GCSE History Short Paper A
Covers Medicine in Britain, c1250-c1700, Medicine in Britain, c1700-Present, The Trench System on the Western Front and 3 more.
Questions
Question 1 [2 marks]
Elizabeth I and Government
Give two features of the Religious Settlement of 1559.
Question 2 [4 marks]
The Trench System on the Western Front
Describe two features of the British trench system on the Western Front.
Question 3 [4 marks]
Medicine in Britain, c1250-c1700
Describe two features of medieval hospitals.
Question 4 [4 marks]
Medicine in Britain, c1700-Present
Explain one way in which John Snow's investigation of the 1854 cholera outbreak was different from earlier explanations of disease based on miasma theory.
Question 5 [4 marks]
Elizabethan Society and the Spanish Armada
Explain one way in which the voyages of John Hawkins were different from the voyages organised by Walter Raleigh.
Question 6 [4 marks]
Medicine in Britain, c1250-c1700
Explain one way in which the work of William Harvey on the circulation of the blood was different from the work of Galen.
Question 7 [6 marks]
Wounds, Illness and Treatment on the Western Front
Explain why the introduction of mobile X-ray units improved surgical outcomes for wounded soldiers on the Western Front.
Question 8 [6 marks]
Elizabeth I and Government
Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question: a third-person summary in the style of an account of Peter Wentworth's parliamentary speech in 1576 before his arrest, from the imagined viewpoint of an unnamed MP supporting free speech. This is constructed teaching material, not a quotation from a historical document.
Wentworth argued that free speech was essential if Parliament was to scrutinise affairs rather than merely flatter those in authority. Defending that freedom could put a member's liberty at risk.
How useful is Source A to a historian studying tension between Elizabeth and Parliament over free speech? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.
Question 9 [6 marks]
The Trench System on the Western Front
Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question, in the style of an issue of a satirical newspaper produced by British soldiers near Ypres in 1916. The writer and situation are imagined; this is not a quotation from a historical document.
'Wanted: a quiet spot for a summer holiday. Must have good drainage, no shelling after 9pm and a pleasant view unspoiled by barbed wire. Previous applicants report the district somewhat overcrowded with rats.'
How useful is Source A to a historian studying how British soldiers coped with life in the trenches? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.
Model solutions
| Question 1[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| each of two distinct historically correct answers, up to 2 marks. The following are examples, not an exhaustive list. 1 mark for the Act of Supremacy making Elizabeth Supreme Governor of the Church of England. | B1 |
| the Act of Uniformity requiring a single Book of Common Prayer to be used in every church and imposing fines on those who did not attend. Accept other historically correct answers that meet the question's time frame and focus. Do not count the same example twice or require explanations beyond what the question asks. | 1 |
| Final answer: The Act of Supremacy made Elizabeth Supreme Governor of the Church, and the Act of Uniformity required one Book of Common Prayer, with fines for non-attendance. | |
| Question 2[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Award up to 2 marks for each of two distinct features: B1 for identifying a valid feature and B1 for relevant supporting detail about that same feature. Maximum 4 marks. The examples below are indicative; accept other accurate features and linked development. Identifies that the system was made up of several lines of trenches, including a front line trench, a support trench and a reserve trench. | |
| Develops this by explaining that these lines were linked by communication trenches, which allowed men, supplies and messages to move between them without crossing open ground. | |
| Identifies that trenches were dug in a zigzag pattern rather than straight lines. Develops this by explaining that this limited the damage from a shell landing directly in a trench and stopped an enemy soldier who entered the trench from firing straight along its whole length. | |
| Do not demand these particular two features, double-count the same detail, or award a development mark for an unrelated third feature. | |
| Final answer: Several linked lines (front, support and reserve) joined by communication trenches, and trenches dug in a zigzag pattern to limit blast and enfilade fire. | |
| Question 3[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Award up to 2 marks for each of two distinct features: B1 for identifying a valid feature and B1 for relevant supporting detail about that same feature. Maximum 4 marks. The examples below are indicative; accept other accurate features and linked development. Identifies that most hospitals were run by religious orders such as monks and nuns. | |
| Develops this by explaining that care focused on rest, prayer and a clean environment rather than medical cure. | |
| Identifies that hospitals restricted who they admitted. Develops this by explaining that many refused patients with infectious diseases, the dying or the incurable, keeping beds for those who might recover. | |
| Do not demand these particular two features, double-count the same detail, or award a development mark for an unrelated third feature. | |
| Final answer: Many hospitals were run by religious institutions and provided nursing, rest, food and prayer rather than effective cures. Admission was selective: some excluded infectious patients or people considered incurable. | |
