GCSE Religious Studies Essentials 3 includes Revelation (Theme C: The Existence of God and Revelation); Religious Upbringing and Its Influence on Belief in God (Theme C: The Existence of God and Revelation); The Influence of Science on Belief in the Existence of God (Theme C: The Existence of God and Revelation); Solutions to the Problem of Evil and Suffering (Theme C: The Existence of God and Revelation); Visions as a Source of Knowledge of God (Theme C: The Existence of God and Revelation); The Nature and Importance of Dreams as a Source of Knowledge of God (Theme C: The Existence of God and Revelation); Atheism, Agnosticism and the Nature of Non-Belief (Theme C: The Existence of God and Revelation); The Causes of War (Theme D: Religion, Peace and Conflict); Just War Theory and Holy War (Theme D: Religion, Peace and Conflict); Pacifism and Peacemaking (Theme D: Religion, Peace and Conflict); Weapons of Mass Destruction (Theme D: Religion, Peace and Conflict); Religion and Terrorism (Theme D: Religion, Peace and Conflict); The Victims of War (Theme D: Religion, Peace and Conflict); Reasons for Peace: Justice, Freedom and the Protection of the Innocent (Theme D: Religion, Peace and Conflict); Religious Organisations Working for Peace: Case Studies in Peacemaking (Theme D: Religion, Peace and Conflict); Nuclear Deterrence and the Disarmament Debate (Theme D: Religion, Peace and Conflict); The Just War Theory and the Treatment of Prisoners (Theme D: Religion, Peace and Conflict); Refugees and the Plight of Civilians Displaced by War (Theme D: Religion, Peace and Conflict); Religious and Non-Religious Perspectives on Reconciliation After Conflict (Theme D: Religion, Peace and Conflict); Religion and the Causes of Crime (Theme E: Religion, Crime and Punishment); The Aims of Punishment (Theme E: Religion, Crime and Punishment); Treatment of Criminals: Prison and Community Sentences (Theme E: Religion, Crime and Punishment); Forgiveness (Theme E: Religion, Crime and Punishment); Suffering Caused and Relieved by Punishment (Theme E: Religion, Crime and Punishment); The Death Penalty (Theme E: Religion, Crime and Punishment); Corporal Punishment: Religious Arguments For and Against (Theme E: Religion, Crime and Punishment); Islamic Criminal Justice: Shariah, Hudud, Qisas and Diyya (Theme E: Religion, Crime and Punishment); Sin, Temptation and Human Responsibility for Wrongdoing (Theme E: Religion, Crime and Punishment); Restorative Justice: Religious Rehabilitation Schemes for Offenders (Theme E: Religion, Crime and Punishment); Human Rights and Responsibilities (Theme F: Religion, Human Rights and Social Justice); Prejudice and Discrimination (Theme F: Religion, Human Rights and Social Justice); Religious Freedom (Theme F: Religion, Human Rights and Social Justice); Wealth and Poverty (Theme F: Religion, Human Rights and Social Justice); Attitudes to Money and the Exploitation of the Poor (Theme F: Religion, Human Rights and Social Justice); Charity (Theme F: Religion, Human Rights and Social Justice); Racial Harmony and Martin Luther King as a Case Study in Religious Action (Theme F: Religion, Human Rights and Social Justice); Human Rights Law: The UN Declaration and the Human Rights Act 1998 (Theme F: Religion, Human Rights and Social Justice); Causes and Effects of Poverty in the Developing World (Theme F: Religion, Human Rights and Social Justice); Trade Justice and Fair Trade Campaigns (Theme F: Religion, Human Rights and Social Justice).
Method recap - Weapons of Mass Destruction
- Learn the definition of a weapon of mass destruction and its three main categories (nuclear, chemical, biological), with no technical detail.
- Learn key vocabulary: deterrence, indiscriminate, disarmament.
- Learn religious teachings on the sanctity of human life and how they apply to the ethics of these weapons.
- Learn the main arguments for and against deterrence as a strategy for safety.
Worked example - Weapons of Mass Destruction
A newspaper headline claims a proposed weapon can 'target only military bases with no risk to nearby towns.' Using the definition of a weapon of mass destruction, explain whether this weapon, if the claim were true, would count as a weapon of mass destruction, and why.
- Recall the definition: a weapon of mass destruction causes large-scale, indiscriminate destruction, unable to distinguish combatants from civilians.
- Compare the headline's claim, that it targets only military bases with no risk to nearby towns, against this definition.
- Note that the claim describes a weapon able to discriminate between military and civilian targets.
- Conclude that, if the claim were true, the weapon would not meet the 'indiscriminate' part of the definition.
