A Level Religious Studies flashcards
Arguments for God, evil, religious language and experience, ethics and Christian thought. 70 cards across 8 topics, each with its answer.
Arguments for the Existence of God
- 1
What is the basic structure of a cosmological argument for God's existence?
Answer: It argues from a feature of the universe (motion, causation or contingency) to God as the necessary first cause or explanation of that feature.
- 2
What is Aquinas' First Way, the argument from motion?
Answer: Things in the universe are in motion (change); nothing moves itself, so each mover is moved by another; this cannot regress infinitely, so there must be an unmoved mover, which Aquinas calls God.
Worked example: A stick moves a stone only because a hand moves the stick; trace the chain of movers back and it cannot go on forever.
- 3
What is Aquinas' Second Way, the argument from causation?
Answer: Nothing causes itself; every effect has a prior cause; an infinite regress of causes is impossible, so there must be an uncaused first cause, which is God.
- 4
What is Aquinas' Third Way, the argument from contingency?
Answer: Everything in the universe is contingent, meaning it could fail to exist; if everything were contingent, at some point nothing would exist; so there must be a necessary being that grounds all contingent things.
- 5
What is Leibniz's Principle of Sufficient Reason, applied to the cosmological argument?
Answer: Everything that exists must have a reason or explanation for its existence; since the universe as a whole needs an explanation, that explanation is a necessary being, God.
- 6
What is the teleological, or design, argument for God's existence?
Answer: It argues that the order, purpose and apparent design in the universe are best explained by an intelligent designer, God, rather than by chance.
- 7
What is Paley's watch analogy?
Answer: Finding a watch on a heath implies a watchmaker, because its parts work together for a purpose; the universe shows the same complexity and purpose, so it implies a divine designer.
Worked example: Paley pointed to the intricate, mutually adjusted parts of the eye as evidence of the same kind of purposeful design.
- 8
Give three of Hume's criticisms of the design argument.
Answer: The universe may result from chance operating over infinite time; the analogy between a machine and the universe is weak; and any designer inferred need not be all-good or all-powerful, only competent enough.
- 9
What is the ontological argument, in outline, and who first proposed it?
Answer: Anselm's a priori argument: God is defined as 'that than which nothing greater can be conceived'; a being that exists is greater than one that does not, so God must exist, or the definition is contradicted.
The Problem of Evil
- 1
What is the logical problem of evil?
Answer: The claim that the existence of evil is logically inconsistent with an omnipotent, omniscient and omnibenevolent God; if such a God existed, evil could not.
- 2
What is the evidential problem of evil?
Answer: The claim that the amount and severity of evil in the world counts as strong evidence against the probability of God's existence, even if it is not a strict logical contradiction.
- 3
State Mackie's inconsistent triad.
Answer: God is omnipotent; God is omnibenevolent; evil exists. Mackie argued that at most two of these three claims can be true together.
- 4
Distinguish moral evil from natural evil.
Answer: Moral evil results from human free choices, such as cruelty or violence; natural evil arises from the natural world itself, such as disease, earthquakes and famine.
- 5
Outline Augustine's theodicy.
Answer: Evil is not a substance but a privation, an absence of good; a perfect world was corrupted by the misuse of free will at the Fall, so God is not the author of evil.
- 6
Outline the soul-making theodicy of Irenaeus, as developed by John Hick.
Answer: The world was made imperfect on purpose, as a place of 'soul-making'; humans develop moral virtue and character by facing and overcoming genuine evil and suffering.
- 7
Give one criticism of Augustine's theodicy.
Answer: Schleiermacher argued it is contradictory to claim a wholly good, perfect world produced the first sin, since perfection should not be able to generate imperfection.
- 8
Give one criticism of the soul-making theodicy.
Answer: Suffering is often disproportionate and pointless, such as a child's suffering with no chance to develop virtue from it, which undermines the claim that all evil serves moral development.
Religious Language
- 1
What is the difference between cognitivism and non-cognitivism about religious language?
Answer: Cognitivists hold that religious statements express factual claims that are true or false; non-cognitivists hold that they express attitudes, commitments or feelings rather than facts.
