Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
Sociology

Year 11 Paper 1: Crime and Deviance

Covers both crime topics, explanations of crime and how crime is controlled, alongside sociological theory, research methods and education policy.

15 questions - 60 marks

Year 11 follows a typical teaching order. No exam board defines what belongs to Year 11, and schools sequence the course differently. Check it against your own scheme of work before using it to decide what a class has covered.

Download PDF

Open GCSE Sociology workspace

Questions

Question 1 [2 marks]

Research Methods and Design

As well as primary data collected first-hand, sociologists can also use secondary data, information that already exists and was not originally collected for their own study.

Identify two examples of secondary data a sociologist might use in their research.

Question 2 [2 marks]

Education Structure and Policy

The UK school system includes different types of secondary school, such as comprehensive schools, academies and grammar schools.

Identify two types of secondary school found in the UK education system.

Question 3 [3 marks]

Patterns, Trends and Social Control

Recorded offending can vary by age and by offence type.

Explain one reason why teenagers and young adults may be more likely to be recorded as offenders than older adults for some offences.

Question 4 [3 marks]

Explanations of Crime and Deviance

Functionalist sociologist Emile Durkheim argued that crime is normal in society and can sometimes perform useful functions.

Explain one way in which functionalists argue that crime can be beneficial for society.

Question 5 [3 marks]

Sociological Perspectives and Theory

Postmodern sociologists argue that society today is too diverse and fast-changing for a single 'big theory', such as functionalism or Marxism, to explain everything about it.

Explain one way in which the postmodernist view of society differs from a functionalist view.

Question 6 [4 marks]

Explanations of Crime and Deviance

Differential association theory argues that criminal behaviour, like any other behaviour, is learned through interaction with other people.

Explain two ways in which differential association theory explains why some people become more likely to commit crime.

Question 7 [4 marks]

Sociological Perspectives and Theory

Positivist sociologists believe society can be studied objectively, in a similar way to a natural science, while interpretivist sociologists argue that understanding the meanings behind people's actions matters more than simply measuring behaviour.

Explain two ways in which a positivist approach to sociology differs from an interpretivist approach.

Question 8 [4 marks]

Education Structure and Policy

Comprehensive schools were introduced from the 1960s to replace the earlier system that sorted pupils into grammar and secondary modern schools at age eleven.

Explain two reasons why comprehensive schools were introduced in the UK.

Question 9 [4 marks]

Sociological Perspectives and Theory

Functionalists tend to see social change as a gradual process of adaptation, while Marxists tend to see social change as driven by conflict between classes with opposing interests.

Explain two ways in which functionalists explain social change differently from Marxists.

Question 10 [4 marks]

Patterns, Trends and Social Control

Security measures and everyday activities can change the opportunities for offences such as theft and burglary.

Explain two distinct changes that could reduce opportunities for theft or burglary, showing how each could reduce offending.

Question 11 [4 marks]

Sociological Perspectives and Theory

Marxist sociologists argue that most institutions in society, including education and the media, work in the interests of the ruling class.

Explain two ways in which Marxists argue institutions serve the interests of the ruling class.

Question 12 [5 marks]

Research Methods and Design

Sociologists judge research methods using two different ideas: validity, whether a method truly captures what it claims to measure, and reliability, whether the same method would produce the same results if repeated.

Explain what validity and reliability each assess, then use an example to explain how data can be reliable but lack validity.

Question 13 [6 marks]

Explanations of Crime and Deviance

Some sociologists argue that a lack of legitimate opportunities in deprived areas pushes some young people towards gang membership and crime.

Explain two ways in which a lack of legitimate opportunities can lead to gang-related crime.

Question 14 [6 marks]

Sociological Perspectives and Theory

Some sociologists argue that no single perspective, such as functionalism, Marxism or feminism, can fully explain a complex institution like the family on its own.

Explain two reasons why using more than one sociological perspective can give a fuller understanding of an institution such as the family.

Question 15 [6 marks]

Explanations of Crime and Deviance

Marxist sociologists analyse how capitalist ownership and class power can shape criminal law, enforcement and opportunities for offending.

Explain two ways in which Marxist sociologists explain patterns of crime and its control.

