TARA flashcards
Standalone multiple-choice practice from existing TARA questions. 40 cards across 10 topics, each with its answer.
Applying principles
- 1
A footpath was closed solely because repair equipment blocked it. The equipment has now gone, the path is safe, and there is no other reason for closure. The council should reopen it rather than wait for its usual annual review. Waiting until the review would leave walkers barred from a path that the council already knows they can use safely. Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case? A. A club should retain a ban on room bookings after a leak is repaired because the same room still has an unsafe ceiling requiring a separate closure. B. A shop should end a temporary entry limit before its crowding problem is resolved because several customers have asked to enter together and dislike waiting outside. C. A school should restore access to a storeroom once the spill that solely justified locking it has been cleared, although its routine access review is next month. D. A campsite should keep a bridge closed until its scheduled meeting even though the single defect behind the closure has been repaired and no other danger remains. E. A warehouse should replace its temporary aisle closure with a permanent one after the only obstruction is removed because the original closure has become familiar to staff.
Answer: C. A school should restore access to a storeroom once the spill that solely justified locking it has been cleared, although its routine access review is next month. The principle is to remove a restriction once its sole temporary justification has ceased and no other justification exists, without waiting for a routine review. The safe, unobstructed footpath meets both conditions. A: Introduces a continuing independent justification. The unsafe ceiling means that removing the leak does not leave the room without a reason for closure. B: Ends a restriction while its justification remains. Customer preference does not establish that the crowding problem, the reason for the limit, has disappeared. C: The spill was the sole reason for locking the room and has been cleared. Restoring access immediately rather than waiting for review follows the same recommendation. D: Treats a review date as a substantive reason to restrict access. The only defect is gone and no other danger remains, exactly the conditions supporting reopening. E: Treats familiarity as a reason to preserve a restriction after its sole justification ends. Habit does not supply a new need for keeping the aisle closed. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
- 2
A residents' association already pays a fixed annual fee for its hall. A member's private meeting adds a cleaning charge but does not alter that annual fee. The association should recover the cleaning charge from the member, but should not add a share of the annual fee. Its purpose here is solely to recover expenses caused by that meeting, not to raise general income. Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case? A. A print room should charge a guest for paper used by their job, but not for its unchanged rent, when recovering only expenses that job creates. B. A caretaker should divide a fixed security bill equally among visitors, even though admitting them changes no costs, because each visitor benefits from the protected building. C. A music room should charge nothing for a private booking, despite the extra heating it requires, because the room would otherwise have stood empty that evening. D. A club should add a contribution to its existing equipment fund to each visitor's bill, although visits create no extra costs, to help finance next year's purchases. E. A kitchen should charge a visiting group the full monthly fuel bill, although its cooking causes only a small increase, because that group can afford the payment.
Answer: A. A print room should charge a guest for paper used by their job, but not for its unchanged rent, when recovering only expenses that job creates. The principle is to recover only the additional expenses attributable to an activity when cost recovery for that activity is the sole aim. Existing costs that remain unchanged are excluded. A: The paper expense is caused by the job, while the rent is unchanged. Recovering the former and excluding the latter applies precisely the same distinction. B: Confuses receiving a benefit with causing an expense. The unchanged security bill is an existing cost, like the annual hall fee, and falls outside this cost-recovery aim. C: Confuses unused capacity with absence of extra expense. The heating cost is caused by the booking and should be recovered under the passage's principle. D: Substitutes general fundraising for recovery of expenses caused by the visit. A contribution to future purchases is not an additional expense of admitting this visitor. E: Confuses ability to pay with responsibility for additional costs. Only the increase caused by the cooking, rather than the whole monthly bill, fits the principle. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
- 3
A makers' centre discovers a fault in one of its four workrooms. Locking that room completely removes the danger, and the other three rooms remain safe and useful. The manager should close only the faulty room rather than the entire centre. Since isolating the fault fully protects users, stopping the other activities would impose restrictions without adding protection. Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case? A. A swimming centre should close a safe pool temporarily while staff repair cosmetic damage to its entrance because completing all the work in one session reduces labour costs. B. A delivery office should disable one faulty sorting chute when that fully removes the danger and its remaining chutes can continue operating safely and usefully. C. A sports club should close every court after finding one damaged net, even though isolating that court removes the danger and the others remain safe to use. D. A food store should keep a damaged freezer running beside sound freezers, although its loose cable threatens staff, because most of its equipment is still safe. E. A library should stop using its older entrance and route readers through an equally safe new entrance because the new route gives faster access to the lending desk.
