Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
History
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?

Year 11 Paper 1: Medicine, the Western Front and Elizabethan England

Covers medicine in Britain from the medieval period to the present day, the trench system and medical treatment on the Western Front, and Elizabethan government and society.

17 questions - 80 marks

Year 11 follows a typical teaching order. No exam board defines what belongs to Year 11, and schools sequence the course differently. Check it against your own scheme of work before using it to decide what a class has covered.

Download PDF

Open GCSE History workspace

Questions

Question 1 [2 marks]

Elizabeth I and Government

Give two features of the Religious Settlement of 1559.

Question 2 [2 marks]

Elizabethan Society and the Spanish Armada

Give two reasons why English sailors undertook voyages of exploration and trade during Elizabeth's reign.

Question 3 [4 marks]

Medicine in Britain, c1250-c1700

Describe two features of medieval hospitals.

Question 4 [4 marks]

Elizabethan Society and the Spanish Armada

Describe two features of the causes of poverty in Elizabethan England.

Question 5 [4 marks]

Wounds, Illness and Treatment on the Western Front

Describe two features of the chain of evacuation used to move wounded soldiers away from the front line.

Question 6 [4 marks]

The Trench System on the Western Front

Describe two features of the British trench system on the Western Front.

Question 7 [4 marks]

Medicine in Britain, c1700-Present

Explain one way in which the response to the discovery of the link between smoking and lung cancer was different from earlier public health approaches.

Question 8 [4 marks]

Elizabeth I and Government

Explain one way in which the Revolt of the Northern Earls in 1569 was different from the Ridolfi Plot of 1571.

Question 9 [6 marks]

The Trench System on the Western Front

Explain why the introduction of tanks at the Battle of the Somme in 1916 was significant for trench warfare.

Question 10 [6 marks]

Medicine in Britain, c1700-Present

Explain why the Public Health Act of 1848 had only a limited impact on public health in Britain.

Question 11 [6 marks]

The Trench System on the Western Front

Explain why trench raids were regularly carried out by both sides on the Western Front.

Question 12 [6 marks]

Medicine in Britain, c1700-Present

Explain why the discovery of the structure of DNA by Watson and Crick in 1953 was important for the later development of medicine.

Question 13 [4 marks]

Elizabethan Society and the Spanish Armada

Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question, in the style of a letter written by an English sea captain to his family shortly after the Spanish Armada was defeated in 1588. The writer and situation are imagined; this is not a quotation from a historical document.

'We chased the Spanish ships for days, firing on them whenever we came close enough, but our powder ran low before we could sink many. It was the fireships off Calais, and then the great storm that drove them north, that truly broke them.'

How useful is Source A to a historian studying why the Spanish Armada was defeated? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.

Question 14 [6 marks]

The Trench System on the Western Front

Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question, in the style of a letter written by a stretcher-bearer serving with a British regiment in Flanders in 1917. The writer and situation are imagined; this is not a quotation from a historical document.

'It took four of us three hours to bring one man back from the line last night, wading through mud up to our knees the whole way. The communication trench was so narrow in places that we had to lift the stretcher above our heads. Shells were falling near the support line as we passed.'

How useful is Source A to a historian studying the evacuation of wounded soldiers on the Western Front? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.

Question 15 [6 marks]

Medicine in Britain, c1700-Present

Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question, in the style of an account written by a surgeon describing an operation performed in a London hospital in 1847, shortly after ether had begun to be used. The writer and situation are imagined; this is not a quotation from a historical document.

'The patient breathed the vapour from the sponge and within minutes lay still, feeling nothing of the knife. Only months ago such an operation would have brought screams that unnerved the whole ward. Some colleagues still doubt whether the vapour is safe to use.'

How useful is Source A to a historian studying the introduction of anaesthetics in British surgery? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.

Question 16 [6 marks]

Medicine in Britain, c1250-c1700

Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question: a third-person summary in the style of medical notes about Thomas Sydenham's approach in London in the 1660s, from the imagined viewpoint of an unnamed student interested in observation. This is constructed teaching material, not a quotation from a historical document.

Sydenham's approach emphasised watching patients closely and recording the course of a fever before identifying the illness. Observation could challenge explanations inherited from ancient Greek medical texts.

How useful is Source A to a historian studying changing approaches to medicine in the later seventeenth century? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.

Question 17 [6 marks]

Wounds, Illness and Treatment on the Western Front

Source A: an invented extract written for this practice question, in the style of the diary of a surgeon working at a Casualty Clearing Station in France in 1916. The writer and situation are imagined; this is not a quotation from a historical document.