- 2
State the verification principle associated with the Vienna Circle and A. J. Ayer.
Answer: A statement is meaningful only if it can be verified empirically, or is analytically true; since religious claims cannot be empirically verified, Ayer held they are meaningless.
- 3
What is Antony Flew's falsification challenge to religious language?
Answer: For a statement to be meaningful, some possible evidence must count against it; Flew argued believers let nothing count against 'God loves us', so it dies 'the death by a thousand qualifications'.
- 4
What is R. M. Hare's response to Flew, using the idea of a blik?
Answer: A blik is an unfalsifiable but genuine way of interpreting the world; religious belief is a blik that shapes how a believer sees events, and remains meaningful even though unfalsifiable.
- 5
What is John Hick's concept of eschatological verification?
Answer: Religious claims cannot be verified in this life, but could in principle be verified after death; Hick's parable of the Celestial City shows two travellers who only learn who was right on arrival.
- 6
Distinguish univocal and equivocal language about God, and explain Aquinas' alternative of analogy.
Answer: Univocal language uses a word in exactly the same sense of God and humans; equivocal language uses it in totally different senses. Aquinas proposed analogy: words apply to God proportionately, in a related but not identical sense.
- 7
What is Wittgenstein's 'language games' approach to religious language?
Answer: Language has meaning within the rules and context of its own 'game'; religious language is meaningful within the practice of religion, and should not be judged by the rules of science.
Religious Experience
- 1
What is a religious experience?
Answer: A non-ordinary experience felt by the subject to be an encounter with, or awareness of, a transcendent reality such as God, often bringing a sense of the sacred.
- 2
Name William James' four features of a genuine mystical experience.
Answer: Ineffability, meaning words cannot fully capture it; noetic quality, meaning it feels like real knowledge; transiency, meaning it is brief; and passivity, meaning it happens to the subject.
- 3
What does Rudolf Otto mean by the numinous and the phrase mysterium tremendum et fascinans?
Answer: The numinous is the overwhelming sense of a 'wholly other' holy presence; mysterium tremendum et fascinans describes a mystery that is at once terrifying and fascinating.
- 4
Give three types of religious experience studied in this topic.
Answer: Mystical experience, a direct sense of union with God; conversion experience, a sudden change of belief such as Paul on the road to Damascus; and corporate experience, shared by a group during worship.
- 5
Outline Swinburne's principles of credulity and testimony.
Answer: The principle of credulity says we should believe things are as they seem unless we have good reason not to; the principle of testimony says we should trust others' reports of experience unless we have reason to doubt them.
- 6
Give one psychological criticism of religious experience.
Answer: Freud argued religious experience is a form of wish fulfilment, an illusion produced by unconscious longing for a protective father figure, rather than genuine contact with God.
- 7
What is meant by the 'fruits' of a religious experience as a test of its authenticity?
Answer: William James argued a genuine religious experience should be judged partly by its lasting effects, that is, whether it produces a positive, lasting moral change in the person's life.
Natural Law and Situation Ethics
- 1
What is Natural Law ethics, as developed by Aquinas?
Answer: An absolutist, deontological theory holding that God built a rational moral order into nature; humans can discover right and wrong through reason by reflecting on nature's purposes.
- 2
Name Aquinas' four tiers of law.
Answer: Eternal law, existing in God's mind; divine law, revealed in scripture; natural law, discovered through reason; and human law, made by the state, which should reflect natural law.
- 3
What are Aquinas' primary precepts of Natural Law, and how do secondary precepts relate to them?
Answer: The primary precepts are basic goods reason identifies from human nature: preserve life, reproduce and educate the young, live in society and worship God. Secondary precepts, such as do not murder, are specific rules derived by applying reason to these.
- 4
What is the doctrine of double effect in Natural Law ethics?
Answer: An act with a bad side effect can be permissible if the act itself is good, the bad effect is not the means to the good one, and the bad effect is foreseen but not intended.
Worked example: Giving pain relief that hastens death is permitted if the intended effect is easing pain, not causing death.
