A Level Paper 2: Government Institutions
Practice questions on the constitution, Parliament, the Prime Minister and executive, relations between the branches of government, and devolution and multi-level governance.
Questions
Question 1 [2 marks]
Relations Between the Branches
State two grounds on which a court can find a public body's decision unlawful in judicial review.
Question 2 [2 marks]
The Prime Minister and Executive
State two features of the doctrine of collective Cabinet responsibility.
Question 3 [3 marks]
Relations Between the Branches
Identify three ways in which judges are appointed independently of the government in the UK.
Question 4 [3 marks]
The Constitution
Identify three functions that a codified constitution typically performs in political systems that have one.
Question 5 [3 marks]
Devolution and Multi-level Governance
Identify the three nations of the United Kingdom, other than England, that have their own devolved legislature or assembly.
Question 6 [4 marks]
The Constitution
The Constitutional Reform Act 2005 made significant changes to the UK's judicial and constitutional arrangements.
Explain two changes made by the Constitutional Reform Act 2005.
Question 7 [4 marks]
Devolution and Multi-level Governance
Devolution in the UK is often described as asymmetric.
Explain two ways in which devolution across the UK is asymmetric.
Question 8 [5 marks]
Parliament
The Commons and the Lords sometimes disagree repeatedly over the same bill as it passes between the two Houses.
Explain what is meant by legislative gridlock between the two Houses, and explain one mechanism that exists to resolve it.
Question 9 [5 marks]
Relations Between the Branches
Judicial review allows the courts to assess the legality of decisions made by public bodies.
Explain two limitations on the effectiveness of judicial review as a check on executive power in the UK, using a named example to support at least one point.
Question 10 [5 marks]
Devolution and Multi-level Governance
England is the only UK nation without its own devolved legislature.
Explain two attempts to address the 'English Question', using a named example to support at least one point.
Question 11 [6 marks]
The Prime Minister and Executive
Explain three ways in which the relationship between the Prime Minister and the Chancellor of the Exchequer can affect the direction of government.
Question 12 [6 marks]
Relations Between the Branches
Explain three ways in which parliamentary sovereignty and judicial independence can be seen as complementary, rather than conflicting, features of the UK constitution.
Question 13 [6 marks]
The Prime Minister and Executive
Explain three ways in which the power of the Prime Minister has been described as 'presidential'.
Question 14 [6 marks]
Parliament
Explain three ways in which select committees are designed to operate independently of government control.
Model solutions
| Question 1[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : illegality, meaning the public body acted beyond the legal powers it was given (ultra vires) | 1 |
| a second valid ground, such as irrationality, meaning the decision was so unreasonable that no reasonable decision-maker could have made it, or procedural impropriety, meaning a fair process was not followed | 1 |
| Final answer: Any two of: illegality (ultra vires); irrationality; procedural impropriety | |
| Question 2[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : ministers must publicly support all Cabinet decisions or resign | 1 |
| a second valid feature, such as Cabinet discussions being kept confidential, or a minister who cannot accept a decision being expected to leave government | 1 |
| Final answer: Any two of: ministers must publicly support Cabinet decisions or resign; Cabinet discussions are kept confidential; a dissenting minister is expected to leave government | |
| Question 3[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : senior judicial appointments being made on the recommendation of the independent Judicial Appointments Commission | 1 |
| : appointments being made on merit through open competition rather than political patronage | 1 |
| a third valid feature, such as the Lord Chancellor's role in appointments being reduced since the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 | 1 |
| Final answer: Any three of: recommendation by the independent Judicial Appointments Commission; appointment on merit through open competition; the reduced role of the Lord Chancellor since 2005 | |
| Question 4[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : setting out and limiting the powers of the different branches of government | 1 |
| : entrenching citizens' rights so they cannot easily be removed by an ordinary law | 1 |
| a third valid function, such as acting as a higher form of law that other legislation must be consistent with, or providing a single authoritative reference point for the rules of government | 1 |
| Final answer: Any three of: setting out and limiting the powers of government branches; entrenching citizens' rights against ordinary legislation; acting as higher law that other legislation must be consistent with; providing a single authoritative reference point | |
| Question 5[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : Scotland | 1 |
| : Wales | 1 |
| : Northern Ireland | 1 |
| Final answer: Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland | |
| Question 6[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first change, such as the creation of a new Supreme Court | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that this replaced the Law Lords sitting as the Appellate Committee of the House of Lords | 1 |
| identifying a second change, such as reforming the role of the Lord Chancellor | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that the Act aimed to strengthen the separation of the judiciary from the legislature and executive | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed points, such as: creation of the Supreme Court to replace the Law Lords; reform of the Lord Chancellor's role to strengthen separation of powers | |
| Question 7[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first way, such as Scotland having a wider range of powers than Wales, including greater tax-varying powers | 1 |
| developing this, such as noting that the Scottish Parliament can vary income tax rates and bands in ways the Senedd cannot to the same extent | 1 |
| identifying a second way, such as England having no single devolved legislature of its own, unlike Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland | 1 |
| developing this, such as noting that England is governed directly by the UK Parliament and government, alongside more limited local devolution deals such as metro mayors | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed points, such as: Scotland holding wider powers, including tax powers, than Wales; England lacking a single devolved legislature unlike the other three nations | |
| Question 8[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| explaining the core idea, such as that legislative gridlock describes a situation where the Commons and the Lords repeatedly disagree over a bill and neither side gives way | 1 |
| developing this, such as describing 'ping-pong', where a bill is passed back and forth between the two Houses as each amends or rejects the other's changes | 1 |
| identifying a mechanism to resolve it, such as the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949 | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that these Acts allow the Commons, in specific circumstances, to pass a bill into law even without the consent of the Lords | 1 |
| a further valid point, such as noting that the mere existence of the Parliament Acts gives the Commons useful leverage in negotiations, since the Lords knows a bill can ultimately proceed without it | 1 |