'We amputated the leg by lamplight, the chloroform our only relief for the man beneath the knife. Even so, I fear infection more than the surgery itself, for the ground here breeds it faster than we can guard against.'

How useful is Source A to a historian studying surgical conditions at a Casualty Clearing Station on the Western Front? Explain your answer using Source A and your own knowledge of the historical context. Distinguish what the extract can illustrate from what it can establish as historical evidence.

Model solutions

Mark scheme for Question 1 [2 marks]
Question 1[2 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
each of two distinct historically correct answers, up to 2 marks. The following are examples, not an exhaustive list. 1 mark for the Act of Supremacy making Elizabeth Supreme Governor of the Church of England.B1
the Act of Uniformity requiring a single Book of Common Prayer to be used in every church and imposing fines on those who did not attend. Accept other historically correct answers that meet the question's time frame and focus. Do not count the same example twice or require explanations beyond what the question asks.1
Final answer: The Act of Supremacy made Elizabeth Supreme Governor of the Church, and the Act of Uniformity required one Book of Common Prayer, with fines for non-attendance.
Mark scheme for Question 2 [2 marks]
Question 2[2 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
each of two distinct historically correct answers, up to 2 marks. The following are examples, not an exhaustive list. 1 mark for the search for new, more profitable trade routes to Asia, such as a Northwest Passage around North America, to avoid routes already controlled by Spain and Portugal.B1
the hope of gaining wealth by plundering Spanish treasure ships and colonies in the Americas. Accept other historically correct answers that meet the question's time frame and focus. Do not count the same example twice or require explanations beyond what the question asks.1
Final answer: Searching for new trade routes such as a Northwest Passage, and hoping to plunder wealth from Spanish treasure ships and colonies.
Mark scheme for Question 3 [4 marks]
Question 3[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Award up to 2 marks for each of two distinct features: B1 for identifying a valid feature and B1 for relevant supporting detail about that same feature. Maximum 4 marks. The examples below are indicative; accept other accurate features and linked development. Identifies that most hospitals were run by religious orders such as monks and nuns.
Develops this by explaining that care focused on rest, prayer and a clean environment rather than medical cure.
Identifies that hospitals restricted who they admitted. Develops this by explaining that many refused patients with infectious diseases, the dying or the incurable, keeping beds for those who might recover.
Do not demand these particular two features, double-count the same detail, or award a development mark for an unrelated third feature.
Final answer: Many hospitals were run by religious institutions and provided nursing, rest, food and prayer rather than effective cures. Admission was selective: some excluded infectious patients or people considered incurable.
Mark scheme for Question 4 [4 marks]
Question 4[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Award up to 2 marks for each of two distinct features: B1 for identifying a valid feature and B1 for relevant supporting detail about that same feature. Maximum 4 marks. The examples below are indicative; accept other accurate features and linked development. Identifies that the population grew rapidly during Elizabeth's reign, increasing demand for food and jobs.
Develops this by explaining that this led to rising prices (inflation) and made it harder for poorer people to afford basic goods.
Identifies that enclosure of common land by landowners reduced the land available to ordinary people for farming. Develops this by explaining that some landowners also switched from growing crops to keeping sheep, which needed fewer workers, leaving many labourers without work.
Do not demand these particular two features, double-count the same detail, or award a development mark for an unrelated third feature.
Final answer: Rapid population growth pushing up prices, and enclosure of common land, often for sheep farming, reducing work available to labourers.
Mark scheme for Question 5 [4 marks]
Question 5[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Award up to 2 marks for each of two distinct features: B1 for identifying a valid feature and B1 for relevant supporting detail about that same feature. Maximum 4 marks. The examples below are indicative; accept other accurate features and linked development. Identifies that a wounded soldier was first seen at a Regimental Aid Post close to the front line.
Develops this by explaining that here a Regimental Medical Officer gave basic first aid, such as dressing a wound, before deciding whether the man could return to duty or needed to be moved further back.
Identifies that more serious cases were passed on to an Advanced Dressing Station and then a Casualty Clearing Station. Develops this by explaining that a Casualty Clearing Station carried out more serious treatment and emergency surgery, before the most seriously wounded were sent on by train or barge to a Base Hospital.
Do not demand these particular two features, double-count the same detail, or award a development mark for an unrelated third feature.
Final answer: The chain ran from the Regimental Aid Post, giving basic first aid, through the Advanced Dressing Station to the Casualty Clearing Station for emergency surgery, then on to a Base Hospital.
Mark scheme for Question 6 [4 marks]
