Year 11 Paper 5: Crime and Stratification in Depth
Covers both crime topics, both stratification topics, research methods, sociological theory and educational achievement.
Year 11 follows a typical teaching order. No exam board defines what belongs to Year 11, and schools sequence the course differently. Check it against your own scheme of work before using it to decide what a class has covered.
Questions
Question 1 [2 marks]
Social Class and Life Chances
Income is a flow of money received, such as wages, benefits or returns on investments. Wealth is a stock of assets, with debts deducted when measuring net wealth.
Identify two examples of wealth that a person might own.
Question 2 [2 marks]
Patterns, Trends and Social Control
Crime statistics are gathered from more than one source, including police-recorded crime and victim surveys such as the Crime Survey for England and Wales.
Identify two sources sociologists use to measure the amount of crime.
Question 3 [2 marks]
Differential Educational Achievement
Government statistics show that pupils eligible for free school meals achieve, on average, lower GCSE grades than other pupils.
Identify two factors that sociologists say can affect a pupil's educational achievement.
Question 4 [3 marks]
Explanations of Crime and Deviance
Fraud can be concealed within apparently legitimate business activity, making it difficult for victims or investigators to recognise.
Explain one reason why white-collar offending can be difficult to detect or punish.
Question 5 [3 marks]
Sociological Perspectives and Theory
Functionalism is usually described as a 'structural' or 'macro' theory, studying society's large-scale institutions, while interactionism is usually described as a 'social action' or 'micro' theory, studying everyday interaction between individuals.
Explain one way in which a structural theory differs from a social action theory in its approach to studying society.
Question 6 [3 marks]
Research Methods and Design
A sociologist analyses school attendance registers going back ten years to see whether truancy rates have changed over time.
Explain one strength of using existing documents, such as school registers, as a source of sociological data.
Question 7 [3 marks]
Differential Educational Achievement
Some pupils in UK schools speak English as an additional language (EAL) rather than as their first language.
Explain one reason why pupils who speak English as an additional language may find some GCSE subjects harder to access.
Question 8 [4 marks]
Social Class and Life Chances
Marxist sociologists argue that society is divided into two main classes: the bourgeoisie, who own the means of production, and the proletariat, who sell their labour.
Explain two ways in which Marxists argue social class shapes people's life chances.
Question 9 [4 marks]
Gender, Ethnicity and Age Stratification
Feminist sociologists argue that patriarchy, a system where men hold most power, continues to shape opportunities for women in areas such as work and politics.
Explain two ways in which patriarchy can limit opportunities for women.
Question 10 [4 marks]
Differential Educational Achievement
Basil Bernstein argued that middle-class and working-class pupils are often taught to use language differently at home, which he called restricted and elaborated speech codes.
Explain two ways in which cultural factors in the home can affect a pupil's educational achievement.
Question 11 [5 marks]
Gender, Ethnicity and Age Stratification
The concept of the 'glass ceiling' describes an invisible barrier that stops some qualified women from reaching the most senior positions in an organisation.
Explain two reasons sociologists give for the existence of a 'glass ceiling' for women at work.
Question 12 [5 marks]
Differential Educational Achievement
Government figures show that pupils with special educational needs (SEN) achieve, on average, lower GCSE grades than pupils without SEN.
Explain two reasons why pupils with special educational needs may, on average, achieve lower grades.
Question 13 [5 marks]
Patterns, Trends and Social Control
Self-report studies ask people directly, often anonymously, whether they have committed any crimes, rather than relying on police records.
Explain two strengths of using self-report studies to measure the amount of crime.
Question 14 [5 marks]
Explanations of Crime and Deviance
Not every explanation of crime is sociological; some psychologists and biologists look for the causes of crime within the individual offender rather than in society.
Explain two ways in which a sociological explanation of crime differs from a biological explanation of crime.
Question 15 [6 marks]
Patterns, Trends and Social Control
Some people commit further offences after release from prison.
Explain two reasons why a person released from prison may go on to reoffend.
Question 16 [6 marks]
Social Class and Life Chances
Functionalists such as Davis and Moore argue that unequal rewards exist because society needs to fill its most important roles with the most talented people, while Marxists argue inequality mainly serves the interests of a ruling class.
Explain two ways in which the functionalist explanation of inequality differs from the Marxist explanation.
Question 17 [6 marks]
Sociological Perspectives and Theory
Marxist feminists argue that the family and capitalism work together, with women's unpaid domestic labour benefiting the capitalist economy.
Explain two ways in which Marxist feminists argue that women's unpaid domestic labour benefits capitalism.
Question 18 [6 marks]
Social Class and Life Chances
Family networks can provide access to work experience, advice and contacts that affect children's later occupational opportunities.
Explain two ways in which access to social networks and contacts can help pass on class advantage between generations.
