A Level Politics Essentials 2 includes Core Ideas and Principles of Socialism (Core political ideas); Revolutionary Socialism and Social Democracy: Tensions Within the Tradition (Core political ideas); Socialist Thinkers: Karl Marx and Rosa Luxemburg (Core political ideas); Socialist Thinkers: Beatrice Webb and Anthony Crosland (Core political ideas); Traditional Conservatism and the New Right: Tensions Within the Tradition (Core political ideas); Core Ideas and Principles of Feminism (Non-core political ideas); Liberal and Radical Feminism: Tensions Within the Tradition (Non-core political ideas); Feminist Thinkers: Mary Wollstonecraft and Betty Friedan (Non-core political ideas); Feminist Thinkers: Kate Millett and Sylvia Walby (Non-core political ideas); Core Ideas and Principles of Anarchism (Non-core political ideas); Collectivist and Individualist Anarchism: Tensions Within the Tradition (Non-core political ideas); Anarchist Thinkers: William Godwin and Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (Non-core political ideas); Anarchist Thinkers: Mikhail Bakunin and Emma Goldman (Non-core political ideas); The US Constitution: Principles and the Amendment Process (US politics and comparative politics); US Federalism: The Changing Relationship Between Federal and State Government (US politics and comparative politics); US Presidency (US politics and comparative politics); US Congress: Structure and Formal Powers of the House and Senate (US politics and comparative politics); Congress in Practice: Committees, Incumbency and Relations with the Presidency (US politics and comparative politics); Comparative Theories: Structural, Rational and Cultural Approaches (US politics and comparative politics); The US Supreme Court: Role, Appointment and Judicial Philosophy (US politics and comparative politics); Civil Rights in the United States: Race, Gender and LGBT+ Rights (US politics and comparative politics); US Elections: The Electoral College, Primaries and Caucuses (US politics and comparative politics); US Political Parties, Pressure Groups and Campaign Finance (US politics and comparative politics); Comparative US/UK Constitutions: Federal and Unitary Government (US politics and comparative politics); Comparative US/UK Legislatures: Congress and Parliament (US politics and comparative politics); Comparative US/UK Executives: The President and the Prime Minister (US politics and comparative politics); Comparative US/UK Judiciaries and Rights Protection (US politics and comparative politics); Comparative US/UK Democracy and Participation (US politics and comparative politics); US Voting Behaviour and the Participation Crisis (US politics and comparative politics).
Method recap - US Presidency
- Split presidential power into formal, constitutional powers under Article II (commander-in-chief, appointments with Senate consent, treaty-making with Senate ratification, veto, pardon) and informal powers that have grown through practice (executive orders, executive agreements, signing statements, going public).
- Learn the difference between an executive order (a directive managing the executive branch, which can be challenged in court and reversed by a successor) and an executive agreement (an international agreement that does not require Senate ratification, unlike a treaty).
- Learn what the cabinet is and is not: it is nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate, but it has no constitutional role, meets relatively rarely as a body, and its influence is frequently exceeded by the president's own White House staff.
- Learn the specific limits Congress places on the presidency (confirmation of nominees, the power of the purse, oversight hearings, veto override by two-thirds of both chambers, impeachment) separately from the limits the courts impose (judicial review of executive orders and actions, e.g. Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co v Sawyer, 1952, which limited a president's emergency powers).
Worked example - US Presidency
Assess the extent to which informal powers, rather than the formal powers set out in Article II, are now the main source of presidential influence.
- Define both terms precisely: formal powers are those written into Article II (veto, commander-in-chief, treaty-making, appointments, pardon); informal powers are practices that have grown up around the office (executive orders, executive agreements, signing statements, going public/the bully pulpit).
- Build the case for informal powers being dominant: executive orders let a president act unilaterally without needing Congress at all, and their use has grown as legislative gridlock has made passing new laws harder; executive agreements let presidents make binding international commitments without the two-thirds Senate hurdle a treaty requires.
- Build the case for formal powers remaining central: the veto (and the mere threat of one) still shapes what Congress is willing to pass in the first place, and the Senate's power to reject nominations or refuse to ratify a treaty is a formal check that no informal power can bypass.
- Add a qualifying point: informal powers such as executive orders are themselves constrained by the formal structure, since courts can strike them down as unconstitutional and a successor president can simply revoke them, so they are a weaker and more reversible form of power than a formal, especially a ratified, action.
- Reach a conclusion: informal powers have grown as a practical response to the difficulty of achieving formal, cross-branch agreement, but they are more fragile and reversible than formal powers, so their prominence reflects legislative gridlock as much as it reflects presidential strength.