Question 6[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Award up to 2 marks for each of two distinct features: B1 for identifying a valid feature and B1 for relevant supporting detail about that same feature. Maximum 4 marks. The examples below are indicative; accept other accurate features and linked development. Identifies that the system was made up of several lines of trenches, including a front line trench, a support trench and a reserve trench.
Develops this by explaining that these lines were linked by communication trenches, which allowed men, supplies and messages to move between them without crossing open ground.
Identifies that trenches were dug in a zigzag pattern rather than straight lines. Develops this by explaining that this limited the damage from a shell landing directly in a trench and stopped an enemy soldier who entered the trench from firing straight along its whole length.
Do not demand these particular two features, double-count the same detail, or award a development mark for an unrelated third feature.
Final answer: Several linked lines (front, support and reserve) joined by communication trenches, and trenches dug in a zigzag pattern to limit blast and enfilade fire.
Mark scheme for Question 7 [4 marks]
Question 7[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Apply a holistic 4-mark comparison scale. 0 marks: no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): a simple comparison or relevant information with limited explanation. Level 2 (3-4 marks): one clear similarity or difference is explained with specific accurate detail supporting both sides; award 4 for a fully developed comparison. The following content is indicative, not four separate compulsory marks. Accept any historically correct comparison meeting the prompt, and allow full marks for one developed way. Unconnected facts without a comparison remain in Level 1.
Identifies that earlier public health efforts, such as nineteenth-century sewers and clean water supplies, focused on preventing infectious disease spread through the shared environment.
Develops this by explaining that these earlier improvements were achieved mainly through engineering projects and legislation controlling conditions such as water supply and waste disposal. Identifies that research by Richard Doll and Austin Bradford Hill in the 1950s established a statistical link between smoking and lung cancer.
Develops this by explaining that this shifted some public health effort towards changing individual lifestyle choices, for example through government health warnings and later restrictions on cigarette advertising.
Final answer: Earlier public health measures tackled the shared environment through engineering and law; Doll and Hill's 1950s research on smoking and lung cancer shifted some effort towards changing individual lifestyle choices through warnings and advertising restrictions.
Mark scheme for Question 8 [4 marks]
Question 8[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Apply a holistic 4-mark comparison scale. 0 marks: no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): a simple comparison or relevant information with limited explanation. Level 2 (3-4 marks): one clear similarity or difference is explained with specific accurate detail supporting both sides; award 4 for a fully developed comparison. The following content is indicative, not four separate compulsory marks. Accept any historically correct comparison meeting the prompt, and allow full marks for one developed way. Unconnected facts without a comparison remain in Level 1.
Identifies that the Revolt of the Northern Earls in 1569 was an open armed rebellion, led by Catholic nobles who raised troops and briefly took control of Durham Cathedral.
Develops this by explaining that Elizabeth's government defeated it with military force and punished those involved severely, including executing hundreds of ordinary rebels. Identifies that the Ridolfi Plot of 1571 was instead a secret conspiracy, involving a plan for Spanish invasion, a rebellion by English Catholics and the marriage of Mary, Queen of Scots to the Duke of Norfolk.
Develops this by explaining that it relied on secrecy and foreign support rather than an open uprising, and was uncovered through William Cecil's investigations before it could be carried out.
Final answer: The Revolt of the Northern Earls was an open armed rebellion crushed by force; the Ridolfi Plot was a secret conspiracy involving foreign invasion and a planned marriage, uncovered before it happened.
Mark scheme for Question 9 [6 marks]
Question 9[6 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Short practice task using a local 6-mark scale, not the official 12-mark explanation tariff. Apply levels holistically: 0 marks for no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): relevant reasons or effects are identified with little causal development. Level 2 (3-4 marks): develops a supported causal explanation. Level 3 (5-6 marks): develops a coherent explanation supported by precise, relevant evidence, showing how reasons or effects answer the question. Award 6 for sustained accurate reasoning. The following content is indicative. Accept other accurate explanations within the prompt's focus. Do not count one bullet per mark, require every listed factor, or award full marks for a list without explaining the connection to the question.
Tanks were introduced by the British for the first time at the Battle of the Somme in September 1916.
They were designed to be able to cross difficult ground, including trenches and barbed wire, that had proved so costly for infantry attacking on foot.
Their armour offered some protection against machine-gun fire, which had caused huge infantry casualties in earlier attacks such as the first day of the Somme. Early tanks were unreliable, slow and often broke down or became stuck in the mud, so their actual impact at the Somme itself was limited.
Despite this, they represented a new way of trying to overcome the deadlock of trench warfare, offering a possible means of breaking through enemy lines that infantry and artillery alone had struggled to achieve.
