AS Paper 2: The Constitution and Government
Practice questions on democracy and participation, electoral systems, the constitution, Parliament, the Prime Minister and executive, and devolution and multi-level governance.
Questions
Question 1 [2 marks]
Electoral Systems
State two advantages of the First Past the Post system.
Question 2 [2 marks]
Democracy and Participation
State two features of representative democracy.
Question 3 [3 marks]
The Prime Minister and Executive
Identify three bodies or resources within Number 10 or the Cabinet Office that support the Prime Minister.
Question 4 [3 marks]
The Constitution
Identify three conventions that operate within the UK constitution.
Question 5 [3 marks]
Democracy and Participation
Identify three arguments made in favour of lowering the UK voting age to 16.
Question 6 [4 marks]
Parliament
Explain two differences in the powers of the House of Commons and the House of Lords.
Question 7 [4 marks]
Democracy and Participation
Pressure groups are often described as either insider or outsider groups.
Explain two ways in which pressure groups can enhance democracy in the UK.
Question 8 [5 marks]
Devolution and Multi-level Governance
England is the only UK nation without its own devolved legislature.
Explain two attempts to address the 'English Question', using a named example to support at least one point.
Question 9 [5 marks]
The Prime Minister and Executive
Government departments are headed by a Secretary of State supported by junior ministers and civil servants.
Explain two ways in which the doctrine of individual ministerial responsibility operates in the UK, using a named example to support at least one point.
Question 10 [5 marks]
Electoral Systems
The Supplementary Vote system was used to elect police and crime commissioners and directly elected mayors in England before 2023.
Explain how the Supplementary Vote system works, and give one reason it is used for these single-office elections rather than First Past the Post.
Question 11 [6 marks]
The Prime Minister and Executive
Explain three ways in which international summitry and diplomacy have increased the public profile of the office of Prime Minister.
Question 12 [6 marks]
Devolution and Multi-level Governance
Explain three arguments against granting Scotland full independence from the rest of the UK.
Question 13 [6 marks]
Electoral Systems
Explain three arguments in favour of retaining First Past the Post for UK general elections.
Question 14 [6 marks]
The Constitution
Explain three arguments in favour of the UK adopting a more entrenched constitution.
Model solutions
| Question 1[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : it usually produces a clear single-party government with a workable majority | 1 |
| a second valid advantage, such as it maintaining a clear single-member link between an MP and their constituency, or being simple for voters to use and quick to count | 1 |
| Final answer: Any two of: usually producing single-party majority government; maintaining a clear single-member constituency link; being simple for voters and quick to count | |
| Question 2[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : citizens elect representatives who make political decisions on their behalf | 1 |
| a second valid feature, such as representatives being held accountable at regular, periodic elections | 1 |
| Final answer: Any two of: citizens elect representatives to decide on their behalf; representatives are accountable at regular elections; decisions are made by elected representatives rather than by direct public vote | |
| Question 3[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : the Prime Minister's Office (Number 10), providing personal policy and political advice | 1 |
| : the Cabinet Office, coordinating policy across government departments | 1 |
| a third valid resource, such as special advisers, or bodies such as the National Security Council | 1 |
| Final answer: Any three of: the Prime Minister's Office (Number 10); the Cabinet Office; special advisers; the National Security Council | |
| Question 4[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : the Salisbury Convention, under which the House of Lords does not block a manifesto commitment of the elected government | 1 |
| : the Sewel Convention, under which Westminster normally seeks the consent of a devolved legislature before legislating on a devolved matter | 1 |
| a third valid convention, such as individual or collective ministerial responsibility, or the convention that the monarch acts on the advice of ministers | 1 |
| Final answer: Any three of: the Salisbury Convention; the Sewel Convention; individual or collective ministerial responsibility; the convention that the monarch acts on ministerial advice | |
| Question 5[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : 16 and 17 year olds pay taxes and can work, so should have a say in how that money is spent | 1 |
| : the voting age has already been lowered to 16 for the Scottish Parliament and Welsh Senedd elections, creating a precedent | 1 |
| : engaging young people earlier builds a habit of voting and may raise long-term turnout | 1 |
| Final answer: Any three of: no taxation without representation; precedent set in Scotland and Wales; other rights already granted at 16; earlier engagement builds a voting habit | |
| Question 6[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first difference, such as only the House of Commons being able to determine the survival of a government through a vote of no confidence | 1 |
| developing this, such as noting that the House of Lords cannot force a government to resign | 1 |
| identifying a second difference, such as the House of Lords being unable to block money bills (it can delay them by only one month) | 1 |
| developing this, such as noting that under the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949 the Lords' power over other bills is limited to delay, not veto | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed points, such as: only the Commons can bring down a government; the Lords cannot block money bills and can only delay other bills under the Parliament Acts | |
| Question 7[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first way, such as pressure groups giving citizens a voice on specific issues between elections | 1 |
| developing this with an example, such as the National Trust representing conservation interests directly to government | 1 |
| identifying a second way, such as pressure groups increasing information available to the public and to Parliament | 1 |
| developing this with an example, such as a group submitting expert evidence to a select committee inquiry | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed points, such as: representing specific interests between elections (e.g. the National Trust); educating the public and Parliament through expert evidence | |
| Question 8[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first attempt, such as English Votes for English Laws (EVEL) | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that EVEL gave English MPs a veto stage over legislation applying only to England, before it was abolished in 2021 | 1 |
| identifying a second attempt, such as directly elected metro mayors | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that mayors such as those for Greater Manchester and the West Midlands were given devolved powers over areas such as transport and skills within their regions | 1 |
| a relevant supporting example, such as the Greater Manchester Combined Authority as an example of sub-national devolution within England | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed attempts, such as: English Votes for English Laws (2015 to 2021); directly elected metro mayors with devolved regional powers, such as in Greater Manchester | |
| Question 9[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first way, such as a minister being accountable to Parliament for their department's policy and performance | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a minister must answer questions and give explanations to Parliament for decisions taken in their department | 1 |
| identifying a second way, such as a minister being expected to resign for serious personal or departmental failure | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a resignation is intended to preserve public confidence in the accountability of ministers, though in practice ministers do not always resign even after serious failures | 1 |
| a relevant supporting example, such as a minister resigning following a serious breach of the Ministerial Code | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed points, such as: ministers answering to Parliament for their department; the expectation, not always followed in practice, that a minister resigns after serious personal or departmental failure, sometimes following a breach of the Ministerial Code | |
| Question 10[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| explaining that voters mark a first and a second choice candidate on the ballot paper | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that if no candidate wins more than half the first-choice votes, all but the top two are eliminated | 1 |
| developing this further, such as explaining that the second choices of eliminated candidates' voters are then added to the two remaining candidates' totals to determine the winner | 1 |
| giving a reason it suits single-office elections, such as it helping to ensure the winning candidate has broader support than a simple plurality | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that, unlike First Past the Post, the winner's total includes second-choice votes from supporters of eliminated candidates, so the winner's support is broader than a bare first-choice plurality | 1 |
| Final answer: Voters rank a first and second choice; if no candidate has a majority of first choices, all but the top two are eliminated and second choices are redistributed between them; it is used for single offices such as mayoralties to give the winner broader support than a simple plurality | |
| Question 11[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first way, such as the Prime Minister regularly representing the UK at international summits, such as meetings of the G7 or NATO | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that this gives the Prime Minister a prominent international role that generates significant domestic media coverage | 1 |
| identifying a second way, such as the growth of direct personal diplomacy between the Prime Minister and other world leaders | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that modern communication allows a Prime Minister to negotiate and build relationships with foreign leaders personally, rather than only through the Foreign Secretary or diplomats | 1 |
| identifying a third way, such as the Prime Minister's role in explaining and defending major international decisions to the domestic public | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that decisions such as military deployment or a major international agreement are typically presented to the public as decisions of the Prime Minister personally, even though they are decided collectively | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed ways, such as: representing the UK personally at summits such as the G7 or NATO, generating domestic coverage; the growth of direct personal diplomacy between leaders; the Prime Minister personally explaining and defending major international decisions to the public | |
| Question 12[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first argument, such as economic uncertainty over currency and public finances | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that an independent Scotland would need to resolve questions such as what currency to use and how to manage a fiscal deficit without the pooling and sharing of resources across the wider UK | 1 |
| identifying a second argument, such as the benefits of remaining within a larger domestic market and defence union | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that Scottish businesses currently trade freely across the whole of the UK, and Scotland benefits from UK-wide defence and security arrangements | 1 |
| identifying a third argument, such as uncertainty over Scotland's relationship with international organisations after independence | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a newly independent Scotland would have to negotiate its own membership of organisations such as the European Union, rather than inheriting the UK's existing arrangements | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed arguments, such as: economic uncertainty over currency and public finances outside the pooling of UK-wide resources; the benefits of remaining within a larger domestic market and shared defence arrangements; uncertainty over negotiating fresh international memberships, such as of the European Union | |
| Question 13[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first argument, such as the system usually producing strong, single-party government | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a government with a workable majority can govern effectively without needing to negotiate with coalition partners | 1 |
| identifying a second argument, such as the clear constituency link it maintains between an MP and their local area | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that each constituency has a single, identifiable MP who is directly accountable to those who elected them | 1 |
| identifying a third argument, such as its simplicity for voters | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that marking a single X is easy to understand and the result is quick to declare, unlike more complex proportional counts | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed arguments, such as: it tends to produce strong single-party government; it maintains a clear single-MP constituency link; it is simple for voters to understand and quick to count | |
| Question 14[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first argument, such as entrenchment providing greater long-term protection for individual rights | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a right protected only by an ordinary Act, such as the Human Rights Act 1998, can be repealed or amended by a simple parliamentary majority, unlike an entrenched right requiring a special procedure to change | 1 |
| identifying a second argument, such as entrenchment providing greater stability and certainty about the rules of government | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that requiring a super-majority or referendum to alter key constitutional provisions makes it harder for a single government to change the rules of the political system for short-term advantage | 1 |
| identifying a third argument, such as entrenchment better protecting the position of minorities or devolved institutions from being overridden by a simple Westminster majority | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that an entrenched guarantee of devolved powers would be harder for a future UK government to reduce unilaterally than the current arrangement, which in law Westminster could alter | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed arguments, such as: stronger long-term protection for rights than an ordinary Act like the Human Rights Act 1998 provides; greater stability by requiring a super-majority or referendum for constitutional change; better protection for minorities or devolved institutions against a simple Westminster majority | |