| Question 4[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Apply a holistic 4-mark comparison scale. 0 marks: no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): a simple comparison or relevant information with limited explanation. Level 2 (3-4 marks): one clear similarity or difference is explained with specific accurate detail supporting both sides; award 4 for a fully developed comparison. The following content is indicative, not four separate compulsory marks. Accept any historically correct comparison meeting the prompt, and allow full marks for one developed way. Unconnected facts without a comparison remain in Level 1. | |
| Identifies that miasma theory held that diseases such as cholera spread through bad air, so earlier responses focused on removing smells rather than tracing a specific source. | |
| Develops this by explaining that miasma-based action targeted bad smells rather than tracing contaminated drinking water, although sanitation inspired by miasma could still improve health. Identifies that Snow instead mapped cholera deaths in Soho and traced them to a single water pump on Broad Street, suggesting the disease was carried by contaminated water rather than air. | |
| Develops this by explaining how mapping cases and investigating water use supported a waterborne explanation before germ theory was widely accepted. Removing the pump handle limited access to the suspected water; a subsequent fall in cases alone does not prove it caused the decline. | |
| Final answer: Miasma theory blamed bad air, encouraging action against smells. Snow investigated cases and their water supply, linking cholera to the Broad Street pump rather than the air. His evidence supported contaminated water as the route; removing the handle restricted use of that water. | |
| Question 5[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Apply a holistic 4-mark comparison scale. 0 marks: no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): a simple comparison or relevant information with limited explanation. Level 2 (3-4 marks): one clear similarity or difference is explained with specific accurate detail supporting both sides; award 4 for a fully developed comparison. The following content is indicative, not four separate compulsory marks. Accept any historically correct comparison meeting the prompt, and allow full marks for one developed way. Unconnected facts without a comparison remain in Level 1. | |
| Identifies that in the 1560s, John Hawkins undertook some of the earliest English voyages carrying enslaved Africans to sell in Spanish colonies in the Americas, seeking profit through this trade. | |
| Develops this by explaining that Hawkins' slave-trading voyages sought profit in Spanish America and brought him into conflict with Spanish control of colonial trade. Identifies that Raleigh sponsored and organised attempts to establish a colony at Roanoke in North America in the 1580s, rather than personally leading the colonists there. | |
| Develops this by explaining the contrast between establishing a settlement and Hawkins' slave-trading voyages. The Roanoke ventures failed; do not invent return voyages personally made by Raleigh. | |
| Final answer: Hawkins personally undertook slave-trading voyages in the 1560s, carrying enslaved Africans for sale in Spanish America. Raleigh instead sponsored and organised attempts at settlement at Roanoke in the 1580s; he did not personally lead those colonial voyages. | |
| Question 6[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Apply a holistic 4-mark comparison scale. 0 marks: no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): a simple comparison or relevant information with limited explanation. Level 2 (3-4 marks): one clear similarity or difference is explained with specific accurate detail supporting both sides; award 4 for a fully developed comparison. The following content is indicative, not four separate compulsory marks. Accept any historically correct comparison meeting the prompt, and allow full marks for one developed way. Unconnected facts without a comparison remain in Level 1. | |
| Identifies that Galen believed blood was made in the liver from food and was then used up, or burned, by the body as fuel, so new blood constantly had to be made. | |
| Develops this by explaining that this idea meant Galen did not think blood circulated around the body in a closed system. Identifies that Harvey, through dissection and calculation of how much blood the heart pumped, showed in 1628 that the heart acts as a pump and that the same blood circulates around the body. | |
| Develops this by explaining that this directly contradicted Galen's theory and correctly identified the heart, not the liver, as the centre of the blood system. | |
| Final answer: Galen believed blood was made in the liver and used up as fuel; Harvey showed in 1628 that the heart pumps the same blood around the body in a circulating system. | |
| Question 7[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Short practice task using a local 6-mark scale, not the official 12-mark explanation tariff. Apply levels holistically: 0 marks for no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): relevant reasons or effects are identified with little causal development. Level 2 (3-4 marks): develops a supported causal explanation. Level 3 (5-6 marks): develops a coherent explanation supported by precise, relevant evidence, showing how reasons or effects answer the question. Award 6 for sustained accurate reasoning. The following content is indicative. Accept other accurate explanations within the prompt's focus. Do not count one bullet per mark, require every listed factor, or award full marks for a list without explaining the connection to the question. | |
| Before mobile X-ray units, surgeons often had to search for bullets or shrapnel inside a wound by feel or by exploratory cutting, which was slow and caused further damage to tissue. | |
