Functionalist and Marxist Perspectives on the Family - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
11 original exam-style questions - 3 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Functionalist and Marxist Perspectives on the Family revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Sociology practice
This topic is chapter 9 of A Level Sociology Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 9 of A Level Sociology 10-Minute Tests.
2.1 Functionalist and Marxist Perspectives on the Family
Question 1
- identifies a recognised criticism, e.g. it is deterministic and ignores family diversityB1
- brief development, e.g. critics argue many family types coexist and the nuclear family is not universally dominantB1
- Answer: A criticism is that Parsons' view is deterministic and ignores diversity, since many different family types coexist and the nuclear family is not universally dominant even in industrial societies.
Question 2
- identifies a first difference, e.g. Murdock sees universal positive functions while Engels sees the family as reproducing class inequalityB1
- explains the difference, e.g. Murdock presents functions as beneficial to all societies, Engels sees the family as historically specific and serving ruling class interestsB1
- identifies a second difference, e.g. Murdock focuses on social order and stability, Engels focuses on inheritance and ownershipB1
- explains the difference, e.g. Murdock's approach is functionalist and consensual, Engels is conflict-oriented and emphasises economic causesB1
- Answer: Murdock presents the family as performing universal, generally beneficial functions supporting social order, while Engels argues the family historically developed to protect private property and reproduce class inequalities; Murdock is consensual and functionalist, Engels is conflict-based and economic in focus.
Question 3
- identifies ISA idea: institutions like the family transmit ideology that supports the state and ruling classB1
- development, e.g. the family socialises children into acceptance of existing class structures and capitalist relationsB1
- Answer: Althusser argued the family is an Ideological State Apparatus because it helps transmit ruling-class ideology, socialising children to accept existing class structures and capitalist relations.
Question 4
- identifies one limitation: the functions Murdock assigns to the family may also be carried out by other institutionsB1
- development: this challenges the claim that the family is universally necessary to perform those functions, since they need not depend on the family aloneB1
- further development or example, e.g. some functions may be performed by other institutions like schools or the stateB1
- Answer: One limitation is that the functions Murdock assigns to the family may also be carried out by other institutions. For example, schools provide formal education and the state can provide economic support through welfare. This challenges the claim that the family is universally necessary to perform these functions, since they need not depend on the family alone. Diversity of family form does not itself show that a function is absent: whether a family performs a function must be considered separately from its structure.
Question 5
- Level 1 Basic statements about the family and capitalism with limited use of sociological ideas. Little or no development or evaluation. Conclusions, if present, are unsupported.1-3
- Level 2 Some relevant sociological knowledge and description of Marxist claims that the family benefits capitalism. Limited engagement with alternative perspectives and limited evaluation. Conclusion may be simplistic.4-6
- Level 3 Clear explanation of Marxist views that the family serves capitalist interests, with some developed counter-arguments from functionalist and feminist perspectives. Good use of sociological evidence and concepts, and an attempt at evaluation leading to a reasoned conclusion.7-9
- Level 4 Detailed and balanced answer: well-developed Marxist analysis (Engels, Zaretsky, Althusser) explaining how the family reproduces labour power, ideology and private property, combined with substantial, developed counter-arguments from functionalism, feminism and interactionism. Evaluation addresses strengths and limitations of Marxist accounts and reaches a supported, qualified judgement.10-12
- Indicative content:
- Marxist agreement: Engels argued the family developed to protect private property and ensure inheritance, serving the bourgeoisie.
- Marxist agreement: Zaretsky argued the family reproduces labour power, provides emotional support that stabilises workers and acts as a unit of consumption, sustaining capitalism.
- Marxist agreement: Althusser saw the family as an Ideological State Apparatus, socialising children into acceptance of capitalist relations and legitimising inequality.
- Support for Marxism: empirical examples where families transmit wealth and class advantage, consumer culture targeted at families, roles that reproduce gendered labour power.
- Functionalist counter-argument: Parsons and Murdock claim the family performs necessary universal functions for social order and is not simply an instrument of capitalist class interests.
- Feminist critique: some feminists accept Marxist points about class but argue patriarchy within the family benefits men as well as capitalists, so class is not the only power structure reproduced.
- Interactionist critique: focus on family as site of action and meaning, suggesting families can resist or reinterpret capitalist ideology rather than simply reproduce it.
- Empirical and methodological limitations of Marxism: tends to be deterministic and economically reductionist, may overstate the unity of family interests and underplay diversity of family experience.
- Evaluation could conclude that Marxist theories offer powerful insights into links between family and capitalism, especially over inheritance and ideology, but that they need to be combined with other perspectives to account for gender, agency and family diversity. On balance a qualified agreement is plausible, with reservations.
Question 6
- identifies that primary socialisation is the process where young children learn basic norms and valuesB1
- development, e.g. this learning is carried out mainly within the family during early childhood and prepares children for adult roles in industrial societyB1
- Answer: Primary socialisation is the process by which young children learn basic norms and values; Parsons saw this happening mainly within the family during early childhood, preparing children for adult roles in industrial society.
Question 7
- identifies one function, e.g. reproductionB1
- explains how it fits Murdock's idea, e.g. reproduction provides new members to sustain societyB1
- identifies a second function, e.g. economic supportB1
- explains how it fits Murdock's idea, e.g. the family provides food, shelter and financial support for membersB1
- Answer: Example: reproduction, which provides new members needed to maintain society; and economic support, where the family supplies food, shelter and care for dependent members.
Question 8
- identifies the warm bath idea: the family soothes adults after workB1
- development, e.g. the family's emotional support helps restore adults, making them effective at workB1
- further development or example, e.g. affectionate family relationships reduce stress and help social stabilityB1
- Answer: The warm bath idea is that the family soothes adults after the stresses of work; the emotional support and affection provided by family life helps restore and stabilise adult personalities so people can return to work refreshed and maintain social order.
Question 9
- identifies Engels' claim that the monogamous nuclear family developed alongside private property to ensure inheritance of wealthB1
- development, e.g. Engels argued this benefitted men and helped reproduce class inequality across generationsB1
- Answer: Engels argued that the monogamous nuclear family emerged with private property so men could pass on wealth to legitimate heirs; this change served to reproduce class inequalities and benefit the bourgeoisie.
Question 10
- identifies one Marxist view, e.g. the family serves capitalism by guaranteeing inheritance of private property (Engels)B1
- explains the link, e.g. monogamy and the nuclear family help ensure clear lines of descent and property transmissionB1
- identifies a second Marxist view, e.g. the family acts as a unit of consumption and ideological support (Zaretsky, Althusser)B1
- explains the link, e.g. families buy goods the capitalist system produces and socialise children into accepting capitalist values, cushioning the system from challengeB1
- Answer: Marxist views include Engels' claim that the family developed to protect inheritance of private property, reproducing class inequality, and Zaretsky/Althusser's view that the family functions as a unit of consumption and ideological apparatus, socialising members into accepting capitalist norms.
Question 11
- identifies the core idea that family structure fits the needs of the wider society, e.g. nuclear family fits industrial societyB1
- development, e.g. extended families suited pre-industrial societies with stable local economiesB1
- further development, e.g. industrial societies need geographically mobile, socially flexible nuclear familiesB1
- example or consequence, e.g. the nuclear family supports a mobile labour force and clear role divisionsB1
- Answer: Parsons' functional fit theory claims family structure changes to fit society's needs: extended families fit pre-industrial, locally rooted economies, while industrial society demands geographically mobile nuclear families with clear role divisions, which better support a mobile labour force.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.