Model solutions

Mark scheme for Question 1 [2 marks]
Question 1[2 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Identify previously collected official statistics as one example of secondary data.B1
Identify an existing diary, document or earlier research dataset as a distinct secondary source. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: An earlier researcher's published survey results can be analysed as secondary data in a new project. Distinct-credit limit: Do not count an interview conducted by the current researcher as secondary simply because its transcript is written down later. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: An earlier researcher's published survey results can be analysed as secondary data in a new project. Exclusions: Do not count an interview conducted by the current researcher as secondary simply because its transcript is written down later.B1
Final answer: Previously published census tables are secondary data when analysed for a new study. Existing personal diaries written independently of this study are another secondary source.
Mark scheme for Question 2 [2 marks]
Question 2[2 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
one correctly identified type of secondary school, such as a comprehensive schoolB1
a second correctly identified type, such as an academy, grammar school, free school or independent schoolB1
Final answer: Any two of: comprehensive school, academy, grammar school, free school, independent (private) school
Mark scheme for Question 3 [3 marks]
Question 3[3 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
identifying a valid reason, such as young people spending more time out in public spaces with peersB1
a linked development of that reasonB1
a further linked development or example that completes the explanationB1
Final answer: Example answer: Young people may seek approval from risk-taking peers. Offending can earn group status. Visible group activity can also make their offences more likely to attract police attention. Accept other valid answers: Peer pressure, risk-taking, weaker conventional commitments or selective policing; distinguish actual offending from recording.
Mark scheme for Question 4 [3 marks]
Question 4[3 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
identifying a valid way crime can be beneficial, such as crime reinforcing shared values when society reacts against itB1
a linked development of that wayB1
a further linked development or example that completes the explanationB1
Final answer: Example answer: Public condemnation of a crime reaffirms shared norms. People unite in disapproval of the offence. This strengthens solidarity and clarifies acceptable behaviour. Accept other valid answers: Boundary maintenance, social solidarity or deviance enabling social change, each with a linked mechanism.
Mark scheme for Question 5 [3 marks]
Question 5[3 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Contrast postmodern rejection of one universal grand account with functionalist systemic explanation.B1
Explain why diverse identities and experiences challenge an account premised on shared integration.B1
Develop how functionalism seeks institutional interdependence or value consensus where postmodernism questions one common social narrative. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: Postmodern emphasis on diverse identities can contrast with functionalist emphasis on shared value consensus. Distinct-credit limit: Do not claim functionalists deny every social difference or that postmodernists reject all empirical enquiry. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: Postmodern emphasis on diverse identities can contrast with functionalist emphasis on shared value consensus. Exclusions: Do not claim functionalists deny every social difference or that postmodernists reject all empirical enquiry.B1
Final answer: Postmodernists question a universal account of society because identities and ways of life are diverse. Functionalism instead seeks to explain how institutions and shared values form an integrated social system.
Mark scheme for Question 6 [4 marks]
Question 6[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
identifying a first way, such as spending a lot of time with people who hold pro-criminal attitudes making a person more likely to adopt those attitudes themselvesB1
a linked development of the first wayB1
identifying a second way, such as learning specific techniques for committing an offence from more experienced offendersB1
a linked development of the second wayB1
Final answer: Example answer: Close interaction with offenders can teach criminal techniques. Knowing how to commit an offence makes participation more possible. Repeated favourable definitions of lawbreaking can outweigh unfavourable ones. Offending becomes justified and more likely through learned attitudes. Accept other valid answers: Learning techniques and learning favourable definitions; frequency, duration, priority or intensity may develop the learning process.
Mark scheme for Question 7 [4 marks]
Question 7[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Contrast positivist interest in observable causal patterns with interpretivist understanding of subjective meanings.B1
Explain how measuring behavioural regularities differs from understanding what an action means to its actor.B1
Contrast common positivist preference for standardised numerical methods with interpretivist preference for flexible qualitative enquiry.B1
