AS Paper 4: Government in Practice
Practice questions on democracy and participation, political parties, voting behaviour and the media, the constitution, Parliament, the Prime Minister and executive, and devolution and multi-level governance.
Questions
Question 1 [2 marks]
Parliament
State two types of member who sit in the House of Lords.
Question 2 [2 marks]
The Prime Minister and Executive
State two powers exercised by the Prime Minister.
Question 3 [2 marks]
Devolution and Multi-level Governance
State two powers that are devolved to the Welsh Senedd.
Question 4 [3 marks]
Democracy and Participation
Identify three problems associated with representative democracy as it operates in the UK.
Question 5 [3 marks]
The Constitution
Identify three conventions that operate within the UK constitution.
Question 6 [3 marks]
Voting Behaviour and the Media
Identify three factors associated with the rational choice model of voting behaviour.
Question 7 [4 marks]
Political Parties
Explain two advantages that being a broad-based, or 'catch-all', party can bring.
Question 8 [4 marks]
Parliament
Explain two differences in the powers of the House of Commons and the House of Lords.
Question 9 [4 marks]
Devolution and Multi-level Governance
Unlike the Scottish Parliament and the Senedd, the Northern Ireland Executive is built on mandatory power-sharing.
Explain two reasons why power-sharing was built into the government of Northern Ireland.
Question 10 [4 marks]
Parliament
Departmental select committees are a key method by which the House of Commons scrutinises government.
Explain two ways in which select committees hold the executive to account.
Question 11 [4 marks]
The Prime Minister and Executive
Explain two functions performed by Cabinet committees.
Question 12 [5 marks]
Voting Behaviour and the Media
Opinion polls are widely reported during general election campaigns.
Explain two ways in which opinion polls can influence voting behaviour, using a named example to support at least one point.
Question 13 [5 marks]
Parliament
The Commons and the Lords sometimes disagree repeatedly over the same bill as it passes between the two Houses.
Explain what is meant by legislative gridlock between the two Houses, and explain one mechanism that exists to resolve it.
Question 14 [5 marks]
Political Parties
Political scientists have observed that parties often move their policies towards the views of the average voter.
Explain what is meant by parties positioning themselves near the 'median voter', and explain one criticism of parties adopting this strategy.
Question 15 [6 marks]
Parliament
Explain three ways in which Parliament's ability to scrutinise the executive is limited.
Question 16 [6 marks]
Devolution and Multi-level Governance
Explain three consequences of devolution for UK politics and government.
Question 17 [6 marks]
Parliament
Explain three ways in which Parliament's law-making function operates in practice.
Question 18 [6 marks]
Democracy and Participation
Explain three factors that can affect how likely an individual is to participate in politics beyond voting, such as by joining a party or a pressure group.
Question 19 [6 marks]
Parliament
Explain three arguments in favour of reforming the House of Lords to make it a wholly or mainly elected chamber.
Model solutions
| Question 1[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : life peers, appointed usually on the recommendation of the Prime Minister or the House of Lords Appointments Commission | 1 |
| a second valid type, such as the remaining hereditary peers retained after the House of Lords Act 1999, or the Lords Spiritual, the bishops of the Church of England who sit in the chamber | 1 |
| Final answer: Any two of: life peers; the remaining hereditary peers; the Lords Spiritual (bishops) | |
| Question 2[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : appointing and dismissing ministers | 1 |
| a second valid power, such as chairing Cabinet, recommending honours, or representing the UK in international negotiations | 1 |
| Final answer: Any two of: appointing/dismissing ministers; chairing Cabinet; recommending honours; conducting foreign policy; recommending a dissolution of Parliament | |
| Question 3[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| a first devolved power, such as health | 1 |
| a second devolved power, such as education, or aspects of local government | 1 |
| Final answer: Any two of: health; education; local government; aspects of transport | |
| Question 4[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : a safe seat can leave an MP with little incentive to represent constituents who did not vote for them | 1 |
| : elected representatives may not reflect the social make-up of the electorate, for example in terms of gender or ethnicity | 1 |
| a third valid problem, such as low turnout undermining the legitimacy of an elected representative, or a representative voting against the wishes of their constituents | 1 |
| Final answer: Any three of: safe seats reducing accountability; under-representation of the population's make-up in elected bodies; low turnout weakening legitimacy; representatives voting against constituent wishes | |
| Question 5[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : the Salisbury Convention, under which the House of Lords does not block a manifesto commitment of the elected government | 1 |
| : the Sewel Convention, under which Westminster normally seeks the consent of a devolved legislature before legislating on a devolved matter | 1 |
| a third valid convention, such as individual or collective ministerial responsibility, or the convention that the monarch acts on the advice of ministers | 1 |
| Final answer: Any three of: the Salisbury Convention; the Sewel Convention; individual or collective ministerial responsibility; the convention that the monarch acts on ministerial advice | |
| Question 6[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| : voters assess which party's policies best serve their own interests | 1 |
| : voters may judge the competence of the governing party's economic record, sometimes called valence voting | 1 |
| a third valid factor, such as voters evaluating the perceived competence or personality of party leaders | 1 |
| Final answer: Any three of: assessment of self-interest against party policy; judgement of governing competence (valence voting); evaluation of party leaders | |
| Question 7[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first advantage, such as a broad-based party being able to appeal to a wider range of voters than a narrowly ideological one | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that this wider appeal helps a party build the size of electoral coalition needed to win a Commons majority under First Past the Post | 1 |