Answer: B. A delivery office should disable one faulty sorting chute when that fully removes the danger and its remaining chutes can continue operating safely and usefully. The principle is to confine a protective restriction to the faulty part when isolating that part fully removes the danger and leaves the remainder safe and useful. The other workrooms add no reason for a wider closure. A: Bases a closure on efficient scheduling of cosmetic repairs, rather than on isolating a danger. No faulty part threatens users, so the passage's protective condition is absent. B: Isolating the faulty chute removes all the relevant danger, and the remaining chutes still serve their purpose safely. Disabling only that chute meets every condition. C: Expands the restriction beyond what protection requires. Isolating the damaged court is sufficient, so closing safe courts adds inconvenience without removing further danger. D: Confuses most equipment being safe with removal of the danger. Leaving the faulty freezer operating does not isolate its threatening cable and fails the protective condition. E: Selects a more convenient route between two safe alternatives. This can improve access, but it does not isolate a fault or limit a restriction needed to remove danger. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit.
- 4
A theatre needs to adapt a historic costume for a new performer. An internal alteration and a removable insert would fit equally well, cost the same and take the same time. The alteration would permanently remove some original fabric; the insert would leave it intact. The wardrobe manager therefore recommends the insert, since achieving the required fit gives no reason to accept an avoidable permanent loss. Which one of the following most closely applies the principle underlying the argument to a new case? A. A school should replace worn desks with new ones because repairing them would cost more and would leave them unsuitable for the pupils who need them. B. A workshop should keep a damaged mould untouched because preserving its original material matters more than producing the accurate copies required for an urgent order. C. A garden should use freestanding signs rather than carve living trees when both methods meet its labelling needs equally well at equal cost and effort. D. A club should laminate its only handwritten record because the process is cheaper than making a protective box, even though lamination permanently changes the record. E. A gallery should repaint an original frame rather than use a removable cover because the permanent treatment gives the distinctive appearance its new exhibition requires.
Answer: C. A garden should use freestanding signs rather than carve living trees when both methods meet its labelling needs equally well at equal cost and effort. The principle is to avoid permanent loss or alteration when an equally effective alternative, with no cost or effort disadvantage, preserves the original. The insert meets the fit requirement without sacrificing fabric. A: Substitutes replacement of an inadequate object for a choice between equally effective methods. Repair does not meet the school's needs, so the preservation condition is absent. B: Treats preservation as an overriding aim even when the required result is lost. The passage favours preservation only where the alternative fulfils the same purpose equally well. C: Both methods fulfil the labelling purpose on equal terms, but freestanding signs avoid permanent damage to the trees. The same conditional preference supports choosing them. D: Trades permanent change for a cost advantage. The record may benefit from protection, but the equal-cost condition supporting the theatre's recommendation does not hold. E: Chooses a permanent treatment for an appearance the removable alternative cannot supply. This lacks equal effectiveness and does not apply the stated preference for preservation. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
Assessing the impact of additional evidence
- 1
A rehearsal centre often promises the same room to two groups at once because its two receptionists keep separate booking diaries. The centre proposes one shared calendar that both receptionists must use. Its manager argues that this will reduce these double bookings. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument? A. The calendar rejects any overlapping bookings for the same room. B. Both receptionists prefer the colours used in the shared calendar to those in their diaries. C. The shared calendar can also store the centre's list of instrument-repair contacts. D. Groups will still be able to book rooms for the same range of session lengths. E. Receptionists can enter two simultaneous bookings without either seeing a warning.
Answer: A. The calendar rejects any overlapping bookings for the same room. The conclusion predicts fewer double bookings by replacing separate records with a shared one. A supplies a direct mechanism: once a room is booked, the required calendar blocks an overlapping booking. This specifically addresses the error the proposal is intended to reduce. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
- 2
A communal garden began sending plot holders a weekly reminder to turn off taps. Water use fell in the following six weeks compared with the preceding six weeks. The committee concludes that the reminders caused the reduction. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the argument? A. The reminders reached every plot holder through the same messaging service. B. A leak after the garden's water meter was repaired when reminders began. C. Several plot holders asked for the reminders to continue throughout the summer. D. The garden used one meter to measure water in both six-week periods. E. The number of occupied plots stayed the same throughout both periods.
Answer: B. A leak after the garden's water meter was repaired when reminders began. The conclusion singles out the reminders as the cause of lower metered water use. B supplies a competing cause at exactly the relevant time: repairing a leak could reduce metered water loss without any change in tap-turning habits. The before-and-after figures cannot separate the two changes. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit.
- 3
An employer asked staff to vote online on whether to retain a compulsory uniform. Four fifths of those voting supported retaining it. The personnel officer concludes that a majority of all staff support keeping the uniform. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument? A. The uniform supplier can continue supplying the same design for another year. B. Managers who support retaining the uniform circulated the voting link most often. C. Some staff who did not vote have worked at the organisation for many years. D. The uniform costs the employer less than issuing each worker a clothing allowance. E. A separate random sample of all staff found similar support among non-voters.