Tanks were used in greater numbers and with more success later in the war, for example at the Battle of Cambrai in 1917, showing their growing importance as the technology improved.
Final answer: Tanks, introduced at the Somme in 1916, were designed to cross trenches and barbed wire while resisting machine-gun fire; though unreliable at first, they offered a new way to try to break the trench deadlock and grew more effective, as at Cambrai in 1917.
Mark scheme for Question 10 [6 marks]
Question 10[6 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Short practice task using a local 6-mark scale, not the official 12-mark explanation tariff. Apply levels holistically: 0 marks for no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): relevant reasons or effects are identified with little causal development. Level 2 (3-4 marks): develops a supported causal explanation. Level 3 (5-6 marks): develops a coherent explanation supported by precise, relevant evidence, showing how reasons or effects answer the question. Award 6 for sustained accurate reasoning. The following content is indicative. Accept other accurate explanations within the prompt's focus. Do not count one bullet per mark, require every listed factor, or award full marks for a list without explaining the connection to the question.
The Act followed the cholera epidemics of the 1830s-40s and Edwin Chadwick's 1842 Report on the sanitary condition of the labouring population, which had exposed the link between dirty living conditions and disease.
The Act created a largely permissive framework for local sanitary improvements rather than universal duties on every council. Do not imply there were no mechanisms at all for intervention.
Many local authorities chose not to act, since improvements were expensive and would mean raising local rates (taxes) to pay for them. There was also strong opposition to interference from central government in local affairs, based on the belief that towns should be free to run their own affairs.
The General Board of Health had limited powers and faced political opposition; it ended in 1858.
The 1875 Act strengthened compulsory local duties. Earlier progress was uneven rather than wholly absent, so credit specific explanations of limited implementation, cost and resistance.
Final answer: The 1848 Act left much sanitary action to local initiative. Councils could resist expensive improvements and rate increases, while opposition to central interference weakened enforcement. Its impact was uneven; later legislation strengthened compulsory duties.
Mark scheme for Question 11 [6 marks]
Question 11[6 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Short practice task using a local 6-mark scale, not the official 12-mark explanation tariff. Apply levels holistically: 0 marks for no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): relevant reasons or effects are identified with little causal development. Level 2 (3-4 marks): develops a supported causal explanation. Level 3 (5-6 marks): develops a coherent explanation supported by precise, relevant evidence, showing how reasons or effects answer the question. Award 6 for sustained accurate reasoning. The following content is indicative. Accept other accurate explanations within the prompt's focus. Do not count one bullet per mark, require every listed factor, or award full marks for a list without explaining the connection to the question.
Small groups of soldiers were sent, usually at night, to cross No Man's Land and enter an enemy trench in order to gather information about which units were opposite them.
Raiders often tried to capture prisoners for interrogation, since prisoners could reveal useful details such as troop numbers, morale or plans for an attack.
Raids allowed commanders to test the strength of enemy defences, such as the state of their wire and the alertness of sentries, without committing to a full attack. Destroying sections of enemy trench, dugouts or equipment during a raid could weaken the enemy's defences ahead of a larger planned offensive.
Commanders also used raids to keep their own soldiers active and aggressive, believing that constant raiding maintained morale and an offensive spirit even during quiet periods.
Raids gave junior officers and men practical experience of attacking and moving through No Man's Land under fire, which was useful preparation for larger operations.
Final answer: Raids captured prisoners and documents, giving commanders intelligence about opposing units and defences. They could damage enemy positions before larger attacks. Commanders also believed frequent small attacks would maintain an offensive spirit and give troops practical experience rather than letting quiet sectors become inactive.
Mark scheme for Question 12 [6 marks]
Question 12[6 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Short practice task using a local 6-mark scale, not the official 12-mark explanation tariff. Apply levels holistically: 0 marks for no relevant material. Level 1 (1-2 marks): relevant reasons or effects are identified with little causal development. Level 2 (3-4 marks): develops a supported causal explanation. Level 3 (5-6 marks): develops a coherent explanation supported by precise, relevant evidence, showing how reasons or effects answer the question. Award 6 for sustained accurate reasoning. The following content is indicative. Accept other accurate explanations within the prompt's focus. Do not count one bullet per mark, require every listed factor, or award full marks for a list without explaining the connection to the question.
Before 1953, scientists did not fully understand how genetic information was stored and passed on, which limited understanding of the causes of many inherited conditions.
Watson and Crick's model of the double helix explained how DNA could copy itself accurately, providing a physical explanation for heredity that could be tested and built upon.