- Final answer: no, by definition a weapon of mass destruction is indiscriminate, so a genuinely precise weapon as described would not count as one, though many would be sceptical that such precision is realistic in practice.
Question 7 - Weapons of Mass Destruction
5 marks
A disarmament treaty requires two countries to each reduce their stockpile of a banned weapon type by an equal percentage. Country A holds 800 units and Country B holds 500 units. If both agree to cut their stockpiles by 25 percent, calculate how many units each country would have left, and explain one reason critics might argue that equal percentage cuts do not necessarily make the world safer.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 7 [5 marks]| Question 7[5 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| Country A left with 800 multiplied by 0.75, giving 600 units | 1 |
| Country B left with 500 multiplied by 0.75, giving 375 units | 1 |
| identifies that a 25 percent cut still leaves an unequal gap between the two countries, 225 units apart | 1 |
| explains that critics could argue percentage-based cuts leave the already larger stockpile still much bigger in real numbers, so relative fairness does not guarantee genuinely equal safety | 1 |
| notes that how disarmament is measured, by percentage or by absolute numbers, can itself be a source of disagreement between countries | 1 |
Question 8 - Weapons of Mass Destruction
6 marks
Justify the view that a country's decision to keep weapons of mass destruction purely for deterrence, with no intention of ever using them, can be treated differently, morally, from a decision to use them.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [6 marks]| Question 8[6 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| distinguishes between possession, holding a weapon in reserve, and use, actually deploying it to kill | 1 |
| argues that intending never to use a weapon changes its moral status, since a weapon never fired causes no direct harm to anyone | 1 |
| supports this with the just war idea of proportionality, under which avoiding a larger, more destructive war can justify holding weapons that would themselves be disproportionate to use | 1 |
| notes the objection that possession still carries the ever-present risk of accident, miscalculation or eventual use, so the moral distinction is not absolute | 1 |
| recognises that some pacifist-influenced believers reject the distinction altogether, holding that keeping a weapon that could never be used justly is itself already wrong | 1 |
| reaches a supported judgement about how much weight the possession-versus-use distinction can really bear | 1 |
Method recap - Religion and Terrorism
- Learn the definition of terrorism and how it differs from a legitimate armed conflict.
- Learn why terrorism fails the just war criteria of discrimination between combatants and civilians, and legitimate authority.
- Learn the two meanings of jihad, and why many Muslims give most weight to the inner, spiritual struggle.
- Learn mainstream religious teachings, each with an accurately cited source, that reject terrorism.
Question 8 - Religion and Terrorism
8 marks
Compare the reasons mainstream religious scholars give for rejecting terrorism with the reasons Humanists give for rejecting terrorism, and reach a justified conclusion about which set of reasons you find more persuasive.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [8 marks]| Question 8[8 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| mainstream religious scholars reject terrorism because it deliberately targets non-combatants and lacks legitimate authority, both breaching principles most traditions treat as fundamental | 1 |
| supports this with the seriousness given to taking one innocent life, for example 'whoever kills a soul... it is as if he had slain mankind entirely' (Qur'an 5:32) | 1 |
| Humanists reject terrorism on entirely secular grounds, arguing that deliberately harming people who have done nothing to deserve it violates the principle that everyone's wellbeing matters equally | 1 |
| notes that this Humanist reasoning does not depend on any scripture or religious authority, resting instead on reason and empathy | 1 |
| compares the two approaches: both reach the same practical conclusion, that terrorism is wrong, but by different routes | 1 |
| notes that having two independent routes to the same conclusion could be seen as making the overall moral case against terrorism stronger, not weaker | 1 |
| reaches a supported judgement about which set of reasons is found more persuasive, with a reason given | 1 |
| shows accurate understanding of both religious and non-religious positions without conflating them | 1 |
Question 7 - Religion and Terrorism
5 marks
A charity that supports people leaving extremist groups reports that, of 80 people it worked with last year, 52 said a sense of social exclusion had been a bigger factor in their journey towards extremism than religious belief. (a) Calculate what percentage of the 80 people this represents. (b) Using this figure, explain one way this data supports the view that non-religious, social causes can be more significant than religious belief in individual cases of radicalisation.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 7 [5 marks]| Question 7[5 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| correct method shown, 52 divided by 80 multiplied by 100 | 1 |
| result is 65 percent | 1 |
| 65 percent is a clear majority of the people in this illustrative sample | 1 |
| this supports the view that, in many individual cases, social exclusion may weigh more heavily than religious belief in someone's path towards extremism | 1 |
| notes an appropriate limitation, for example that this is a small, single-charity sample and may not represent the causes of terrorism in general | 1 |