Question 8 - US Presidency
12 marks
Explain and analyse three ways in which Congress or the courts can limit presidential power.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [12 marks]| Question 8[12 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| identifies limits with little or no explanation. | Level 11-3 marks |
| explains limits with limited development or occasional inaccuracy. | Level 24-6 marks |
| clearly explains three accurate limits, e.g. Senate confirmation, the power of the purse, and judicial review of executive orders. | Level 37-9 marks |
| as Level 3 with precise supporting detail, e.g. naming Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co v Sawyer (1952) for judicial limits on emergency power, explaining that the Senate can reject or delay confirmation of key appointees, and that Congress can refuse to appropriate funding for a presidential initiative. | Level 410-12 marks |
| Senate confirmation and treaty ratification, congressional power of the purse, oversight hearings, veto override (two-thirds of both chambers), impeachment, and judicial review of executive orders/actions by the courts. | |
Question 9 - US Presidency
25 marks
Assess the extent to which informal powers, rather than the formal powers set out in Article II, are now the main source of presidential influence.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 9 [25 marks]| Question 9[25 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| unsupported or very general assertions. | Level 11-5 marks |
| some accurate knowledge but limited or one-sided analysis. | Level 26-10 marks |
| balanced treatment with accurate examples of both formal and informal powers, but underdeveloped analysis. | Level 311-15 marks |
| sustained, well-evidenced argument on both sides with clear analytical links and an emerging judgement. | Level 416-20 marks |
| sophisticated evaluation that directly weighs formal against informal powers and reaches a clear, justified judgement. | Level 521-25 marks |
| rising use of executive orders in response to legislative gridlock, executive agreements bypassing the Senate's treaty role, signing statements and going public to shape the political agenda without needing Congress. | |
| the veto and veto threat still shape what Congress passes; Senate confirmation and treaty ratification remain a hard constraint that no informal power avoids; executive orders can be struck down by the courts or reversed by a successor, making them a weaker and more reversible form of power than a formal, especially a ratified, action. | |
Method recap - US Congress: Structure and Formal Powers of the House and Senate
- Learn the size, term length and basis of representation for each chamber precisely: House, 435 seats, population-based, two-year terms; Senate, 100 seats, two per state, six-year staggered terms.
- Split Congress's powers into shared formal powers (Article I Section 8, e.g. taxing, spending, declaring war, regulating commerce), House-exclusive powers (originate revenue bills, impeach by simple majority), and Senate-exclusive powers (ratify treaties by two-thirds, confirm nominations by simple majority, try impeachments and convict by two-thirds).
- Learn the difference between the formal, constitutionally granted powers of Congress and how those powers actually operate once combined with practices such as the committee system or the Senate filibuster, since exam questions often ask you to evaluate power in practice, not just on paper.
- For a 'how powerful is Congress' style question, weigh Congress's formal powers (e.g. power of the purse, override of a presidential veto by two-thirds of both chambers) against constraints on that power (e.g. presidential veto itself, the difficulty of achieving supermajorities, and divided government slowing legislation).
Question 8 - US Congress: Structure and Formal Powers of the House and Senate
12 marks
Explain and analyse three formal powers that distinguish the Senate from the House of Representatives.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [12 marks]| Question 8[12 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| identifies one or two powers with minimal or inaccurate explanation. | Level 11-3 marks |
| identifies Senate-exclusive powers but with limited detail or occasional inaccuracy about thresholds. | Level 24-6 marks |
| clearly and mostly accurately explains three Senate-exclusive powers (treaty ratification, confirmation of nominations, trying impeachments) with correct vote thresholds. | Level 37-9 marks |
| as Level 3 with precise, well-evidenced detail, e.g. correctly stating the two-thirds threshold for treaty ratification and conviction on impeachment, a simple majority for confirming nominations, and linking each power to why the Senate's longer, staggered term was designed to give it this more deliberative role. | Level 410-12 marks |
| treaty ratification (two-thirds), confirmation of presidential and judicial nominations (simple majority), trying impeachments and convicting (two-thirds), and the constitutional design rationale of the Senate as a more insulated, deliberative chamber. | |
Question 9 - US Congress: Structure and Formal Powers of the House and Senate
25 marks
'Congress's formal powers make it the most powerful branch of the federal government.' Evaluate this statement.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 9 [25 marks]| Question 9[25 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| unsupported or very general assertions about Congress's power. | Level 11-5 marks |
| some accurate knowledge of formal powers but limited or one-sided analysis. | Level 26-10 marks |
| balanced treatment of Congress's formal powers against constraints, with accurate examples, but underdeveloped analysis. | Level 311-15 marks |
| sustained, well-evidenced argument on both sides with clear analytical links and an emerging judgement. | Level 416-20 marks |
| sophisticated evaluation weighing Congress's formal powers against the practical constraints on exercising them, reaching a clear, justified judgement. | Level 521-25 marks |
| the power of the purse (spending and taxation), power to override a presidential veto with two-thirds of both chambers, Senate confirmation and treaty powers, and the power to declare war. | |
| divided government and partisan gridlock routinely prevent Congress from acting on its formal powers, the presidential veto and threat of veto shapes what Congress can pass, the high two-thirds threshold for overriding a veto or ratifying a treaty is rarely reached, and the Senate filibuster (a supermajority requirement to end debate on most legislation) can block action even with majority support. | |