This discovery laid the foundation for later genetic research, including identifying the genes responsible for specific inherited diseases. It contributed to the eventual development of genetic testing, allowing some conditions to be diagnosed, or a person's risk assessed, before symptoms appeared.
It also underpinned longer-term developments such as gene therapy, which aims to treat disease by correcting or replacing faulty genetic material.
The double-helix model transformed molecular understanding and later medical research; genetics and the study of inheritance existed before 1953.
Final answer: By explaining how genetic information is stored and copied, Watson and Crick's 1953 discovery of DNA's structure laid the foundation for genetic testing, gene therapy and modern genetic medicine.
Mark scheme for Question 13 [4 marks]
Question 13[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
identifies relevant detail or gives a simple usefulness judgement.Level 11 mark
explains a relevant inference using detail and accurate context, or explains a specific evidential limit.Level 22 marks
supports a reasoned judgement with detail and linked context, explaining the limit of a constructed teaching extract as evidence. Select the mark by reasoning and accuracy, not the number of comments.Level 33-4 marks
Short practice task with a local 4-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation. Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: The captain stresses ammunition limits and fireships, then weather. Evidence audit: The imagined captain's viewpoint illustrates naval experience but may simplify causation; context should distinguish Gravelines and return-voyage storms. This is constructed teaching material, not a historical document. The stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario; they do not establish that a real witness said or observed these things. Evaluate the illustrative content and hypothetical perspective, without awarding genuine eyewitness or official authority. Seek traceable contemporary records for historical evidence relevant to this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and well-explained limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or asserting authenticity from the supplied attribution.
Final answer: The captain stresses ammunition limits and fireships, then weather. The imagined captain's viewpoint illustrates naval experience but may simplify causation; context should distinguish Gravelines and return-voyage storms. As a constructed teaching extract it illustrates the issue but cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience. Its type, date and viewpoint are part of the imagined scenario. A historian needs traceable contemporary records and relevant corroborating evidence for this enquiry.
Mark scheme for Question 14 [6 marks]
Question 14[6 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Short practice task with a local 6-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation.
identifies relevant illustrative detail or makes a simple comment on the extract's usefulness, with limited supporting context.Level 11-2 marks
explains what relevant detail illustrates, using accurate contextual knowledge, and explains a specific limit of what can be inferred.Level 23-4 marks
develops a reasoned judgement for the enquiry using detail and linked context; explains that the constructed extract cannot establish genuine eyewitness testimony or historical provenance. Select the mark by the accuracy and development of reasoning, not by counting comments.Level 35-6 marks
Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: Knee-deep mud, narrow trenches and shellfire show slow, dangerous stretcher evacuation.
Evidence audit: The scenario assigns relevant experience to a bearer, but that role is imagined; one depicted journey cannot represent every route or authenticate the letter. This is constructed teaching material, not a historical document. The stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario; they do not establish that a real witness said or observed these things. Evaluate the illustrative content and hypothetical perspective, without awarding genuine eyewitness or official authority. Seek traceable contemporary records for historical evidence relevant to this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and well-explained limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or asserting authenticity from the supplied attribution.
Final answer: Knee-deep mud, narrow trenches and shellfire show slow, dangerous stretcher evacuation. The scenario assigns relevant experience to a bearer, but that role is imagined; one depicted journey cannot represent every route or authenticate the letter. As a constructed teaching extract it illustrates the issue but cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience. Its type, date and viewpoint are part of the imagined scenario. A historian needs traceable contemporary records and relevant corroborating evidence for this enquiry.
Mark scheme for Question 15 [6 marks]
Question 15[6 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Short practice task with a local 6-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation.
identifies relevant illustrative detail or makes a simple comment on the extract's usefulness, with limited supporting context.Level 11-2 marks
explains what relevant detail illustrates, using accurate contextual knowledge, and explains a specific limit of what can be inferred.Level 23-4 marks
develops a reasoned judgement for the enquiry using detail and linked context; explains that the constructed extract cannot establish genuine eyewitness testimony or historical provenance. Select the mark by the accuracy and development of reasoning, not by counting comments.Level 35-6 marks
Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: The extract shows anaesthesia suppressing pain and resistance about safety.
