Year 10 Paper 5: Medicine, Society and the Wider World
Covers medicine in Britain from the medieval period to the present day, Elizabethan society and the Spanish Armada, the early settlement of the American West, and the origins of the Cold War.
Year 10 follows a typical teaching order. No exam board defines what belongs to Year 10, and schools sequence the course differently. Check it against your own scheme of work before using it to decide what a class has covered.
Questions
Question 1 [2 marks]
Medicine in Britain, c1700-Present
Give two problems associated with inoculation against smallpox before Edward Jenner developed vaccination.
Question 2 [2 marks]
Medicine in Britain, c1250-c1700
Give two ways in which medieval physicians tried to diagnose which humour was out of balance in a patient.
Question 3 [4 marks]
Early Settlement of the American West, c1835-c1862
Describe two features of the Mormon handcart companies that travelled to Utah between 1856 and 1860.
Question 4 [4 marks]
Medicine in Britain, c1250-c1700
Describe two features of the different types of medical practitioner available in medieval and Tudor England.
Question 5 [4 marks]
Elizabethan Society and the Spanish Armada
Describe two features of the causes of poverty in Elizabethan England.
Question 6 [4 marks]
The Origins of the Cold War, 1941-58
Describe two features of the ideological differences between the USA and the USSR after 1945.
Question 7 [4 marks]
Early Settlement of the American West, c1835-c1862
Explain one way in which the experience of migrants in the Donner Party in 1846-47 was different from the experience of most migrants travelling the Oregon Trail.
Question 8 [4 marks]
Medicine in Britain, c1700-Present
Explain why the National Health Service was set up in 1948.
Question 9 [4 marks]
Early Settlement of the American West, c1835-c1862
Explain one way in which the experience of Chinese immigrants during the Gold Rush era was different from the experience of most white American settlers.
Question 10 [4 marks]
Medicine in Britain, c1700-Present
Explain one way in which the response to the discovery of the link between smoking and lung cancer was different from earlier public health approaches.
Question 11 [4 marks]
Elizabethan Society and the Spanish Armada
Explain one way in which the causes of the Spanish Armada of 1588 were different from the causes of earlier tension between England and Spain in the 1560s and 1570s.
Question 12 [6 marks]
Early Settlement of the American West, c1835-c1862
Explain why the Pony Express, though it operated for less than two years, was significant.
Question 13 [6 marks]
The Origins of the Cold War, 1941-58
Explain why the Korean War (1950-53) was significant for the development of the wider Cold War.
Question 14 [4 marks]
Elizabethan Society and the Spanish Armada
Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question, in the style of a letter written by an English sea captain to his family shortly after the Spanish Armada was defeated in 1588. The writer and situation are imagined; this is not a quotation from a historical document.
'We chased the Spanish ships for days, firing on them whenever we came close enough, but our powder ran low before we could sink many. It was the fireships off Calais, and then the great storm that drove them north, that truly broke them.'
How useful is Source A to a historian studying why the Spanish Armada was defeated? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.
Question 15 [6 marks]
The Origins of the Cold War, 1941-58
Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question, in the style of a British newspaper report published in October 1949, shortly after the announcement of a new state in the Soviet zone of Germany. The writer and situation are imagined; this is not a quotation from a historical document.
'Following the establishment of a separate West German state in the spring, the Soviet authorities have now announced their own German Democratic Republic in the eastern zone. What was one occupied country now appears set to remain two, each looking to a different superpower.'
How useful is Source A to a historian studying the division of Germany in 1949? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.
Question 16 [6 marks]
Early Settlement of the American West, c1835-c1862
Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question, in the style of a letter written by a settler to his brother in Ohio, describing his journey along the Oregon Trail in 1852. The writer and situation are imagined; this is not a quotation from a historical document.
'We buried two children from our party this month, taken by the cholera. The river crossing near Fort Laramie near swept away one of our wagons. Still, the land we are told awaits us in Oregon is said to be the finest a man could farm.'
How useful is Source A to a historian studying the dangers faced by migrants travelling west in the mid-nineteenth century? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.