Answer: E. A separate random sample of all staff found similar support among non-voters. The conclusion extends the result from people who chose to vote to the entire workforce. E supplies independent evidence about the missing group. Similar support among randomly sampled non-voters makes it less likely that voluntary voting produced an unrepresentative result, strengthening the majority claim. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit.
- 4
A firm finds that employees who attend its optional lunchtime mentoring sessions complete more assignments on time than employees who do not attend. The director concludes that attending mentoring improves employees' punctual completion of assignments. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the argument? A. Employees already finishing on time have spare lunch time for mentoring. B. Mentors discuss ways of planning assignments during the lunchtime sessions. C. Some employees say mentoring helped them to schedule their assignments. D. The attendance register is checked carefully at the start of every session. E. Employees in both groups use the same system for recording completed assignments.
Answer: A. Employees already finishing on time have spare lunch time for mentoring. The conclusion moves from an association between attendance and performance to the claim that attendance causes better performance. A reverses the proposed causal direction: already finishing on time enables attendance. Selection into mentoring could therefore explain the difference without mentoring producing any improvement. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
Detecting reasoning errors
- 1
A shop moved its returns desk to the entrance at the start of April. In April it received fewer complaints than in March. The owner says that this proves the new position caused the fall in complaints, since the fall occurred after the move. Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument? A. It assumes that fewer complaints must mean that more goods were returned. B. It confuses a fall in the number of complaints with a fall in their seriousness. C. It treats a change following the move as proof that the move caused the change. D. It infers the number of complaints in March from the desk's position in April. E. It assumes that a change benefiting the owner must also benefit every customer.
Answer: C. It treats a change following the move as proof that the move caused the change. The evidence establishes the order of the move and the fall in complaints. It does not isolate the move as the cause. Another change could account for the fall while both stated facts remain true. C identifies the unsupported move from sequence to causation. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
- 2
The local seed exchange guarantees a free packet of seeds to everyone who brings a labelled envelope. Tomas has brought no labelled envelope. The organiser therefore tells him that he cannot receive a free packet under any circumstances. Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument? A. It treats a sufficient condition for a free packet as though it were necessary. B. It treats a promise about individual visitors as a promise about groups of visitors. C. It treats a condition for receiving a packet as a reason for wanting a packet. D. It confuses eligibility for a free packet with willingness to accept a free packet. E. It assumes that a rule applying to everyone is justified because it has no exceptions.
Answer: A. It treats a sufficient condition for a free packet as though it were necessary. Bringing a labelled envelope is enough to guarantee a free packet. Nothing says that it is the only route to a free packet. Tomas could receive one through another arrangement while the guarantee remains true. A identifies the mistaken treatment of a sufficient condition as necessary. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
- 3
A club treasurer is asked why a new spending rule is fair. She replies: "It is fair because it treats members justly. We know it treats members justly because it is a fair rule." She concludes that these reasons establish the rule's fairness. Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument? A. It offers the claim under discussion as support for an equivalent version of that claim. B. It assumes that a rule which was fair in the past must still be fair in the future. C. It rejects criticism of the rule solely because the critic is not the treasurer. D. It infers that all club rules are fair from evidence about one spending rule. E. It treats a majority vote in favour of the rule as proof that the rule is fair.
Answer: A. It offers the claim under discussion as support for an equivalent version of that claim. Treating members justly restates the fairness claim in this context. Its offered support is then the original assertion that the rule is fair. Neither statement has independent support: each depends on accepting the other. A identifies the circular reasoning. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
- 4
Whenever the warehouse alarm is being tested, a blue lamp beside the door flashes. The blue lamp is flashing now. The supervisor concludes that the alarm must be undergoing a test, so there is no need to find out why the lamp is flashing. Which one of the following best identifies the flaw in the argument? A. It assumes that a test must have finished before its warning lamp begins to flash. B. It treats a rule about every alarm test as though it concerned only the last test. C. It assumes that an association between tests and flashing proves that tests cause flashing. D. It treats a signal that accompanies tests as proof that a test is taking place. E. It assumes that a signal which was reliable in the past must remain reliable now.
Answer: D. It treats a signal that accompanies tests as proof that a test is taking place. The reason says that a test guarantees flashing. The conclusion reverses that direction: flashing is taken to guarantee a test. The lamp could also flash for another reason without violating the stated rule. D identifies this unsupported reversal, often called affirming the consequent. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit.