| Mobile X-ray units, such as the vehicles developed with the help of Marie Curie, allowed surgeons to see the exact location of metal fragments before operating. | |
| This meant surgery could be more precise, removing fragments directly rather than through prolonged searching, which reduced the amount of tissue damage caused. Shorter, more accurate operations reduced the time a patient spent under anaesthetic, lowering the risks associated with prolonged surgery. | |
| Faster, more precise surgery also reduced the length of time a wound was left open, which helped lower the risk of infection taking hold. | |
| Because the units were mobile, they could be brought close to Casualty Clearing Stations, meaning X-rays could be taken and used quickly rather than requiring transport to a fixed hospital first. | |
| Final answer: Mobile X-ray units let surgeons locate shrapnel precisely before operating, making surgery faster and more accurate, which reduced tissue damage, time under anaesthetic and the risk of infection. | |
| Question 8[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Short practice task with a local 6-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation. | |
| identifies relevant illustrative detail or makes a simple comment on the extract's usefulness, with limited supporting context. | Level 11-2 marks |
| explains what relevant detail illustrates, using accurate contextual knowledge, and explains a specific limit of what can be inferred. | Level 23-4 marks |
| develops a reasoned judgement for the enquiry using detail and linked context; explains that the constructed extract cannot establish genuine eyewitness testimony or historical provenance. Select the mark by the accuracy and development of reasoning, not by counting comments. | Level 35-6 marks |
| Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: The summary presents free speech as vital and links its defence with risk to liberty, illustrating a clash over parliamentary discussion. | |
| Evidence audit: The constructed MP's viewpoint supports free speech; this is not Wentworth's testimony or wording. It cannot show that every MP agreed or that Parliament was generally powerless. Do not assume the Crown alone ordered every parliamentary punishment or infer universal parliamentary hostility from one speaker. This is constructed teaching material, not a historical document. The stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario; they do not establish that a real witness said or observed these things. Evaluate the illustrative content and hypothetical perspective, without awarding genuine eyewitness or official authority. Seek traceable contemporary records for historical evidence relevant to this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and well-explained limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or asserting authenticity from the supplied attribution. | |
| Final answer: The summary presents free speech as vital and links its defence with risk to liberty, illustrating a clash over parliamentary discussion. The constructed MP's viewpoint supports free speech; this is not Wentworth's testimony or wording. It cannot show that every MP agreed or that Parliament was generally powerless. Do not assume the Crown alone ordered every parliamentary punishment or infer universal parliamentary hostility from one speaker. As a constructed teaching extract it illustrates the issue but cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience. Its type, date and viewpoint are part of the imagined scenario. A historian needs traceable contemporary records and relevant corroborating evidence for this enquiry. | |
| Question 9[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Short practice task with a local 6-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation. | |
| identifies relevant illustrative detail or makes a simple comment on the extract's usefulness, with limited supporting context. | Level 11-2 marks |
| explains what relevant detail illustrates, using accurate contextual knowledge, and explains a specific limit of what can be inferred. | Level 23-4 marks |
| develops a reasoned judgement for the enquiry using detail and linked context; explains that the constructed extract cannot establish genuine eyewitness testimony or historical provenance. Select the mark by the accuracy and development of reasoning, not by counting comments. | Level 35-6 marks |
| Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: The satirical advertisement turns rats, drainage and shellfire into shared humour. | |
| Evidence audit: It suggests coping through comedy, but a constructed newspaper item cannot reveal every soldier's morale. This is constructed teaching material, not a historical document. The stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario; they do not establish that a real witness said or observed these things. Evaluate the illustrative content and hypothetical perspective, without awarding genuine eyewitness or official authority. Seek traceable contemporary records for historical evidence relevant to this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and well-explained limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or asserting authenticity from the supplied attribution. | |
| Final answer: The satirical advertisement turns rats, drainage and shellfire into shared humour. It suggests coping through comedy, but a constructed newspaper item cannot reveal every soldier's morale. As a constructed teaching extract it illustrates the issue but cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience. Its type, date and viewpoint are part of the imagined scenario. A historian needs traceable contemporary records and relevant corroborating evidence for this enquiry. | |