Question 17 [6 marks]
Elizabethan Society and the Spanish Armada
Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question, in the style of an account written by a resident of a coastal town in Devon, describing preparations in the summer of 1588. The writer and situation are imagined; this is not a quotation from a historical document.
'Beacons have been readied on every hill along this coast, to be lit the moment Spanish sails are sighted. The local militia drills each week, and every man capable of bearing arms has been listed, though few among us have handled a pike before.'
How useful is Source A to a historian studying how England prepared to defend itself against the Spanish Armada? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.
Question 18 [6 marks]
Medicine in Britain, c1700-Present
Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question, in the style of a report by a Medical Officer of Health in a northern industrial town, written in 1880. The writer and situation are imagined; this is not a quotation from a historical document.
'Since the new Act came into force, the council has had no choice but to complete the sewer network and inspect lodging houses each quarter. Ratepayers grumbled loudly at the expense, but the fever cases in the worst streets have already begun to fall.'
How useful is Source A to a historian studying the impact of the Public Health Act of 1875? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.
Model solutions
| Question 1[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| each of two distinct historically correct answers, up to 2 marks. The following are examples, not an exhaustive list. 1 mark for the fact that inoculation involved infecting a patient with a mild dose of smallpox itself, which could occasionally develop into a full, fatal case of the disease. | B1 |
| the fact that an inoculated person remained infectious and could still spread smallpox to other people nearby. Accept other historically correct answers that meet the question's time frame and focus. Do not count the same example twice or require explanations beyond what the question asks. | 1 |
| Final answer: Inoculation could occasionally cause a fatal case of smallpox itself, and an inoculated person could still spread the disease to others. | |
| Question 2[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| each of two distinct historically correct answers, up to 2 marks. The following are examples, not an exhaustive list. 1 mark for examining a sample of the patient's urine, comparing its colour and thickness against a chart to judge which humour was out of balance. | B1 |
| taking the patient's pulse, believed to give further clues about the state of the body's humours. Accept other historically correct answers that meet the question's time frame and focus. Do not count the same example twice or require explanations beyond what the question asks. | 1 |
| Final answer: Examining urine against a chart, and taking the patient's pulse. | |
| Question 3[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Identify human-pulled carts as a method of carrying belongings. These are indicative points; accept other accurate responses answering the printed command and period. Do not award repeated content twice. | B1 |
| Develop with the lower cost compared with a full wagon and animal team, widening access to the migration. | B1 |
| Identify organised companies or the physical demands of travel. | B1 |
| Develop with shared travel arrangements or exposure and effort; do not make all companies experience one disaster or assert an unverified count of affected groups. Development needs additional supporting detail or an explicit explanatory link, not a restatement. | B1 |
| Final answer: Handcart migrants carried possessions in human-pulled carts, offering a cheaper means of reaching Utah than purchasing a full ox-drawn outfit. They travelled in organised companies, sharing the journey and its hardships; severe late-season weather caused disasters for some companies, which should not be treated as the experience of every company. | |
| Question 4[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Award up to 2 marks for each of two distinct features: B1 for identifying a valid feature and B1 for relevant supporting detail about that same feature. Maximum 4 marks. The examples below are indicative; accept other accurate features and linked development. Identifies that physicians trained for several years at university, studying classical texts by Galen and Hippocrates. | |
| Develops this by explaining that their fees made them expensive, so only the wealthy could usually afford to consult one. | |
| Identifies that apothecaries mixed and sold herbal remedies and simple medicines from a shop. Develops this by explaining that they had no formal university training and were cheaper to consult than a physician, so many ordinary people relied on them instead. | |
| Do not demand these particular two features, double-count the same detail, or award a development mark for an unrelated third feature. | |
| Final answer: University-trained physicians were expensive and used mainly by the wealthy; apothecaries, with no university training, mixed and sold cheaper remedies used by ordinary people. | |
| Question 5[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Award up to 2 marks for each of two distinct features: B1 for identifying a valid feature and B1 for relevant supporting detail about that same feature. Maximum 4 marks. The examples below are indicative; accept other accurate features and linked development. Identifies that the population grew rapidly during Elizabeth's reign, increasing demand for food and jobs. | |
| Develops this by explaining that this led to rising prices (inflation) and made it harder for poorer people to afford basic goods. | |
