Comparative Theories: Structural, Rational and Cultural Approaches
Comparative politics uses three named theoretical approaches to explain why similar countries, such as the USA and the UK, develop different political institutions and behaviour.
Before you start
No prerequisites. You can start here.
Method
- Learn all three theories by name, in a fixed order if it helps memory, and be able to state in one sentence what each treats as the main cause of political behaviour: structural, the formal institutions; rational, individual self-interest; cultural, inherited values and history.
- Practise applying all three theories to a single example difference between the USA and the UK, so you can see how the same fact (e.g. the US having a codified constitution and the UK not) can be explained in three different, valid ways depending on which theory is applied.
- Learn to distinguish a structural explanation from a rational one: a structural explanation points to the shape of an institution itself (e.g. 'the separation of powers structurally prevents this'), while a rational explanation points to what an individual actor gains or loses by acting a certain way within that institution (e.g. 'a member of Congress votes this way because it maximises their re-election chances').
- Learn to distinguish a cultural explanation from the other two: a cultural explanation does not point to a rule or an individual's calculation at all, but to a longstanding shared value or historical experience that shapes what a country's institutions and actors consider normal or acceptable in the first place.
- In every comparative essay in this course, apply one of the three theories by name in each paragraph rather than describing the US then the UK and leaving the comparative reasoning implicit; examiners specifically credit explicit, correctly applied use of a named theory.
- For an evaluate question asking which theory best explains a given difference, do not simply describe all three: pick the strongest explanation, justify why it outperforms the alternatives for that specific example, and acknowledge briefly why a rival theory is weaker rather than ignoring it.
Common mistakes
MistakeDescribing a shared national value or historical experience as if it were an individual actor's calculated self-interest, confusing the cultural approach with the rational approach.
InsteadThe rational approach explains a specific actor's calculated self-interest, such as a legislator's re-election incentive; the cultural approach explains shared, inherited values or historical experience, such as a country's general attitude to authority.
MistakeApplying only one theory to a difference and treating the explanation as complete, even where the question asks which theory explains it best.
InsteadWhere a question asks which theory explains a difference best, apply at least two theories to the same example before choosing, and give a specific reason the chosen theory outperforms the alternative for that example.
MistakeUsing a structural explanation to account for one person's particular choice, such as a single senator's vote, as if the institution alone decided it.
InsteadA structural explanation says how institutions and rules shape outcomes in general, for example that the separation of powers makes gridlock more likely; one actor's particular choice within those rules is what the rational approach explains.
Worked examples
Example 1
Using all three comparative theories, explain why the USA has a codified, entrenched constitution while the UK does not.
- State the fact to be explained clearly: the US Constitution is a single codified document requiring the demanding Article V process to amend, while the UK constitution is uncodified and can, in principle, be changed by an ordinary Act of Parliament.
- Apply the structural approach: the US was founded through a deliberate constitutional convention that needed to bind thirteen separate former colonies into a single federal union, which structurally required a single, agreed, written settlement; the UK's constitution instead evolved gradually over centuries with no equivalent single founding moment requiring codification.
- Apply the rational approach: the framers of the US Constitution had a direct self-interest in constraining a powerful central government, having just thrown off a monarchy, so they rationally chose to entrench limits on federal power in a way that would be hard for any future majority to undo; UK political actors across history had less incentive to give up the flexibility that lets a sitting parliamentary majority govern without such constraints.
- Apply the cultural approach: American political culture developed a foundational, and lasting, suspicion of concentrated, unchecked power, reflected in strong rights-consciousness, while British political culture developed a tradition of trust in evolutionary change and parliamentary sovereignty, making a codified, entrenched restraint on Parliament culturally unnecessary in the UK's own self-understanding.
- Conclude by comparing the three explanations directly, noting that they are not mutually exclusive: the structural explanation accounts for the timing and form of codification, the rational explanation accounts for why entrenchment specifically was chosen, and the cultural explanation accounts for why each country's political culture has continued to accept its own model since.
Example 2
Explain why the US Supreme Court can strike down an Act of Congress as unconstitutional, while the traditional UK doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty holds that courts cannot strike down an Act of Parliament in the same way, using all three comparative theories.
- Identify precisely what needs explaining: US courts can declare a federal law unconstitutional, a power the Supreme Court described as judicial review in Marbury v Madison in 1803, while the traditional UK principle of parliamentary sovereignty holds no court may strike down a valid Act of Parliament.
- Apply the structural approach: the US Constitution is a codified, entrenched document that legislation must conform to, giving courts a fixed written standard to measure laws against, which the UK's uncodified constitution does not provide in the same form.
- Apply the rational approach: American judges exercising judicial review can be seen as maintaining and extending the power of their own branch, while UK judges operating under parliamentary sovereignty have less institutional basis for claiming a power the constitutional settlement does not grant them.
- Apply the cultural approach: American political culture's foundational distrust of concentrated power supports courts checking the legislature, while British political culture has historically trusted an elected, sovereign Parliament as the ultimate decision-maker.
- Conclude by comparing the three: the structural explanation accounts for the difference itself (a codified, entrenched constitution gives US courts a higher law to apply), the rational explanation for why judges have used and kept the power, and the cultural explanation for why each arrangement is accepted as legitimate in its own country.
Example 3
Evaluate the extent to which the differences between the UK and US political systems are better explained by structural theory than by cultural theory.
