The Eucharist Debate: Transubstantiation and Memorialism Compared - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
8 original exam-style questions - 3 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
The Eucharist Debate: Transubstantiation and Memorialism Compared revision guideMore GCSE Religious Studies practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 5 of GCSE Religious Studies Topic Workbook 2 and chapter 20 of GCSE Religious Studies 10-Minute Tests 1.
2.12 The Eucharist Debate: Transubstantiation and Memorialism Compared
Question 1
- reference to Jesus's words at the Last Supper being taken literally, for example 'this is my body', oeB1
- appeal to Church teaching and authority, for example the teaching of the Catholic Church and councils, that the substance changes though appearances remain, oeB1
- Answer: E.g. taking Jesus's words at the Last Supper literally, 'this is my body'; appeal to Church teaching that the substance changes though accidents remain the same.
Question 2
- one valid link between Eucharistic belief and frequency, e.g. belief in real presence and sacramental grace encourages frequent Communion, such as weekly or daily Catholic Mass, oeB1
- a second distinct valid link, e.g. some memorialist churches celebrate monthly or quarterly because the rite is a periodic remembrance; others celebrate weekly to obey the command to remember Jesus, oeB1
- a third distinct valid link, e.g. Quakers or the Salvation Army emphasise inward spiritual communion and do not celebrate an outward Communion rite, oe; accept other accurate links to frequency, but a rule about who receives needs an explained effect on frequencyB1
- Answer: Any three valid links, e.g. real-presence belief can encourage frequent Communion, such as weekly or daily Catholic Mass; some memorialist churches hold a monthly or quarterly remembrance, while others break bread weekly; Quakers and the Salvation Army emphasise inward spiritual communion and do not hold the outward rite. Frequency varies within traditions.
Question 3
- one relevant Bible passage with a correct brief reason, e.g. 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 (Last Supper words and remembrance), Luke 22:19-20 (remembrance), John 6:51-58 (bread of life/real presence), Matthew 26:26-28 or Mark 14:22-24 (Last Supper), 1 Corinthians 10:16 (participation in Christ's body and blood), oeB1
- a second, distinct relevant passage with a correct brief reason, oe; any valid passage may earn any of the three marksB1
- a third, distinct relevant passage with a correct brief reason, oe; no particular passage is compulsoryB1
- Answer: 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 (Last Supper words); Luke 22:19-20 (do this in remembrance of me); John 6:51-58 (language about eating flesh and drinking blood used to argue for real presence). Any three relevant passages with correct reasons are credited, e.g. also Matthew 26:26-28, Mark 14:22-24, 1 Corinthians 10:16.
Question 4
- meaning 1: Real Presence can mean a literal, substantial presence of Christ in the elements, as in transubstantiation, oeB1
- explanation 1: this holds that though the appearances remain bread and wine, their substance is changed into Christ, oeB1
- meaning 2: Real Presence can mean that Christ is truly present without the bread and wine changing substance: in Lutheran teaching his body and blood are present 'in, with and under' the bread and wine (a sacramental union, sometimes called consubstantiation, a label Lutherans themselves reject), and in Reformed (Calvinist) teaching he is spiritually present and received by faith, oeB1
- explanation 2: this view rejects transubstantiation (the bread and wine remain bread and wine) but affirms that Christ is truly present to believers in Communion, oeB1
- Answer: E.g. Real Presence as literal substantial change (transubstantiation); Real Presence as Christ truly present without any change of substance (the Lutheran sacramental union, 'in, with and under' the bread and wine, or the Reformed view of a spiritual presence received by faith).
Question 5
- point 1: strong reverence and ritual towards the consecrated elements, because they are believed to be Christ's real presence, oeB1
- development: this leads to practices such as reservation of the consecrated host and careful handling and distribution, oeB1
- point 2: strict rules about who may receive Communion, reflecting belief that Communion is reception of Christ and requires proper spiritual readiness, oeB1
- development: this can lead to confession and preparation before receiving, and to closed Communion with non-Catholics in some contexts, oeB1
- Answer: E.g. heightened reverence and reservation of the consecrated host; stricter rules on reception and preparation for communicants, both arising from belief in real presence.
