Functionalist and New Right Perspectives on the Role of Education - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
8 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Functionalist and New Right Perspectives on the Role of Education revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Sociology practice
This topic is chapter 1 of A Level Sociology Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 1 of A Level Sociology 10-Minute Tests.
1.1 Functionalist and New Right Perspectives on the Role of Education
- A) Bowles and Gintis
- B) Durkheim and Parsons
- C) Chubb and Moe
- D) Becker and Willis
Question 1
- Level 1 Simple statements identifying a limited use of the Item or a basic criticism, with little or no development or sociological knowledge.1-2
- Level 2 Some accurate use of the Item with one or two developed sociological points that begin to evaluate the New Right claim, but limited range or depth.3-4
- Level 3 Clear use of the Item and relevant sociological knowledge, giving at least two developed points that evaluate the New Right view, including evidence for and against.5-6
- Level 4 Detailed and well-focused evaluation using the Item and wider sociological knowledge. At least two distinct and well-developed ways of using the evidence to support balanced judgement about marketisation and parental choice, showing understanding of implications for standards and meritocracy.7-10
- Indicative content:
- Support for New Right: higher average rises (9% vs 6%) and higher parental satisfaction in voucher schools can be used to argue competition raised standards and responsiveness to parents.
- Counter-evidence: disadvantaged pupils improved less in voucher schools (2% vs 7%), suggesting marketisation can increase inequalities and fail to deliver meritocratic outcomes for the disadvantaged.
- Selection and cream-skimming: inspector's report of increased selection by ability in voucher schools supports the criticism that marketisation encourages selection, undermining equal opportunity.
- Higher administrative costs: higher per-pupil costs in the voucher scheme could be used to argue market mechanisms are less efficient or divert funds from teaching, challenging New Right efficiency claims.
- Sociological knowledge: reference to Chubb and Moe's claims about better outcomes under markets, and to criticisms from Marxists and sociologists who stress unequal starting points, cultural capital and reproduction of class advantage.
- Evaluation: students might argue that some measures of 'standards' improved, but that marketisation risks undermining meritocracy and increasing inequality; conclude with balanced judgement about conditional benefits or limits of parental choice.
Question 2
- B (Durkheim and Parsons)B1
- Answer: B
Question 3
- identifies the hidden curriculum as the implicit lessons of rules, routines and teacher expectationsB1
- development, e.g. it can reproduce class-based or gendered norms and thus undermine claims that schools produce a fair meritocratic value consensusB1
- Answer: The hidden curriculum refers to implicit lessons from school rules, routines and teacher expectations; critics say it can reproduce class-based or gendered norms, undermining the claim that schools produce a fair meritocratic value consensus.
Question 4
- Level 1 Basic statements about the functionalist view with little development, limited use of Item A, and little or no evaluation.1-4
- Level 2 Some accurate description of functionalist views (Durkheim, Parsons, Davis and Moore), with attempts to apply Item A and some limited evaluation using one or two criticisms.5-9
- Level 3 Clear and accurate explanation of the main functionalist claims, good use of Item A and wider knowledge to support points, and balanced evaluation using Marxist, feminist and New Right critiques with developed analysis.10-15
- Level 4 Detailed and well-focused assessment that explains functionalist arguments and uses Item A and wider evidence precisely; strong, balanced critical engagement with multiple perspectives and a well-supported conclusion about how far education serves societal needs.16-20
- Indicative content:
- AO1 points: Durkheim on social solidarity and specialist skills; Parsons on school as bridge and meritocratic role allocation; Davis and Moore on role allocation and importance of allocating talents to social roles.
- Use of Item A: evidence that some measures of standards rose (9% in voucher schools) which could be seen as supporting functionalist ideas about education performing economic and integrative functions; parental satisfaction may indicate schools meeting societal expectations.
- Criticisms: Marxist critique that education reproduces class inequalities and is not genuinely meritocratic, Bowles and Gintis on correspondence principle; feminist critiques on gendered reproduction.
- New Right perspective: Chubb and Moe argue markets improve efficiency and standards, which overlaps with functionalist emphasis on skills but differs in policy prescription; Item A also shows counter-evidence such as disadvantaged pupils faring worse under vouchers, suggesting market solutions can undermine social needs.
- Practical evidence from Item A: selection by ability and higher administrative costs challenge functionalist assumptions of equal opportunity and efficient allocation; functionalist claims about meritocracy are undermined if disadvantaged groups are excluded.
- Evaluation: weigh positive claims about social cohesion and skill provision against evidence of inequality, selection and reproduction of advantage. Conclude that education can serve some societal needs, such as training a workforce and fostering shared values, but may fail to provide equal opportunity and can reinforce social divisions unless policies specifically address structural inequalities.
Question 5
- identifies the bridge idea: school replaces particularistic family values with universalistic standardsB1
- development, e.g. this prepares pupils for meritocratic competition in wider societyB1
- Answer: Parsons argued school is a bridge from the particularistic standards of the family to the universalistic standards of wider society, preparing children for meritocratic roles.
Question 6
- a correct example, e.g. national examinations that rank pupils and determine access to university or jobsB1
- Answer: National examinations that rank pupils and determine access to university or jobs.
Question 7
- identifies a criticism, e.g. education reproduces existing class inequalities rather than offering equal opportunitiesB1
- development, e.g. Marxists argue cultural capital and hidden curriculum advantage middle-class pupils so 'meritocracy' is a mythB1
- Answer: Marxists argue education reproduces existing class inequalities rather than offering equal opportunity; cultural capital and the hidden curriculum advantage middle-class pupils, so the claim that success is purely meritocratic is a myth.
Question 8
- identifies Parsons' link, e.g. school teaches universalistic values and achievement orientationB1
- development, e.g. this creates shared standards against which individuals are judgedB1
- further development, e.g. teachers reward effort and ability rather than ascribed family statusB1
- application, e.g. this supports the idea of meritocracy where status is achievedB1
- Answer: Parsons argued school teaches universalistic values and an achievement orientation, creating shared standards against which individuals are judged; teachers reward effort and ability rather than ascribed family status, supporting a meritocratic system where status is achieved.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.