Question 19 [6 marks]
Gender, Ethnicity and Age Stratification
Intersectional sociologists argue that working-class ethnic minority women can face a combination of disadvantages that a single-factor explanation, looking only at gender or only at ethnicity, would miss.
Explain two ways in which social class can combine with gender or ethnicity to shape a person's life chances.
Model solutions
| Question 1[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| one valid example or measure: Equity in an owned home. Accept other valid answers; examples are not exhaustive. | B1 |
| a second distinct valid example or measure: Savings or shares held as assets. Accept other valid answers; do not credit the same example twice. | B1 |
| Final answer: Example answer: Equity in an owned home. Savings or shares held as assets. Accept other valid answers: Property equity, savings, shares, pension assets or valuable possessions; wages received are income rather than an asset example. | |
| Question 2[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| one valid example or measure: Police-recorded crime statistics. Accept other valid answers; examples are not exhaustive. | B1 |
| a second distinct valid example or measure: Victim surveys asking people about crimes experienced, including incidents not reported to police. Accept other valid answers; do not credit the same example twice. | B1 |
| Final answer: Example answer: Police-recorded crime statistics. Victim surveys asking people about crimes experienced, including incidents not reported to police. Accept other valid answers: Self-report offending studies as well as police records and victim surveys; name two genuinely different sources. | |
| Question 3[2 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| one correctly identified factor, such as social class | B1 |
| a second correctly identified factor, such as gender, ethnicity or parental income | B1 |
| Final answer: Any two of: social class, gender, ethnicity, parental income, home background | |
| Question 4[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a valid reason, such as the crime being hidden within complex financial or business systems | B1 |
| a linked development of that reason | B1 |
| a further linked development or example that completes the explanation | B1 |
| Final answer: Example answer: Complex accounting can conceal fraud. Victims may not recognise the loss as a crime or report it. Fewer reports and specialist evidence requirements can reduce detection and prosecution. Accept other valid answers: Victims unaware of offending, complex evidence, specialist investigation costs or powerful offenders resisting scrutiny. | |
| Question 5[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Contrast institutional constraints shaping behaviour with individuals constructing meanings through action. | B1 |
| Explain how a structural theory studies the influence of education or family on social roles. | B1 |
| Develop a social-action example of people interpreting or negotiating those roles to complete the comparison. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: A social action account of pupils negotiating a label can contrast with a structural account of institutional role expectations. Distinct-credit limit: Do not confuse social action theory with any political campaign described colloquially as taking social action. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: A social action account of pupils negotiating a label can contrast with a structural account of institutional role expectations. Exclusions: Do not confuse social action theory with any political campaign described colloquially as taking social action. | B1 |
| Final answer: Structural approaches ask how institutions and social constraints shape behaviour, such as how education transmits norms. Social action approaches ask how people interpret situations and create meanings through interaction, such as negotiating a teacher's label. | |
| Question 6[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Identify access to already recorded attendance information from earlier years. | B1 |
| Explain that these historical circumstances cannot now be observed directly through new fieldwork. | B1 |
| Link existing records to retrospective trend analysis without waiting another decade or assuming all absence is truancy. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: Existing registers may reduce disruption to pupils because researchers can analyse records without repeatedly observing lessons. Distinct-credit limit: Attendance registers alone do not distinguish every unauthorised absence from illness or establish why pupils were absent. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: Existing registers may reduce disruption to pupils because researchers can analyse records without repeatedly observing lessons. Exclusions: Attendance registers alone do not distinguish every unauthorised absence from illness or establish why pupils were absent. | B1 |
| Final answer: Historical registers let the researcher examine attendance across years that cannot now be observed directly. Using those existing records can reveal change over ten years without waiting ten years to collect new observations. | |
| Question 7[3 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a valid reason, such as needing extra time to become fluent in subject-specific academic vocabulary | B1 |
| a linked development of that reason | B1 |
| a further linked development or example that completes the explanation | B1 |
| Final answer: e.g. pupils who speak English as an additional language may need extra time to build up the subject-specific academic vocabulary used in exam questions, which can make some subjects harder to access at first even if the pupil understands the underlying ideas | |
| Question 8[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first valid way, such as the bourgeoisie holding economic power and being able to pass on wealth | B1 |
| a linked development of the first way | B1 |
| identifying a second valid way, such as the proletariat depending on wages and having less job security | B1 |
| a linked development of the second way | B1 |
| Final answer: Example answer: Owners receive profits from others' labour and control productive resources. This provides advantages in income and security. Workers must sell labour to survive and have less control over work. Exploitation and insecure employment can restrict their life chances. Accept other valid answers: Property ownership, surplus extraction, wage dependence, inherited privilege or class power, applied to life chances. | |
