "Of minor importance" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is C: of minor importance.
    Why not A: Treats a few minutes of teaching as vital, putting a short delay on the same level as a patient's safety.
    Why not B: Treats the lost minutes as important. They are a real but small cost that does not alter the right course of action, so they are less than important.
    Why not D: Treats his own learning as something he should definitely ignore. It is a legitimate consideration and he may well want to explain his lateness afterwards, so it is not so wrong to think about it that it should be excluded.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Important)1
    Read the consideration from Ben's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Important' means something important but not vital to take into account.
    What the situation turns on: letting the consultant know he is delayed is courteous and professional, and it means the session, and the other students in it, are not held up waiting for him. It is part of handling the situation well.
    But it is not vital: Mrs Lindqvist's safety comes first, and he can explain once she is back with a nurse. A sensible consideration that is not the deciding one is 'important but not vital'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing A or C here would still score something, but "Important" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is B: important.
    Why not A: Treats a message to the consultant as vital. It is good practice, but the decision does not depend on it, and her safety must come first.
    Why not C: Treats keeping the consultant informed as something that barely matters. Being reliable and keeping colleagues informed is part of professional behaviour, so it is more than optional.
    Why not D: Treats telling the consultant as something to ignore. Nothing about it is improper; it is a sensible part of handling the delay.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Important)1
    Read the consideration from Chloe's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Important' means something important but not vital to take into account.
    What the situation turns on: the talk is followed by questions from the audience, and whoever gives it must be able to explain the work accurately and answer those questions without guessing. Chloe joined late, so her grasp of the methods is a fair thing for her to check before she agrees to present.
    But it is not the vital issue. The vital issue is honesty about whose work it is; even a perfect understanding of the methods would not make it right to claim the audit as her own. So this is 'important but not vital'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing A or C here would still score something, but "Important" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is B: important.
    Why not A: Treats her understanding of the methods as the vital issue. It matters, but the central problem is the request to misrepresent who did the work, which no amount of preparation fixes.
    Why not C: Treats her knowledge of the methods as optional. Presenting work she cannot explain risks giving the audience wrong information, so it is more than a minor point.
    Why not D: Treats her understanding as something she should ignore. There is nothing improper about checking she can present the work accurately; it is a sensible part of deciding.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (Very important)1
    Read the consideration from Chloe's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Very important' means something vital to take into account.
    What the situation turns on: Dr Grant is asking Chloe to claim credit for work she did not do. Misrepresenting authorship is dishonest, and honesty and integrity are core professional values in medicine.
    This is the heart of the situation. Whatever she decides, she must not give a false account of who carried out the research, so this consideration is vital.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing B here would still score something, but "Very important" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: very important.
    Why not B: Treats deceiving the audience as important but not vital. Integrity is the issue the whole scenario turns on, so it must be taken into account.
    Why not C: Treats dishonesty about authorship as optional to consider. That would leave her free to misrepresent the work, which is the most serious risk here.
    Why not D: Treats misleading the audience as something she should ignore, which would be agreeing to the deception.
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (Not important at all)1
    Read the consideration from Chloe's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Not important at all' means something that should definitely not be taken into account.
    What the situation turns on: this consideration asks Chloe to weigh a personal reward for agreeing to misrepresent someone else's work. A better report is exactly the kind of incentive that should never influence a decision about honesty.
    Taking it into account could only pull her towards the dishonest option. Whether something is honest does not depend on what she gains from it, so this should definitely not be taken into account.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing C here would still score something, but "Not important at all" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: not important at all.
    Why not A: Treats a favourable report as vital, which would put her own assessment ahead of her integrity and Sam's credit.
    Why not B: Treats the chance of a better report as important. A reward for agreeing to deception is not a legitimate reason, so it deserves no weight at all.
    Why not C: Treats the reward as harmless to consider. It is not neutral: weighing it can only push her towards misrepresenting the work, so it should definitely not be taken into account.
  9. Question 9

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Of minor importance)1
    Read the consideration from Chloe's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Of minor importance' means something that could be taken into account, but it does not matter whether it is considered or not.
    What the situation turns on: being new to presenting at a meeting is a fair practical point. It might affect how much she prepares or whether she asks Dr Grant for support, so it could be taken into account.
    But it has no bearing on the real question, which is honesty about whose work this is and fair credit for Sam. Whether she has presented before makes no difference to what she should do, so it is of minor importance.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing B or D here would still score something, but "Of minor importance" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is C: of minor importance.
    Why not A: Treats her inexperience as vital, as if nerves about presenting could matter as much as being honest about who did the research.
    Why not B: Treats her inexperience as important. It affects only how she prepares, not whether or how she should agree, so it is less than important.
    Why not D: Treats her inexperience as something she should definitely ignore. Thinking about her own readiness to present is not improper; it simply does not change the decision.
  10. Question 10

