Pure: Differentiation Depth
Differentiation Depth consolidates the chain, product and quotient rules onto the harder settings A Level Maths actually examines them in: curves defined implicitly (where y is not given as a formula in x), curves defined parametrically (x and y both given in terms of a third variable t), connected rates of change (linking two changing quantities through a shared variable, usually time), and optimisation problems where a real quantity has to be written as a function of one variable before it can be differentiated. The examiner is testing whether a student can choose the right technique when the question does not name it, keep dy/dx notation and the chain rule correct when y appears inside another function of y, and justify a maximum or minimum rather than just finding where the gradient is zero.
Method
- Decide which technique applies before differentiating anything. If y is given explicitly in terms of x, differentiate directly with the chain, product or quotient rule. If x and y are both given in terms of a parameter t, use dy/dx = (dy/dt) / (dx/dt). If the equation mixes x and y and is not solved for y, differentiate implicitly.
- For implicit differentiation, differentiate every term of the equation with respect to x. Differentiate an x-only term as normal. Differentiate a y-only term (such as y^2 or y^3) using the chain rule, giving an extra factor of dy/dx (e.g. d/dx(y^2) = 2y dy/dx). Differentiate a mixed term such as xy with the product rule: d/dx(xy) = x dy/dx + y.
- After implicit differentiation, collect every term containing dy/dx on one side, factorise dy/dx out, and divide to make dy/dx the subject. To evaluate the gradient at a point, substitute BOTH the x-value and the y-value into the resulting expression, since it contains y as well as x.
- For connected rates of change, identify the two rates in the question and the variable that links them (commonly time, t). Use the chain rule to connect them, e.g. dV/dt = dV/dr x dr/dt, then substitute the known numerical rate and the value of the linking variable at the instant asked about.
- For parametric differentiation, find dx/dt and dy/dt separately and divide. For a parametric second derivative, do NOT differentiate dy/dx directly with respect to x; instead find d/dt(dy/dx) and divide by dx/dt.
- Learn the extra standard derivatives beyond sin, cos, e^x and ln(x): d/dx(tan x) = sec^2(x), d/dx(sec x) = sec(x)tan(x), d/dx(cosec x) = -cosec(x)cot(x), d/dx(cot x) = -cosec^2(x), and d/dx(a^x) = a^x ln(a), applying the chain rule whenever the argument is not simply x.
- For an optimisation problem, use any given constraint to write the quantity being optimised as a function of a single variable, differentiate, set the derivative to zero and solve. Justify a maximum or minimum using the second derivative (or a sign check either side), and reject any solution that falls outside the physically valid range given by the context.
Common mistakes
MistakeDifferentiating a mixed term such as xy as just y, or as x dy/dx alone.
InsteadA term containing both x and y needs the product rule: d/dx(xy) = x dy/dx + y. Differentiate each factor in turn and keep both pieces.
MistakeFinding d2y/dx2 for a parametric curve by differentiating dy/dx with respect to t and stopping there.
Insteadd2y/dx2 is the rate of change of dy/dx with respect to x. Find d/dt(dy/dx) and then divide by dx/dt.
MistakeWriting the derivative of cosec x as cosec x cot x, dropping the minus sign.
InsteadEvery derivative of a co-function carries a minus sign: d/dx(cosec x) = -cosec x cot x and d/dx(cot x) = -cosec^2 x. The derivatives of sec x and tan x have no minus sign.
MistakeRecording the rate of change of a quantity that is decreasing as a positive number.
InsteadA decreasing quantity has a negative rate. A volume draining at 4 cm^3/s has dV/dt = -4 cm^3/s, and that sign carries through the chain rule into the rate you want.
Worked examples
Example 1
The curve C has equation x^2 + y^2 - 4x + 6y = 12. Find dy/dx in terms of x and y, and hence find the gradient of C at the point (5, 1).
- Differentiate every term of the equation with respect to x: d/dx(x^2) + d/dx(y^2) - d/dx(4x) + d/dx(6y) = d/dx(12), giving 2x + 2y(dy/dx) - 4 + 6(dy/dx) = 0.
- Collect the dy/dx terms on one side: (2y + 6)(dy/dx) = 4 - 2x.