| Question 9[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Identify exclusion from male-dominated promotion networks as one patriarchal mechanism. | B1 |
| Explain how missing sponsorship or vacancy information restricts women's access to senior posts. | B1 |
| Identify gendered expectations of unpaid care as a separate patriarchal mechanism. | B1 |
| Explain how care demands restrict time for training or political participation and hence opportunities. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: Gendered discouragement from technical training can narrow later occupational choices and advancement opportunities. Distinct-credit limit: Simply saying women have fewer senior jobs restates disadvantage without explaining how patriarchy produces it. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: Gendered discouragement from technical training can narrow later occupational choices and advancement opportunities. Exclusions: Simply saying women have fewer senior jobs restates disadvantage without explaining how patriarchy produces it. | B1 |
| Final answer: Male-dominated promotion networks can exclude qualified women from information or sponsorship needed for senior appointments. Expectations that women perform unpaid care can restrict time for training and political activity, limiting progression. | |
| Question 10[4 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first valid cultural factor, such as use of an elaborated speech code at home | B1 |
| a linked development of the first factor | B1 |
| identifying a second valid cultural factor, such as parental attitudes to education or the amount of reading at home | B1 |
| a linked development of the second factor | B1 |
| Final answer: e.g. pupils who use an elaborated speech code at home find it easier to understand teachers' language at school, and parents who value education encourage habits such as regular reading | |
| Question 11[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Identify exclusion from male-dominated informal workplace networks as one promotion barrier. | B1 |
| Explain how reduced access to sponsorship or vacancy information blocks senior appointments. | B1 |
| Identify stereotyped assumptions about mothers' commitment as a separate promotion barrier. | B1 |
| Explain how those assumptions cause equally qualified women to be overlooked for senior roles. | B1 |
| Add new relevant detail, such as promotion criteria rewarding assumed availability rather than demonstrated performance. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: Biased appraisal criteria can undervalue women's achievements and reduce promotion chances despite equivalent performance. Distinct-credit limit: Two examples of exclusion from the same informal promotion network count as one reason unless a distinct mechanism is shown. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: Biased appraisal criteria can undervalue women's achievements and reduce promotion chances despite equivalent performance. Exclusions: Two examples of exclusion from the same informal promotion network count as one reason unless a distinct mechanism is shown. | B1 |
| Final answer: Informal recruitment through male-dominated networks can deny women access to sponsorship for senior roles. Stereotypes that mothers are less committed can cause qualified women to be passed over for promotion. | |
| Question 12[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first reason, such as a specific learning difficulty making some tasks harder | B1 |
| a linked development of the first reason | B1 |
| identifying a second reason, such as schools not always having enough specialist support or resources | B1 |
| a linked development of the second reason | B1 |
| further exemplification or development that completes either explanation | B1 |
| Final answer: e.g. a specific learning difficulty, such as dyslexia, can make reading and writing tasks more difficult under exam conditions, and some schools lack the specialist staff or resources to give every pupil with SEN the support they need to achieve their full potential | |
| Question 13[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identify one strength, such as revealing admitted offences absent from police records. | B1 |
| develop how this adds information about hidden offending. | B1 |
| identify a second distinct strength, such as anonymity potentially encouraging candour. | B1 |
| develop why the design may encourage admissions, without guaranteeing truthfulness. | B1 |
| add a linked example or further development to either strength. Accept other valid strengths; anonymity is not the same as interview mode. | B1 |
| Final answer: Example answer: Self-reports can reveal admitted offences never reported to police. They therefore illuminate part of the dark figure. Anonymous responses may encourage honest admissions about minor or hidden offending. This can reveal offending across groups that police focus on differently. Findings still depend on truthful answers and sampling. Accept other valid answers: Access to hidden offending, wider social distribution or anonymity improving candour; no guarantee of honesty or representativeness. | |
| Question 14[5 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identify a social-process versus biological-trait contrast. | B1 |
| develop both sides of that contrast with relevant causes. | B1 |
| identify a second distinct contrast, such as variation in social definitions or implications for prevention. | B1 |
| develop both approaches on that second axis. | B1 |
| add a linked example or further development to either contrast. Do not count the two sides of one contrast as two differences. | B1 |
| Final answer: Example answer: Sociological accounts explain offending through social relationships and opportunities. Biological accounts examine inherited or physiological characteristics. Sociological accounts can explain variation in legal definitions across societies. A biological characteristic alone cannot explain why the same behaviour is criminalised in one context and permitted in another. This directs attention to social reactions and lawmaking. Accept other valid answers: Social learning versus inherited traits; contextual variation versus stable individual predispositions; distinct implications for prevention. | |
| Question 15[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identifying a first reason, such as prison exposing offenders to other criminals, which can reinforce criminal attitudes and contacts | B1 |
