Left Realist Criminology and Community-Based Crime Prevention - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
12 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Left Realist Criminology and Community-Based Crime Prevention revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Sociology practice
This topic is chapter 14 of A Level Sociology Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 14 of A Level Sociology 10-Minute Tests.
3.2 Left Realist Criminology and Community-Based Crime Prevention
Question 1
- identifies left realist focus on structural causes, victims and community interventionsB1
- identifies right realist focus on individual responsibility, deterrence and harsher controlB1
- explains a difference, e.g. left realism favours multi-agency prevention while right realism favours tougher policing and punishmentB1
- development noting the contrast in who is helped or targeted, for example left realists aim to help victims and reduce inequality, right realists emphasise control of offendersB1
- Answer: Left realists focus on structural causes, victim support and community-based, multi-agency prevention, while right realists emphasise individual responsibility, deterrence and tougher control; left realism seeks to reduce causes and help communities, whereas right realism stresses punishment and control of offenders.
Question 2
- identifies one realistic partner, e.g. youth services, social services, schools, local housing authority, health services or policeB1
- Answer: Youth services (other acceptable answers include social services, schools, housing authority, health services or police).
Question 3
- identifies community policing increases police presence and visibilityB1
- explains how visibility can reduce fear and deter low-level offendingB1
- identifies community policing builds relationships and trust between police and residentsB1
- explains how improved trust encourages reporting and co-operation, helping tackle crime and support victimsB1
- Answer: Community policing increases visible local police presence, which can deter low-level offending and reduce fear, and it builds relationships and trust so residents are more likely to report crime and cooperate, improving victim support and problem solving.
Question 4
- identifies that a victim centred approach prioritises victims needs and reduces harmB1
- development, e.g. provides practical support, improved reporting channels and restorative measures to help victimsB1
- Answer: A victim centred approach prioritises victims needs and reducing harm, providing practical support, better reporting channels and restorative measures so victims are helped and communities feel safer.
Question 5
- identifies that fear of crime affects quality of life and social cohesionB1
- development, e.g. high fear can reduce community interaction and informal social controlB1
- links this to policy, e.g. reducing fear can help restore neighbourhood order and reduce opportunities for crimeB1
- Answer: Left realists stress local perceptions because fear of crime harms quality of life and social cohesion; high fear reduces community interaction and informal social control, so reducing fear is a key policy aim to restore order and lower crime opportunities.
Question 6
- Level 1 Basic knowledge of left realist ideas with limited application to Item B, minimal analysis and no sustained evaluation. Conclusions, if present, are unsupported.1-3
- Level 2 Some accurate knowledge of left realist concepts and policies with straightforward application to Item B. Some analysis of strengths and weaknesses, but limited depth and an undeveloped conclusion.4-6
- Level 3 Clear and accurate knowledge of left realist explanations and community responses, with good application to Item B. Balanced analysis considering alternative sociological perspectives and evaluation of effectiveness, leading to a reasoned conclusion.7-9
- Level 4 Thorough and accurate knowledge of left realist theory and policies, well applied to Item B. Detailed, balanced evaluation that weighs empirical and theoretical strengths and limitations, compares with other perspectives, and reaches a well-supported, explicit conclusion.10-12
- Indicative content:
- Explain left realist causes: relative deprivation, marginalisation, subcultural responses, and the square of crime linking offender, victim, state and public.
- Apply to Item B: low employment links to marginalisation; rising petty theft linked to relative deprivation; poor relations with police increase distrust and underreporting, fitting the square of crime idea.
- Strengths of left realism: focuses on real victims and local-level causes, offers practical, community-focused policies such as multi-agency work and victim support, can restore trust and reduce fear.
- Limitations and criticisms: may underplay deeper structural causes of crime and capitalism, risk of insufficient resources for multi-agency schemes, potential to neglect long-term economic change, and evidence on effectiveness may be mixed.
- Compare other perspectives: right realism emphasises control and deterrence which may reduce short term offending but neglects root causes; Marxist approaches stress class structure and capitalism as underlying causes; interactionism highlights meanings and labelling which left realism accepts only partially.
- Evaluation of policy: community policing and job initiatives may reduce petty crime in the short term, but without broader economic investment and tackling inequality their effects may be limited. Consider evidence for mixed outcomes and the importance of local implementation.
- Conclusion should weigh evidence and argue whether left realist explanations and community solutions are convincing overall, for example useful and pragmatic but incomplete without wider structural change.
Question 7
- identifies multi-agency prevention as coordinated action by local agencies such as police, youth services, housing and health to prevent crimeB1
- development, e.g. explains the aim is to combine resources to tackle causes, help victims and reduce opportunities for crimeB1
- Answer: Community-based multi-agency prevention is coordinated action by local partners such as police, youth services, housing and health to prevent crime, aiming to combine resources to tackle causes, help victims and reduce opportunities for offending.
Question 8
- identifies that relative deprivation is feeling deprived compared with others or with expected standards, not absolute poverty (oe)B1
- development, e.g. left realists link relative deprivation to frustration and rising crime where people compare themselves unfavourably with othersB1
- Answer: Relative deprivation is feeling deprived compared with others or with expected standards rather than absolute poverty; left realists link it to frustration that can increase offending when people see unfair gaps between expectations and reality.
Question 9
- identifies marginalisation as exclusion from jobs, organisations and political voiceB1
- development, e.g. marginalised groups lack clear organised means to improve their situationB1
- links marginalisation to higher rates of unorganised or utilitarian crimeB1
- further development, e.g. marginalisation can produce anger and a search for identity or income through subcultural or criminal activitiesB1
- Answer: Marginalisation means being excluded from secure employment, political voice and organised groups; without legitimate channels to improve their position, marginalised people may resort to unorganised or utilitarian crime, and may seek identity or resources through subcultural or criminal activity.
Question 10
- identifies the four elements: offender, victim, state and publicB1
- development, e.g. explains that interaction between these four produces the social reality of crimeB1
- Answer: Young's square of crime comprises four elements, offender, victim, state and public, and left realists argue crime is best understood by the interactions between these elements in a community.
Question 11
- identifies a community-based policy, e.g. multi-agency youth outreach, environmental improvements, or local CCTV combined with community oversightB1
- development, e.g. explains how the policy aims to reduce opportunities for crime or increase informal social controlB1
- further development, e.g. links the policy to left realist goals of helping victims and reducing root causesB1
- Answer: An example is multi-agency youth outreach combining youth workers, local police and job advisors to provide activities, employment help and positive supervision; this reduces opportunities for crime, increases informal social control and addresses root causes in line with left realist aims.
Question 12
- identifies a recognised criticism, e.g. that left realism accepts the reality of crime but underplays structural class analysis or fails to challenge capitalism strongly enoughB1
- brief development, e.g. Marxists argue left realism does not fully explain wider economic causesB1
- Answer: A common criticism is that left realism accepts the reality of crime but underestimates deeper structural causes tied to capitalism, with Marxists arguing it does not offer a strong enough critique of economic inequality.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.