Drawing a conclusion
- 1
Every hanging sculpture in a gallery has a numbered safety cable. Some objects in the east room have no numbered safety cable. Objects may be displayed in the east room whether or not they are sculptures, and the passage gives no other rules about which objects need cables. Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage? A. Every object with a numbered safety cable is a hanging sculpture. B. Some objects in the east room are not hanging sculptures. C. No object in the east room is a hanging sculpture. D. Fitting a numbered cable would make any east-room object safe to hang. E. Most objects without numbered cables are displayed in the east room.
Answer: B. Some objects in the east room are not hanging sculptures. An object without a numbered cable cannot be a hanging sculpture under the gallery rule. There are such objects in the east room. Those objects supply the instances required by B, without ruling out hanging sculptures elsewhere in that room. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit.
- 2
Eighteen residents each returned one ballot about a proposed courtyard. Eleven ballots supported adding benches, and ten supported adding planters. Each ballot could support either proposal, both proposals or neither. These figures include every returned ballot. Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage? A. Most residents who returned ballots supported both benches and planters. B. Everyone supporting benches also supported adding planters to the courtyard. C. At least three returned ballots supported both benches and planters. D. Exactly three returned ballots supported both benches and planters. E. Adding benches would make most courtyard residents use the space more often.
Answer: C. At least three returned ballots supported both benches and planters. The two support totals add to 21, but there are only 18 ballots. With no overlap, 21 separate ballots would be needed. At least 21 - 18 = 3 ballots must have been counted in both totals. C states this lower bound without treating it as an exact count. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
- 3
A cafe began using a shorter menu at the start of June. On the same day it added a second cook to every lunchtime shift. Its average recorded waiting time was lower in June than in May. No separate trial of either change was made, and the records give no information about how busy the cafe was in either month. Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage? A. The shorter menu was responsible for the whole fall in average waiting time. B. The additional cook had no effect on the average waiting time in June. C. Every customer in June waited less time than every customer in May. D. Returning to the longer menu would certainly restore the May waiting time. E. The records do not establish how much of the fall was due to the shorter menu.
Answer: E. The records do not establish how much of the fall was due to the shorter menu. Menu length and staffing changed together. There is no comparison in which one changed while the other was held fixed, and demand is unrecorded. The lower average is compatible with several different contributions from these factors. E states the resulting limit on attribution without asserting that the menu had no effect. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit.
- 4
A seed club sends the same number of packets each spring. This year it paid more for postage than last year, but its spending on envelopes fell by a larger amount than its postage spending rose. These are its only two dispatch costs. The club has not recorded whether the new envelopes protect packets better or worse. Which one of the following can be drawn as a conclusion from the passage? A. The club paid less postage per packet this year than it did last year. B. The new envelopes caused the increase in the club's postage spending. C. The club's dispatch costs will fall again when it sends packets next spring. D. The club's total dispatch cost per packet was lower this year than last year. E. Every packet arrived in better condition this year because of the new envelopes.
Answer: D. The club's total dispatch cost per packet was lower this year than last year. Subtracting a larger envelope saving than the postage increase makes the combined dispatch cost fall. There are no other dispatch costs to offset that fall. The number of packets is unchanged, so dividing the lower total by the same packet count gives a lower cost per packet. D follows for this year only. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit.
Identifying an assumption
- 1
A design studio offers a travel grant only to applicants who have completed its introductory course and live outside the city. Every applicant who meets both conditions receives the grant. Leena completed the course last month. Leena will therefore receive a travel grant when she applies. Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument? A. Everyone who completes the course applies for a travel grant. B. Leena found the introductory course useful for her design work. C. The grant will cover the full cost of Leena's journey. D. Leena lives outside the city. E. Leena completed the course faster than most other applicants.
Answer: D. Leena lives outside the city. The conclusion is that Leena will receive the grant. Completing the course meets one eligibility condition, but the rule also requires residence outside the city. Negate D: Leena does not live outside the city. She then fails a required condition for receiving the grant, so completing the course no longer supports the conclusion. Therefore D supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select D; no partial credit.
- 2
A wildlife group compares two annual counts of nesting platforms along a canal. Its volunteers recorded more occupied platforms this year than last year. The group therefore concludes that more pairs of birds nested on the canal this year. It bases this conclusion entirely on the platform counts. Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument? A. The same volunteers counted the platforms in both years. B. Every nesting pair successfully raised young in both years. C. The total number of platforms remained unchanged between the counts. D. Every bird species on the canal nests on a platform. E. The extra platform nests are not all relocations from uncounted sites.
Answer: E. The extra platform nests are not all relocations from uncounted sites. The conclusion is about all nesting pairs on the canal, but the evidence counts only occupied platforms. More platform occupants need not mean more pairs overall if existing pairs changed where they nested. Negate E: the entire increase reflects existing pairs moving from uncounted sites. More occupied platforms can then coexist with no increase in nesting pairs, removing the stated basis for the conclusion. Therefore E supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit.
- 3
The organisers of a weekend course asked participants who stayed for the optional final discussion whether the course should be repeated. Almost all of those asked said yes. On this basis, the organisers conclude that most people who attended the course want it to be repeated. Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument? A. Every participant who stayed for the discussion attended every course session. B. The discussion covered exactly the same material as the earlier sessions. C. The organisers can afford to run the course again next year. D. Participants who want a repeat also want the course to be longer. E. Early leavers' views do not overturn the apparent majority.
Answer: E. Early leavers' views do not overturn the apparent majority. The evidence describes a self-selected subgroup, but the conclusion describes a majority of all participants. It needs support to extend far enough beyond any selection effect to form that majority. Negate E: the views of the early leavers overturn the apparent majority among those who stayed. The favourable responses can still be exactly as reported, but most participants overall do not want a repeat. Therefore E supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit.
- 4
An amateur league wants every team to have equal opportunity to appeal a disputed result. The league secretary argues that charging the same appeal fee to each team achieves this aim. The secretary's sole reason is that the fee would be identical for all teams, regardless of their size or budget. Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument? A. Every team will lodge the same number of appeals during the season. B. The league will uphold every appeal that a team submits. C. The common fee will not exclude some teams through inability to pay. D. The cost of administering an appeal is identical in every case. E. The appeal fee will supply most of the league's annual income.
Answer: C. The common fee will not exclude some teams through inability to pay. The conclusion concerns equal opportunity, while the reason establishes only an equal charge. The missing bridge is that the charge does not selectively prevent access because some teams cannot pay it. Negate C: the common fee is an access barrier for some teams because of their ability to pay, but not for others. Equal charges then fail to establish the equal opportunity claimed. Therefore C supplies the missing assumption. The other options are not required for this inference. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
Identifying the main conclusion
- 1
At the repair workshop, volunteers often spend the first half-hour searching for tools. The tools are available, but they are returned to different cupboards each week. A labelled storage board would give every tool a fixed place, making searches much shorter. The workshop ought to install one. It would also let volunteers see what is missing before a session starts, rather than discovering the gap while someone is waiting for a repair. Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument? A. The repair workshop should install a labelled tool storage board. B. Volunteers lose time searching despite the tools being available. C. Giving tools fixed places would shorten the searches for them. D. The workshop should replace any tools missing at the start. E. A storage board would reveal missing tools before repairs begin.
Answer: A. The repair workshop should install a labelled tool storage board. The argument moves from wasted search time to a proposed remedy: installing a labelled storage board. Fixed places would reduce searching, while visible gaps would reveal missing tools sooner. Both benefits support installing the board. The final sentence supplies another reason; its position does not make it the main conclusion. A expresses the recommendation. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
- 2
Last year the arts centre added more performances, and its total attendance rose. Its director calls this proof that the average performance attracted a larger audience. Yet the number of performances increased by a greater proportion than the total attendance. Average attendance per performance must therefore have fallen. The director's claim about larger audiences is mistaken. The rise in total attendance may still be welcome, but that is a different claim. Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument? A. The arts centre increased its total attendance by adding performances. B. The number of performances rose faster than total attendance did. C. The average audience per performance at the arts centre fell. D. The increase in total attendance should still be welcomed. E. The director is wrong to claim that average audiences increased.
Answer: E. The director is wrong to claim that average audiences increased. The director's claim is about average audiences, whereas the initial evidence concerns total attendance. The faster proportional growth in performances means average attendance fell. That intermediate conclusion directly supports the judgement that the director's claim is mistaken. The closing concession does not reverse the criticism. E expresses the judgement the argument aims to establish. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit.
- 3
The committee should keep the reading room open until eight on weekdays. Many residents finish work after the present closing time, so they cannot use it during the week. A trial of later opening brought in people who had never visited on Saturdays. It therefore reached residents whom the existing timetable did not serve. The extra staffing cost can be met from the committee's existing budget, without reducing any other service. Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument? A. The present weekday timetable excludes many residents who work late. B. The opening trial reached people not served by the existing timetable. C. The committee should retain weekday opening until eight in the evening. D. The committee can afford extra staffing without reducing other services. E. The reading room should replace Saturday opening with weekday evenings.
Answer: C. The committee should retain weekday opening until eight in the evening. The passage asks the committee to retain later weekday opening. The access problem and the trial provide reasons for that recommendation. The claim that the trial reached previously unserved residents is an intermediate conclusion: the new Saturday non-visitors support it, and it in turn supports later opening. The budget point removes a practical obstacle to the same recommendation. Thus C states the main conclusion. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
- 4
The orchestra should select next season's rehearsal venue by asking all its members, rather than only those attending this week. Several regular players are away for performances elsewhere. A vote this week would therefore leave out people who will use the venue throughout next season. Waiting for an online vote open to everyone would avoid that exclusion. The booking deadline is still a month away, so there is no need to decide before absent members can take part. Which one of the following best expresses the main conclusion of the argument? A. All orchestra members should be asked to choose the rehearsal venue. B. Several regular players are absent because of other performances. C. A vote this week would exclude some regular users of the venue. D. The orchestra has a month before the venue booking deadline. E. An online vote open to everyone would avoid excluding absent players.
Answer: A. All orchestra members should be asked to choose the rehearsal venue. The opening sentence recommends involving every member in the venue choice. The absence of regular users explains why consulting only this week's attendees would be inadequate. The online vote is a means of including those members, and the deadline shows there is time to do so. The argument supports consultation of all members, expressed by A; neither a single supporting fact nor the procedure's benefit captures that main point. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
Matching arguments
- 1
All the charcoal drawings in this portfolio are monochrome works. Therefore all the monochrome works in this portfolio are charcoal drawings. Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage? A. Every brass fitting in this crate is a reusable component. Therefore every reusable component in this crate is a brass fitting. B. Every language tutor in this centre has a staff pass. Therefore everyone in this centre without a staff pass is not a language tutor. C. All the express trains on this route stop at West Quay. Therefore some trains on this route that stop at West Quay are express trains. D. None of the wool rugs in this storeroom are machine washable. Therefore none of the machine washable items in this storeroom are wool rugs. E. Some gardeners in this village are beekeepers. Therefore some beekeepers in this village are gardeners.
Answer: A. Every brass fitting in this crate is a reusable component. Therefore every reusable component in this crate is a brass fitting. The passage takes an inclusion of the charcoal class within the monochrome class and reverses it. Other materials could also produce monochrome works. A repeats this invalid universal conversion: all brass fittings are reusable does not imply that every reusable component is brass. The single premise and universal converse conclusion both match. B uses negation to form the contrapositive; C weakens the conclusion to some; D converts an exclusion; E converts an existential overlap. These are different patterns. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
- 2
If a community garden installs raised beds, its planting register is updated. The planting register has been updated. Therefore the garden has installed raised beds. Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage? A. The rehearsal room has a red light showing. If a recording is in progress, that room shows a red light. Therefore a recording is in progress. B. If a notebook has numbered pages, it receives an index. This notebook has numbered pages. Therefore it receives an index. C. If a walker follows the ridge path, they reach the stone shelter. This walker did not follow the ridge path. Therefore they did not reach the shelter. D. If a machine completes its cycle, it sounds a bell. This machine has not sounded a bell. Therefore it has not completed its cycle. E. If a trolley carries fragile goods, it has a yellow tag. This trolley has a yellow tag. Therefore it carries no fragile goods.
Answer: A. The rehearsal room has a red light showing. If a recording is in progress, that room shows a red light. Therefore a recording is in progress. The passage reasons backwards: installing raised beds would update the register, and the register was updated, so it claims raised beds were installed. A makes the same converse error. Recording would produce the red light, and the light is showing, so it claims recording is happening. The reordered premises leave the pattern intact. Both inferences are invalid because the stated rule allows other ways for the consequence to occur. B and D use different, valid patterns; C denies the condition and E negates the conclusion. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select A; no partial credit.
- 3
If a theatre books a touring orchestra, it hires extra music stands. The theatre has not booked a touring orchestra. Therefore it has not hired extra music stands. Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage? A. If a parcel contains seeds, it carries a green sticker. This parcel does not carry a green sticker. Therefore it contains no seeds. B. This workshop is not using solvent varnish. If a workshop uses solvent varnish, it opens its roof vents. Therefore this workshop has not opened its roof vents. C. If a restaurant serves breakfast, it orders fresh rolls. This restaurant has ordered fresh rolls. Therefore it serves breakfast. D. If a printer receives a colour file, it loads a colour cartridge. This printer has received a colour file. Therefore it loads a colour cartridge. E. If a school holds a sports day, it hires a marquee. This school is not holding a sports day. Therefore it has hired a marquee.
Answer: B. This workshop is not using solvent varnish. If a workshop uses solvent varnish, it opens its roof vents. Therefore this workshop has not opened its roof vents. The passage denies the rule's condition and therefore denies its consequence. This is the inverse error: other bookings might still require extra stands. B repeats that invalid pattern. Not using solvent varnish does not establish that the vents stayed shut, since another activity might require ventilation. The fact preceding the rule makes no structural difference. A rules out a condition from a missing consequence, C infers a condition from its consequence, D applies a rule forwards and E concludes a positive consequence. Only B matches. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit.