- 5
Give one criticism of Natural Law ethics.
Answer: It relies on a fixed view of human nature and purpose that many now reject; a purpose-based ethic looks weaker once evolutionary biology explains nature without appeal to design.
- 6
What is Situation Ethics, as developed by Joseph Fletcher?
Answer: A relativist, teleological Christian ethic holding that the only intrinsic good is agape, selfless love; the most loving act in each situation is the right one, whatever a fixed rule would say.
- 7
Name Fletcher's four working principles of Situation Ethics.
Answer: Pragmatism, meaning an act must work in practice; relativism, meaning it rejects fixed rules; positivism, meaning agape is chosen as the starting value by faith; and personalism, meaning people come before laws.
- 8
Give one criticism of Situation Ethics.
Answer: It gives too little guidance in advance of an act, since 'do the most loving thing' can be used to justify almost any action once the situation is described in a particular way.
Kantian Ethics, Utilitarianism and Virtue Ethics
- 1
What is Kantian ethics, in outline?
Answer: An absolutist, deontological theory holding that moral duty is discovered by reason alone; an act is right only if it is done from duty, in line with the categorical imperative.
- 2
State the universal law formulation of Kant's categorical imperative.
Answer: Act only according to a maxim you could, at the same time, will to become a universal law; if the maxim cannot be universalised without contradiction, the act is wrong.
Worked example: Lying fails the test: if everyone universally lied whenever convenient, the practice of trusting promises would collapse, making the original lie impossible.
- 3
State the 'humanity as an end' formulation of Kant's categorical imperative.
Answer: Always treat humanity, whether in yourself or in another, as an end in itself, and never merely as a means to an end.
- 4
Distinguish a hypothetical imperative from a categorical imperative.
Answer: A hypothetical imperative commands conditionally, in the form 'if you want X, do Y'; a categorical imperative commands unconditionally, as a duty binding regardless of desires or outcomes.
- 5
What is utilitarianism, in outline?
Answer: A relativist, teleological theory holding that the right act is the one that produces the greatest good, usually understood as happiness, for the greatest number of people affected.
- 6
What is Bentham's hedonic calculus?
Answer: A method for measuring the amount of pleasure or pain an act produces, using factors such as intensity, duration, certainty, extent, propinquity, fecundity and purity.
- 7
Distinguish act utilitarianism from rule utilitarianism.
Answer: Act utilitarianism applies the greatest happiness principle separately to each individual act; rule utilitarianism applies it to choosing general rules that, if followed, tend to maximise happiness.
- 8
What did Mill mean by distinguishing higher and lower pleasures?
Answer: Mill distinguished intellectual, moral and aesthetic pleasures (higher) from purely physical pleasures (lower), arguing higher pleasures are more valuable even in smaller quantity.
- 9
What is virtue ethics, as developed by Aristotle?
Answer: An agent-centred theory focused on developing good character, or virtue, rather than following rules or calculating outcomes; the right act is what a person of practical wisdom would do.
- 10
What is Aristotle's doctrine of the golden mean, and what is eudaimonia?
Answer: Each virtue is a mean between two vices of excess and deficiency, for example courage lies between rashness and cowardice; eudaimonia is the flourishing, fulfilled life that virtue aims at.
Worked example: Generosity is the mean between wastefulness (excess) and stinginess (deficiency).
Meta-ethics, Conscience and Applied Ethics
- 1
What question does meta-ethics ask, as opposed to normative ethics?
Answer: Meta-ethics asks what moral language and moral properties actually are and mean, such as whether 'good' refers to a real property, rather than asking which particular acts are right.
- 2
Distinguish moral realism from moral anti-realism.
Answer: Moral realism holds that moral properties exist independently of what anyone thinks; moral anti-realism holds that moral claims do not describe objective, mind-independent facts.
- 3
What is emotivism, as a form of moral anti-realism?
Answer: The view, associated with A. J. Ayer, that moral statements express emotional approval or disapproval rather than facts; calling an act wrong is like saying 'boo' to it.
- 4
What is intuitionism, as developed by G. E. Moore?