- Structural theory explains differences through formal institutions and constitutional rules, whereas cultural theory explains them through inherited political values and historical experience. Structural theory is stronger at explaining how the UK and US systems constrain power, but cultural theory helps explain why these different arrangements were adopted and accepted. The extent of structural theory's advantage therefore depends on whether the question concerns the operation of institutions or their origins and legitimacy.
- Executive-legislative relations support the structural argument. US separation of powers places a separately elected President outside Congress, whereas the UK's fusion of powers draws the Prime Minister and Cabinet from Parliament. Separate institutions create checks between executive and legislature; fusion connects the executive to the legislature through which it governs. These rules explain the contrasting institutional relationship more precisely than a general statement about national values. Yet cultural theory explains the same contrast by linking American suspicion of concentrated power to a checked and fragmented executive, and British acceptance of evolutionary constitutional change and parliamentary sovereignty to a fused executive. Structure explains the mechanism; culture helps explain the choice of mechanism.
- Judicial review gives structural theory a second strong case. The US codified, entrenched Constitution supplies a higher-law standard against which courts can judge legislation, and the Supreme Court's judicial review allows it to declare an Act of Congress unconstitutional. Under the traditional UK doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty, courts cannot strike down a valid Act of Parliament in the same way. This difference in constitutional authority explains the contrasting judicial checks directly. Cultural theory interprets the same contrast as reflecting American distrust of unchecked power and British historical acceptance of a sovereign Parliament. That interpretation helps explain legitimacy, but values alone do not specify the legal authority available to each court, so structural theory is stronger for explaining this institutional difference.
- Cultural theory nevertheless challenges the idea that formal rules are a complete explanation. American experience of breaking from British rule can be argued to have encouraged suspicion of concentrated power, helping to explain both a separated executive and judicial checks. The British tradition of gradual constitutional development and acceptance of parliamentary sovereignty helps explain both executive-legislative fusion and the traditional limits on courts. In each case, taking the rules as the starting point leaves the question of why those rules were chosen or maintained unanswered. These are cultural interpretations of institutional development, rather than proof that every citizen shares one attitude.
- The two theories also interact. Cultural values can influence the choice and acceptance of institutions; once adopted, institutions shape political behaviour through their own rules and can become self-reinforcing. The same separated executive and judicial checks can therefore be understood as products of distrust of concentrated power and as mechanisms that constrain it. Conversely, parliamentary sovereignty provides a structural framework within which the British tradition of constitutional evolution operates. Neither explanation needs to exclude the other, and the cultural origin of a rule does not remove its independent institutional effects.
- Overall, the claim is convincing to a substantial extent for the institutional differences examined: separation versus fusion of powers and contrasting judicial authority are explained most directly by formal rules. Structural theory has the advantage of identifying precise mechanisms rather than relying solely on broad cultural tendencies. Its advantage is qualified, however, because it does not by itself explain why these structures emerged or were accepted. Cultural theory supplies that historical and legitimating layer. The strongest overall judgement is therefore that structural theory better explains how these differences operate, while a combined structural and cultural account explains more of their development and persistence.
Practice questions
Q1[3 marks]Name the three comparative theories.Show answer
Answer: The structural (institutional), rational and cultural approaches.
Q2[1 mark]What does the structural approach treat as the main cause of political behaviour?Show answer
Answer: A country's formal institutions and constitutional arrangements.
Q3[1 mark]What does the rational approach treat as the main cause of political behaviour?Show answer
Answer: Individual political actors pursuing their own self-interest within the rules they face.
Q4[1 mark]What does the cultural approach treat as the main cause of political behaviour?Show answer
Answer: A country's inherited political history, ideas and values, transmitted across generations.
Q5[3 marks]Give an example of a structural explanation for a difference between US and UK legislatures.Show answer
Answer: That Congress and Parliament behave differently mainly because Congress operates under a separation of powers while Parliament operates under a fusion of powers.
Q6[3 marks]Give an example of a rational explanation for a difference in party discipline between the USA and the UK.Show answer
Answer: That UK MPs are more loyal to their party because their promotion and reselection depend on party leadership approval, while US members of Congress depend more on primary voters, weakening the leadership's hold over their incentives.
Q7[2 marks]Why should a strong comparative essay name a specific theory in each paragraph, rather than just describing both countries?Show answer
Answer: Because the comparative element of the mark scheme specifically rewards explicit, correctly applied use of a named theory to explain a similarity or difference, not just accurate description of each country separately.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a A Level Politics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- Use each theory's own terms: structural for how institutions and rules shape outcomes, rational for calculated self-interest, cultural for shared values and history.
- When asked to use all three theories, apply each to the same named example, so the three explanations can be compared.
- When judging which theory explains most, let the answer depend on the example: one theory may best explain a difference in institutions, another the way actors behave within them.
Q1[12 marks]Using all three comparative theories, explain why the USA has a codified, entrenched constitution while the UK does not.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 12 available
Q2[25 marks]'The rational approach explains differences between US and UK politics better than the structural or cultural approaches.' Evaluate this view.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 25 available
See real A Level Politics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
This topic in real past papers
We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:
- AQA A Level Politics past papers: 4 questions across 4 papers, latest tagged June 2023
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Comparative Theories: Structural, Rational and Cultural Approaches worksheet pack - 5 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This topic is chapter 19 of A Level Politics Essentials 2, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 16 of A Level Politics Topic Workbook 3 and chapter 18 of A Level Politics 10-Minute Tests 2, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: