Reading and Comprehension (Non-Fiction) Set 4 - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
20 original exam-style questions - 7 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Reading and Comprehension (Non-Fiction) Set 4 revision guideMore 13+ Common Entrance practice
This topic is chapter 4 of 13+ English Topic Workbook 3.
1.6-4 Reading and Comprehension (Non-Fiction) Set 4
Nine Souls from the Sea: Grace Darling and the Wreck of the Forfarshire
Original narrative account written for Revision Library, grounded in the real events of the wreck of the Forfarshire and Grace Darling's rescue of its survivors in September 1838; no historical document or past-paper text reproduced verbatim.
[1] Longstone Lighthouse stands on a bare outcrop of rock in the Farne Islands, some six kilometres off the Northumberland coast, surrounded on every side by a cold, restless sea. In September 1838, the lighthouse was home to William Darling, its keeper of more than twenty years, his wife, and their youngest daughter, twenty-two-year-old Grace. Visitors were rare and supplies came only by boat from the mainland, so the family had grown used to a life measured out by the turning of the great lamp above their heads and the endless, changing moods of the water below.
[2] On the night of the 6th of September, a fierce storm swept in from the north-east, driving heavy seas across the islands and reducing visibility to almost nothing. Somewhere out in the darkness, the paddle steamer Forfarshire, carrying more than forty passengers and crew from Hull to Dundee, was already in serious trouble. One of its two engines had failed hours earlier, leaving the vessel dangerously underpowered against the wind and current. Unable to fight clear of the rocks, the ship struck the jagged reef of Big Harcar with tremendous force in the early hours of the following morning, and within minutes had broken apart into two pieces, the stern section sinking almost immediately beneath the waves.
[3] At first light, Grace happened to glance out of an upstairs window and, through the driving rain, made out a dark shape on the rocks nearly a mile away. Raising her father's telescope to her eye, she realised with a jolt that the shape was moving: survivors, clinging to the exposed reef as waves broke over them again and again. William Darling studied the churning water for a long moment and judged the crossing too dangerous even to attempt. Grace refused to accept this, and after further argument he agreed to try, on one condition: with the two of them alone at the lighthouse, only a small rowing boat called a coble could be launched, and it would carry just the pair of them across open water that had already claimed a ship twice the coble's size.
[4] Rowing side by side, father and daughter steered the coble along the sheltered side of the islands before turning directly into open water, where the full force of the storm caught them. Grace fought the oars for nearly a mile, her arms burning, while her father worked to keep the small boat pointed into the waves and clear of submerged rock. When they finally reached Big Harcar, they found nine survivors still alive, exhausted and half-frozen, clinging to a ledge barely above the reach of the tide. The coble could not carry everyone at once, so William Darling climbed onto the rock with three of the strongest survivors while Grace held the boat steady against the swell, and the little vessel made the perilous crossing twice more before all nine were finally safe.
[5] News of the rescue spread through the newspapers within days, and Grace Darling became, almost overnight, one of the most famous women in Britain. Letters, gifts and marriage proposals arrived at the lighthouse by the sackful, portrait painters queued for the chance to capture her likeness, and the Royal National Institution for the Preservation of Life from Shipwreck awarded both her and her father a silver medal for gallantry. Yet the attention that made her famous also unsettled her; Grace found the constant stream of visitors and requests exhausting, and she remained happiest back at her post on Longstone, tending the lamp with her family. Her health, never especially robust, began to decline within a few years, and in 1842 she was diagnosed with tuberculosis. She died on the 20th of October that year, at Bamburgh, at the age of just twenty-six.
[6] More than a century and a half later, Grace Darling is remembered as one of Britain's best-known maritime heroines. A museum bearing her name stands in Bamburgh, close to the churchyard where she is buried beneath an elaborate stone memorial, and the modern lifeboat charity that today rescues thousands of people around the British coast each year still cites her courage as part of its founding inspiration. It is a striking thought that one difficult decision, made in the grey light of a single September morning, could still be remembered so clearly almost two hundred years later.
- A) they were extremely cold, close to hypothermia
- B) they were half asleep from exhaustion
- C) they were partly injured from the wreck
- D) they had lost half of their belongings
- A) surrounded on every side by a cold, restless sea
- B) Visitors were rare and supplies came only by boat from the mainland
- C) the turning of the great lamp above their heads
- D) their youngest daughter, twenty-two-year-old Grace
- A) not having enough engine power to cope with the conditions
- B) travelling too fast to control safely
- C) carrying too many passengers for its size
- D) badly damaged below the waterline
Question 1
- (a) a piece of rock or land that juts out from its surroundings (oe)B1
- (b) constantly moving, or never calm/still (oe)B1
- Answer: (a) A piece of rock that juts out from its surroundings. (b) Constantly moving, never calm or still.
Question 2
- (a) her father's telescope, caoB1
- (a) Answer: Her father's telescope.
- (b) at first light / dawn, caoB1
- (b) Answer: At first light (dawn).
Question 3
- (a) nine, caoB1
- (a) Answer: Nine.
- (b) nearly a mile, caoB1
- (b) Answer: Nearly a mile.
Question 4
- (a) any one of: letters / gifts / marriage proposals, cao (accept any one)B1
- (a) Answer: Letters (accept gifts or marriage proposals).
- (b) tuberculosis, caoB1
- (b) Answer: Tuberculosis.
Question 5
- Longstone (Lighthouse), caoB1
- Answer: Longstone Lighthouse.
Question 6
- (a) twenty-two (22), caoB1
- (a) Answer: Twenty-two.
- (b) (lighthouse) keeper, caoB1
- (b) Answer: He was the lighthouse keeper.
Question 7
- the 6th of September (1838), caoB1
- Answer: The 6th of September (1838).
Question 8
- (a) a paddle steamer, caoB1
- (a) Answer: A paddle steamer.
- (b) one of its two engines (had failed), caoB1
- (b) Answer: One of its two engines had failed.
Question 9
- he studied the rough/churning sea carefully for a long time before deciding (oe)B1
- he judged that crossing to Big Harcar in such conditions would be too dangerous to attempt (oe)B1
- Answer: He studied the churning water carefully for a long moment and judged that the crossing to Big Harcar was simply too dangerous to attempt, given how rough the sea still was.
Question 10
- A only, caoB1
- Answer: A) they were extremely cold, close to hypothermia.
Question 11
- B only, caoB1
- Answer: B) Visitors were rare and supplies came only by boat from the mainland.
Question 12
- recognises that their days were structured/organised around the rhythms of the lighthouse rather than ordinary life (oe)B1
- developed comment, e.g. suggests a repetitive, disciplined or almost timeless existence, cut off from the outside world (oe)B1
- Answer: It suggests that their sense of time was shaped by the lighthouse itself, its lamp turning again and again, rather than by ordinary daily routines. This creates an impression of a repetitive, disciplined life that felt quite cut off from the outside world.
Question 13
- A only, caoB1
- Answer: A) not having enough engine power to cope with the conditions.
Question 14
- a severe storm blew in from the north-east, badly reducing visibility (oe)B1
- one of the ship's two engines had already failed, leaving it without enough power (oe)B1
- unable to steer clear of the rocks, the ship struck Big Harcar and broke apart into two pieces (oe)B1
- Answer: A severe storm blew in from the north-east and reduced visibility to almost nothing; one of the ship's two engines had already failed, leaving it without enough power against the wind and current; and, unable to steer clear of the rocks, it struck Big Harcar and broke apart into two pieces.
Question 15
- identifies that only a small rowing boat, called a coble, was available (oe)B1
- identifies that, with only Grace and her father at the lighthouse, the coble could only be rowed by the two of them (oe)B1
- explains the risk: they had to cross open water that had already wrecked a ship far bigger than their boat, showing how vulnerable the coble was by comparison (oe)B1
- Answer: The only boat available was a small rowing boat called a coble, and because just Grace and her father were at the lighthouse, it could only be rowed by the two of them. This was especially risky because the same open water had already wrecked a ship twice the coble's size, showing how vulnerable such a small boat would be in those conditions.
Question 16
- identifies an apt quotation, e.g. 'her arms burning' (any apt quotation showing physical strain)B1
- explains the effect of quotation 1, e.g. conveys the extreme pain and effort Grace endured while rowing against the storm (oe)B1
- identifies a second, different apt quotation, e.g. 'the little vessel made the perilous crossing twice more'B1
- explains the effect of quotation 2, e.g. 'perilous' emphasises the danger of each crossing, while 'twice more' shows the sheer scale of repeated risk needed to save everyone (oe)B1
- Answer: The detail 'her arms burning' conveys the extreme physical pain and effort Grace endured while rowing against the storm. The phrase 'the little vessel made the perilous crossing twice more' emphasises, through the word 'perilous', just how dangerous each crossing was, while 'twice more' shows the sheer scale of repeated risk needed to bring all nine survivors to safety.
Question 17
- recognises the irony: despite becoming hugely famous, Grace herself found the fame exhausting/unsettling and preferred her quiet life at the lighthouse (oe)B1
- developed comment, e.g. this challenges the idea that fame automatically brings happiness, or shows a mismatch between public admiration and Grace's own wishes (oe)B1
- Answer: It is ironic because although Grace became one of the most famous women in Britain, she found all the attention exhausting and unsettling, and was actually happiest back doing her ordinary work at the lighthouse. This shows a clear mismatch between how the public saw her and what she herself actually wanted.
Question 18
- recognises the ordering creates a contrast, moving from celebration to decline (oe)B1
- developed comment on effect, e.g. makes her early death feel more tragic or poignant by contrast with the height of her fame, or mirrors the swift rise and fall of her short life (oe)B1
- Answer: Describing her fame first creates a sharp contrast with the decline and death that follow, moving the reader from celebration to loss within a single paragraph. This makes her early death feel more tragic and poignant, mirroring how quickly her extraordinary fame gave way to a short life cut off by illness.
Question 19
- Level 1 Identifies a detail or technique with little or no explanation of how it contributes to a sense of courage; may retell events rather than analyse the writing.1-2
- Level 2 Explains, with some development, how one or two paragraphs contribute to a sense of courage, supported by relevant reference to the text.3-4
- Level 3 Gives a clear, well-developed explanation of how at least three paragraphs work together to build a cumulative sense of courage, with precise textual reference and secure understanding of the text's overall structure.5-6
- Indicative content:
- paragraph [1] establishes the isolated, exposed setting, so the reader understands from the outset how dangerous the family's environment already is
- paragraph [2] raises the stakes further by describing the severity of the storm and the scale of the wreck, showing what any would-be rescuer would be up against
- paragraph [3] shows Grace actively pushing for the rescue despite her father's caution, positioning her as the driving force behind the decision to act
- paragraph [4] gives a detailed, physical account of the rescue itself (the mile of rowing, three crossings to save nine people), letting the reader feel the scale of the physical courage required
- paragraph [5] complicates a simple picture of heroism by showing Grace uncomfortable with fame, which arguably reinforces her courage as genuine rather than attention-seeking
- paragraph [6] closes by placing her courage in a lasting, national context, broadening a personal act into an enduring legacy
- the chronological structure throughout builds cumulatively, each paragraph raising the stakes or adding a new dimension to the reader's understanding of her courage
Question 20
- Level 1 Simple agreement or disagreement with little or no reference to the text; general, unsupported comment.1-2
- Level 2 Some relevant comment on either the rescue or its aftermath, with limited textual reference; a one-sided or partial view.3-4
- Level 3 Clear, supported comparison of the rescue and its aftermath, with relevant quotation or close reference to both paragraphs [3]/[4] and paragraph [5], reaching a reasoned judgement.5-6
- Level 4 A sophisticated, balanced response that weighs the rescue and its aftermath precisely against each other, integrates well-chosen textual reference throughout, and reaches a considered, well-justified personal judgement, potentially recognising how the two parts work together.7-8
- Indicative content:
- candidates agreeing with the statement might focus on paragraph [5]: the strangeness of instant celebrity, gifts arriving 'by the sackful', and the quiet dignity of Grace finding fame 'unsettled' her and preferring ordinary lighthouse work, as more thought-provoking than the physical rescue itself
- candidates disagreeing might argue that paragraphs [3] and [4] are the true heart of the account, showing physical courage and quick decision-making under extreme danger (the mile of rowing, three crossings, nine lives saved) that overshadows anything that follows
- candidates might note that paragraph [6] only makes sense as a consequence of the rescue, suggesting the rescue, not the aftermath, is structurally the account's true climax
- a balanced answer might argue the aftermath is only impressive because of what came before it: the fame described in paragraph [5] only carries weight because paragraphs [3] and [4] have already shown exactly what Grace risked and achieved
- credit any well-supported view, whether the candidate ultimately privileges the rescue, the aftermath, or judges them as equally impressive, provided the judgement is backed by close, accurate reference to the text
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.