Exam Technique: Extended Essays on Rational Choice and Utility Theory - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
6 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Exam Technique: Extended Essays on Rational Choice and Utility Theory revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Economics practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 14 of A Level Economics Topic Workbook 2 and chapter 28 of A Level Economics 10-Minute Tests 1.
1.29 Exam Technique: Extended Essays on Rational Choice and Utility Theory
Question 1
- Level 1 Basic knowledge of the law of diminishing marginal utility with little application to demand, minimal structure and no balanced evaluation. May include an unlabelled or missing diagram.1-5
- Level 2 Accurate explanation of diminishing marginal utility and a simple link to why demand falls as price rises, with at least one clear diagram. Limited evaluation or unbalanced discussion, and the judgement is weak or unsupported.6-10
- Level 3 Good analysis linking diminishing marginal utility to the downward slope of demand, including mechanism and diagram annotation. Some evaluation of alternative explanations or limitations, and a supported but not fully developed judgement.11-15
- Level 4 Comprehensive answer: explains the mechanism clearly, correctly uses marginal utility per pound reasoning to derive demand, includes a well-labelled diagram, considers alternative explanations and limitations, and reaches a balanced, well-supported judgement.16-20
- Indicative content:
- Definition of marginal utility and the law of diminishing marginal utility
- Mechanism: as consumption of a good increases MU falls, so consumers require a lower price to buy additional units, linking MU to willingness to pay
- Argument that MU per pound equalisation across goods implies substitution when price changes, giving a downward-sloping demand curve
- Diagram: price vertical, quantity horizontal, downward-sloping demand curve, annotation linking movement along curve to falling MU
- Limitations and evaluation: other reasons for downward slope such as income effects, substitution effects independent of MU, diminishing marginal rate of substitution in indifference-curve framework, and empirical evidence from behavioural economics
- Consideration of cases where MU explanation is weak: multi-attribute goods, corner solutions, habitual goods, or where utility is not cardinal
- Conclusion: balanced judgement that MU offers a clear micro-foundation for demand but is not the sole explanation and sometimes fails empirically
Question 2
- one valid example stated, e.g. 'Savings shortfall evidence where present bias leads to under-saving for retirement, motivating default enrolment nudges'B1
- second valid example stated, e.g. 'Behavioural responses to energy bills where framing and inertia reduce switching despite financial benefits, supporting targeted information campaigns or regulation'B1
Question 3
- paragraph makes a balanced conclusion acknowledging behavioural critiques but noting contexts where MU remains usefulB1
- includes a policy implication, for example recommending a mixed toolkit of price-based instruments and behavioural nudges targeted by evidenceB1
Question 4
- identifies a missing analytical point: no concrete real-world example of inconsistent choice is given (for example, preference reversals in lab experiments or time-inconsistent choices)M1
- explains why its absence matters: an example would support the critique by showing the assumption fails empirically and allow development into consequences for demand predictionsA1
- identifies a missing analytical point: the paragraph lacks discussion of bounded rationality and cognitive costs which limit optimizationM1
- explains why its absence matters: considering bounded rationality explains mechanistically why the optimisation assumption is unrealistic and offers an alternative behavioural predictionA1
- identifies a missing evaluative point: no consideration of the conditions under which the assumption might be a useful approximation (e.g. for simple discrete choices or small stakes)M1
- explains why its absence matters: showing when the model remains useful allows a balanced judgement, which is required for higher marksA1
- identifies a missing methodological counter-argument: no mention of how market-level outcomes may still align with utility theory even if individuals deviateM1
- explains why its absence matters: this point would develop analysis by showing micro deviations do not automatically invalidate aggregate demand predictions, strengthening evaluationA1
Question 5
- Level 1 Limited description of total and marginal utility with minimal discussion of income changes, lacking structure and evaluation.1-5
- Level 2 Clear explanation of total and marginal utility and some discussion of how income changes affect consumption, with a simple diagram. Evaluation is present but undeveloped.6-10
- Level 3 Good discussion of both strengths and weaknesses, includes diagram and considers empirical or behavioural caveats, and provides a supported policy implication or application.11-15
- Level 4 Comprehensive and balanced discussion, integrates theoretical exposition with pedagogic clarity, empirical evidence and policy implications, and concludes with a well-argued judgement on the usefulness of MU teaching for welfare maximisation.16-20
- Indicative content:
- Explanation of total utility and marginal utility and how students can use MU to judge additional consumption at different incomes
- Strengths: clear, tractable model; teaches optimisation and trade-offs; provides numerical examples for classroom pedagogy
- Use of diagram to show diminishing MU and to show how a rise in income can increase consumption of a normal good (income effect)
- Weaknesses: cardinal utility is a strong assumption, interpersonal comparisons of utility problematic, real consumers face information costs and behavioural biases
- Policy implications: MU-based teaching helps in understanding taxation/subsidy effects but overlooks distributional and behavioural factors so policy based solely on MU could mispredict outcomes
- Conclusion: MU is a useful teaching tool but must be complemented by behavioural and welfare economics to give students a realistic view
Question 6
- Level 1 Basic description of behavioural critiques or rational choice, lacking development, application to policy, and no clear judgement.1-5
- Level 2 Accurate description of behavioural biases and some implications for marginal utility theory and policy, but limited analysis and weak conclusion.6-10
- Level 3 Good analysis contrasting behavioural findings with rational choice predictions, examples of policy implications, and a supported but not fully nuanced judgement.11-15
- Level 4 Comprehensive evaluation: integrates theoretical critique, empirical evidence on bias magnitude and persistence, heterogeneity, contexts where behavioural insights matter for policy, and concludes with a nuanced, evidence-based judgement.16-20
- Indicative content:
- Outline of rational economic man and marginal utility theory as the basis for price-based policy and welfare analysis
- Behavioural critiques: systematic biases (loss aversion, present bias, framing, bounded rationality), heuristics and preference reversals
- Evidence on magnitude and persistence: small laboratory biases versus large real-world effects, and whether nudges or regulation are justified
- Policy relevance: where fine-tuning taxes/subsidies via MU works versus where behavioural interventions or paternalistic policies are better
- Consideration of heterogeneity: some consumers approximate rational agents while others consistently deviate, so policy should be targeted
- Conclusion: behavioural economics does not make standard theory wholly obsolete but shows limits and suggests a complementary policy toolkit
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.