- Divide to make dy/dx the subject: dy/dx = (4 - 2x) / (2y + 6), which simplifies to (2 - x) / (y + 3).
- Check the point (5, 1) lies on C: 5^2 + 1^2 - 4(5) + 6(1) = 25 + 1 - 20 + 6 = 12, confirmed.
- Substitute x = 5 and y = 1 into dy/dx: (2 - 5) / (1 + 3) = -3/4.
- Final answer: the gradient of C at (5, 1) is -3/4.
Example 2
A curve is given parametrically by x = t^2 + 2t and y = t^3 - 6t, for t > 0. (a) Find dy/dx in terms of t. (b) Find d2y/dx2 in terms of t. (c) Find the coordinates of the stationary point of the curve and determine whether it is a maximum or a minimum.
- dx/dt = 2t + 2 and dy/dt = 3t^2 - 6, so dy/dx = (3t^2 - 6)/(2t + 2) = 3(t^2 - 2)/(2(t + 1)).
- For d2y/dx2, first differentiate dy/dx with respect to t using the quotient rule: [6t(2t + 2) - 2(3t^2 - 6)]/(2t + 2)^2 = (6t^2 + 12t + 12)/(4(t + 1)^2) = 3(t^2 + 2t + 2)/(2(t + 1)^2).
- Now divide by dx/dt = 2(t + 1): d2y/dx2 = 3(t^2 + 2t + 2)/(4(t + 1)^3).
- The stationary point is where dy/dx = 0, so t^2 = 2 and t = sqrt(2) (since t > 0). Then x = 2 + 2 sqrt(2) and y = 2 sqrt(2) - 6 sqrt(2) = -4 sqrt(2).
- For t > 0 both t^2 + 2t + 2 and (t + 1)^3 are positive, so d2y/dx2 > 0 and the stationary point is a minimum.
- Final answer: dy/dx = 3(t^2 - 2)/(2(t + 1)) and d2y/dx2 = 3(t^2 + 2t + 2)/(4(t + 1)^3). There is a minimum at (2 + 2 sqrt(2), -4 sqrt(2)), about (4.83, -5.66).
Example 3
The curve C has equation x^2 + 3xy + y^3 = 24, and P is the point (2, 2). A student differentiates to get 2x + 3x(dy/dx) + 3y^2(dy/dx) = 0 and claims that the tangent gradient at P is -2/9. Identify the missing contribution, repair the expression for dy/dx and verify the corrected tangent gradient at P using the full differentiated equation. Explain why checking that P lies on C does not check the claimed gradient.
- Check the supplied point first: 2^2 + 3(2)(2) + 2^3 = 4 + 12 + 8 = 24, so P lies on C. This checks its coordinates, but says nothing about the tangent gradient.
- The mixed term needs the product rule because y depends on x: d/dx(3xy) = 3x(dy/dx) + 3y. The student differentiated y but missed the contribution 3y from differentiating the factor x.
- Keep that contribution and differentiate the whole equation: 2x + 3x(dy/dx) + 3y + 3y^2(dy/dx) = 0. The factor dy/dx in the last term comes from the chain rule on y^3.
- Collect and factorise the derivative terms: (3x + 3y^2)(dy/dx) = -(2x + 3y). Hence dy/dx = -(2x + 3y)/(3x + 3y^2), provided 3x + 3y^2 is not zero.
- At P, the denominator is 3(2) + 3(2^2) = 18, which is non-zero. Substitute both coordinates: dy/dx = -(2(2) + 3(2))/18 = -10/18 = -5/9.
- Check the gradient in the full differentiated equation at P: 4 + 6 + 18(-5/9) = 0. In contrast, the claimed gradient gives 4 + 6 + 18(-2/9) = 6, not zero. It satisfies the incomplete equation only because the missing 3y contributes 6 here.
- Final answer: the missing contribution is 3y; dy/dx = -(2x + 3y)/(3x + 3y^2) where the denominator is non-zero, and the tangent gradient at (2, 2) is -5/9.
Practice questions
Q1[1 mark]State the rule used to find dy/dx when x and y are both given in terms of a parameter t.Show answer
Answer: dy/dx = (dy/dt) / (dx/dt).