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (Very important)1
    Read the consideration from Chloe's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Very important' means something vital to take into account.
    What the situation turns on: Sam designed the audit, collected the data and analysed it, and the talk is about his work. Giving fair credit to the people who did the work is a basic part of research integrity and of treating a colleague fairly.
    Chloe could present only if Sam's contribution is clearly acknowledged, ideally with his agreement. This is vital to whatever she decides.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing B here would still score something, but "Very important" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: very important.
    Why not B: Treats fair credit for Sam as important but not vital. Failing to credit him would be the dishonesty at the centre of the scenario, so it is vital.
    Why not C: Treats crediting Sam as optional. Leaving out the person who did the work would wrong him and mislead the audience.
    Why not D: Treats Sam's credit as something to ignore, which is what Dr Grant's suggestion amounts to and is exactly what she should not do.
  11. Question 11

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Of minor importance)1
    Read the consideration from Raj's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Of minor importance' means something that could be taken into account, but it does not matter whether it is considered or not.
    What the situation turns on: Raj's own time and wellbeing are legitimate, and losing one afternoon of a planned weekend is a real but small cost. It is fair for him to be aware of it.
    But it does not decide anything that matters here. Ellie's wellbeing, her confidence and a workable plan for the poster are what should drive his response, and one afternoon of his weekend does not change the right course of action. So it could be considered, but it does not matter whether it is: minor importance.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing B or D here would still score something, but "Of minor importance" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is C: of minor importance.
    Why not A: Treats one afternoon of Raj's weekend as vital, putting a small personal inconvenience on a level with a colleague in a family crisis.
    Why not B: Treats his weekend plans as important. They are a genuine but small cost that does not alter what he should do, so they are less than important.
    Why not D: Treats his own time as something he should definitely ignore. Looking after his own wellbeing and family time is legitimate; it simply does not change the decision.
  12. Question 12

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (Very important)1
    Read the consideration from Raj's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Very important' means something vital to take into account.
    What the situation turns on: a colleague has told Raj she is struggling because her father is seriously ill. Looking out for a peer who is under strain, and making sure she knows where to find support, is part of being a good team member.
    Any response that ignored her wellbeing, for example simply demanding her section, could make things worse for her. So this is vital to take into account.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing B here would still score something, but "Very important" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: very important.
    Why not B: Treats a struggling colleague's wellbeing as important but not vital. Her situation is the reason the group has a problem at all, so it must be taken into account.
    Why not C: Treats her wellbeing as optional to consider, which could lead Raj to respond only to the missing work.
    Why not D: Treats her wellbeing as something to ignore, which would make Raj's response unkind and could make her situation worse.
  13. Question 13

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (Not important at all)1
    Read the consideration from Raj's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Not important at all' means something that should definitely not be taken into account.
    What the situation turns on: what Ellie did or did not do on an unrelated assignment last year has no bearing on her present situation or on the poster. It is an old grievance, not information about what is needed now.
    Letting it shape his response would mean treating a struggling colleague less kindly to settle a score. Holding a grudge should definitely not be taken into account when deciding how to respond.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing C here would still score something, but "Not important at all" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: not important at all.
    Why not A: Treats an old grievance as vital, as if last year's assignment could decide how Raj responds to a colleague in a family crisis now.
    Why not B: Treats the old grievance as important. It is unrelated to the poster and to Ellie's current situation, so it deserves no weight.
    Why not C: Treats the grievance as harmless to consider. Weighing it could only make Raj less supportive out of resentment, so it should definitely not be taken into account.
  14. Question 14

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Important)1
    Read the consideration from Raj's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Important' means something important but not vital to take into account.
    What the situation turns on: the deadline is real and four people's marks depend on the poster, so a plan for finishing it is a fair part of Raj's thinking.
    But the scenario says the module guide lets a group ask for a short extension when a member has serious family circumstances, and that such requests are usually granted, so the date is not fixed in stone. It matters to the plan without being something everything else must give way to, which is 'important but not vital'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing A or C here would still score something, but "Important" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is B: important.
    Why not A: Treats the deadline as vital. The module guide allows a short extension for exactly this kind of family circumstance, and such requests are usually granted, so the date can move and does not have to override Ellie's situation.
    Why not C: Treats the deadline as optional. Three other people's assessment also depends on the poster, so planning around the date is more than a minor point.
    Why not D: Treats the deadline as something to ignore. Planning to meet, or properly extend, a shared commitment is a legitimate and sensible part of his decision.
  15. Question 15

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (Very important)1
    Read the consideration from Raj's point of view and ask how much it should weigh in the decision. 'Very important' means something vital to take into account.
    What the situation turns on: Ellie shared something personal and asked Raj to keep it private. Respecting a confidence builds trust, and her family's illness is her information to share, not his.
    Raj can still help, for example by encouraging her to tell the group or a tutor whatever she is comfortable with, or by explaining only that she needs support with her section. Breaking her confidence could damage her trust and make things worse, so this is vital to take into account.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, so choosing B here would still score something, but "Very important" is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: very important.
    Why not B: Treats her request for privacy as important but not vital. Breaking a confidence about a family illness could do real harm, so it must be taken into account.
    Why not C: Treats her request as optional. Ignoring it could lead Raj to share her private situation with the group, which would let her down.
    Why not D: Treats her request as something to ignore, which would mean telling others about her father against her wishes.

Keep going

More free UCAT practice