Question 6
- Level 3 A well-structured answer that explains several ways the Eucharist debate affects unity and identity, with clear evidence and developed reasoning showing impact across denominations.5-6
- Level 2 An answer that explains some relevant effects on unity and identity, with reasonable supporting detail but limited development.3-4
- Level 1 A simple answer that makes one or two basic points about the debate's importance, with little development.1-2
- Level 0 No relevant content.0
- Indicative content:
- Doctrinal difference over the presence of Christ can create clear theological boundaries between traditions, shaping denominational identity.
- Practical consequences such as closed Communion or differing frequency of celebration reinforce separate identities and worship patterns.
- Disagreement can hinder full visible unity but also provide a focus for ecumenical dialogue where churches work to understand each other's theology.
- For individual believers the debate can affect belonging, for example whether they feel welcome at another church's Communion service.
- Some reconciliatory approaches, such as recognizing different valid understandings while sharing other forms of fellowship, show the debate is important but not always decisive for cooperation.
Question 7
- Level 1 A limited response offering basic, undeveloped points for or against transubstantiation with little reference to Christian theology.1-3
- Level 2 A response that gives some developed reasons for and against the view, with reference to Christian teaching, but with limited analysis or balance.4-6
- Level 3 A clear, balanced response that develops arguments for and against transubstantiation, refers to Christian sources and shows awareness of counterarguments.7-9
- Level 4 A thorough, well-reasoned evaluation that considers theological, scriptural and practical arguments on both sides, engages with counterarguments and reaches a justified, supported conclusion.10-12
- Indicative content:
- Arguments for transubstantiation: literal reading of Jesus's words at the Last Supper, the continuity of historic Church teaching, and the theological coherence of sacraments as means of grace.
- Arguments against transubstantiation: memorialist emphasis on remembering Jesus based on 1 Corinthians 11, the challenge of an undetectable metaphysical change, and the Protestant stress on faith rather than ritual change.
- Christian arguments in the middle: Lutheran or Reformed 'real presence' views that affirm Christ is truly present without claiming a change of substance, offering a compromise position.
- Practical considerations: transubstantiation explains reverence and pastoral practice around Communion but may create barriers to ecumenical sharing; memorialism supports frequent, open Communion but may seem to deny Christ's presence to Catholics.
- A supported conclusion will weigh scriptural interpretation, the role of Church authority, and pastoral effects, and may argue which explanation is more convincing for particular theological priorities.
Question 8
- Level 1 A limited response offering basic assertions about memorialism with little development or theological reference.1-3
- Level 2 A response that gives some reasons supporting and opposing memorialism, with some reference to scripture or tradition.4-6
- Level 3 A balanced response that develops points for and against memorialism, including Christian theological arguments and implications for worship.7-9
- Level 4 A thorough evaluation that weighs scriptural, theological and practical evidence, addresses counterarguments, and reaches a clear, justified conclusion.10-12
- Indicative content:
- Arguments for memorialism: it directly follows Jesus's command to remember as recorded in 1 Corinthians 11:24-25 and Luke 22:19, and it highlights the ethical memory of Christ's sacrifice.
- Arguments against memorialism: it may be criticised for reducing the sacrament to symbolism and for not accounting for other biblical texts, such as John 6, which some read as implying a deeper presence.
- Christian alternatives: Catholic transubstantiation and Lutheran or Reformed real-presence positions argue that remembrance does not exclude a true presence of Christ, offering different theological explanations.
- Practical implications: memorialism supports frequent, inclusive celebrations focusing on community and remembrance, but critics argue this approach may lack the theological depth some believers seek.
- A well-reasoned conclusion will consider which theological priorities are most persuasive, such as scriptural literalism, the authority of tradition, or pastoral outcomes in congregational life.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.