Explain how those methodological tendencies serve different aims without treating every method choice as exclusive or automatic. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: Standardisation and researcher distance versus flexible engagement may be developed as a further comparison when linked to epistemological aims. Distinct-credit limit: Do not assert every questionnaire is quantitative or every interpretivist rejects every numerical technique. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: Standardisation and researcher distance versus flexible engagement may be developed as a further comparison when linked to epistemological aims. Exclusions: Do not assert every questionnaire is quantitative or every interpretivist rejects every numerical technique.B1
Final answer: Positivists seek observable patterns and causal explanations, whereas interpretivists prioritise understanding actors' subjective meanings. Positivists often favour standardised quantitative measures, whereas interpretivists often favour flexible qualitative enquiry; these are tendencies rather than exclusive method rules.
Mark scheme for Question 8 [4 marks]
Question 8[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
identifying a first valid reason, such as concern that the eleven-plus exam was unfair to working-class pupilsB1
a linked development of the first reasonB1
identifying a second valid reason, such as a wish to give all pupils equal opportunity regardless of backgroundB1
a linked development of the second reasonB1
Final answer: e.g. many argued the eleven-plus unfairly disadvantaged working-class pupils, and comprehensive schools aimed to give pupils of all backgrounds the same opportunities
Mark scheme for Question 9 [4 marks]
Question 9[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Contrast functionalist adaptation and coordination with Marxist class contradiction as mechanisms of change.B1
Explain how institutional adjustment differs from conflict arising from opposing ownership and labour interests.B1
Contrast gradual order-preserving change with the possibility of revolutionary structural transformation.B1
Explain how changing ownership relations differs in depth from adaptation, while acknowledging these are tendencies rather than universal rules. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: Changes restoring institutional coordination can contrast with transformation of ownership relations as another developed illustration. Distinct-credit limit: Do not claim Marxists explain every instance of change as an immediate revolution or functionalists deny change altogether. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: Changes restoring institutional coordination can contrast with transformation of ownership relations as another developed illustration. Exclusions: Do not claim Marxists explain every instance of change as an immediate revolution or functionalists deny change altogether.B1
Final answer: Functionalists emphasise adaptation that restores coordination between institutions, whereas Marxists explain change through contradictions and conflict in class relations. Functionalists tend to stress gradual adjustment preserving order, whereas Marxists allow revolutionary transformation of class relations, without claiming every change must be revolutionary.
Mark scheme for Question 10 [4 marks]
Question 10[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
identify one change reducing opportunities, such as improved locks or immobilisers.B1
explain how it raises effort or risk and can reduce offending.B1
identify a distinct change, such as carrying less cash, reducing accessible rewards.B1
explain the second prevention mechanism. Accept other distinct opportunity changes; two examples of the same security mechanism alone are not two explanations.B1
Final answer: Example answer: Better locks and vehicle immobilisers can increase the effort of theft and prevent unauthorised entry or use. This reduces opportunities for successful theft. If people carry less cash, a theft offers a smaller accessible reward. Some offenders may judge that reward insufficient, reducing opportunities for cash theft. Accept other valid distinct opportunity changes with a linked explanation. Two security devices alone do not establish two distinct mechanisms.
Mark scheme for Question 11 [4 marks]
Question 11[4 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Identify the hidden curriculum teaching acceptance of authority in a Marxist account.B1
Explain how obedience can prepare pupils to accept employer authority, benefiting the ruling class.B1
Identify media legitimation of capitalist inequality as a distinct institutional mechanism.B1
Explain how presenting inequality as natural or deserved can reduce challenges to ruling-class power. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: Education may legitimate class inequality by presenting unequal outcomes as entirely meritocratic within a Marxist explanation. Distinct-credit limit: Do not treat the Marxist interpretation as an empirically proven description of every school or media message. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: Education may legitimate class inequality by presenting unequal outcomes as entirely meritocratic within a Marxist explanation. Exclusions: Do not treat the Marxist interpretation as an empirically proven description of every school or media message.B1
Final answer: Marxists argue schools can reward obedience through the hidden curriculum, preparing workers to accept employer authority. They argue media can present capitalist inequality as normal or deserved, helping legitimate ruling-class advantage.
Mark scheme for Question 12 [5 marks]