| identifying a second advantage, such as a broad-based party being more able to accommodate different factions and viewpoints within a single organisation | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that this reduces the risk of votes being split between rival parties on the same side of the political spectrum | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed advantages, such as: appealing to a wider range of voters, helping build a majority under First Past the Post; accommodating different internal factions, reducing the risk of a split vote on the same side of the spectrum | |
| Question 8[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first difference, such as only the House of Commons being able to determine the survival of a government through a vote of no confidence | 1 |
| developing this, such as noting that the House of Lords cannot force a government to resign | 1 |
| identifying a second difference, such as the House of Lords being unable to block money bills (it can delay them by only one month) | 1 |
| developing this, such as noting that under the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949 the Lords' power over other bills is limited to delay, not veto | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed points, such as: only the Commons can bring down a government; the Lords cannot block money bills and can only delay other bills under the Parliament Acts | |
| Question 9[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first reason, such as Northern Ireland's history of division between unionist and nationalist communities | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a simple majoritarian system risked one community consistently dominating government at the expense of the other | 1 |
| identifying a second reason, such as the need to build cross-community confidence in the new devolved institutions after the Troubles | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that guaranteeing both main traditions a place in the Executive was intended to give both communities a stake in making devolution work | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed points, such as: preventing one community from consistently dominating government given Northern Ireland's history of division; building cross-community confidence in new devolved institutions after the Troubles | |
| Question 10[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first method, such as calling ministers and civil servants to give evidence in public sessions | 1 |
| developing this, such as noting that public questioning can expose weaknesses in government policy or decision-making | 1 |
| identifying a second method, such as publishing reports that recommend changes to government policy | 1 |
| developing this, such as noting that the government is expected to respond formally to committee recommendations, creating reputational pressure to act | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed points, such as: questioning ministers and officials in public evidence sessions; publishing reports that create pressure on government to respond | |
| Question 11[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first function, such as allowing detailed policy work to be carried out in a specific area without needing full Cabinet to consider every detail | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a smaller committee of relevant ministers can examine a complex issue, such as economic policy, in more depth than full Cabinet has time for | 1 |
| identifying a second function, such as resolving disagreements between government departments before they reach full Cabinet | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that settling disputes at committee level helps prevent full Cabinet meetings from being taken up with departmental conflicts | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed functions, such as: allowing detailed policy work in a specific area without needing full Cabinet; resolving disputes between departments before they reach full Cabinet | |
| Question 12[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first way, such as the bandwagon effect, where voters are drawn towards a party shown to be leading | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that some voters prefer to back a likely winner, reinforcing a party's poll lead | 1 |
| identifying a second way, such as tactical voting encouraged by polling in individual constituencies | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a voter may switch away from their preferred party to vote for the strongest challenger to a party they wish to defeat, based on local poll evidence | 1 |
| a relevant supporting example, such as tactical voting websites and campaigns using constituency polling to recommend how supporters should vote | 1 |
| Final answer: Two developed points, such as: the bandwagon effect drawing support towards a poll leader; polling data encouraging tactical voting against a disliked party | |
| Question 13[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| explaining the core idea, such as that legislative gridlock describes a situation where the Commons and the Lords repeatedly disagree over a bill and neither side gives way | 1 |
| developing this, such as describing 'ping-pong', where a bill is passed back and forth between the two Houses as each amends or rejects the other's changes | 1 |
| identifying a mechanism to resolve it, such as the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949 | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that these Acts allow the Commons, in specific circumstances, to pass a bill into law even without the consent of the Lords | 1 |
| a further valid point, such as noting that the mere existence of the Parliament Acts gives the Commons useful leverage in negotiations, since the Lords knows a bill can ultimately proceed without it | 1 |
| Final answer: Legislative gridlock describes the Commons and Lords repeatedly disagreeing over a bill, sometimes through 'ping-pong' as it passes back and forth; the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949 resolve this by allowing the Commons, in specific circumstances, to pass a bill into law without the Lords' consent, which also gives the Commons leverage in negotiation | |
| Question 14[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| explaining the core idea, such as that parties have an incentive to position their policies close to the views of the voter in the political centre in order to maximise votes | 1 |