| Identifies that enclosure of common land by landowners reduced the land available to ordinary people for farming. Develops this by explaining that some landowners also switched from growing crops to keeping sheep, which needed fewer workers, leaving many labourers without work. | |
| Do not demand these particular two features, double-count the same detail, or award a development mark for an unrelated third feature. | |
| Final answer: Rapid population growth pushing up prices, and enclosure of common land, often for sheep farming, reducing work available to labourers. | |
| Question 6[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Identifies that the USA supported capitalism and democracy, believing in private ownership of property and businesses and in free elections between competing political parties. | |
| Develops this by explaining that Americans saw the spread of communism as a direct threat to individual freedom and to their own economic and political system. | |
| Identifies that the USSR supported communism, believing property and industry should be owned collectively rather than by individuals, and operated as a one-party state under the Communist Party. | |
| Develops this by explaining that Soviet leaders saw capitalism as an unjust system that exploited ordinary workers, and believed communism would eventually spread worldwide. | |
| Final answer: The USA stood for capitalism, private property and multi-party democracy, while the USSR stood for communism, collective ownership and one-party rule, each seeing the other's system as a threat. | |
| Question 7[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Identify the Donner Party's extreme winter entrapment. These are indicative points; accept other accurate responses answering the printed command and period. Do not award repeated content twice. | B1 |
| Develop with starvation and deaths in the Sierra Nevada in 1846-47. | B1 |
| Identify that this was not the typical experience of migrants who completed the Oregon journey. | B1 |
| Explain the linked difference in outcome, such as prolonged entrapment and cannibalism in the Donner disaster, while recognising ordinary trail dangers and the California-bound destination. Development needs additional supporting detail or an explicit explanatory link, not a restatement. | B1 |
| Final answer: The Donner Party became trapped by snow in the Sierra Nevada in the winter of 1846-47, suffering starvation and deaths. Most migrants who completed the Oregon Trail did not experience this extreme entrapment and resort to cannibalism; the Donner disaster followed a California-bound route and should not be described as the normal Oregon journey. | |
| Question 8[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Short practice task using a local 4-mark scale, not the official 12-mark explanation tariff. Apply levels holistically: 0 marks for no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): relevant reasons or effects are identified with little causal development. Level 2 (3-4 marks): a supported explanation links accurate detail to the question; award 4 for clear, well-developed reasoning. The following content is indicative. Accept other accurate explanations within the prompt's focus. Do not count one bullet per mark, require every listed factor, or award full marks for a list without explaining the connection to the question. | |
| Before 1948, access to care was uneven: fees and gaps in existing provision left many people unable to afford adequate treatment, despite insurance, charitable and other services. | |
| The Beveridge Report of 1942 identified 'Disease' as one of five giant problems facing Britain and recommended a free health service for all. The Second World War showed that organised, centrally run medical care, such as the Emergency Medical Service, could work and increased public support for a fairer system. | |
| The Labour government elected in 1945 was committed to welfare reform, and Health Minister Aneurin Bevan drove through the National Health Service Act 1946. | |
| Final answer: Many people could not afford adequate care, creating demand for a service available regardless of income. The Beveridge Report and wartime experience strengthened support for coordinated provision; the Labour government elected in 1945 then enacted the reforms that opened the NHS in 1948. | |
| Question 9[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Identify racial discrimination affecting Chinese immigrants. These are indicative points; accept other accurate responses answering the printed command and period. Do not award repeated content twice. | B1 |
| Develop with a relevant restriction, hostility or burden that reduced their mining opportunities, subject to authoritative checking of exact legal examples. | B1 |
| Identify the comparatively wider access available to many white American settlers. | B1 |
| Explain how this difference affected access to claims or work; avoid treating every white migrant as having identical rights or opportunities. Development needs additional supporting detail or an explicit explanatory link, not a restatement. | B1 |
| Final answer: Chinese immigrants encountered racial discrimination and exclusion that most white American settlers did not face in the same way. Hostility and discriminatory restrictions could reduce Chinese miners' access to profitable claims and opportunities, whereas white settlers generally had greater access to rights and resources, even though mining was difficult for many groups. | |