Q2[3 marks]A curve has parametric equations x = t^2 + 1, y = 3t - 2. Find dy/dx in terms of t.Show answer
Answer: dx/dt = 2t and dy/dt = 3, so dy/dx = 3/(2t).
Q3[3 marks]Find dy/dx for the curve x^2 y = 8, using implicit differentiation.Show answer
Answer: By the product rule, 2xy + x^2(dy/dx) = 0, so dy/dx = -2xy/x^2 = -2y/x.
Q4[4 marks]The radius of a circular oil spill is increasing at a constant rate of 0.4 m/s. Find the exact rate of increase of the area of the spill, in m^2/s, at the instant the radius is 5 m.Show answer
Answer: A = pi*r^2, so dA/dr = 2*pi*r. dA/dt = dA/dr x dr/dt = 2*pi*r x 0.4 = 0.8*pi*r. At r = 5, dA/dt = 4*pi m^2/s (about 12.6 m^2/s).
Q5[2 marks]Explain why, when differentiating y^3 implicitly with respect to x, the result is 3y^2(dy/dx) and not simply 3y^2.Show answer
Answer: y is itself a function of x, so the chain rule applies: d/dx(y^3) = d/dy(y^3) x dy/dx = 3y^2 x dy/dx. The extra factor of dy/dx comes from differentiating y with respect to x rather than treating y as the variable of differentiation.
Q6[2 marks]Differentiate y = tan(3x) with respect to x.Show answer
Answer: dy/dx = 3sec^2(3x), using the chain rule on the standard derivative of tan(x).
Q7[5 marks]A curve has parametric equations x = t^2, y = t^3 - 3t. Find dy/dx in terms of t, and find the coordinates of the two stationary points of the curve.Show answer
Answer: dx/dt = 2t and dy/dt = 3t^2 - 3, so dy/dx = 3(t^2-1)/(2t). Stationary points occur where dy/dt = 0 (and dx/dt is not 0): t = 1 gives (1, -2); t = -1 gives (1, 2).
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a A Level Maths exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- Write each given rate and the wanted rate as derivatives with units, such as dV/dt in cm^3/s, before building the chain rule. The units show which derivatives to multiply.
- In an optimisation problem, use the constraint to eliminate the variable that leaves the simpler expression, and state the allowed range of the remaining variable before differentiating.
- Check a final derivative at one convenient point by comparing it with the slope between two nearby points on the curve, using a calculator.
Q1[6 marks]The curve C has equation x^2 + xy + y^2 = 7. The point P(1, 2) lies on C. (a) Find dy/dx in terms of x and y. (3) (b) Find the equation of the tangent to C at P, giving your answer in the form ax + by = c, where a, b and c are integers. (3)Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 6 available
Q2[4 marks]Air is pumped into a spherical balloon at a constant rate of 15 cm^3/s. Find the rate of increase of the radius of the balloon, in cm/s, at the instant the radius is 10 cm. Give your answer to 3 significant figures.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 4 available
Q3[8 marks]An open-top box is made by cutting a square of side x cm from each corner of a square sheet of card of side 20 cm, then folding up the sides. Let V cm^3 be the volume of the box. (a) Show that V = 4x^3 - 80x^2 + 400x. (2) (b) Find dV/dx, and find the value of x, in the domain 0 < x < 10, for which V is stationary. (3) (c) By finding d^2V/dx^2, show that this value of x gives a maximum volume, and find the exact maximum volume. (3)Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 8 available
See real A Level Maths past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
This topic in real past papers
We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:
- OCR A Level Maths past papers: 29 questions across 19 papers, latest tagged June 2024
- AQA A Level Maths past papers: 27 questions across 16 papers, latest tagged June 2023
- WJEC A Level Maths past papers: 7 questions across 4 papers, latest tagged Summer 2024
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Pure: Differentiation Depth worksheet pack - 7 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This topic is chapter 16 of A Level Maths Pure Essentials, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 7 of A Level Maths Pure Topic Workbook 2 and chapter 16 of A Level Maths 10-Minute Tests 1, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: