Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
University Admissions
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

UCAT Situational Judgement: Rating importance, set 2

Rating how much one consideration should weigh with a named person deciding what to do: very important, important, of minor importance, or not important at all. Demanding. 15 questions, 15 marks, about 6 minutes.

Download the questions (PDF) Download with worked solutions (PDF)

  • Each scenario is followed by several questions. Answer from the point of view of the person named in the question.
  • Judge each response on its own: more than one response to a scenario can earn the same rating.
  • No medical knowledge is needed.
  1. 11 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Aisha when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That Ms Carter is likely to feel upset when she learns that her request for secrecy cannot be met.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  2. 21 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Aisha when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That the cuts suggest Ms Carter's safety may be at risk, which the team caring for her needs to know.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  3. 31 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Aisha when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That raising the disclosure with Dr Hughes might earn Aisha credit as a perceptive student.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  4. 41 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Aisha when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That any promise Aisha makes to Ms Carter must be one she is able to keep.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  5. 51 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Aisha when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That Dr Hughes is busy with another patient for about the next ten minutes.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  6. 61 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Ben when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That patients could be harmed if Dr Price makes decisions or operates while impaired.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  7. 71 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Ben when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That Ben is a student and Dr Price is a senior doctor in the team he is working under.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  8. 81 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Ben when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That Dr Price is well liked by the nursing staff.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  9. 91 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Ben when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That Dr Price will be writing Ben's end-of-placement report next week.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  10. 101 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Ben when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That the ward round is done at the bedside, where patients and nurses can hear what is said.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  11. 111 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Tomasz when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    The hospital's written policy on accepting gifts.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  12. 121 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Tomasz when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That the cash would help pay for Tomasz's flight home.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  13. 131 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Tomasz when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That Dr Osei is off site today and will not be back until tomorrow morning.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  14. 141 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Tomasz when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That the family's gratitude is sincere and should be acknowledged kindly when he declines the money.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all
  15. 151 mark

    How important to take into account are the following considerations for Tomasz when deciding how to respond to the situation?

    That accepting a large cash gift could look like payment for care and weaken trust in the hospital's staff.

    1. A Very important
    2. B Important
    3. C Of minor importance
    4. D Not important at all

Worked solutions

Each solution below shows the working. The official material for this test gives only the correct option letter.

  1. Question 1

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Important)1
    This consideration is about Ms Carter's feelings: she has asked for secrecy and will probably be upset to hear that Aisha cannot promise it.
    Against the principles: Her feelings matter to how Aisha responds: she should explain kindly why she cannot keep it secret, who will be told and that the aim is to help, so that Ms Carter keeps trusting the team. They do not decide whether the information is shared, because the cuts are a risk to her safety that the team caring for her needs to know about. So her likely upset shapes the manner of the response, not the decision itself.
    Against the definitions: 'Important' means something important but not vital to take into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Important'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Important' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is B: important.
    Why not A: Treats her upset as decisive. If it were vital, avoiding it could justify keeping the secret, but her safety has to come first; her feelings affect how Aisha explains, not whether she shares.
    Why not C: Undervalues the patient's feelings. Ignoring how she will react risks handling the conversation badly and losing her trust, so it clearly matters to the response rather than being optional.
    Why not D: Treats her feelings as something that should be ignored. Respect for the patient makes them a legitimate thing to weigh, even though they cannot override safety.
  2. Question 2

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (Very important)1
    This consideration is the risk to the patient: recent and increasing self-harm in a woman currently under the ward team's care.
    Against the principles: Patient safety comes first. Self-harm that has become more frequent is a risk the clinical team must know about so they can assess her and offer support, and a student cannot carry that risk alone. This is the central reason Aisha cannot simply keep the disclosure to herself, and it should be at the heart of her decision.
    Against the definitions: 'Very important' means something vital to take into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Very important'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Very important' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: very important.
    Why not B: Weighs safety as one factor among several. Here it is the factor that decides what Aisha must do, so it is vital, not merely important.
    Why not C: Is misled by Ms Carter saying she has no plans to end her life. That statement does not remove the risk of further self-harm or the team's need to know about it.
    Why not D: Treats Ms Carter's request for secrecy as overriding her safety. A risk to a patient is never something to leave out of the decision.
  3. Question 3

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (Not important at all)1
    This consideration is about what Aisha herself might gain from passing the information on.
    Against the principles: Whether to share a patient's disclosure must be decided by the patient's safety and interests, and by honesty. Letting the hope of impressing a supervisor influence how she handles a vulnerable patient's confidence would be acting from self-interest, and could push her to share it carelessly or for the wrong reasons.
    Against the definitions: 'Not important at all' means something that should definitely not be taken into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Not important at all'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Not important at all' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: not important at all.
    Why not A: Confuses the right outcome with the right reason. Aisha should tell Dr Hughes, but because of the risk to Ms Carter, not to gain credit.
    Why not B: Treats her own assessment as a fair thing to weigh. Personal advantage has no legitimate place in a decision about a patient's confidence.
    Why not C: Treats self-interest as harmless background. It is not neutral: it should definitely be left out, because it could distort how she treats the patient.
  4. Question 4

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (Very important)1
    This consideration is about honesty: Ms Carter has asked for a promise of secrecy that Aisha may not be able to honour.
    Against the principles: Aisha cannot keep a disclosure of self-harm from the team, so promising to do so would mean either breaking the promise or putting the patient at risk. Being honest at once, explaining that she cannot promise secrecy and why, protects trust and avoids a later betrayal. Honesty with patients is a core duty, so this should shape what she says next.
    Against the definitions: 'Very important' means something vital to take into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Very important'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Very important' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: very important.
    Why not B: Underrates honesty. A false promise here would almost certainly be broken, damaging Ms Carter's trust in the whole team, so it is vital to weigh.
    Why not C: Treats the promise as a small courtesy. Whether Aisha misleads a vulnerable patient is a core matter of integrity, not something optional.
    Why not D: Assumes Aisha should simply give the reassurance asked for. Making a promise she cannot keep would be dishonest and would make things worse.
  5. Question 5

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Of minor importance)1
    This consideration is a practical one about when Aisha can reach her supervisor.
    Against the principles: Ms Carter has said she has no plans to end her life, she is staying on the ward for at least two more days and her nurse is in the bay, so a ten-minute wait before Aisha speaks to Dr Hughes changes nothing about what she should do: she still responds honestly to Ms Carter and still tells Dr Hughes. Aisha could reasonably bear the timing in mind when planning the next few minutes, and there is nothing improper in doing so, but whether she considers it or not makes no difference to the right response.
    Against the definitions: 'Of minor importance' means something that could be taken into account, but it does not matter whether it is considered or not. That is why this consideration is rated 'Of minor importance'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Of minor importance' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is C: of minor importance.
    Why not A: Treats a ten-minute wait as vital. Nothing in the scenario suggests the risk is so immediate that those minutes decide the outcome.
    Why not B: Gives the timing real weight. Aisha does the same things whether Dr Hughes is free now or in ten minutes, so the decision does not depend on it.
    Why not D: Treats a neutral practical fact as something that must be ignored. Unlike a self-interested motive, noting when her supervisor is free could not lead her astray; it simply makes little difference.
  6. Question 6

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (Very important)1
    This consideration is the risk to patients on the ward round and on the theatre list if Dr Price is under the influence of alcohol.
    Against the principles: Patient safety comes first. A surgeon who may be impaired is about to make clinical decisions and then operate, so the possible harm is serious and immediate. This is the reason Ben must raise his concern promptly with someone senior who can act, such as Mr Shah, rather than wait.
    Against the definitions: 'Very important' means something vital to take into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Very important'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Very important' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: very important.
    Why not B: Treats a serious and immediate risk to patients as one factor among several. It is the factor that makes acting now necessary, so it is vital.
    Why not C: Assumes the risk is small because Dr Price is only slightly unsteady. Even mild impairment matters in surgery, and the consequences of being wrong fall on patients.
    Why not D: Sees the risk as Dr Price's responsibility rather than Ben's. Anyone in the team who notices a risk to patients should take it into account and raise it.
  7. Question 7

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Important)1
    This consideration is about the difference in seniority between Ben and the person he is worried about.
    Against the principles: The hierarchy matters to how Ben acts: it is not his place to stop a registrar operating or to confront him about drinking, so the right course is to take what he observed to someone with authority, such as Mr Shah. It is also a pressure Ben needs to recognise so that it does not silence him. It is not vital, because the duty to raise a risk to patients applies whatever the seniority of the person involved; the hierarchy changes the route, not whether he speaks up.
    Against the definitions: 'Important' means something important but not vital to take into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Important'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Important' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is B: important.
    Why not A: Treats seniority as the deciding factor. If it were vital it could justify deferring to Dr Price and saying nothing, but patient safety outranks any hierarchy.
    Why not C: Undervalues the hierarchy. Whether Ben acts himself or goes through a senior is a real difference in what he should do, so it is more than optional background.
    Why not D: Treats the difference in seniority as something to ignore. Recognising his position as a student is proper; it shows him the appropriate way to raise the concern.
  8. Question 8

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (Not important at all)1
    This consideration is about how popular Dr Price is with colleagues.
    Against the principles: Whether a doctor is liked has no bearing on whether patients are at risk if he operates while impaired. Letting popularity weigh in the decision could only push Ben towards staying silent to avoid upsetting people, which is the wrong reason. A safety concern must be judged on what Ben observed, not on who it is about.
    Against the definitions: 'Not important at all' means something that should definitely not be taken into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Not important at all'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Not important at all' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: not important at all.
    Why not A: Treats Dr Price's popularity as decisive. That would let social pressure outweigh patients' safety.
    Why not B: Accepts popularity as a fair factor. How much colleagues like someone should never shape whether a safety concern about them is raised.
    Why not C: Treats popularity as harmless background. It is not neutral: it is the kind of pressure that stops people speaking up, so it should definitely be left out.
  9. Question 9

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (Not important at all)1
    This consideration is about how raising the concern might affect Ben's own assessment.
    Against the principles: Fear for his report is a self-interested reason that could tempt Ben to stay silent while patients are put at risk. A decision about patient safety should be made on the facts of the risk, not on its possible consequences for the student raising it. Ben should definitely not let this influence him.
    Against the definitions: 'Not important at all' means something that should definitely not be taken into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Not important at all'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Not important at all' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: not important at all.
    Why not A: Treats Ben's report as vital. Allowing it to shape the decision would put his own interests ahead of patients' safety.
    Why not B: Accepts self-interest as a fair thing to weigh. Concern about a report should never be part of deciding whether to raise a safety concern.
    Why not C: Treats the report as harmless background. It is not neutral: it is exactly the kind of pressure that leads people not to speak up, so it should be left out.
  10. Question 10

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Important)1
    This consideration is a fact about the setting: anything Ben says on the ward round will be heard by patients and nurses.
    Against the principles: It matters to how Ben acts: raising the concern there would alarm patients, humiliate Dr Price in public and could be unfair if Ben is mistaken, so he should step away and speak to Mr Shah privately. It is not vital, because the overriding point is that the concern reaches someone who can act before Dr Price operates; the setting decides where and how Ben raises it, not whether he does.
    Against the definitions: 'Important' means something important but not vital to take into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Important'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Important' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is B: important.
    Why not A: Treats the setting as decisive. If it were vital it could justify waiting until there is no audience, which might be after Dr Price has operated.
    Why not C: Undervalues the setting. Raising the concern in front of patients would cause real alarm and embarrassment, so where Ben speaks genuinely matters.
    Why not D: Treats the setting as irrelevant. Respect for patients and for a colleague's dignity makes it proper to consider who will overhear.
  11. Question 11

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (Very important)1
    This consideration is the hospital's own rule, which Tomasz signed: cards and food may be accepted, money may not, and any gift offered must be reported to Dr Osei.
    Against the principles: As a guest student Tomasz must follow the rules of the hospital he is working in. The policy tells him directly what to do: accept the card, decline the cash and tell his supervisor. It is the central fact in his decision.
    Against the definitions: 'Very important' means something vital to take into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Very important'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Very important' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: very important.
    Why not B: Treats a rule Tomasz has signed as one factor to weigh. It answers the question directly, so it is vital, not just important.
    Why not C: Assumes a short elective places him outside the hospital's rules. He signed the policy and is bound by it for every day he is there.
    Why not D: Treats local rules as irrelevant to a visiting student. Following the policies of the place he works is a basic professional duty.
  12. Question 12

    Answer or workingMarks
    D (Not important at all)1
    This consideration is about the financial benefit to Tomasz himself.
    Against the principles: His personal finances have no place in deciding whether to accept money from a patient's family, especially when the policy forbids it. Letting his own need influence him would be acting from self-interest and would risk his integrity.
    Against the definitions: 'Not important at all' means something that should definitely not be taken into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Not important at all'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Not important at all' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is D: not important at all.
    Why not A: Treats personal gain as the vital factor. That would put his own interests ahead of the hospital's policy and the trust placed in staff.
    Why not B: Accepts self-interest as a fair consideration. His travel costs should not enter a decision about accepting a gift from a patient's family.
    Why not C: Treats the benefit as harmless background. It should definitely be left out, because it pulls him towards accepting what he must refuse.
  13. Question 13

    Answer or workingMarks
    C (Of minor importance)1
    This consideration is about when Tomasz can tell his supervisor about the gift.
    Against the principles: The policy already tells Tomasz what to do now: accept the card and decline the money. The policy gives him a week to tell Dr Osei, so telling her tomorrow morning rather than today changes nothing about that decision or its outcome. Tomasz could reasonably note it when planning when to report the offer, and there is nothing improper in doing so, but whether he considers it or not makes no difference.
    Against the definitions: 'Of minor importance' means something that could be taken into account, but it does not matter whether it is considered or not. That is why this consideration is rated 'Of minor importance'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Of minor importance' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is C: of minor importance.
    Why not A: Treats the supervisor's absence as vital. Tomasz does not need Dr Osei present to decline money the policy already forbids.
    Why not B: Gives the timing real weight. The policy allows a week to report the offer, so Dr Osei's absence only affects which day he reports it, not what he does with the gift.
    Why not D: Treats a neutral practical fact as something that must be ignored. Unlike personal gain, knowing when his supervisor is back could not lead him astray; it simply makes little difference.
  14. Question 14

    Answer or workingMarks
    B (Important)1
    This consideration is about the family's feelings and the risk that a refusal seems ungrateful.
    Against the principles: Respect for the family matters: Tomasz should thank them warmly, accept the card and explain that the hospital does not allow staff to take money, so that they do not feel rejected. It does not change the decision itself, because the policy forbids accepting money whatever the family feel. So it is important to how he responds, but not vital.
    Against the definitions: 'Important' means something important but not vital to take into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Important'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Important' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is B: important.
    Why not A: Lets the family's feelings decide the matter. If they were vital they could justify accepting the money to avoid hurting them, which the policy forbids.
    Why not C: Undervalues the family's feelings. A cold refusal could hurt a grateful family, so care in how he declines genuinely matters.
    Why not D: Treats the family's feelings as something to ignore. Showing respect and kindness to patients and relatives is part of good practice.
  15. Question 15

    Answer or workingMarks
    A (Very important)1
    This consideration is about why rules on gifts exist: money from patients can make care look as if it depends on payment.
    Against the principles: Patients and families must be able to trust that the care they receive does not depend on what they give. A large cash gift, unlike a card, could give that impression to others and could make staff feel obliged to some patients over others. Protecting that trust is central to Tomasz's integrity as a future doctor.
    Against the definitions: 'Very important' means something vital to take into account. That is why this consideration is rated 'Very important'.
    In the real test a rating one step away from the keyed one earns partial credit, but 'Very important' is the full-mark answer.
    The answer is A: very important.
    Why not B: Treats public trust as a secondary factor. It is the core reason money must be refused, so it is vital.
    Why not C: Assumes no one would see or mind because the patient is going home. The principle applies whether or not anyone finds out.
    Why not D: Assumes gratitude after care is complete cannot raise concerns. Accepting money still affects how care at the hospital is seen, so it should definitely be weighed.

Keep going

More free UCAT practice