| Final answer: Legislative gridlock describes the Commons and Lords repeatedly disagreeing over a bill, sometimes through 'ping-pong' as it passes back and forth; the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949 resolve this by allowing the Commons, in specific circumstances, to pass a bill into law without the Lords' consent, which also gives the Commons leverage in negotiation | |
| Question 9[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first limitation, such as the courts being unable to strike down an Act of Parliament because of parliamentary sovereignty | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that judicial review can quash secondary legislation and executive decisions but cannot overturn primary legislation itself | 1 |
| identifying a second limitation, such as the cost and strict time limits involved in bringing a claim | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a claim must normally be brought within three months, and the legal costs involved can deter an individual or a small campaign group from challenging a government decision | 1 |
| a relevant supporting example, such as citing that, even under the Human Rights Act 1998, the highest sanction the courts can impose on primary legislation is a non-binding declaration of incompatibility, which Parliament is not legally required to act on | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed limitations, such as: the courts cannot strike down an Act of Parliament, limited instead to quashing secondary legislation and executive decisions, or issuing a non-binding declaration of incompatibility under the Human Rights Act 1998; strict time limits and legal costs restrict practical access to judicial review | |
| Question 10[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first attempt, such as English Votes for English Laws (EVEL) | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that EVEL gave English MPs a veto stage over legislation applying only to England, before it was abolished in 2021 | 1 |
| identifying a second attempt, such as directly elected metro mayors | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that mayors such as those for Greater Manchester and the West Midlands were given devolved powers over areas such as transport and skills within their regions | 1 |
| a relevant supporting example, such as the Greater Manchester Combined Authority as an example of sub-national devolution within England | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed attempts, such as: English Votes for English Laws (2015 to 2021); directly elected metro mayors with devolved regional powers, such as in Greater Manchester | |
| Question 11[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first way, such as the Chancellor controlling the government's economic and fiscal policy, giving them influence second only to the Prime Minister | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a Chancellor sets the Budget, shaping taxation and spending decisions that affect every other department's policy | 1 |
| identifying a second way, such as a strong working relationship between the two allowing consistent economic and political strategy | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that close cooperation helps ensure the government presents a single, agreed position on economic policy rather than mixed messages | 1 |
| identifying a third way, such as tension between the two undermining the government's authority | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that public disagreement between a Prime Minister and Chancellor can be seen as a sign of division at the heart of government, damaging confidence in its economic policy | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed points, such as: the Chancellor's control of fiscal policy giving them exceptional influence; a strong working relationship allowing consistent economic and political strategy; tension between the two undermining confidence in the government's direction | |
| Question 12[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first way, such as judicial independence allowing courts to check that the executive is acting within the powers that a sovereign Parliament has actually granted it | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that, by enforcing the exact limits of ministers' statutory powers, independent judges uphold rather than undermine what Parliament has legislated | 1 |
| identifying a second way, such as parliamentary sovereignty ultimately guaranteeing that judicial independence itself rests on legislation Parliament could, in principle, change | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that protections such as judges' security of tenure exist because Parliament has legislated for them, showing sovereignty and independence operating together rather than in opposition | 1 |
| identifying a third way, such as the Human Rights Act 1998 combining both principles rather than setting them against each other | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a declaration of incompatibility lets independent judges identify a conflict with rights while leaving the sovereign Parliament the final decision on what to do about it | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed points, such as: independent courts enforcing the exact limits of powers a sovereign Parliament has granted; judicial independence itself resting on protections a sovereign Parliament has legislated for; the Human Rights Act 1998 combining both principles through declarations of incompatibility | |
| Question 13[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first way, such as the Prime Minister's personal media profile dominating election campaigns | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that party leaders are now presented directly to voters through televised debates and personalised campaigning, in a way that echoes a presidential contest | 1 |
| identifying a second way, such as the Prime Minister increasingly bypassing full Cabinet in favour of a small inner circle of advisers | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that this concentrates decision-making around the Prime Minister personally, similar to a president's relationship with their own advisers | 1 |
| identifying a third way, such as the Prime Minister's growing role in setting the overall direction and image of government policy | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that policy is often associated publicly with the Prime Minister personally rather than with the collective government or governing party | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed points, such as: a personalised media and campaign profile; reliance on a small inner circle rather than full Cabinet; policy being associated publicly with the Prime Minister personally | |
| Question 14[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first way, such as committee chairs being elected by the whole House of Commons rather than appointed by the government | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that this election, introduced in 2010, makes a chair harder for party managers to remove or control than when appointments were more heavily influenced by the whips | 1 |
| identifying a second way, such as committee membership reflecting the overall party balance of the Commons rather than being controlled by the government alone | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that this gives opposition and backbench members a guaranteed presence, reducing the government's ability to pack a committee with loyal MPs | 1 |
| identifying a third way, such as committees having the power to summon witnesses, including ministers and civil servants, and to publish their own reports | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a committee decides for itself which inquiries to launch and what its reports will say, rather than these being agreed with government in advance | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed ways, such as: committee chairs elected by the whole House since 2010, rather than appointed; membership reflecting the Commons' overall party balance rather than government control; the power to summon witnesses and publish independent reports | |