- 4
The exhibition received funding from the town council or from a private trust, possibly both. It received no funding from the town council. Therefore it received funding from a private trust. Which one of the following arguments has the same pattern of reasoning as the passage? A. The walking group will visit the lake or the old quarry, possibly both. It will visit the lake. Therefore it will not visit the old quarry. B. The fault is not in the cable. It is in the cable or in the socket, possibly both. Therefore the fault is in the socket. C. The parcel is at the reception desk and in the sorting room. It is not at the reception desk. Therefore it is in the sorting room. D. The booking was made by telephone or through the website, possibly both. It was not made by telephone. Therefore it was not made through the website. E. If a lamp has a cracked base, it is sent for repair. This lamp does not have a cracked base. Therefore it is sent for repair.
Answer: B. The fault is not in the cable. It is in the cable or in the socket, possibly both. Therefore the fault is in the socket. The passage states that at least one of two sources funded the exhibition. Excluding council funding leaves trust funding, even though both sources were initially allowed. B repeats this disjunctive elimination. The fault must be in at least one of cable and socket; once the cable is ruled out, the socket remains. The negative premise comes first. A incorrectly excludes an alternative after affirming the other, C asserts both alternatives, D denies the survivor and E supplies a conditional rather than alternatives. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit.
Finding procedures
- 1
A rectangular garden has perimeter 34 m. Its length is 3 m more than its width. What is its area? A. 49 m2 B. 70 m2 C. 72 m2 D. 238 m2 E. 100 m2
Answer: B. 70 m2 Two lengths and two widths total 34 m, so one length and one width total 17 m. Remove the extra 3 m from the length: two widths total 17 - 3 = 14 m. The width is 7 m and the length is 10 m. The area is 7 x 10 = 70 m2. B1: Award 1 mark for option B (70 m2).
- 2
A hall has 120 seats. At the start, 3/5 of the seats are occupied. Then 18 people leave and 12 arrive. What percentage of the seats are occupied now? A. 45% B. 50% C. 55% D. 60% E. 65%
Answer: C. 55% Initially, 120 / 5 x 3 = 72 seats are occupied. After the changes, 72 - 18 + 12 = 66 seats are occupied. Each 1% of the 120 seats is 1.2 seats, so 66 / 1.2 = 55% are occupied. Equivalently, 66/120 = 11/20 = 55/100. B1: Award 1 mark for option C (55%).
- 3
A shop reduces a 40-pound item by 25%, then takes a further 5 pounds off the reduced price. What is the final price? A. 25 pounds B. 30 pounds C. 35 pounds D. 26.25 pounds E. 55 pounds
Answer: A. 25 pounds The percentage discount is a quarter of 40, which is 10 pounds. The reduced price is 40 - 10 = 30 pounds. Apply the further discount to that price: 30 - 5 = 25 pounds. B1: Award 1 mark for option A (25 pounds).
- 4
A rectangular noticeboard is 12 cm wide. Its area is 180 cm2. A border strip is placed once around the outside edge. How many centimetres of strip are needed? A. 54 B. 39 C. 27 D. 60 E. 78
Answer: A. 54 The missing side length is 180 / 12 = 15 cm because area is the product of the two side lengths. Walking once around the rectangle uses two 12 cm sides and two 15 cm sides: 12 + 15 + 12 + 15 = 54 cm. Therefore 54 cm of strip is needed. B1: Award 1 mark for option A (54).
Identifying similarity
- 1
A survey records each visitor's single preferred activity. | Activity | Visitors | | Reading | 2 | | Walking | 3 | | Drawing | 5 | A seed mixture has herb, flower and grass seeds in the same proportions as Reading, Walking and Drawing respectively. Which profile gives the numbers of the three types in a sample of 60 seeds? A. 2, 3, 5 B. 58, 57, 55 C. 12, 18, 30 D. 30, 18, 12 E. 60, 90, 150
Answer: C. 12, 18, 30 The transferable relationship is part divided by total: category shares are preserved when the total changes. There are 2 + 3 + 5 = 10 visitors. Each visitor represents 60 / 10 = 6 seeds, giving 2 x 6 = 12, 3 x 6 = 18 and 5 x 6 = 30. Therefore select C: 12, 18, 30. A: Copies counts without scaling to the new total. This gives 2, 3, 5. B: Subtracts each category count from 60 instead of scaling its share. This gives 58, 57, 55. D: Reverses the category order after scaling. This gives 30, 18, 12. E: Uses the first category, 2, as the denominator instead of the total, 10. This gives 60, 90, 150. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
- 2
A count of plants is taken before and after a growing season. | Bed | Before | After | | North | 40 | 50 | | East | 60 | 120 | | West | 80 | 100 | Three clubs have the same respective starting and ending membership numbers as these plant counts. Which profile gives the percentage increases in membership for North, East and West? A. -25, -100, -25 B. 10, 60, 20 C. 20, 50, 20 D. 125, 200, 125 E. 25, 100, 25
Answer: E. 25, 100, 25 The transferable relationship is relative growth: divide each increase by its own starting value, then multiply by 100. The increases are 10, 60 and 20. Their percentages are 100 x 10 / 40 = 25, 100 x 60 / 60 = 100 and 100 x 20 / 80 = 25. Therefore select E: 25, 100, 25. A: Computes a fall by subtracting the final count from the starting count. This gives -25, -100, -25. B: Reports absolute increases as percentages. This gives 10, 60, 20. C: Uses the ending value as the percentage base. This gives 20, 50, 20. D: Reports the final value as a percentage of the start, including the original 100 percent. This gives 125, 200, 125. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select E; no partial credit.
