Suffering Caused and Relieved by Punishment - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
7 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Suffering Caused and Relieved by Punishment revision guideMore GCSE Religious Studies practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 14 of GCSE Religious Studies Topic Workbook 7 and chapter 12 of GCSE Religious Studies 10-Minute Tests 4.
9.6 Suffering Caused and Relieved by Punishment
Question 1
- (a) a person who has been directly harmed by a crime, e.g. physically, emotionally or financially, oeB1
- (a) Answer: A person who has been directly harmed by a crime, e.g. physically, emotionally or financially.
- (b) making amends for harm caused, e.g. by paying compensation or by an apology, oeB1
- (b) Answer: Making amends for harm caused, e.g. by paying compensation or by an apology.
- (c) money or another form of payment given to make up for harm or loss caused, oeB1
- (c) Answer: Money or another form of payment given to make up for harm or loss caused.
- (d) practical and emotional help given to a victim of crime, e.g. by charities or support services, oeB1
- (d) Answer: Practical and emotional help given to a victim of crime, e.g. by charities or support services.
- (e) pain or hardship, physical, emotional or financial, experienced as a result of a crime or its punishment, oeB1
- (e) Answer: Pain or hardship, physical, emotional or financial, experienced as a result of a crime or its punishment.
Question 2
- the victim of the crime can suffer physical, emotional or financial harm, oeB1
- the offender can suffer through the punishment itself, e.g. the loss of liberty in prison, oeB1
- the offender's family can suffer, e.g. through loss of income or the stigma of having a family member in prison, oeB1
- Answer: Any three: victims can suffer physical, emotional or financial harm; offenders can suffer through the punishment itself; offenders' families can also suffer, e.g. loss of income or stigma.
Question 3
- point 1: some Christian teaching holds that the suffering caused by punishment, e.g. discipline, can serve a positive purpose if it leads to genuine change, oeB1
- development: 'No discipline seems pleasant at the time, but painful. Later on, however, it produces a harvest of righteousness and peace' (Hebrews 12:11), oeB1
- point 2: Islamic teaching on qisas holds that the possibility of punishment, even where it causes suffering, protects society and can save lives, oeB1
- development: 'there is for you in legal retribution [saving of] life... that you may become righteous' (Qur'an 2:179), oeB1
- Answer: E.g. suffering through discipline producing later good (Hebrews 12:11); qisas as protecting life even where it causes suffering (Qur'an 2:179).
Question 4
- view 1: some argue this suffering, while regrettable, is an unavoidable consequence of a proportionate punishment for the original crime, oeB1
- development: this can be supported by the general principle of proportionate justice in Exodus 21:23-25, oeB1
- view 2: others argue the suffering of an innocent family, e.g. children losing a parent to prison, should be reduced wherever possible, such as through community sentences, oeB1
- development: this can draw on teaching about compassion for the vulnerable, e.g. Matthew 25:40, 'whatever you did for one of the least of these... you did for me', oeB1
- reference to a source of wisdom and authority made accurately, oeB1
- Answer: Contrast: an offender's family's suffering as an unavoidable consequence of proportionate justice (Exodus 21:23-25) vs a view that this suffering should be minimised out of compassion for the vulnerable (Matthew 25:40).
Question 5
- (a) the victim of the crime, or the offender's family, or the wider community, oeB1
- (a) Answer: E.g. the victim of the crime (also accept: the offender's family; the wider community).
- (b) compensation or reparation paid to the victim, oeB1
- (b) support services offered to the victim or to the offender's family, oeB1
- (b) Answer: E.g. compensation to the victim; support services for the victim or the offender's family (also accept: restorative justice meetings; rehabilitation that reduces future offending).
- (c) point 1: many Christians believe they have a duty to help carry the burdens of those who are suffering, oeB1
- (c) development: 'Carry each other's burdens, and in this way you will fulfil the law of Christ' (Galatians 6:2), oeB1
- (c) point 2: many Muslims believe relieving another person's suffering is of the highest importance, oeB1
- (c) development: 'whoever saves one [life], it is as if he had saved mankind entirely' (Qur'an 5:32), oeB1
- (c) Answer: E.g. the duty to carry others' burdens (Galatians 6:2); the high value placed on relieving harm and saving life (Qur'an 5:32).
- (d) view 1: many argue the community has a primary duty to support victims of crime, e.g. through victim support services and compensation, oeB1
- (d) development: this can be supported by teaching to carry the burdens of those who are suffering (Galatians 6:2), applied to victims specifically, oeB1
- (d) view 2: others argue that supporting an offender's rehabilitation also relieves suffering, because it reduces the number of future victims, oeB1
- (d) development: on this view, relieving suffering is not only about the present victim but about preventing future harm to others, oeB1
- (d) reference to a source of wisdom and authority or another appropriate source made accurately, oeB1
- (d) Answer: Contrast: primary focus on supporting current victims (Galatians 6:2) vs a wider focus that includes offender rehabilitation to prevent future victims' suffering.
- (e) L4 A well-argued, balanced answer that considers more than one point of view in a developed way, using accurate and detailed references to religious teaching and/or scripture to support each point, and reaches a clear, justified conclusion.10-12
- (e) L3 A clear and reasoned answer that considers more than one point of view, supported by relevant references to religious teaching and/or scripture, though the justification of the conclusion may be less developed.7-9
- (e) L2 A reasoned answer that considers at least one point of view, with some relevant supporting evidence, but with limited or no consideration of an alternative view.4-6
- (e) L1 One or more relevant points are made, but with little or no supporting evidence and no reasoned conclusion.1-3
- (e) L0 No relevant content.0
- (e) Indicative content:
- Note for markers: this question can be answered with either conclusion; credit any well-supported argument, whether it agrees, disagrees, or takes a middle position.
- Agree: victims can suffer lasting physical, emotional and financial harm, and some argue the justice system has historically focused more on offenders than on properly supporting victims.
- Agree: Galatians 6:2's teaching to 'carry each other's burdens' is often applied to supporting victims specifically, since they did not choose the harm done to them.
- Agree: without strong victim support, some argue confidence in the justice system as a whole is weakened, since victims may feel forgotten.
- Disagree: Qur'an 5:32 teaches that saving one life is like saving all mankind, which some use to argue that preventing future crime, including through offender rehabilitation, ultimately protects future victims too.
- Disagree: if a system focuses only on the current victim and ignores rehabilitation, an unreformed offender may go on to create more victims, so some argue this is not truly in victims' long-term interests either.
- Disagree: 'always the top priority' may be too strong, since a justice system also has duties to protect the wider public and to act fairly towards the accused and convicted.
- A balanced answer might conclude that supporting victims must always be a central priority, but that this is best achieved alongside, not instead of, measures that reduce future offending and so future victims' suffering.
Question 6
- point 1: many Humanists argue that reducing overall human suffering, wherever it falls, should guide how punishment is designed, oeB1
- development: this can lead to support for punishments that are proportionate and that avoid unnecessary suffering, e.g. to an offender's innocent family, while still holding the offender accountable, oeB1
- point 2: some argue that practical, evidence-based support for victims, such as counselling and compensation schemes, matters more than religious concepts such as sin, oeB1
- development: on this view, the state and community, not only the offender, share responsibility for relieving a victim's suffering, oeB1
- Answer: E.g. a utilitarian, suffering-minimising Humanist argument; a practical, evidence-based case for victim support.
Question 7
- financial loss, e.g. through theft, damage or being unable to work, oeB1
- emotional or psychological harm, e.g. fear, anxiety or distress, oeB1
- a lasting loss of a sense of safety or trust, oeB1
- Answer: Any three: financial loss; emotional or psychological harm; a lasting loss of a sense of safety or trust.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.