Question 12[5 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Contrast validity as measuring the intended phenomenon with reliability as measurement consistency.B1
Explain that truthfulness or appropriateness and repeatability under comparable conditions answer different evaluative questions.B1
Identify their logical independence through consistently distorted responses or another appropriate example.B1
Explain how a leading instrument can repeat the same biased pattern while failing to measure genuine views.B1
Add new illustration or detail distinguishing instrument inconsistency from genuine change in the social circumstances measured. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: A consistently miscalibrated measure illustrates reliable but invalid findings, provided the intended concept and distortion are explained. Distinct-credit limit: Reliability does not mean truth, and changing social circumstances can change results without demonstrating an unreliable instrument. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: A consistently miscalibrated measure illustrates reliable but invalid findings, provided the intended concept and distortion are explained. Exclusions: Reliability does not mean truth, and changing social circumstances can change results without demonstrating an unreliable instrument.B1
Final answer: Validity concerns whether findings capture the intended phenomenon; reliability concerns consistency when measurement is repeated under comparable conditions. A consistently leading questionnaire may repeatedly elicit the same distorted answers, showing that reliability can be high while validity is low.
Mark scheme for Question 13 [6 marks]
Question 13[6 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
identifying a first way, such as young people turning to gangs for an alternative route to money and statusB1
development of the first wayB1
a linked example or further explanation of the first wayB1
identifying a second way, such as gang membership offering a sense of belonging and protectionB1
development of the second wayB1
a linked example or further explanation of the second wayB1
Final answer: Example answer: Blocked access to well-paid jobs limits legitimate income. A gang may offer illegal earning opportunities. Some young people may join to obtain material rewards. Educational exclusion can block recognised status. Gang peers can offer belonging and respect. Offending may then win status unavailable through school or work. Accept other valid answers: Illegal income, status frustration, protection or belonging, if each is linked to blocked legitimate opportunities and gang offending.
Mark scheme for Question 14 [6 marks]
Question 14[6 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
Identify different perspectives illuminating different dimensions of an institution.B1
Explain how functionalist socialisation and feminist analysis of domestic inequality address different aspects of family life.B1
Develop why considering both widens coverage beyond the questions one perspective prioritises.B1
Identify critical comparison of competing interpretations as a distinct benefit.B1
Explain how comparing harmony and domination accounts exposes assumptions needing evidence.B1
Develop how further research can test those claims without pretending incompatible theories automatically merge or guarantee truth. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: Conflicting predictions can prompt further empirical questions, testing whether family arrangements integrate members or reproduce domination. Distinct-credit limit: Do not claim theories can always be merged without contradictions or that including more perspectives guarantees correctness. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: Conflicting predictions can prompt further empirical questions, testing whether family arrangements integrate members or reproduce domination. Combining structural explanations with interactionist accounts can connect institutional pressures to actors' differing meanings, as a distinct level-of-analysis reason rather than repeating wider coverage. Exclusions: Do not claim theories can always be merged without contradictions or that including more perspectives guarantees correctness.B1
Final answer: Functionalism highlights socialisation while feminism examines unequal domestic labour, revealing different dimensions of family life. Comparing rival interpretations allows claims about harmony or conflict to be challenged against evidence, exposing assumptions a single perspective might leave untested.
Mark scheme for Question 15 [6 marks]
Question 15[6 marks]
Answer or workingMarks
identifying a first way, such as laws mainly protecting the property and interests of the wealthyB1
development of the first wayB1
a linked example or further explanation of the first wayB1
identifying a second way, such as working-class areas being policed more heavily than white-collar crime is investigatedB1
development of the second wayB1
a linked example or further explanation of the second wayB1
Final answer: Example answer: Marxists argue powerful owners influence lawmaking. Protection of private property safeguards their assets. This can criminalise acts threatening capitalist ownership. Enforcement may concentrate on visible working-class offences. Complex corporate offending can receive less scrutiny. Recorded patterns can therefore reflect selective control as well as offending. Accept other valid answers: Capitalism producing pressures towards corporate profit-seeking offences; selective enforcement or class-shaped lawmaking with distinct mechanisms.

Build a free practice pack.

Pick the topics, add the student's name and print one PDF.