| Question 10[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Apply a holistic 4-mark comparison scale. 0 marks: no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): a simple comparison or relevant information with limited explanation. Level 2 (3-4 marks): one clear similarity or difference is explained with specific accurate detail supporting both sides; award 4 for a fully developed comparison. The following content is indicative, not four separate compulsory marks. Accept any historically correct comparison meeting the prompt, and allow full marks for one developed way. Unconnected facts without a comparison remain in Level 1. | |
| Identifies that earlier public health efforts, such as nineteenth-century sewers and clean water supplies, focused on preventing infectious disease spread through the shared environment. | |
| Develops this by explaining that these earlier improvements were achieved mainly through engineering projects and legislation controlling conditions such as water supply and waste disposal. Identifies that research by Richard Doll and Austin Bradford Hill in the 1950s established a statistical link between smoking and lung cancer. | |
| Develops this by explaining that this shifted some public health effort towards changing individual lifestyle choices, for example through government health warnings and later restrictions on cigarette advertising. | |
| Final answer: Earlier public health measures tackled the shared environment through engineering and law; Doll and Hill's 1950s research on smoking and lung cancer shifted some effort towards changing individual lifestyle choices through warnings and advertising restrictions. | |
| Question 11[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Apply a holistic 4-mark comparison scale. 0 marks: no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): a simple comparison or relevant information with limited explanation. Level 2 (3-4 marks): one clear similarity or difference is explained with specific accurate detail supporting both sides; award 4 for a fully developed comparison. The following content is indicative, not four separate compulsory marks. Accept any historically correct comparison meeting the prompt, and allow full marks for one developed way. Unconnected facts without a comparison remain in Level 1. | |
| Identifies that earlier tension between England and Spain was rooted in longer-term religious rivalry between Protestant England and Catholic Spain, and in competition over trade and colonies in the Americas. | |
| Develops this by explaining that this tension caused persistent friction, for example over English trading voyages and privateering, but did not immediately lead to open war. Identifies that the Armada itself was more directly triggered by specific events in the mid-1580s, including Elizabeth's execution of Mary, Queen of Scots in 1587 and English military support for the Protestant Dutch Revolt against Spanish rule. | |
| Develops this by explaining that Drake's 1587 Cadiz raid damaged and delayed Spanish preparations. It demonstrates escalation, but the invasion was already being planned, so the raid must not be treated as the original decision to invade. | |
| Final answer: Earlier tension involved religious and commercial rivalry and English attacks on Spanish interests. By the mid-1580s direct English military aid to the Dutch revolt sharpened the conflict, while Mary's execution in 1587 further heightened hostility. Drake's Cadiz raid damaged and delayed an invasion already being prepared. | |
| Question 12[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Identify the relay of riders and fresh horses. These are indicative points; accept other accurate responses answering the printed command and period. Do not award repeated content twice. | B1 |
| Explain how it carried mail faster than earlier transport, improving communication. | B1 |
| Identify the need to link California and other western communities to distant information. | B1 |
| Explain why reliable faster news mattered before a continuous telegraph connection. | B1 |
| Identify the service as a short-lived transition in communications. | B1 |
| Explain why the telegraph reduced its value despite its earlier contribution; dangers alone do not establish significance. Development needs additional supporting detail or an explicit explanatory link, not a restatement. | B1 |
| Final answer: The Pony Express used relays of riders and fresh horses to carry mail rapidly across the West, improving communication before a continuous telegraph link. Its short operation demonstrated demand for fast long-distance communication and the practical value of relay organisation. The completion of the transcontinental telegraph made its service less competitive, so its significance lies in communication and its transitional role rather than long-term commercial survival. | |
| Question 13[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Short practice explanation using a local 6-mark scale. Apply holistically; do not count the indicative facts as a compulsory checklist. 0 marks for no relevant response. | |
| Lower range (1-3 marks): relevant reasons or description with limited supporting detail or causal development. | |
| Upper range (4-6 marks): accurate supporting detail and developed causal explanation addressing the stated enquiry. Select within the range by accuracy, relevance and development, not the number of named examples. | |
| Accept other accurate explanations within scope. Accept supported armed containment, Chinese intervention and continued division; do not require absolute claims that the superpowers never fought directly. | |
| Indicative explanation: Korea showed how Cold War rivalry could develop into international armed conflict: the UN response to the invasion meant opposition to communist expansion involved military force. Chinese intervention then enlarged the conflict further, as troops were sent to support North Korea against advancing UN forces. The eventual stalemate and armistice left division unresolved, showing limits to the results of military intervention. This explanation does not depend on an unverified absolute about direct superpower contact, or on unsupported spending totals. | |