Answer: The view that 'good' names a simple, indefinable property known directly through moral intuition; Moore argued defining good in other terms commits the naturalistic fallacy.
- 5
How did Aquinas understand conscience?
Answer: Aquinas saw conscience as reason making moral judgements by applying synderesis, an innate grasp of basic moral principles, to a particular situation; conscience can therefore err in applying it.
- 6
How did Joseph Butler understand conscience?
Answer: Butler saw conscience as a God-given moral faculty within human nature that intuitively and authoritatively judges right and wrong, standing above mere self-love.
- 7
How did Freud understand conscience psychologically?
Answer: Freud saw conscience as the superego, formed in childhood from internalised parental and social authority, which produces guilt whenever the ego acts against its standards.
- 8
Give one criticism of treating conscience as a reliable moral guide.
Answer: Conscience clearly differs between cultures and individuals and can be trained to approve of cruel acts, for example under an oppressive regime, so it cannot be a wholly reliable guide.
- 9
In the euthanasia debate, distinguish voluntary, non-voluntary and involuntary euthanasia.
Answer: Voluntary euthanasia is requested by a competent patient; non-voluntary is performed when the patient cannot express a wish, such as in a coma; involuntary is performed against the patient's wishes.
- 10
Distinguish active and passive euthanasia.
Answer: Active euthanasia involves a deliberate act that causes death, such as a lethal injection; passive euthanasia involves withholding or withdrawing treatment, letting death occur naturally.
- 11
How might a Natural Law approach evaluate voluntary euthanasia?
Answer: Natural Law would generally forbid it, since it violates the primary precept to preserve life; the doctrine of double effect might still permit pain relief that shortens life as a foreseen but unintended side effect.
- 12
How might an act utilitarian approach evaluate voluntary euthanasia?
Answer: An act utilitarian would assess each case by its likely consequences, and could support euthanasia where it reduces suffering and increases overall happiness for the patient and those around them.
Christian Thought
- 1
What did Augustine teach about the effect of the Fall on human nature?
Answer: Augustine taught that Adam's original sin corrupted all humanity, leaving everyone born with original sin and a will bound to sin, unable to avoid evil without the help of God's grace.
- 2
What did Augustine mean by evil as a privation of good?
Answer: Evil has no independent existence; it is a lack or corruption of the good that should be present, just as blindness is an absence of sight rather than a thing that exists in itself.
- 3
How did Aquinas argue that God's existence can be known through reason as well as revelation?
Answer: Aquinas held that natural reason, reflecting on effects in the world such as motion, causation and design, can demonstrate God's existence, alongside truths known only through revelation.
- 4
What is Aquinas' understanding of natural law as evidence of God's rational order?
Answer: Aquinas held that God built a rational moral order into creation; by using reason to reflect on human nature and its purposes, people can discover natural law and thereby God's will for how to live.
- 5
What was Dietrich Bonhoeffer's concept of 'costly grace'?
Answer: Costly grace is grace that costs the believer their old, self-willed life and calls them to genuine discipleship and obedience to Christ, contrasted with 'cheap grace', forgiveness without repentance or change.
- 6
Why did Bonhoeffer oppose the Nazi regime, and what did this cost him?
Answer: Bonhoeffer held that Christian discipleship demanded active resistance to injustice; he helped found the Confessing Church against Nazi control, was imprisoned, and was executed in 1945.
- 7
What is the key theme of liberation theology, associated with Gustavo Gutierrez?
Answer: Liberation theology reads the Christian gospel as God's 'preferential option for the poor', calling the Church to work actively for social, economic and political justice, not only personal salvation.
- 8
What is praxis, in liberation theology?
Answer: Praxis is reflective action for justice: theology is done by reflecting on lived experience and struggle alongside the poor, then acting to change unjust structures, rather than only by abstract theory.
- 9
What is religious pluralism, as a Christian approach to other faiths, associated with John Hick?
Answer: Pluralism holds that many religions are valid, culturally shaped responses to the same ultimate divine reality, rather than only one religion possessing the whole truth.