- 3
Rectangular gardens have these dimensions in metres. | Garden | Length | Width | | Fern | 3 | 5 | | Moss | 4 | 6 | | Reed | 5 | 7 | A display uses rectangular arrays of counters with 3 rows of 5, 4 rows of 6 and 5 rows of 7. Which profile gives the counter totals that correspond numerically to the garden areas in square metres, in Fern, Moss and Reed order? A. 8, 10, 12 B. 15, 24, 35 C. 9, 16, 25 D. 30, 48, 70 E. 16, 20, 24
Answer: B. 15, 24, 35 The transferable relationship is a rectangular product: rows x counters per row has the same structure as length x width. The products are 3 x 5 = 15, 4 x 6 = 24 and 5 x 7 = 35. Therefore select B: 15, 24, 35. A: Adds the two dimensions instead of multiplying. This gives 8, 10, 12. C: Squares the first dimension and ignores the second. This gives 9, 16, 25. D: Doubles the product as though there were two complete arrays. This gives 30, 48, 70. E: Computes perimeters, 2 x (length + width), rather than areas. This gives 16, 20, 24. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select B; no partial credit.
- 4
A booking system lists all available seats and those already booked. | Room | Total | Booked | | Hazel | 40 | 10 | | Willow | 60 | 24 | | Ash | 80 | 40 | A workshop has three stocks of identical components. Their totals and numbers already used match the respective rows. Which profile gives the percentages of components still unused in Hazel, Willow and Ash order? A. 40, 60, 80 B. 30, 36, 40 C. 75, 60, 50 D. 10, 24, 40 E. 25, 40, 50
Answer: C. 75, 60, 50 The transferable relationship is the complementary share: unused percentage = 100 x (total - used) / total. Unused counts are 30, 36 and 40. These are 30 / 40 = 75 / 100, 36 / 60 = 60 / 100 and 40 / 80 = 50 / 100 of the stocks. Therefore select C: 75, 60, 50. A: Reports the stock totals as percentages without calculating a share. This gives 40, 60, 80. B: Reports unused counts as though they were percentages. This gives 30, 36, 40. D: Reports used counts as percentages without dividing by the totals. This gives 10, 24, 40. E: Reports the used percentage instead of its complement. This gives 25, 40, 50. Mark | Award condition B1 (1 mark) | Select C; no partial credit.
Relevant selection
- 1
A 360 ml drink is poured equally into 8 cups. What volume is in 3 cups? The drink is orange and the cups are 10 cm tall. A. 360 B. 45 C. 120 D. 135 E. 357
Answer: D. 135 Each cup contains 360 / 8 = 45 ml. Three cups contain 3 x 45 = 135 ml. Colour and cup height do not affect the calculation.
- 2
A machine makes 25 parts per day for 6 days. How many parts does it make in the first 2 days? The machine is painted grey and is 4 m long. E. 150 B. 25 C. 75 D. 100 A. 50
Answer: A. 50 The machine makes 25 parts each day, so in 2 days it makes 2 x 25 = 50 parts. The other facts do not affect the requested period.
- 3
A parcel contains a 2 kg book and a 350 g notebook. Its label is green and it is posted at 2 pm. What is the combined mass in grams? A. 2000 B. 1350 C. 352 D. 2350 E. 350
Answer: D. 2350 Since 1 kg = 1000 g, the book has mass 2000 g. Add the notebook mass: 2000 + 350 = 2350 g. The label and posting time are irrelevant.
- 4
A shop reduces a coat priced at 800 pounds by 15 percent. The coat is size 12, and the shop closes at 6 pm. What is the amount of the reduction? A. 800 B. 680 E. 15 D. 785 C. 120
Answer: C. 120 Ten percent of 800 is 80 and five percent is half of that, 40. The reduction is 80 + 40 = 120 pounds. Size and closing time are irrelevant.