| Do not count the same explanation twice, reward later consequences as causes without a link, or require every indicative point. No official board tariff is claimed. | |
| Final answer: Korea showed how Cold War rivalry could develop into international armed conflict: the UN response to the invasion meant opposition to communist expansion involved military force. Chinese intervention then enlarged the conflict further, as troops were sent to support North Korea against advancing UN forces. The eventual stalemate and armistice left division unresolved, showing limits to the results of military intervention. This explanation does not depend on an unverified absolute about direct superpower contact, or on unsupported spending totals. | |
| Question 14[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifies relevant detail or gives a simple usefulness judgement. | Level 11 mark |
| explains a relevant inference using detail and accurate context, or explains a specific evidential limit. | Level 22 marks |
| supports a reasoned judgement with detail and linked context, explaining the limit of a constructed teaching extract as evidence. Select the mark by reasoning and accuracy, not the number of comments. | Level 33-4 marks |
| Short practice task with a local 4-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation. Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: The captain stresses ammunition limits and fireships, then weather. Evidence audit: The imagined captain's viewpoint illustrates naval experience but may simplify causation; context should distinguish Gravelines and return-voyage storms. This is constructed teaching material, not a historical document. The stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario; they do not establish that a real witness said or observed these things. Evaluate the illustrative content and hypothetical perspective, without awarding genuine eyewitness or official authority. Seek traceable contemporary records for historical evidence relevant to this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and well-explained limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or asserting authenticity from the supplied attribution. | |
| Final answer: The captain stresses ammunition limits and fireships, then weather. The imagined captain's viewpoint illustrates naval experience but may simplify causation; context should distinguish Gravelines and return-voyage storms. As a constructed teaching extract it illustrates the issue but cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience. Its type, date and viewpoint are part of the imagined scenario. A historian needs traceable contemporary records and relevant corroborating evidence for this enquiry. | |
| Question 15[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Short practice task with a local 6-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation. | |
| identifies relevant illustrative detail or makes a simple comment on usefulness, with limited supporting context. | Level 11-2 marks |
| explains relevant detail using accurate context and a specific limit of inference. | Level 23-4 marks |
| develops a reasoned judgement linked to the enquiry, detail and context, explaining why a constructed extract cannot establish historical testimony or provenance. Select the mark by accuracy and development, not by counting comments. | Level 35-6 marks |
| Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: The formation of two German states illustrates how occupation developed into political division aligned with rival powers. Context: The blockade and airlift reflected conflict over Germany; West Germany formed in May 1949 and East Germany in October. | |
| Evidence audit: The constructed prediction cannot establish what a British newspaper actually said or explain decisions within either German state. This is constructed teaching material. Its stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario and confer no eyewitness, contemporary or official authority. Seek traceable historical records and corroborating evidence for this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and specific limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or assertions of authenticity from the imagined attribution. | |
| Final answer: The formation of two German states illustrates how occupation developed into political division aligned with rival powers. The blockade and airlift reflected conflict over Germany; West Germany formed in May 1949 and East Germany in October. The constructed prediction cannot establish what a British newspaper actually said or explain decisions within either German state. As a constructed teaching extract it cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience, or an authentic official viewpoint. Its usefulness is illustrative; historical conclusions require traceable records and corroborating evidence. | |
| Question 16[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Short practice task with a local 6-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation. | |
| identifies relevant illustrative detail or makes a simple comment on usefulness, with limited supporting context. | Level 11-2 marks |
| explains relevant detail using accurate context and a specific limit of inference. | Level 23-4 marks |
| develops a reasoned judgement linked to the enquiry, detail and context, explaining why a constructed extract cannot establish historical testimony or provenance. Select the mark by accuracy and development, not by counting comments. | Level 35-6 marks |
| Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: Cholera deaths and a dangerous river crossing illustrate risks of migration; hoped-for farmland helps explain continuing west. Context: Disease, river crossings and extreme weather made the journey west dangerous. | |
| Evidence audit: The fictional party cannot establish particular deaths or show the frequency of each danger along the whole trail. This is constructed teaching material. Its stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario and confer no eyewitness, contemporary or official authority. Seek traceable historical records and corroborating evidence for this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and specific limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or assertions of authenticity from the imagined attribution. | |
| Final answer: Cholera deaths and a dangerous river crossing illustrate risks of migration; hoped-for farmland helps explain continuing west. Disease, river crossings and extreme weather made the journey west dangerous. The fictional party cannot establish particular deaths or show the frequency of each danger along the whole trail. As a constructed teaching extract it cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience, or an authentic official viewpoint. Its usefulness is illustrative; historical conclusions require traceable records and corroborating evidence. | |
| Question 17[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Short practice task with a local 6-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation. | |
| identifies relevant illustrative detail or makes a simple comment on the extract's usefulness, with limited supporting context. | Level 11-2 marks |
| explains what relevant detail illustrates, using accurate contextual knowledge, and explains a specific limit of what can be inferred. | Level 23-4 marks |
| develops a reasoned judgement for the enquiry using detail and linked context; explains that the constructed extract cannot establish genuine eyewitness testimony or historical provenance. Select the mark by the accuracy and development of reasoning, not by counting comments. | Level 35-6 marks |
| Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: Beacons, militia lists and drilling show warning systems and local mobilisation. | |
| Evidence audit: The imagined resident's viewpoint illustrates local preparations but gives no reliable national readiness measure or naval strategy. This is constructed teaching material, not a historical document. The stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario; they do not establish that a real witness said or observed these things. Evaluate the illustrative content and hypothetical perspective, without awarding genuine eyewitness or official authority. Seek traceable contemporary records for historical evidence relevant to this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and well-explained limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or asserting authenticity from the supplied attribution. | |
| Final answer: Beacons, militia lists and drilling show warning systems and local mobilisation. The imagined resident's viewpoint illustrates local preparations but gives no reliable national readiness measure or naval strategy. As a constructed teaching extract it illustrates the issue but cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience. Its type, date and viewpoint are part of the imagined scenario. A historian needs traceable contemporary records and relevant corroborating evidence for this enquiry. | |
| Question 18[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Short practice task with a local 6-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation. | |
| identifies relevant illustrative detail or makes a simple comment on the extract's usefulness, with limited supporting context. | Level 11-2 marks |
| explains what relevant detail illustrates, using accurate contextual knowledge, and explains a specific limit of what can be inferred. | Level 23-4 marks |
| develops a reasoned judgement for the enquiry using detail and linked context; explains that the constructed extract cannot establish genuine eyewitness testimony or historical provenance. Select the mark by the accuracy and development of reasoning, not by counting comments. | Level 35-6 marks |
| Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: The extract suggests compulsory sewer provision and inspection despite objections over rates, followed by fewer fevers. | |
| Evidence audit: One officer may defend council spending; a local claimed decline cannot isolate causation or establish national impact. This is constructed teaching material, not a historical document. The stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario; they do not establish that a real witness said or observed these things. Evaluate the illustrative content and hypothetical perspective, without awarding genuine eyewitness or official authority. Seek traceable contemporary records for historical evidence relevant to this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and well-explained limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or asserting authenticity from the supplied attribution. | |
| Final answer: The extract suggests compulsory sewer provision and inspection despite objections over rates, followed by fewer fevers. One officer may defend council spending; a local claimed decline cannot isolate causation or establish national impact. As a constructed teaching extract it illustrates the issue but cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience. Its type, date and viewpoint are part of the imagined scenario. A historian needs traceable contemporary records and relevant corroborating evidence for this enquiry. | |