Evidence audit: One surgeon's report may favour adoption; it says nothing about solving infection, and the report is constructed. This is constructed teaching material, not a historical document. The stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario; they do not establish that a real witness said or observed these things. Evaluate the illustrative content and hypothetical perspective, without awarding genuine eyewitness or official authority. Seek traceable contemporary records for historical evidence relevant to this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and well-explained limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or asserting authenticity from the supplied attribution.
Final answer: The extract shows anaesthesia suppressing pain and resistance about safety. One surgeon's report may favour adoption; it says nothing about solving infection, and the report is constructed. As a constructed teaching extract it illustrates the issue but cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience. Its type, date and viewpoint are part of the imagined scenario. A historian needs traceable contemporary records and relevant corroborating evidence for this enquiry.
Mark scheme for Question 16 [6 marks]
Question 16[6 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Short practice task with a local 6-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation.
identifies relevant illustrative detail or makes a simple comment on the extract's usefulness, with limited supporting context.Level 11-2 marks
explains what relevant detail illustrates, using accurate contextual knowledge, and explains a specific limit of what can be inferred.Level 23-4 marks
develops a reasoned judgement for the enquiry using detail and linked context; explains that the constructed extract cannot establish genuine eyewitness testimony or historical provenance. Select the mark by the accuracy and development of reasoning, not by counting comments.Level 35-6 marks
Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: Close observation and recording fevers suggest diagnosis from cases rather than inherited texts.
Evidence audit: The constructed student viewpoint favours observation; this summary cannot establish a real pupil's testimony, Sydenham's exact words or how widely his methods were used. This is constructed teaching material, not a historical document. The stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario; they do not establish that a real witness said or observed these things. Evaluate the illustrative content and hypothetical perspective, without awarding genuine eyewitness or official authority. Seek traceable contemporary records for historical evidence relevant to this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and well-explained limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or asserting authenticity from the supplied attribution.
Final answer: Close observation and recording fevers suggest diagnosis from cases rather than inherited texts. The constructed student viewpoint favours observation; this summary cannot establish a real pupil's testimony, Sydenham's exact words or how widely his methods were used. As a constructed teaching extract it illustrates the issue but cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience. Its type, date and viewpoint are part of the imagined scenario. A historian needs traceable contemporary records and relevant corroborating evidence for this enquiry.
Mark scheme for Question 17 [6 marks]
Question 17[6 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Short practice task with a local 6-mark scale; this is not an official exam-board source-question tariff. Apply the levels holistically. 0 marks: no relevant interpretation or evaluation.
identifies relevant illustrative detail or makes a simple comment on the extract's usefulness, with limited supporting context.Level 11-2 marks
explains what relevant detail illustrates, using accurate contextual knowledge, and explains a specific limit of what can be inferred.Level 23-4 marks
develops a reasoned judgement for the enquiry using detail and linked context; explains that the constructed extract cannot establish genuine eyewitness testimony or historical provenance. Select the mark by the accuracy and development of reasoning, not by counting comments.Level 35-6 marks
Indicative interpretation, not a compulsory checklist: Lamplight and chloroform show emergency operating conditions; fear of infection shows continuing danger.
Evidence audit: A genuine surgeon's experience could be useful, but the supplied role is imagined; this extract cannot establish all CCS facilities or outcomes. This is constructed teaching material, not a historical document. The stated type, date and viewpoint define the imagined scenario; they do not establish that a real witness said or observed these things. Evaluate the illustrative content and hypothetical perspective, without awarding genuine eyewitness or official authority. Seek traceable contemporary records for historical evidence relevant to this enquiry. Accept other historically accurate interpretations, contextual checks and well-explained limitations. Do not award separate marks for generic bias labels, unlinked knowledge or asserting authenticity from the supplied attribution.
Final answer: Lamplight and chloroform show emergency operating conditions; fear of infection shows continuing danger. A genuine surgeon's experience could be useful, but the supplied role is imagined; this extract cannot establish all CCS facilities or outcomes. As a constructed teaching extract it illustrates the issue but cannot establish an actual witness's words or experience. Its type, date and viewpoint are part of the imagined scenario. A historian needs traceable contemporary records and relevant corroborating evidence for this enquiry.

Build a free practice pack.

Pick the topics, add the student's name and print one PDF.