| development of the first reason | B1 |
| a linked example or further explanation of the first reason | B1 |
| identifying a second reason, such as a criminal record making it hard to find legitimate employment or housing after release | B1 |
| development of the second reason | B1 |
| a linked example or further explanation of the second reason | B1 |
| Final answer: Example answer: A conviction and time in prison can disrupt employment. Stigma can restrict work after release. Reduced legitimate income may increase pressure to offend. Prison can expose people to offending peers and techniques. Continuing these relationships after release may support further crime. Weak support on release can make leaving those networks harder. Accept other valid answers: Learning from peers, employment stigma, housing barriers, disrupted ties or weak rehabilitation, each linked to reoffending. | |
| Question 16[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identify a functional-necessity versus class-interest contrast. | B1 |
| develop the functionalist incentive mechanism. | B1 |
| develop the Marxist exploitation or ownership mechanism. | B1 |
| identify a second contrast, such as role allocation through talent versus reproduction of inherited class advantage. | B1 |
| develop the functionalist side without treating fairness as a proven fact. | B1 |
| develop the Marxist side. Accept equivalent paired contrasts; two sides of one contrast are not two differences. | B1 |
| Final answer: Example answer: Functionalists view unequal rewards as incentives to train and fill important roles. Inequality is explained as contributing to social needs. Marxists explain it through ownership and exploitation benefiting a ruling class. Functionalist accounts suggest rewards help allocate talent to roles. Marxists argue inherited property and class power can restrict opportunity. Unequal outcomes can therefore reproduce privilege rather than reflect merit. Accept other valid answers: Functional necessity versus exploitation; meritocratic allocation versus reproduced ownership advantages, with both perspectives in each contrast. | |
| Question 17[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Identify unpaid housework maintaining the existing workforce in a Marxist feminist account. | B1 |
| Explain how cooking or cleaning helps restore workers' daily capacity to work. | B1 |
| Develop how unpaid provision reduces costs otherwise borne through wages or services, without claiming employers bear no costs. | B1 |
| Identify unpaid childcare helping raise the future workforce as a separate intergenerational contribution. | B1 |
| Explain how caring for children supports reproduction of labour power across generations. | B1 |
| Develop why this benefits future labour supply while keeping the argument attributed rather than claiming all reproduction costs are unpaid. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: Emotional support that restores a worker's capacity to work may count if developed separately from cooking and cleaning as another mechanism. Distinct-credit limit: Two household tasks such as cooking and cleaning do not automatically become two distinct capitalist benefits. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: Emotional support that restores a worker's capacity to work may count if developed separately from cooking and cleaning as another mechanism. Exclusions: Two household tasks such as cooking and cleaning do not automatically become two distinct capitalist benefits. | B1 |
| Final answer: Unpaid cooking and cleaning maintain workers' daily capacity to work, reducing the costs employers would otherwise need to cover through wages or services. Unpaid childcare contributes to raising future workers, supporting the reproduction of labour power across generations. | |
| Question 18[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| identify a first network route, such as access to placements or introductions. | B1 |
| develop how contacts make this possible. | B1 |
| explain the benefit for later occupational chances. | B1 |
| identify a second distinct route, such as sharing application information or mentoring. | B1 |
| develop the informational advantage. | B1 |
| explain its contribution to intergenerational class advantage. Accept other distinct routes; one placement chain is not automatically two ways. | B1 |
| Final answer: Example answer: Contacts can arrange work experience or introductions. This provides experience valued by recruiters. Children may then gain access to professional careers. Networks share information about opportunities and selection expectations. Advice can strengthen applications and interviews. This helps transmit advantage across generations. Accept other valid answers: Introductions, references, information, mentoring or access to placements; two independently explained routes, not one repeated chain. | |
| Question 19[6 marks] | |
|---|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
| Identify low class resources combining with gendered caring expectations as one mechanism. | B1 |
| Explain that a low-paid woman may be unable to purchase replacement childcare. | B1 |
| Link restricted training time to reduced access to better-paid work as further development. | B1 |
| Identify limited household resources combining with ethnic labelling as a second mechanism. | B1 |
| Explain how lack of paid educational support can compound low or racist teacher expectations. | B1 |
| Link the combined barriers to reduced educational opportunities without generalising to every minority pupil. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: Low-income ethnic minority applicants may be unable to take unpaid internships while also lacking access to ethnically exclusionary professional networks. Distinct-credit limit: Do not award interaction credit for a bare list of class, gender and ethnicity with no linked effect on life chances. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: Low-income ethnic minority applicants may be unable to take unpaid internships while also lacking access to ethnically exclusionary professional networks. Exclusions: Do not award interaction credit for a bare list of class, gender and ethnicity with no linked effect on life chances. | B1 |
| Final answer: A low-paid woman may be unable to purchase childcare, so gendered caring expectations restrict her access to training and better-paid jobs. An ethnic minority pupil in a low-income household may lack paid tutoring while also facing racist teacher expectations, combining resource and labelling barriers. | |