| developing this, such as noting that ignoring the centre ground risks losing votes to a rival party positioned closer to most voters' views | 1 |
| identifying a criticism, such as that this strategy can make rival parties' policies converge and appear similar to one another | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that voters may feel they are offered a narrower real choice if all major parties compete for the same centre ground | 1 |
| a further valid point, such as noting that this convergence can leave voters with more distinct views feeling unrepresented by any of the major parties | 1 |
| Final answer: Parties have an incentive to move their policies towards the political centre, where most voters are assumed to sit, to maximise votes; critics argue this can make major parties converge and appear similar, leaving voters with more distinct views feeling unrepresented | |
| Question 15[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first limit, such as a government with a large Commons majority being able to rely on whipped votes to pass its programme | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that party discipline reduces the number of MPs willing to vote against their own government | 1 |
| identifying a second limit, such as the payroll vote, meaning ministers and parliamentary private secretaries are bound by collective responsibility to support the government | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that this removes a significant number of MPs from independent scrutiny | 1 |
| identifying a third limit, such as the government's control over the parliamentary timetable | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that this allows the government to limit the time available for debating or amending its own legislation | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed points, such as: whipped majorities limiting rebellion; the payroll vote binding ministers to support government; government control of the parliamentary timetable | |
| Question 16[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first consequence, such as policy divergence between the different nations of the UK | 1 |
| developing this, such as citing an example of differing policy, such as different approaches to university tuition fees or prescription charges across the nations | 1 |
| identifying a second consequence, such as growing pressure for further constitutional change | 1 |
| developing this, such as noting that further powers were granted to Scotland through later Scotland Acts following the 2014 independence referendum | 1 |
| identifying a third consequence, such as raising questions about how England should be governed, given it has no devolved legislature of its own | 1 |
| developing this, such as citing the West Lothian Question or the short-lived introduction and later abolition of English Votes for English Laws as attempted responses | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed points, such as: policy divergence between nations; pressure for further devolution and constitutional change; unresolved questions about English governance, such as the West Lothian Question | |
| Question 17[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first way, such as most legislation originating from government bills rather than from individual backbenchers | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a government with a Commons majority can normally secure the passage of its own legislative programme | 1 |
| identifying a second way, such as Private Members' Bills allowing individual backbenchers to propose legislation | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that a Private Member's Bill has a much lower chance of becoming law than a government bill because of limited debating time | 1 |
| identifying a third way, such as delegated legislation allowing ministers to make detailed law without a full Act of Parliament | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that delegated legislation lets government fill in the technical detail of an Act quickly, though it usually receives less parliamentary scrutiny than primary legislation | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed points, such as: government bills dominating the legislative programme; Private Members' Bills giving backbenchers a limited route to legislate; delegated legislation allowing ministers to make detailed law with less scrutiny | |
| Question 18[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first factor, such as socio-economic status, including income and education | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that individuals with higher incomes or more education are, on average, more likely to have the time, confidence and resources to participate beyond voting | 1 |
| identifying a second factor, such as age | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that older citizens are, on average, more likely than younger ones to join a political party or attend a public meeting | 1 |
| identifying a third factor, such as a sense of political efficacy, meaning a belief that participation can make a difference | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that someone who doubts their involvement will change anything is less likely to devote time to campaigning or activism | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed factors, such as: socio-economic status, including income and education; age; a sense of political efficacy - the belief that participation can make a difference | |
| Question 19[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first argument, such as increasing the chamber's democratic legitimacy | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that an elected chamber could claim a direct public mandate that an appointed or hereditary chamber lacks | 1 |
| identifying a second argument, such as removing the remaining hereditary peers | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that inheriting a seat in the legislature is difficult to justify in a modern democracy, even after their number was reduced by the House of Lords Act 1999 | 1 |
| identifying a third argument, such as reducing the Prime Minister's patronage power over appointments | 1 |
| developing this, such as explaining that an elected chamber would end the current system in which the Prime Minister effectively decides who sits in the second chamber | 1 |
| Final answer: Three developed arguments, such as: greater democratic legitimacy; removing the remaining hereditary peers; reducing prime ministerial patronage over appointments | |